New Honda, same old problem?

All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if the new bike is suffering from the same trouble? Both of Roczen's crashes on it seemed to be like that, but who am I to say.
|
early
Posts
10045
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
1/21/2017 10:36pm
Nope
aeffertz
Posts
12739
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
1/21/2017 10:38pm
Who are you to say?
Tokyo_Tiddler
Posts
2160
Joined
7/25/2009
Location
Somewhere in, NJ, USA
1/21/2017 10:42pm
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if...
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if the new bike is suffering from the same trouble? Both of Roczen's crashes on it seemed to be like that, but who am I to say.
that's bullshit

The Shop

cameron96
Posts
836
Joined
10/4/2016
Location
CA
1/21/2017 10:44pm
Seelys going good
cali11
Posts
1545
Joined
2/28/2016
Location
Federal Way, WA, USA
1/21/2017 10:44pm
Blame the bike
Sargent Rock
Posts
302
Joined
4/6/2012
Location
Liberty Lake, WA, USA
1/21/2017 10:51pm
Hmmm.....not a bad point.
ML512
Posts
17021
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
Fantasy
1/21/2017 10:52pm
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
kiwifan
Posts
9826
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
USA
1/21/2017 11:15pm
ML512 wrote:
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic: "I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC...
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
now now ML, dont bring facts in here, people want to blame Honda
FARANG
Posts
861
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/21/2017 11:19pm
Not the bike. A combination of imperfect riding and a bit of bad luck with the lip.
Plugga
Posts
634
Joined
3/30/2016
Location
Beanbag, QLD, AU
1/22/2017 12:43am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2017 1:17am
aeffertz wrote:
Who are you to say?
.
tek14
Posts
4950
Joined
1/26/2014
Location
Vantaa, FI
1/22/2017 12:45am
ML512 wrote:
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic: "I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC...
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
If you watch replay doesn't seem to have any rut on left side on that jump? Maybe rear shock just can't handle kicks when setting softer side like MEC.
Lucifa.
Posts
1415
Joined
4/14/2009
Location
Christchurch, NZ
1/22/2017 12:51am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2017 12:53am
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if...
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if the new bike is suffering from the same trouble? Both of Roczen's crashes on it seemed to be like that, but who am I to say.
Could you explain in mechanical terms what "all the sudden just jump up and bite you" means? Does this relate to a specific mechanical part or parts on the Honda? I'd be interested to know exaculy why this would only relate to the Honda.

Edit, I'm sure the guys at Honda would like to know too.
fullysicmate
Posts
1646
Joined
1/4/2013
Location
Queensland, AU
1/22/2017 12:52am
ML512 wrote:
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic: "I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC...
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
Yep, kens fault not the bike. He is clearly loving it but his mistakes caused the crashes, not the bike.
Motofinne
Posts
11553
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
1/22/2017 12:57am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2017 1:01am
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if...
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if the new bike is suffering from the same trouble? Both of Roczen's crashes on it seemed to be like that, but who am I to say.
Lucifa. wrote:
Could you explain in mechanical terms what "all the sudden just jump up and bite you" means? Does this relate to a specific mechanical part or...
Could you explain in mechanical terms what "all the sudden just jump up and bite you" means? Does this relate to a specific mechanical part or parts on the Honda? I'd be interested to know exaculy why this would only relate to the Honda.

Edit, I'm sure the guys at Honda would like to know too.
Just a stupid narrative that most bikes or brands get from people that are too lazy to actually analyze different bikes and what they do. If bike X was a good turning bike in 2008 it still is in 2017 according to a lot of people.

Suzuki turns so good that you don't even have to turn it! It actually turns and finds ruts for you! Yamaha turns like titanic, so good engine that even a vet can holeshot it and "bites you at any time"! Kawasaki is meant to turn with the back wheel! You are screwed if you don't ride like RV!

You know the drill...
1/22/2017 1:10am
ML512 wrote:
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic: "I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC...
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
Someone with a logical ,calculated response to a stupid and utterly ridiculous theory,your my man Mike.
1/22/2017 2:44am
Yep, kens fault not the bike. He is clearly loving it but his mistakes caused the crashes, not the bike.
And I'm sure that Ken will be the first to admit it was his fault that he didn't win.
aees
Posts
2834
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
USA
1/22/2017 3:06am
you could see this tendency in his bike earlier laps. to quick rebound or soft compression. turns great and good for whoops, but man it has no margin for errors or bad luck.

same with stewarts setup, stiff and fast rebound but dont ride it out of shape, and be aware it can bite you on the track (stewart is no.1 in loosing front ends)

Dungey has found the perfect balance.
neysbo
Posts
2014
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edelstein, IL, USA
1/22/2017 5:15am
Both Kenny's crashes were his fault and would have happened on any bike. Rider error.
1/22/2017 5:24am
The more I watch the crash the more weird it appears. I thought at first it dragged his right foot off the peg, but no it didn't do that. If you watch closely in the previous few laps, it seems like this same thing nearly happened once or twice already. More than once he looked to be jumping more nose down than his competitors.
On this lap he came in to that section on the very left of the track, desperate to get a nose ahead of the lapper- it's possible he launched off of that plateu a little hard, compressing a little harder than normal into the ruts between the jumps.
1stSSPZ
Posts
257
Joined
3/17/2014
Location
Lubbock, TX, USA
1/22/2017 5:31am
Bush's fault.
nascarnate326
Posts
3008
Joined
11/3/2014
Location
Charlotte, MI, USA
1/22/2017 5:45am
Bikes terrible, everyone that has one should just dump them and get an Alta. /s
neysbo
Posts
2014
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edelstein, IL, USA
1/22/2017 6:07am
The more I watch the crash the more weird it appears. I thought at first it dragged his right foot off the peg, but no it...
The more I watch the crash the more weird it appears. I thought at first it dragged his right foot off the peg, but no it didn't do that. If you watch closely in the previous few laps, it seems like this same thing nearly happened once or twice already. More than once he looked to be jumping more nose down than his competitors.
On this lap he came in to that section on the very left of the track, desperate to get a nose ahead of the lapper- it's possible he launched off of that plateu a little hard, compressing a little harder than normal into the ruts between the jumps.
Ya definitely weird. Watch his bike even in the beginning of the race, back end looks soft and fast rebound. He was still hauling though. I think though just a bit of a mistake by taking that line and hitting a soft spot.
86honda
Posts
908
Joined
12/23/2008
Location
Sickofit, AR, USA
1/22/2017 6:23am
A red cape would allow any rider to escape a kick that throws you 20 feet in the air. I have a Go Fund Me to make this happen! They are all Supermen(exept Vince Freaky)
KMC440
Posts
7764
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/22/2017 6:28am
Dirt Wurx fault ... obviously. Whistling
yak651
Posts
8964
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI, USA
Fantasy
1/22/2017 6:32am
ML512 wrote:
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic: "I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC...
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
tek14 wrote:
If you watch replay doesn't seem to have any rut on left side on that jump? Maybe rear shock just can't handle kicks when setting softer...
If you watch replay doesn't seem to have any rut on left side on that jump? Maybe rear shock just can't handle kicks when setting softer side like MEC.
Yeah his line was pretty much the only one without a rut. Emig was saying the same thing about the ruts and you can see no rut there. It did look like there was a funny transition there though, maybe Jmart was right about the jumps not being the same all the way across the width of the track
Mit12
Posts
2222
Joined
6/23/2014
Location
Lake Havasu City, AZ, USA
1/22/2017 6:38am
Wake up guys, Tomacs results, Webbs troubles and Roczens crash are not caused by the bike.
Racer111
Posts
2766
Joined
5/23/2009
Location
Concord, NC, USA
1/22/2017 6:52am
ML512 wrote:
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic: "I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC...
I'll throw something in here I posted in another topic:

"I'll dip in some info here that should hopefully help you understand what happened. At MEC, Ken overshot the first rhythm in this section, compressing the suspension heavily and causing it to pop weird for the next set, which he then cased after losing his pop, then endo-ing off the third...

Tonight, he landed a little deep off the first rhythm, into a rut, blowing the shock through the stroke right as the bike hit a very abrupt triple face (a few guys had similar bucks with the abruptness of this lip).

Another factor, in my opinion, on why the reaction was so severe is Ken typically likes softer settings (from what I've been told by both his prior teams) which could compound this reaction.

Lastly, the bike itself wouldn't have a "flaw" in my opinion. The linkage ratio on this bike has been modified to match up to a near equal value of the previous models (well within the range of what other manufactures use). Their shock travel/stroke length wasn't compromised with the change either."
If anyone will notice, he didn't over jump the plateau. It honestly looks to me as though he just chopped the throttle too early. In the close up slow mo replay, there are no ruts or kickers on the left side.

He simply just got off the gas too soon. That's all it was.
1/22/2017 7:25am
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if...
All the top guys said the last few gene of Honda was good then would all the sudden just jump up and bite you. Wonder if the new bike is suffering from the same trouble? Both of Roczen's crashes on it seemed to be like that, but who am I to say.
Lucifa. wrote:
Could you explain in mechanical terms what "all the sudden just jump up and bite you" means? Does this relate to a specific mechanical part or...
Could you explain in mechanical terms what "all the sudden just jump up and bite you" means? Does this relate to a specific mechanical part or parts on the Honda? I'd be interested to know exaculy why this would only relate to the Honda.

Edit, I'm sure the guys at Honda would like to know too.
That is a term the Yamaha haters started using when they went to the backward cylinder but I guess the Honda now does it too. Pinch
Mr. Info
Posts
1671
Joined
5/3/2010
Location
Perris, CA, USA
1/22/2017 7:33am
It is the fault of the lying press and all there fake news. They reported it was sold out and I saw empty seats. It was the biggest Anaheim turnout ever. POTUS

Post a reply to: New Honda, same old problem?

The Latest