When will safety come back into style

yz133rider
Posts
4823
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA US
Edited Date/Time 2/25/2024 5:25am

So neck braces came into style and then out

chest protectors in and then out

You remember how much padding pastrana would put on before xgames, and then went and did fucking acrobatics on the bike. And these guys don’t wear more than .5 mm of Jersey and padding and then have season ending crashes constantly.

 

meanwhile the gear gets lighter, tighter, thinner, etc. 

 

i feel like they’re all sacrificing safety for fashion and what’s “in”

 

not to mention some of the track designs both at the pro and the amateur level but that’s another topic entirely, oh and the current bikes but also another topic entirely.

 

tracks are gnarlier than ever, bikes gnarlier than ever, and we’re wearing less gear than ever. Makes sense.

10
22
|
joshd
Posts
397
Joined
3/17/2016
Location
Lucedale, MS US
2/25/2024 5:25am

You can put what ever little bit of padding you want. The bikes are too damn fast  

7
10
WY228
Posts
49
Joined
6/7/2018
Location
Asheville, NC US
2/25/2024 5:25am

Someone correct me if I’m wrong but didn’t the neck braces fall out of favor with the pro guys because they hated the limited range of motion and view? Don’t think it was because of style.

9
Joey Bridges
Posts
5181
Joined
1/19/2022
Location
Kingston, TN US
2/25/2024 5:25am

AP looks to be the only one wearing any kind of body armor under his jersey.

1
12
reded301
Posts
286
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS US
2/25/2024 5:56am Edited Date/Time 2/25/2024 5:56am

Can’t fit much for safety under those fuckin spandex outfits they wear these days.

5

The Shop

c0ncEpT
Posts
1281
Joined
5/13/2015
Location
Harrison Twp., MI US
2/25/2024 5:59am

Alot of these guys wear chest protectors under their jerseys. I know Tomac does.

3
soyMotero
Posts
249
Joined
5/7/2023
Location
Cantabria , Cantabria ES
Fantasy
2483rd
2/25/2024 6:04am

Protective gear like braces or chest protectors are restrictive, the more restriction you have the slower you become, riders are choosing performance over safety, as long as the AMA don't enforce protective gear, riders won't wear it. Safety rule changes won't happen in motorsport until a misfortune happens, like we have seen in MotoGP, F1...

4
soggy
Posts
5875
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
UT US
Fantasy
4355th
2/25/2024 6:16am

I think Fork wears an under protector 

He does. He was wearing it last night

2/25/2024 6:22am Edited Date/Time 2/25/2024 6:31am

Here we go. Sports elevate, injuries happen. It’s a damn shame, but it’s part of it. “The bikes are too damn fast.” But you guys are the first ones to put down a deposit on the newest 450 each year.   
 

I think we’re at a good spot regarding gear, safety and training. Where the sport lacks safety is the corners cut for track building. I agree with everyone else, exposed concrete is the dumbest idea. With that said, there are 80+ riders that ride the same tracks each weekend and ride their bikes back to the pits.

6
yz133rider
Posts
4823
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA US
2/25/2024 6:36am

Those roost deflectors aren’t chest protectors….

1
9
yz133rider
Posts
4823
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA US
2/25/2024 6:37am

If it’s fitting underneath the xxxxs jersey they’re wearing it isn’t thick enough to absorb much.

 

its better than nothing but they could do a lot better.

4
lumpy790
Posts
10016
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC US
2/25/2024 6:44am

Why aren’t safety gear pants called leathers any more?

IMG 0104

1
2
MxAddic
Posts
4117
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
NY US
2/25/2024 6:50am
soyMotero wrote:
Protective gear like braces or chest protectors are restrictive, the more restriction you have the slower you become, riders are choosing performance over safety, as long...

Protective gear like braces or chest protectors are restrictive, the more restriction you have the slower you become, riders are choosing performance over safety, as long as the AMA don't enforce protective gear, riders won't wear it. Safety rule changes won't happen in motorsport until a misfortune happens, like we have seen in MotoGP, F1...

jmb.jpg?VersionId=2Db.OUaWJ6McQ8aYka8Sd

1
3
gti
Posts
137
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Winnipeg CA
2/25/2024 7:56am

We should be talking about Forkner making the good decision to wear a chest pro. Does anyone know what model of fox  protection he wears?

2
1
2/25/2024 8:03am
joshd wrote:

You can put what ever little bit of padding you want. The bikes are too damn fast  

I dont agree. Professionals should be able to control machinery with double the power if necessary. The 'game' is about 'control'.

When do riders simply wise up and take fewer risks? 

 

5
Magoofan
Posts
8647
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
2/25/2024 8:13am

 

Chest protectors aren't going to save someone from neck/back injuries.

Some extra padding in jersies/pants isn't going to do shit either.   

2
4
mxb2
Posts
22472
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD US
2/25/2024 8:17am
joshd wrote:

You can put what ever little bit of padding you want. The bikes are too damn fast  

I dont agree. Professionals should be able to control machinery with double the power if necessary. The 'game' is about 'control'. When do riders simply wise...

I dont agree. Professionals should be able to control machinery with double the power if necessary. The 'game' is about 'control'.

When do riders simply wise up and take fewer risks? 

 

Bingo ,throttle goes both ways.   Local riders better sell their 450 s then lol

1
OldTech
Posts
482
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur , AL US
2/25/2024 8:19am
lumpy790 wrote:
Why aren’t safety gear pants called leathers any more?

Why aren’t safety gear pants called leathers any more?

IMG 0104

Because no riders want to call them nylons 

6
2/25/2024 10:33am
Here we go. Sports elevate, injuries happen. It’s a damn shame, but it’s part of it. “The bikes are too damn fast.” But you guys are...

Here we go. Sports elevate, injuries happen. It’s a damn shame, but it’s part of it. “The bikes are too damn fast.” But you guys are the first ones to put down a deposit on the newest 450 each year.   
 

I think we’re at a good spot regarding gear, safety and training. Where the sport lacks safety is the corners cut for track building. I agree with everyone else, exposed concrete is the dumbest idea. With that said, there are 80+ riders that ride the same tracks each weekend and ride their bikes back to the pits.

"Bikes are too damn fast"

Doesn't buy an RMZ cos MXA say its 'underpowered'!Laughing

2
Gator 4
Posts
198
Joined
12/31/2021
Location
Southern California, CA US
2/25/2024 11:46am

Personal choice.  Where what you want.  

drewd237
Posts
53
Joined
8/1/2022
Location
West Linn, OR US
2/25/2024 12:01pm

The level 2 D3O stuff is pretty good and it’s not bulky at all. When mountain biking, I’d wear the Fox vest with front and back protection under my shirt and you couldn’t barely tell I was wearing it.

People shaking their fists in the air about how they all need to be wearing some sort of chest and back protector. How do you know they aren’t? Just because they don’t look like a linebacker all bulked up with pads or a chest protector over the jersey doesn’t mean they aren’t wearing anything.

Also them not wearing anything, how does it affect your life? Pro’s wrecking themselves causing injury doesn’t stop you from living your life. Who cares what or what they don’t wear. Everybody has their own choice to do what they want. Wear it, don’t wear it, it's up to you and at the end of the day how much your body is worth it to you. 

2/25/2024 12:40pm
drewd237 wrote:
The level 2 D3O stuff is pretty good and it’s not bulky at all. When mountain biking, I’d wear the Fox vest with front and back...

The level 2 D3O stuff is pretty good and it’s not bulky at all. When mountain biking, I’d wear the Fox vest with front and back protection under my shirt and you couldn’t barely tell I was wearing it.

People shaking their fists in the air about how they all need to be wearing some sort of chest and back protector. How do you know they aren’t? Just because they don’t look like a linebacker all bulked up with pads or a chest protector over the jersey doesn’t mean they aren’t wearing anything.

Also them not wearing anything, how does it affect your life? Pro’s wrecking themselves causing injury doesn’t stop you from living your life. Who cares what or what they don’t wear. Everybody has their own choice to do what they want. Wear it, don’t wear it, it's up to you and at the end of the day how much your body is worth it to you. 

I agree about the bulk. Like saying a ford grenada is safer than a honda accord...or something

1
mtbkris2
Posts
367
Joined
1/17/2024
Location
San Diego, CA US
Fantasy
3329th
2/25/2024 9:28pm

Anyone rocking the alpinestars a1 pro? Just ordered one from rmatv after that brutal crash last night. 

2
2/26/2024 12:46am

It's damn murder to allow athletes to be running at such speed, along obstacles like this, right beside concrete floors.   Are we going to see a death before this is addressed?  The promoters are making millions from the sport, how about, on selected areas, Circus style netting.  Sure, it won't stop you hitting the concrete, but, like an AirBag, offer a cushioning effect.  What happened on the weekend just cannot be allowed to happen.  This is a possible career ending incident... just because the careless attitude towards the athletes and basic safety.   Raw concrete as a landing area.  No way.

net

RussB
Posts
888
Joined
7/12/2014
Location
GB
Fantasy
581st
2/26/2024 12:48am

I fully agree on a good chest and back protector. Wearing just a jersey or a foam roost vest is just plain stupid.

Having plastic around your chest and back will spread and dissipate the impact which will lessen its effect on one acute spot on the body. As well as stopping nasty injuries from bar and lever impacts stated above.

Neck braces...... look at the screen grab of Forkner hitting the deck on page one on the Forkner thread. After that style of impact and he didn't break his neck. So how could a neck brace have helped? I honestly think they cause more harm than good by adding a leverage point which shouldn't be there. 

9
2/26/2024 1:04am Edited Date/Time 2/26/2024 1:05am
RussB wrote:
I fully agree on a good chest and back protector. Wearing just a jersey or a foam roost vest is just plain stupid. Having plastic around...

I fully agree on a good chest and back protector. Wearing just a jersey or a foam roost vest is just plain stupid.

Having plastic around your chest and back will spread and dissipate the impact which will lessen its effect on one acute spot on the body. As well as stopping nasty injuries from bar and lever impacts stated above.

Neck braces...... look at the screen grab of Forkner hitting the deck on page one on the Forkner thread. After that style of impact and he didn't break his neck. So how could a neck brace have helped? I honestly think they cause more harm than good by adding a leverage point which shouldn't be there. 

Good point, I wonder how AirBag technology could be adapted in our sport. Measuring speed and G-Force... if a rider detached from the bike, to deploy. Probably not suitable for Travis Pastrana & Co.

Richy
Posts
3096
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK GB
2/26/2024 1:09am
RussB wrote:
I fully agree on a good chest and back protector. Wearing just a jersey or a foam roost vest is just plain stupid. Having plastic around...

I fully agree on a good chest and back protector. Wearing just a jersey or a foam roost vest is just plain stupid.

Having plastic around your chest and back will spread and dissipate the impact which will lessen its effect on one acute spot on the body. As well as stopping nasty injuries from bar and lever impacts stated above.

Neck braces...... look at the screen grab of Forkner hitting the deck on page one on the Forkner thread. After that style of impact and he didn't break his neck. So how could a neck brace have helped? I honestly think they cause more harm than good by adding a leverage point which shouldn't be there. 

I'm not that kind of engineer and certainly no medical professional, but thinking about how much flex in the body must have been involved in Forkners crash and then thinking about if he'd been wearing a neck brace which would have limited that movement (possibly good, I don't know) but would have ramped up the force as a result and directed it into the shoulders etc... I agree with you, I also don't like the concept of neck braces.

Infinitely faster and/or smarter people than my dumb self seem to be on this train also.

I also agree the concrete isn't ideal at all, but what practical, actionable alternative is there? Netting, while I like that people are thinking, just doesn't make sense when a motorcycle and grown man, at pace, are likely gonna land on it. Also when people/riders/medical mules need to navigate the off track area.

1

Post a reply to: When will safety come back into style

The Latest