Hunter Lawrence to Race 2025 CRF450R

1911
Posts
4999
Joined
4/2/2008
Location
LAS VEGAS, NV, USA
8/9/2024 4:52pm Edited Date/Time 8/9/2024 4:53pm
bvm111 wrote:
Do you guys really think you are smarter than HRC or AMA… like honda is trying to get one over on everyone and it is somehow...

Do you guys really think you are smarter than HRC or AMA… like honda is trying to get one over on everyone and it is somehow a “works bike” and doesn’t follow the production rule? Do you really think Lars hasn’t cleared it through AMA, you really think there aren’t enough 2025s in the country available to anyone including privateers that want to purchase one? 

It’s Vital, of course we are smart then HRC! And the AMA, CIA, FBI, ATF and all the other 3 letter agencies. Now where did I put my crayons, I need to pen a letter to the AMA and alert them to the error in their ways.  

9
OldTech
Posts
1331
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
8/9/2024 5:43pm

RC was under the works exemption rule. Honda burned theirs in 01 with Ryno

Tumic wrote:
My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would...

My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would come in production the next year so he was good to go. 

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that...

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that would be cool to dig into

Please elaborate on Ryno, was that the new 450? he was 125 before that?

Village Idiot
Posts
2622
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW, USA
8/9/2024 5:49pm
Tumic wrote:
My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would...

My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would come in production the next year so he was good to go. 

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that...

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that would be cool to dig into

OldTech wrote:

Please elaborate on Ryno, was that the new 450? he was 125 before that?

Yes; he helped develop the original CRF.

Funny, I haven't seen anyone mention McGrath and the new frame in '97. Apparently, it made a straight guy turn full-on Suzuki.

1
1
TeamGreen
Posts
37424
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
8/9/2024 6:12pm

Hmmmmm...

If I'm reading that correctly...

They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).

Does the AMA require them to have 200 available NOW as some sort of addenda to be eligible...? And, therefore, 400 by next June...?

1

The Shop

Village Idiot
Posts
2622
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW, USA
8/9/2024 6:23pm
TeamGreen wrote:
Hmmmmm...If I'm reading that correctly...They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).Does the...

Hmmmmm...

If I'm reading that correctly...

They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).

Does the AMA require them to have 200 available NOW as some sort of addenda to be eligible...? And, therefore, 400 by next June...?

"If I'm reading that correctly..."

And that's the problem with so much of the AMA Rulebook - you shouldn't have to wonder if you're "reading it correctly" - its primary objective should be to define clear boundaries on the subject at hand so participants know how to behave within the parameters of the rules and not have a "yeah, but" defense if they violate them.

I'm far from an authority on the publication but so much of what I have read is inexcusably vague and poorly written. I don't know how they can expect to enforce so many of the rules in it because anyone with a semi-critical thought process could poke holes in whatever position they try to take on one.

1
TeamGreen
Posts
37424
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
8/9/2024 6:25pm
TeamGreen wrote:
Hmmmmm...If I'm reading that correctly...They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).Does the...

Hmmmmm...

If I'm reading that correctly...

They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).

Does the AMA require them to have 200 available NOW as some sort of addenda to be eligible...? And, therefore, 400 by next June...?

"If I'm reading that correctly..."And that's the problem with so much of the AMA Rulebook - you shouldn't have to wonder if you're "reading...

"If I'm reading that correctly..."

And that's the problem with so much of the AMA Rulebook - you shouldn't have to wonder if you're "reading it correctly" - its primary objective should be to define clear boundaries on the subject at hand so participants know how to behave within the parameters of the rules and not have a "yeah, but" defense if they violate them.

I'm far from an authority on the publication but so much of what I have read is inexcusably vague and poorly written. I don't know how they can expect to enforce so many of the rules in it because anyone with a semi-critical thought process could poke holes in whatever position they try to take on one.

Sir,

In the future please end all opinions on these matters with the following phrase:

"...not that there's anything unusual about that after all these years."🤣

1
Johnny Ringo
Posts
8219
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ, USA
8/9/2024 6:26pm
Tumic wrote:
My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would...

My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would come in production the next year so he was good to go. 

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that...

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that would be cool to dig into

OldTech wrote:

Please elaborate on Ryno, was that the new 450? he was 125 before that?

He was in Europe before that. Came back in 01 and rode nationals on the prototype CRF.

Village Idiot
Posts
2622
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW, USA
8/9/2024 6:33pm
TeamGreen wrote:
Hmmmmm...If I'm reading that correctly...They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).Does the...

Hmmmmm...

If I'm reading that correctly...

They have to have 200 available by March 2025 (March 2024 has passed and so has June...so....I'm looking at 2025 requirements).

Does the AMA require them to have 200 available NOW as some sort of addenda to be eligible...? And, therefore, 400 by next June...?

"If I'm reading that correctly..."And that's the problem with so much of the AMA Rulebook - you shouldn't have to wonder if you're "reading...

"If I'm reading that correctly..."

And that's the problem with so much of the AMA Rulebook - you shouldn't have to wonder if you're "reading it correctly" - its primary objective should be to define clear boundaries on the subject at hand so participants know how to behave within the parameters of the rules and not have a "yeah, but" defense if they violate them.

I'm far from an authority on the publication but so much of what I have read is inexcusably vague and poorly written. I don't know how they can expect to enforce so many of the rules in it because anyone with a semi-critical thought process could poke holes in whatever position they try to take on one.

TeamGreen wrote:

Sir,

In the future please end all opinions on these matters with the following phrase:

"...not that there's anything unusual about that after all these years."🤣

Dear sir - my deepest apologies and many thanks for your patience as I endeavor to better myself. I'm still a work in progress... just ask my wife.😄

1
OldTech
Posts
1331
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
8/9/2024 6:41pm
I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that...

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that would be cool to dig into

OldTech wrote:

Please elaborate on Ryno, was that the new 450? he was 125 before that?

He was in Europe before that. Came back in 01 and rode nationals on the prototype CRF.

He was in Europe before that. Came back in 01 and rode nationals on the prototype CRF.

There's a story there, and I was with a girl. what year did he almost win a 125 championship. What nationals on the 450?

Village Idiot
Posts
2622
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW, USA
8/9/2024 8:05pm
bvm111 wrote:
Do you guys really think you are smarter than HRC or AMA… like honda is trying to get one over on everyone and it is somehow...

Do you guys really think you are smarter than HRC or AMA… like honda is trying to get one over on everyone and it is somehow a “works bike” and doesn’t follow the production rule? Do you really think Lars hasn’t cleared it through AMA, you really think there aren’t enough 2025s in the country available to anyone including privateers that want to purchase one? 

1911 wrote:
It’s Vital, of course we are smart then HRC! And the AMA, CIA, FBI, ATF and all the other 3 letter agencies. Now where did I...

It’s Vital, of course we are smart then HRC! And the AMA, CIA, FBI, ATF and all the other 3 letter agencies. Now where did I put my crayons, I need to pen a letter to the AMA and alert them to the error in their ways.  

Did you try looking under a Little Debbie box?

That's where I would have left them.😁

yak651
Posts
8937
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI, USA
Fantasy
8/9/2024 8:12pm

Will will clear this all up tomorrow when she breaks into the action to tell us she talked to someone about something, maybe this…

1
5
Flatliner
Posts
4292
Joined
11/3/2009
Location
CA
8/10/2024 6:58am Edited Date/Time 8/10/2024 7:07am

RC was under the works exemption rule. Honda burned theirs in 01 with Ryno

Tumic wrote:
My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would...

My memory is a bit foggy on this one but i have a memory of RC saying that he raced another frame one season that would come in production the next year so he was good to go. 

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that...

I know he rode a 98 frame in 01. I don’t remember him riding a new frame early though. If you remember any other details that would be cool to dig into

He didn't get to honda until 02.

 

Edit, I misread.  disregard.   The 25' honda's look amazing.  Ittl take some willpower to not pick one up.

Benhameen
Posts
218
Joined
12/27/2022
Location
Carterville, IL, USA
Fantasy
8/10/2024 7:33am

Seems like a good reason to blame the bike when he doesn’t beat chase. 

1
4
jjavaman
Posts
1600
Joined
3/12/2015
Location
CA
8/10/2024 7:40am
Benhameen wrote:

Seems like a good reason to blame the bike when he doesn’t beat chase. 

Nobody is beating chase until Jett comes back🤷🏼‍♂️

1
2
APLMAN99
Posts
12743
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
Fantasy
8/10/2024 7:55am

The published rules appear to be clear cut until you start putting in scenarios like this one. 

My opinion, and it’s worth about what you pay for it, is that if you are allowed to race a bike that isn’t really available to buy then the AMA should eliminate the production rule altogether. 

1
1
tahoefd
Posts
505
Joined
12/29/2020
Location
Minden, NV, USA
8/10/2024 8:01am

What an awesome Honda promo if Hunter did win today!

1
Village Idiot
Posts
2622
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW, USA
8/10/2024 8:06am
tahoefd wrote:

What an awesome Honda promo if Hunter did win today!

And, if he doesn't, does that mean all the other manufacturers that finish in front of him run ads saying, "Honda: our '24 model is better than their '25"? 😄

1
3
lumpy790
Posts
11680
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
8/10/2024 8:16am

Privateers do this every year so what’s the big deal? 

The Factory teams usually do not have enough time setting them up to bother doing it till A1

2
1
Gravel
Posts
1882
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
8/10/2024 11:31am

What are the chances of a KTM protest if Hunter wins on the 2025? Downvote me all you want, and I know this kind of stuff has been done a lot before, but that 2025 CRF doesn’t meet the AMA homologation rules posted in this thread. 

4
APLMAN99
Posts
12743
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
Fantasy
8/10/2024 11:48am
Gravel wrote:
What are the chances of a KTM protest if Hunter wins on the 2025? Downvote me all you want, and I know this kind of stuff...

What are the chances of a KTM protest if Hunter wins on the 2025? Downvote me all you want, and I know this kind of stuff has been done a lot before, but that 2025 CRF doesn’t meet the AMA homologation rules posted in this thread. 

Lindstrom mentioned that they had to work to get the bike homologated, but not sure what that entailed given the written rules. If the reasoning is that you have to have the bikes available for sale in the year of the ‘model year’ the motorcycle is claimed to be, it seems like you could conceivably change your frame and cases and claim it was a 2029 model and have nearly 5 years to actually have the bike available for sale. 

1
8/10/2024 12:08pm
Gravel wrote:
What are the chances of a KTM protest if Hunter wins on the 2025? Downvote me all you want, and I know this kind of stuff...

What are the chances of a KTM protest if Hunter wins on the 2025? Downvote me all you want, and I know this kind of stuff has been done a lot before, but that 2025 CRF doesn’t meet the AMA homologation rules posted in this thread. 

If the rules are the same as 2023 and before. There is NO penalty that would impact Hunter.  The proposed penalty for breaking the rule was a fine to the manufacturer. 

 I have not had the time to read the entire 2024 rule book. But somebody with time, that cares. Read it and find what the penalty is, IF they added one.  And that would be the worst case.  I really doubt that Honda did not do everything that the AMA said they needed to do.  

 

Somebody should find and post what the penalty for breaking the rule is.

 

I believe that Honda is acting in the spirit of the rule. And that they are racing a bike that will be using the parts form  either the production or WE version 2025 CRF.

 

 Stuff that gives the series a little boost . A racer coming back, a new model, euro coming over, etc. Are things that seem to have been done in the past to keep the interest level in the nationals higher as the season goes buy and the points leads get big. They work to find some new storylines. 

1

Post a reply to: Hunter Lawrence to Race 2025 CRF450R

The Latest