Gate malfunction?

dirtworldmx
Posts
1613
Joined
8/21/2009
Location
USA
5/26/2019 1:02pm
It's an equal opportunity gate drop, giving all the riders with slow reflexes a chance to start well, run up front, and feel better about themselves. You really want to take that away from the less privileged?
honda907
Posts
366
Joined
2/7/2009
Location
Chesterfield, SC, USA
5/26/2019 1:20pm
Hmm.. I don't think they really know what happened. First someone says that Chase Sexton hits it (He's on the left of the starter box) and then that same someone said that the rider 4 gates to the right of the starter box hit it and caused it to flinch on the left of the starter box. No doubt it flinched for Sexton and he drove into from AC94 point of view. GoPro.

Not sure if anyone really knows, but the vital detectives will get to the bottom of it. That I am sure of! More video will surface!

Too bad attendance looked very light. Real shame. The experience is gone for the normal guy I believe.
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/26/2019 1:21pm
gt80rider wrote:
If u look only at ac's gate, it moved.. Should have been a re start....
oldblood wrote:
I thought he won?
Good point, and the funny part...

Should we have stopped the first moto because of the first turn pileup? That was likely one rider's fault, not all four of them that went down. Should we have stopped the second 450 moto at Hangtown because of the rain? No one deserved that, but it happened. Should we have stopped the first 250 moto because Hunter Lawrence's bike let go in front of Jordon Smith, knocking Jordon out? Wasn't Jordon's fault, but he paid the price for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, just like RJ Hampshire in the second moto with Alex Martin...

Racing is a very dynamic thing. Guys jumped before the starting gate actually dropped, and one of them won the race and the overall. Should it not count because he didn't get a great start because someone hit the gate before him?

When there is a real gate malfunction, or a track problem, or a major injury, we will bring out the red flag. This was not such a case and the race went on. The fastest guy won, and he was one of the guys hampered by the situation at the start. We didn't stop it and restart it because there was no malfunction.

I thought it was a really good race, the fastest guys won, and people seemed to really enjoy watching it. On to Thunder Valley.

DC
Racer X
26
4
toroP
Posts
4521
Joined
4/6/2009
Location
Cincinnati, OH, USA
5/26/2019 1:24pm
plowboy wrote:
Fellas, there ain't many people I trust in life but DC is one of 'em. I haven't ever seen him caught out in a lie. He's...
Fellas, there ain't many people I trust in life but DC is one of 'em. I haven't ever seen him caught out in a lie. He's always come across as a hard working honest Joe. He says he checked the gate numerous times and could find nothing wrong. What more can he do? Call the results invalid and award points to your particular favorite rider?
But if we don’t trust you, how does that work?Wink
3

The Shop

honda907
Posts
366
Joined
2/7/2009
Location
Chesterfield, SC, USA
5/26/2019 1:28pm
gt80rider wrote:
If u look only at ac's gate, it moved.. Should have been a re start....
oldblood wrote:
I thought he won?
DC wrote:
Good point, and the funny part... Should we have stopped the first moto because of the first turn pileup? That was likely one rider's fault, not...
Good point, and the funny part...

Should we have stopped the first moto because of the first turn pileup? That was likely one rider's fault, not all four of them that went down. Should we have stopped the second 450 moto at Hangtown because of the rain? No one deserved that, but it happened. Should we have stopped the first 250 moto because Hunter Lawrence's bike let go in front of Jordon Smith, knocking Jordon out? Wasn't Jordon's fault, but he paid the price for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, just like RJ Hampshire in the second moto with Alex Martin...

Racing is a very dynamic thing. Guys jumped before the starting gate actually dropped, and one of them won the race and the overall. Should it not count because he didn't get a great start because someone hit the gate before him?

When there is a real gate malfunction, or a track problem, or a major injury, we will bring out the red flag. This was not such a case and the race went on. The fastest guy won, and he was one of the guys hampered by the situation at the start. We didn't stop it and restart it because there was no malfunction.

I thought it was a really good race, the fastest guys won, and people seemed to really enjoy watching it. On to Thunder Valley.

DC
Racer X
If the gate malfunctions ( I am saying "if"), then yes the race should be restarted. What happens after the gate goes down is much different than the start. That isn't putting the riders in "chance situations" that are racing incidents.

The gate is to make it equal for all riders involved to start at the exact time.

Not sure I follow your logic on first turn crashes, rain and such.
2
13
SEEMEFIRST
Posts
14268
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
5/26/2019 1:33pm
Bring back rubber bands!

Get smacked in the face with surgical tubing once, and you'll learn to wait.
7
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/26/2019 1:40pm
honda907 wrote:
Hmm.. I don't think they really know what happened. First someone says that Chase Sexton hits it (He's on the left of the starter box) and...
Hmm.. I don't think they really know what happened. First someone says that Chase Sexton hits it (He's on the left of the starter box) and then that same someone said that the rider 4 gates to the right of the starter box hit it and caused it to flinch on the left of the starter box. No doubt it flinched for Sexton and he drove into from AC94 point of view. GoPro.

Not sure if anyone really knows, but the vital detectives will get to the bottom of it. That I am sure of! More video will surface!

Too bad attendance looked very light. Real shame. The experience is gone for the normal guy I believe.
Well, I'm that same guy you mentioned -- the one that was there at the start and posted the video. And thendropped the gate several times with officials immediately after the start. And explained that Sexton hit the gate after the guy on the other side hit it first and caused it to shake--it's the same bar for all 40 gates-- but not actually drop, which is when the riders are supposed to actually go. I'm sorry you don't believe me. But I saw what happened and the referee made the right call in letting the race continue.

And you like talking about attendance, like High Point last year, which was probably the biggest crowd we ever had there, but you thought it was light. And you thought yesterday was weak, but it was quite good, though it's just a very big place with too much infield. And we had a much better traffic plan than the other promoter did last time, thank God.

You may not like think the experience is there anymore, and I'm sure for some it isn't what it used to be, but a lot of people are doing the best they can, in a world where kids would rather look at their phones than the life around them. It's tough for any promoter, which is why car tracks are taking out seats left and right. None of this is easy, but I think we're doing pretty good, especially after having to replace a famous facility with an infamous one and starting all over again.

And as you know, I'm from Penciltucky too. We had real red flags at High Point two years ago because we had real gate malfunctions, and that was live on NBC proper. When it happens, we red flag it.

DC
Racer X
20
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/26/2019 1:44pm Edited Date/Time 5/26/2019 1:46pm
oldblood wrote:
I thought he won?
DC wrote:
Good point, and the funny part... Should we have stopped the first moto because of the first turn pileup? That was likely one rider's fault, not...
Good point, and the funny part...

Should we have stopped the first moto because of the first turn pileup? That was likely one rider's fault, not all four of them that went down. Should we have stopped the second 450 moto at Hangtown because of the rain? No one deserved that, but it happened. Should we have stopped the first 250 moto because Hunter Lawrence's bike let go in front of Jordon Smith, knocking Jordon out? Wasn't Jordon's fault, but he paid the price for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, just like RJ Hampshire in the second moto with Alex Martin...

Racing is a very dynamic thing. Guys jumped before the starting gate actually dropped, and one of them won the race and the overall. Should it not count because he didn't get a great start because someone hit the gate before him?

When there is a real gate malfunction, or a track problem, or a major injury, we will bring out the red flag. This was not such a case and the race went on. The fastest guy won, and he was one of the guys hampered by the situation at the start. We didn't stop it and restart it because there was no malfunction.

I thought it was a really good race, the fastest guys won, and people seemed to really enjoy watching it. On to Thunder Valley.

DC
Racer X
honda907 wrote:
If the gate malfunctions ( I am saying "if"), then yes the race should be restarted. What happens after the gate goes down is much different...
If the gate malfunctions ( I am saying "if"), then yes the race should be restarted. What happens after the gate goes down is much different than the start. That isn't putting the riders in "chance situations" that are racing incidents.

The gate is to make it equal for all riders involved to start at the exact time.

Not sure I follow your logic on first turn crashes, rain and such.
Again, the gate didn't malfunction, one of the riders hit it, causing it to flinch in the surrounding area, and a couple of others to go early. That's rider error by one guy that caused others to make mistakes. Like first turn crashes, or what happened to Hampshire, and Jordon Smith...

The gate did drop equally for all forty riders, as it's meant to do. But the guy who hit it caused others to flinch. That's not the gate's fault. That's simple logic Honda907.

DC
Racer X
5
1
crowe176
Posts
6613
Joined
9/8/2006
Location
Spring Lake, MI, USA
5/26/2019 1:51pm
Next post: "Yeah ok, but the gate flinched"

Followed by link to AC gopro.
3
1
smashingpumpkins167
Posts
3349
Joined
8/3/2016
Location
USA
5/26/2019 1:59pm
If we want to boost attendance numbers we really need to rally around the local talent. These two guys come to mind. They're honest hard working Americans that capture the essence of how much cooler things used to be. Just kidding. That's me on the right and this is from when we made it onto the broadcast.



Please don't stop posting here DC. Sorry that so many have an ax to grind over a non issue. I watched you busting your ass all weekend with a smile on your face. Thanks for managing our circus.
2
1
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/26/2019 2:01pm
crowe176 wrote:
Next post: "Yeah ok, but the gate flinched"

Followed by link to AC gopro.
Glad that we had a good race at Pala, and the fastest guys won (regardless of their bad starts (two for AC, and no one is even talking about the first...) and a good start to the new Fox Raceway National at Pala. No one is running away with anything yet, though AC on a roll and Eli looking better than ever (but not until he lets 20 minutes pass).

On to Denver.

DC
Racer X
1
1
plowboy
Posts
14856
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
5/26/2019 2:13pm
toroP wrote:
But if we don’t trust you, how does that work?Wink
Good point my friend. How do we know who to trust. Personally, I trust most folks til they give me reason not to. As for my trustworthiness...I can tell you for true...if you laid a million bucks in front of me and left the country for 20 years...there wouldn't be a penny missing when you came back. If you asked me to lie for a million bucks...I wouldn't. It's not that I don't need money but my integrity and self respect are worth more to me than all the money in the world. I use the same yardstick on myself as I do with any other man. Do I have wrong opinions and make mistakes...yes sir. Do I ever lie, cheat, steal for personal gain...no sir. Don't know if that makes me trustworthy cause it's just words but that's all I got.
2
m121c
Posts
193
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
USA
5/26/2019 2:42pm
So if I’m a team member and one of the riders on my team is in the championship I know what I’m doing... going right by my teammates championship rival and absolutely ramming that gate so it throws him off while my teammate knows to wait...... but hey no malfunction...

That slow-mo video only shows one side of the gate, the big mishap was on the right side where it started. In the incomplete replay from the broadcast (just my observation) the gates did not drop equally for those who didn’t jump forward. To be fair, it’s tough to know if a knobbie was in the gate or not from that angle so that could be why.

Regardless if there was no malfunction of the gate, It’s my opinion if someone hits the gate good enough causing a flinch/wobble which propagates outward to other gates, someone’s gate will be higher and drop later/longer. The energy has to go somewhere and it’s all about timing. Even if the variance is slight, it means a lot. In instances like this, the race should be started and the guy who caused the restart is penalized by having to start backwards, old school rules.

It’s over, the race is done. Onward to the next round. I just think it’s a slippery slope saying no malfunction no restart with only rider error. Although a dirty tactic, with money on the line I wouldn’t put it past a team to try to exploit it.
15
plowboy
Posts
14856
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
5/26/2019 3:02pm
m121c wrote:
So if I’m a team member and one of the riders on my team is in the championship I know what I’m doing... going right by...
So if I’m a team member and one of the riders on my team is in the championship I know what I’m doing... going right by my teammates championship rival and absolutely ramming that gate so it throws him off while my teammate knows to wait...... but hey no malfunction...

That slow-mo video only shows one side of the gate, the big mishap was on the right side where it started. In the incomplete replay from the broadcast (just my observation) the gates did not drop equally for those who didn’t jump forward. To be fair, it’s tough to know if a knobbie was in the gate or not from that angle so that could be why.

Regardless if there was no malfunction of the gate, It’s my opinion if someone hits the gate good enough causing a flinch/wobble which propagates outward to other gates, someone’s gate will be higher and drop later/longer. The energy has to go somewhere and it’s all about timing. Even if the variance is slight, it means a lot. In instances like this, the race should be started and the guy who caused the restart is penalized by having to start backwards, old school rules.

It’s over, the race is done. Onward to the next round. I just think it’s a slippery slope saying no malfunction no restart with only rider error. Although a dirty tactic, with money on the line I wouldn’t put it past a team to try to exploit it.
Holy crap. There is really no end to the argument of what's "fair". When the gate drops...you go. Not when it flinches or you see a pin moving. If you can't make up those few hundredths of a second in a 30+2 moto...does it really matter? I understand the start is uber important but was yesterday any different than it has been forever? If anyone has a better idea for a foolproof start gate...speak up. Red flags and restarts are a non-player.
4
Texas Built
Posts
867
Joined
5/30/2018
Location
Houston, TX, USA
5/26/2019 4:22pm
kkawboy14 wrote:
If anything it should have been a do over because The guy beside AC was able to blow all the way thru the gate. The gate...
If anything it should have been a do over because The guy beside AC was able to blow all the way thru the gate. The gate didn’t flinch
A do over because some privateer jumped the gate?
2
Moto520
Posts
3672
Joined
2/4/2013
Location
Schaumburg, IL, USA
5/26/2019 4:45pm
Great race and good event. Right call was made with the gate. I like that a call was made so quickly and the race continued
Fox88
Posts
1011
Joined
2/11/2012
Location
Galveston Island, TX, USA
5/26/2019 4:46pm
22
lostboy819
Posts
12809
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
5/26/2019 5:18pm
Fox88 wrote:
[img]http://oimg.photobucket.com/albums/v337/thrashedkid03/JLAWIZZ.gif[/img]
That one never gets old Laughing
2
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
5/26/2019 5:31pm
m121c wrote:
So if I’m a team member and one of the riders on my team is in the championship I know what I’m doing... going right by...
So if I’m a team member and one of the riders on my team is in the championship I know what I’m doing... going right by my teammates championship rival and absolutely ramming that gate so it throws him off while my teammate knows to wait...... but hey no malfunction...

That slow-mo video only shows one side of the gate, the big mishap was on the right side where it started. In the incomplete replay from the broadcast (just my observation) the gates did not drop equally for those who didn’t jump forward. To be fair, it’s tough to know if a knobbie was in the gate or not from that angle so that could be why.

Regardless if there was no malfunction of the gate, It’s my opinion if someone hits the gate good enough causing a flinch/wobble which propagates outward to other gates, someone’s gate will be higher and drop later/longer. The energy has to go somewhere and it’s all about timing. Even if the variance is slight, it means a lot. In instances like this, the race should be started and the guy who caused the restart is penalized by having to start backwards, old school rules.

It’s over, the race is done. Onward to the next round. I just think it’s a slippery slope saying no malfunction no restart with only rider error. Although a dirty tactic, with money on the line I wouldn’t put it past a team to try to exploit it.
plowboy wrote:
Holy crap. There is really no end to the argument of what's "fair". When the gate drops...you go. Not when it flinches or you see a...
Holy crap. There is really no end to the argument of what's "fair". When the gate drops...you go. Not when it flinches or you see a pin moving. If you can't make up those few hundredths of a second in a 30+2 moto...does it really matter? I understand the start is uber important but was yesterday any different than it has been forever? If anyone has a better idea for a foolproof start gate...speak up. Red flags and restarts are a non-player.
Yeah but these guys are professionals. Vital says they shouldn’t have to wait until it drops. Word of the day... flinch.


Flinch!




3
1
m121c
Posts
193
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
USA
5/26/2019 6:01pm
plowboy wrote:
Holy crap. There is really no end to the argument of what's "fair". When the gate drops...you go. Not when it flinches or you see a...
Holy crap. There is really no end to the argument of what's "fair". When the gate drops...you go. Not when it flinches or you see a pin moving. If you can't make up those few hundredths of a second in a 30+2 moto...does it really matter? I understand the start is uber important but was yesterday any different than it has been forever? If anyone has a better idea for a foolproof start gate...speak up. Red flags and restarts are a non-player.
I don’t think I expressed what I meant too well with the hundredths of a second. It matters when that 1/100th of a second determines who hits the gate and who doesn’t, who holds back and who takes off, etc. Also, the average human reaction to visual stimuli is 0.25 seconds. The propagation of error between hundredths of a second of difference and 0.25s to react visually is pretty huge when you are talking about a “fair” and “equal” opportunity start (as if it is already).

When you go in the first turn in 38th because some dude drilled the gate on the other side wobbling your gate and the guys beside you got to take off before you did (not saying that was the case here), that matters. You are already 15 seconds behind the leader by the 2nd corner atleast. And that doesn’t warrant a restart because it wasn’t the gates fault? That doesn’t really seem logical to me. Unless I’m the guy who benefited of course!


6
kpiper
Posts
2529
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
USA
5/26/2019 6:32pm
I like the guy who said go back to the surgical tubing start. A lot cheaper too DC!

BTW How about a 'retro' National one day with small jumps. The racing/passing might be awesome.
4
Thor34103
Posts
287
Joined
7/22/2011
Location
Tampa, FL, USA
5/26/2019 8:32pm
kpiper wrote:
I like the guy who said go back to the surgical tubing start. A lot cheaper too DC! BTW How about a 'retro' National one day...
I like the guy who said go back to the surgical tubing start. A lot cheaper too DC!

BTW How about a 'retro' National one day with small jumps. The racing/passing might be awesome.
Retro National? Yes!

I would attend the National at any of the 12 tracks if it was going to be a retro National. Haven't even thought about what that would look like yet but like the concept.
4
500guy
Posts
12468
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
5/26/2019 8:43pm
If you look up to the sky the gate will never flinch.
1
slipdog
Posts
10054
Joined
7/25/2009
Location
Nor Cal, CA, USA
5/26/2019 9:22pm
If we want to boost attendance numbers we really need to rally around the local talent. These two guys come to mind. They're honest hard working...
If we want to boost attendance numbers we really need to rally around the local talent. These two guys come to mind. They're honest hard working Americans that capture the essence of how much cooler things used to be. Just kidding. That's me on the right and this is from when we made it onto the broadcast.



Please don't stop posting here DC. Sorry that so many have an ax to grind over a non issue. I watched you busting your ass all weekend with a smile on your face. Thanks for managing our circus.
That really you? I about died when I saw Duff Man!
3
2
zehn
Posts
7906
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK, USA
5/26/2019 9:27pm
kpiper wrote:
I like the guy who said go back to the surgical tubing start. A lot cheaper too DC! BTW How about a 'retro' National one day...
I like the guy who said go back to the surgical tubing start. A lot cheaper too DC!

BTW How about a 'retro' National one day with small jumps. The racing/passing might be awesome.
And it might also be as fun as watching paint dry. Who the hell wants to watch modern 4 strokes ride around on an AHRMA track
3
2
smashingpumpkins167
Posts
3349
Joined
8/3/2016
Location
USA
5/27/2019 5:30am
slipdog wrote:
That really you? I about died when I saw Duff Man!
Haha yeah it is. We had a blast out there.
toroP
Posts
4521
Joined
4/6/2009
Location
Cincinnati, OH, USA
5/27/2019 6:31am
toroP wrote:
But if we don’t trust you, how does that work?Wink
plowboy wrote:
Good point my friend. How do we know who to trust. Personally, I trust most folks til they give me reason not to. As for my...
Good point my friend. How do we know who to trust. Personally, I trust most folks til they give me reason not to. As for my trustworthiness...I can tell you for true...if you laid a million bucks in front of me and left the country for 20 years...there wouldn't be a penny missing when you came back. If you asked me to lie for a million bucks...I wouldn't. It's not that I don't need money but my integrity and self respect are worth more to me than all the money in the world. I use the same yardstick on myself as I do with any other man. Do I have wrong opinions and make mistakes...yes sir. Do I ever lie, cheat, steal for personal gain...no sir. Don't know if that makes me trustworthy cause it's just words but that's all I got.
I hope you saw the winking emoji.
7eleven
Posts
655
Joined
8/20/2012
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
5/27/2019 7:15am
Yes, the gate flinched around the dog house area. However, it did not flinch at the far end of the gate. So, it is not mechanically possible to be a gate malfunction.

Every pro rider behind that gate has seen a gate flinch before and as a rider, you hope to get your clutch and throttle set again in time, before it drops.

The riders aren't going to piss and moan about that one once they see those vids.

3
plowboy
Posts
14856
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
5/27/2019 7:45am
toroP wrote:
But if we don’t trust you, how does that work?Wink
plowboy wrote:
Good point my friend. How do we know who to trust. Personally, I trust most folks til they give me reason not to. As for my...
Good point my friend. How do we know who to trust. Personally, I trust most folks til they give me reason not to. As for my trustworthiness...I can tell you for true...if you laid a million bucks in front of me and left the country for 20 years...there wouldn't be a penny missing when you came back. If you asked me to lie for a million bucks...I wouldn't. It's not that I don't need money but my integrity and self respect are worth more to me than all the money in the world. I use the same yardstick on myself as I do with any other man. Do I have wrong opinions and make mistakes...yes sir. Do I ever lie, cheat, steal for personal gain...no sir. Don't know if that makes me trustworthy cause it's just words but that's all I got.
toroP wrote:
I hope you saw the winking emoji.
Lol, I did brother. My response (rant) was more tilting at windmills than answering your question. How do we know who to trust these days. Seems like a lot of folks are trustworthy til it requires time, effort, or money.

In this particular case...it seems like there is an abundance of "perspective" as to whether you believe the gate malfunctioned or if an action by a rider (bumping the gate) caused others to perceive a malfunction. The riders and teams know DC far better than I do. They may have a different opinion of him than I do. I'll let them speak to that if they choose to.

If I understand correctly, D.C. checked out the gate pretty pronto and the referee made the call. I can see both sides and honestly...see merit in both arguments. I'm gonna straddle this fence and say, "That's why we have officials at the race". Is everybody happy...nope. is everybody pissed...nope. I reckon that's about as fair as it gets in life.
2

Post a reply to: Gate malfunction?

The Latest