who wins it outdoors in their prime 4 motos takes all. one race US and one in EU

Jean-Michel Bayle.  He’d beat them all in Supercross and on a street bike, too.

1 vote for Aj Catanzaro 

I assume you mean "in a perfect world" ie; no crashes, bike failures, take-outs?

I've seen all those guys and each one has dominated their era/series.  My eyes tell me that Jett is the most complete racer I have ever seen.

Magoo. He did sort of what you’re describing once, it was awesome!

Logic points to Ricky but I can’t help but think Villopoto on a 250f wouldn’t wax every one of them.

KR

Agreed. Bayle was as good as it gets in SX, dare I say, including the King?

Jett is amazing, but I still think RC would just out-hammer him. 

RC always found a way to win at all costs. 

Like people said that Tomac would do?

If they all had to ride Hodakas then the obvious answer would be the Carson Brown

*If he was on a factory bike

It's hard to imagine anybody beating peak Kenny at Millville or Unadilla for example, yeah. 

Same goes for Jett at Pala/RedBud

or Tomac at Hangtown

or Herlings at Lommel or any sand track pretty much

or Gajser at Trentino

or Chase at Washougal

2006 Everts could probably also win at any track, just like 2004-2007 RC

Who has the most outdoor wins in their class? Is it the H guy with 8% votes? 

Not even close. Cairoli has around 20 more premier wins than Herlings and Herlings has two or three more premier class wins than Gajser.

Brandon got my vote. 

I would put money on it that he will beat them and wait for them in the car park for a while.

Man, I love Tomac, but that guy is no RC.

Edit: Plus, Eli was multiple injuries in and on the wrong side of 30 before ever seeing Jett and was still ready to mash (which is why I love that guy).

Outdoors? Hard not to bet on RC. 

Noone would beat peak herlings on a sand track though 

If you're putting RV on that list, the Dunge should be as well!

What you are talking about is mental toughness.  They all have speed. toss up between RV and RC for the win at all costs attitude.  

The Goldenboi #18.

Why can't I vote for Jorge Prado?  

This list is biased, it leaves out Profeshenal 125 

Ricky has twice as many national titles as Tomac. Different levels.

Jett is 22 now. Ricky was 27 when he retired. Jett has 5 years to catch up and only 4 titles currently. He has to win every single championship SX and MX for the next 5 years to catch, not surpass, RC by the same age. He can't miss a single season. And he has no chance of beating him. (No, I haven't looked at the exact birthdates and RC only ran half the year on his last year so it might actually already be impossible for Jett to catch him.)

I voted RC. Track record plus it's hard to bet against an angry Irishman, throw being short in the mix and holy shit talk about feisty 😡😂

Probably not the most popular opinion, but I’d have to strongly consider RV. All of these guys could win, but only a few can consistently deliver when the pressure is really high. Obviously RC too

Josep Garcia

Tomac had trouble with Dungey at times...  I'm a Tomac fan, but RC was in a completely different league.  He took on all comers and found a way to beat them all.  Nothing was too tall of a task for RC, skill, determination, conditioning, technique?  If someone did it better, he mastered it almost immediately.