Tomac VS Carmichael

motomike137
Profile picture for user motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
motomike137
Edited Date/Time 7/19/2022 8:30am
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC was able to hold Stewart at bay for the most part outdoors, how would he handle ET3 in beast mode?
55
|
zehn
Profile picture for user zehn
Posts
7895
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK, USA
zehn 7/12/2022 11:21am
7/12/2022 11:21am

32
fourfourone
Profile picture for user fourfourone
Posts
3046
Joined
10/14/2017
Location
86oh, CT, USA
fourfourone 7/12/2022 11:21am
7/12/2022 11:21am
motomike137 wrote:
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC...
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC was able to hold Stewart at bay for the most part outdoors, how would he handle ET3 in beast mode?
apples to oranges.
4
plowboy
Profile picture for user plowboy
Posts
14703
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
plowboy 7/12/2022 11:30am
7/12/2022 11:30am
There is no real answer...just our imagination. But, I'll bite. Eli is amazing... phenomenal in fact but Ricky ALWAYS found a way to go faster...to win. I'm not sure we ever saw RC's absolute limit. Yes, he was beaten occasionally but he found a way to get back on top. You askedWhistling
31
2
peelout
Profile picture for user peelout
Posts
18405
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT, USA
peelout 7/12/2022 11:43am
7/12/2022 11:43am
i don't know but i would like to see it
16

The Shop

See All »
mx 219
Profile picture for user mx 219
Posts
4045
Joined
8/15/2010
Location
South Central, PA, USA
mx 219 7/12/2022 12:07pm
7/12/2022 12:07pm
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused to lose.
20
1
Nathaniel129 7/12/2022 12:23pm
7/12/2022 12:23pm
mx 219 wrote:
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused...
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused to lose.
Would be legendary. Best part is whoever lost out of those three, you wouldn't here some BS excuse about bike setup or the sniffles.
11
MyBobbym
Profile picture for user MyBobbym
Posts
725
Joined
11/23/2020
Location
Apache Junction, AZ, USA
MyBobbym 7/12/2022 12:24pm
7/12/2022 12:24pm
motomike137 wrote:
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC...
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC was able to hold Stewart at bay for the most part outdoors, how would he handle ET3 in beast mode?
Smoke him.
3
6
davis224
Profile picture for user davis224
Posts
7563
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL, USA
Fantasy
130th
davis224 7/12/2022 12:32pm
7/12/2022 12:32pm
Nobody was touching Tomac at Hangtown 2015. Tomac lately? I bet RC would find a way.
5
1
Lucas Windham 7/12/2022 12:33pm
7/12/2022 12:33pm
mx 219 wrote:
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused...
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused to lose.
Agreed. Villopoto and Eli have more talent but Carmichael hates losing enough to make up any talent gap. Guy just twisted throttle harder and hung on.
9
1
AH387
Profile picture for user AH387
Posts
1705
Joined
8/29/2019
Location
Bridgeville, PA, USA
AH387 7/12/2022 12:37pm
7/12/2022 12:37pm
I just couldn't bet against Ricky. Maybe at some point someone will come along and make me think different, but so far it hasn't happened. I think peak Eli could certainly have a shot at beating RC straight up in a single race but he would have next to no chance to win a title and beat RC over the duration of a series.
18
ElliotB16
Profile picture for user ElliotB16
Posts
1129
Joined
6/10/2019
Location
Cairo, GA, USA
ElliotB16 7/12/2022 12:40pm
7/12/2022 12:40pm
RC was 10 for 10 in outdoor championships with 3 undefeated seasons. I wouldn’t bet against him
36
bite_the_curb 7/12/2022 12:41pm
7/12/2022 12:41pm
it'd be close, for sure

in all honesty if they raced at their peak it'd probably be similar to when james challenged ricky
1
2
olds cool
Profile picture for user olds cool
Posts
4261
Joined
1/17/2010
Location
Claremont, NC, USA
olds cool 7/12/2022 12:42pm
7/12/2022 12:42pm
RC is the GOAT for a reason. He may have an occasional stumble trying to get the right word(s) out while commentating but he didn't earn any of those championships by talking. He straight up kicked ass and took names.
23
Moto520
Profile picture for user Moto520
Posts
3660
Joined
2/4/2013
Location
Schaumburg, IL, USA
Moto520 7/12/2022 12:54pm
7/12/2022 12:54pm
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way to displace RC
12
Press516
Profile picture for user Press516
Posts
5855
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Silver City, CX
Fantasy
367th
Press516 7/12/2022 12:55pm
7/12/2022 12:55pm
Eli would have his races and win some... But Ricky would be right there and win the others. With Tomac's hit and miss non beast mode rides that he still occasionally has, RC would put it away every time. RC was not only brutally fast, he was ALWAYS brutally fast. That's what makes him the GOAT.
19
plowboy
Profile picture for user plowboy
Posts
14703
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
plowboy 7/12/2022 12:57pm
7/12/2022 12:57pm
Moto520 wrote:
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way...
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way to displace RC
Time will tell but that fast Aussie Jett has the makings. I think he has a 6th gear he hasn't clicked into yet.
1
3
Falcon
Profile picture for user Falcon
Posts
12536
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
Falcon 7/12/2022 1:00pm
7/12/2022 1:00pm
RC>Tomac.

Carmichael has every strength Tomac does, plus the absolute, bilious, vile-spitting hatred of losing.
16

Pit Row

See All »
Moto520
Profile picture for user Moto520
Posts
3660
Joined
2/4/2013
Location
Schaumburg, IL, USA
Moto520 7/12/2022 1:03pm
7/12/2022 1:03pm
Moto520 wrote:
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way...
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way to displace RC
plowboy wrote:
Time will tell but that fast Aussie Jett has the makings. I think he has a 6th gear he hasn't clicked into yet.
It's possible. He's definitely showing the signs. That jump from the 250 class to the 450's can be a real bitch. That will be the time when he either runs away from everyone for years or struggles like crazy
1
plowboy
Profile picture for user plowboy
Posts
14703
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
plowboy 7/12/2022 1:09pm
7/12/2022 1:09pm
Moto520 wrote:
It's possible. He's definitely showing the signs. That jump from the 250 class to the 450's can be a real bitch. That will be the time...
It's possible. He's definitely showing the signs. That jump from the 250 class to the 450's can be a real bitch. That will be the time when he either runs away from everyone for years or struggles like crazy
I think I heard or read that the brothers are faster and actually prefer the big bores...just checking off the boxes. It's gonna be fun to see.
1
plowboy
Profile picture for user plowboy
Posts
14703
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
plowboy 7/12/2022 1:21pm
7/12/2022 1:21pm
thatswhathappens wrote:
.
That post won't get you in troubleWink
ACBraap
Profile picture for user ACBraap
Posts
1171
Joined
2/10/2012
Location
Seattlish, WA, USA
Fantasy
1172nd
ACBraap 7/12/2022 1:59pm
7/12/2022 1:59pm
mx 219 wrote:
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused...
I think Tomac vs Villopoto vs Carmichael would be fun to see, but I have a feeling RC would win. That dang little leprochaun just refused to lose.
Exactly right. I'd put Tomac ahead of them both in terms of sheer speed, and behind them both in mental toughness and that 'refuse to lose' quality. Would be a tough call as to whether RV or RC has more of that particular quality.
3
1
mxb2
Profile picture for user mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
mxb2 7/12/2022 2:01pm
7/12/2022 2:01pm
Falcon wrote:
RC>Tomac.

Carmichael has every strength Tomac does, plus the absolute, bilious, vile-spitting hatred of losing.
Yep as a tomac, and rc fan. Rc. Was the baddest mofo ever to race on a mx bike. Not even close.
7
motomike137
Profile picture for user motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
motomike137 7/12/2022 2:23pm
7/12/2022 2:23pm
motomike137 wrote:
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC...
As the thread title says it's Eli vs Ricky outdoors at let's say Red Bud on a nice day like we had a week ago. RC was able to hold Stewart at bay for the most part outdoors, how would he handle ET3 in beast mode?
Haha, 24 downs for a simple bench racing topic! I agree with the sentiment that RC almost never had an off day, especially once James hit the big bike class and Ricky kicked it up a couple notches to stay ahead of the FMOTP.
1
1
MyBobbym
Profile picture for user MyBobbym
Posts
725
Joined
11/23/2020
Location
Apache Junction, AZ, USA
MyBobbym 7/12/2022 2:26pm
7/12/2022 2:26pm
Moto520 wrote:
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way...
i agree wiht Olds cool. Tomac is great but Carmichael is the best ever....someone's going to have to take over the sport in a major way to displace RC
Jett can answer that call.
1
bichwolf
Profile picture for user bichwolf
Posts
532
Joined
2/12/2022
Location
Emerald Isle, NC, USA
bichwolf 7/12/2022 2:33pm
7/12/2022 2:33pm
RC did shit that can't be done. Eli is not that.
5
Big Lenny
Profile picture for user Big Lenny
Posts
14378
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Compton, CA, USA
Big Lenny 7/12/2022 2:34pm
7/12/2022 2:34pm
ElliotB16 wrote:
RC was 10 for 10 in outdoor championships with 3 undefeated seasons. I wouldn’t bet against him
2 undefeated seasons...Dry
2
9
davis224
Profile picture for user davis224
Posts
7563
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL, USA
Fantasy
130th
davis224 7/12/2022 2:43pm
7/12/2022 2:43pm
ElliotB16 wrote:
RC was 10 for 10 in outdoor championships with 3 undefeated seasons. I wouldn’t bet against him
Big Lenny wrote:
2 undefeated seasons...Dry
2 perfect seasons, 1 undefeated season. He won every overall in 05.
15
Hi Side
Profile picture for user Hi Side
Posts
708
Joined
9/19/2013
Location
USA
Hi Side 7/12/2022 2:46pm
7/12/2022 2:46pm
I like Eli and pull for him over anyone in modern day but he couldn’t lube Ricky’s chain.
3
3

Post a reply to: Tomac VS Carmichael