250sx frame

AJ565
Posts
2341
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA

Collective thoughts on fixing this? It’s chromo so I can tig it back together and possibly ad a chromo plate on the inside. I don’t know how long it’s been broken, I saw it when I was putting the engine back in after putting a new crank in it. Frame has 150 hours on it and I did swing arm bearings around 140 hours so sometime between then and now. 

|
SoCalMX70
Posts
3562
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
6/3/2024 10:30am

Popcorn out for this one.

5
2
Marty1028
Posts
950
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA
6/3/2024 2:13pm

How in the hell......

1
FGR01
Posts
6125
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
Fantasy
6/3/2024 2:38pm

Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol

I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot does sit sort of close there so you'll have to keep that in mind.

5
JWACK
Posts
2577
Joined
8/7/2009
Location
USA
6/3/2024 2:43pm

If it were mine I would trash it.  
Not worth the gamble.   

4
1

The Shop

Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
6/3/2024 2:45pm

That's an odd place for a break, no? Interesting for sure.

Is this one of those heat affected zone deals, being a little weaker from the initial welding in that area? Have to believe it would have fatigued long ago if so? Just more stress there as it's before a spar and close to where the engine mount maybe introduces some tension?

Looks quite strange at face value, but I don't know shit. I look forward to the educated comments (hell and the uneducated ones).

Know you'll get it stuck back together man, all the best with it 👍

Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
6/3/2024 2:47pm
FGR01 wrote:
Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot...

Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol

I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot does sit sort of close there so you'll have to keep that in mind.

Just drop the torque a few lbs and it's like riding on a cloud bro

9
crc245
Posts
1338
Joined
10/29/2007
Location
Yorba Linda, CA, USA
6/3/2024 3:17pm

No way I’d ever trust that. 

This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on a 2019-2022 TC250 frame recently as well…

1
zehn
Posts
7888
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK, USA
6/3/2024 3:31pm

Not worth a potentially lethal failure. Find a rolling frame and consider yourself very lucky 

2
AJ565
Posts
2341
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
6/3/2024 4:20pm
FGR01 wrote:
Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot...

Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol

I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot does sit sort of close there so you'll have to keep that in mind.

You can see where the boot already rubs on it. I can’t believe I didn’t feel it either, however my bike is really plush and soaks up bumps so maybe that’s why m I couldn’t feel the difference. 

1
AJ565
Posts
2341
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
6/3/2024 4:21pm

No way I’d ever trust that. 

crc245 wrote:
This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on...

This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on a 2019-2022 TC250 frame recently as well…

It’s a 2018. New frames are $1700 and I haven’t been able to locate a used one yet. 

2
6/3/2024 4:24pm

No way I’d ever trust that. 

crc245 wrote:
This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on...

This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on a 2019-2022 TC250 frame recently as well…

AJ565 wrote:

It’s a 2018. New frames are $1700 and I haven’t been able to locate a used one yet. 

AJ565
Posts
2341
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
6/3/2024 4:24pm
Richy wrote:
That's an odd place for a break, no? Interesting for sure. Is this one of those heat affected zone deals, being a little weaker from the...

That's an odd place for a break, no? Interesting for sure.

Is this one of those heat affected zone deals, being a little weaker from the initial welding in that area? Have to believe it would have fatigued long ago if so? Just more stress there as it's before a spar and close to where the engine mount maybe introduces some tension?

Looks quite strange at face value, but I don't know shit. I look forward to the educated comments (hell and the uneducated ones).

Know you'll get it stuck back together man, all the best with it 👍

First I’ve seen break in that spot. I know chromoly is supposed to be TIG welded and KTM is all mig. I don’t know if they post heat the frames before paint to relieve the stress or not. I would hope they would. 

1
AJ565
Posts
2341
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
6/3/2024 4:25pm
crc245 wrote:
This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on...

This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on a 2019-2022 TC250 frame recently as well…

AJ565 wrote:

It’s a 2018. New frames are $1700 and I haven’t been able to locate a used one yet. 

Rickyisms wrote:

I saw that one, it was my understanding the husky sub frame and plastic mounts are in different locations tho. 

6/3/2024 4:26pm

That’s a hell of a break. I’d can it and start looking for something else, I’d say you got your monies worth. 

1
cwtoyota
Posts
2400
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA, USA
6/3/2024 4:26pm
zehn wrote:

Not worth a potentially lethal failure. Find a rolling frame and consider yourself very lucky 

That's how I feel, especially if the frame is still available new or with low hours.

On a trail bike, I might consider a weld with a diamond shaped plate there to spread the stress out.   
A good-used frame for a late mode KTM is not that expensive and well worth the piece of mind.

RMATV...
2022 KTM 250SX
Frame 555S3                   Part# 55503001000EB                    Our Price:  $1,662.18

If that's too much, check MXLocker and eBay... Frames come up on those places all the time.


I have a 2002 YZ250 frame that cracked across the front down tube just above Y for the cradle.   That bike had hundreds of hours of hard moto.   I grabbed a good 2003 frame even though I have all the production welding equipment to fix it.

KX500 frames crack up by the shock tower through one of the longer welds.   I've repaired that crack on a buddy's frame and done some welding to replace foot peg mounts with upgrade parts and consider those bikes 100% safe.
 

1
BIGmizzyAZ
Posts
53
Joined
8/25/2020
Location
Phoenix, AZ, USA
6/3/2024 4:30pm

No way I’d ever trust that. 

crc245 wrote:
This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on...

This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on a 2019-2022 TC250 frame recently as well…

AJ565 wrote:

It’s a 2018. New frames are $1700 and I haven’t been able to locate a used one yet. 

Try CM off road in AZ. They part out a ton of bikes. 

Frame is Backordered with no ETA from KTM. Good Luck. 

1
OldTech
Posts
1286
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
6/3/2024 4:35pm

Sexton's frame probably looks like that now

8
6/3/2024 4:37pm

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

10
6/3/2024 4:42pm
AJ565 wrote:

It’s a 2018. New frames are $1700 and I haven’t been able to locate a used one yet. 

Rickyisms wrote:
AJ565 wrote:

I saw that one, it was my understanding the husky sub frame and plastic mounts are in different locations tho. 

Tank mount is the same for KTM/Husq/GasGas. I’m nearly 100% positive all the subframes mount the same on all three bikes. 

6/3/2024 5:25pm
ToolMaker wrote:
I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that...

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

You’re probably right, but I personally wouldn’t be able to ride it without getting that thought out of my head. If I was an engineer and understood Yield, flex, etc then maybe it’d be different, but I’d much prefer picking up something that’s still in one piece. Just my $0.02. 

1
Broseph
Posts
1204
Joined
4/28/2018
Location
Stevenson, WA, USA
6/3/2024 6:07pm Edited Date/Time 6/3/2024 6:08pm

No way I’d ever trust that. 

crc245 wrote:
This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on...

This. I’d start fresh if it were mine (assuming new is available for you still). Curious - What year 250SX? Saw the exact same problem on a 2019-2022 TC250 frame recently as well…

AJ565 wrote:

It’s a 2018. New frames are $1700 and I haven’t been able to locate a used one yet. 

If you spend $60 (I think?) on a KTM Talk membership, Munn racing gives some pretty good discounts:

4
6/3/2024 6:13pm
ToolMaker wrote:
I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that...

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

Rickyisms wrote:
You’re probably right, but I personally wouldn’t be able to ride it without getting that thought out of my head. If I was an engineer and...

You’re probably right, but I personally wouldn’t be able to ride it without getting that thought out of my head. If I was an engineer and understood Yield, flex, etc then maybe it’d be different, but I’d much prefer picking up something that’s still in one piece. Just my $0.02. 

I tell my son sometimes that you guys have it pretty damn good. Things are so reliable these days. It's pretty rare that when you go out riding and something breaks and your day is cut short. I mostly JetSki'd and we just expected we'd be towing someone home. But back to the topic on hand, back in the 70s I don't think you could find a bike that didn't have the frame welded up some how, some where. In todays age we think of it as dangerous, and it is a risk, but in previous days, it was just expected at some point you'd be welding on the frame somewhere. In this case, if someone does not have confidence in their equipment, it was the wrong decision.

TM

5
brimx153
Posts
3344
Joined
5/3/2012
Location
IE
6/3/2024 6:27pm

Weld and plate it . It will be 100% . check it after every ride . 

1
mx317
Posts
5344
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
6/3/2024 7:00pm

Weld it and send it. How do you think they are put together anyway? 

4
AJ565
Posts
2341
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
6/3/2024 7:03pm
ToolMaker wrote:
I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that...

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

This is the direction I’ve been leaning. We have some 1/8” chromoly plate at the shop that I can fab a back plate out of. Actually I think I can get two strips on the back and front of that inside section. I send it off big jumps and it hasn’t catastrophically ended my day yet. 

2
FGR01
Posts
6125
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
Fantasy
6/3/2024 7:12pm
FGR01 wrote:
Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot...

Guys who swear by flexy engine mounts can't believe you didn't feel that... lol

I like the idea of a plate on the backside.  The airboot does sit sort of close there so you'll have to keep that in mind.

AJ565 wrote:
You can see where the boot already rubs on it. I can’t believe I didn’t feel it either, however my bike is really plush and soaks...

You can see where the boot already rubs on it. I can’t believe I didn’t feel it either, however my bike is really plush and soaks up bumps so maybe that’s why m I couldn’t feel the difference. 

... a take on other memes I've seen where people wear through the subframe with their boots.....  Laughing

image-20240603191212-1

3
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
6/3/2024 11:19pm
ToolMaker wrote:
I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that...

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

Rickyisms wrote:
You’re probably right, but I personally wouldn’t be able to ride it without getting that thought out of my head. If I was an engineer and...

You’re probably right, but I personally wouldn’t be able to ride it without getting that thought out of my head. If I was an engineer and understood Yield, flex, etc then maybe it’d be different, but I’d much prefer picking up something that’s still in one piece. Just my $0.02. 

ToolMaker wrote:
I tell my son sometimes that you guys have it pretty damn good. Things are so reliable these days. It's pretty rare that when you go...

I tell my son sometimes that you guys have it pretty damn good. Things are so reliable these days. It's pretty rare that when you go out riding and something breaks and your day is cut short. I mostly JetSki'd and we just expected we'd be towing someone home. But back to the topic on hand, back in the 70s I don't think you could find a bike that didn't have the frame welded up some how, some where. In todays age we think of it as dangerous, and it is a risk, but in previous days, it was just expected at some point you'd be welding on the frame somewhere. In this case, if someone does not have confidence in their equipment, it was the wrong decision.

TM

I know they were likely lower consistency blends or varying quality control, assembly or treatment processes (although I swear chromoly has been around since world war II at least), but I was gonna say I'm sure those old timer heros who were hauling ass with sporks as footpegs and barely knobby tyres were welding frames up every other week and proceeding to send it 😂

Granted new frames probably weren't as readily available and they weren't airing the thing out like AJ does... But if it didn't let go while it was like that and you have the facilities and skills to try a repair, I'd give it a go. I'm a cheap bastard though.

Bearuno
Posts
5436
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
6/4/2024 2:20am
ToolMaker wrote:
I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that...

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

AJ565 wrote:
This is the direction I’ve been leaning. We have some 1/8” chromoly plate at the shop that I can fab a back plate out of. Actually...

This is the direction I’ve been leaning. We have some 1/8” chromoly plate at the shop that I can fab a back plate out of. Actually I think I can get two strips on the back and front of that inside section. I send it off big jumps and it hasn’t catastrophically ended my day yet. 

If you do that - Do the same to the other side - the tube over tube reinforcement.

Because if one side has broken, the other side is on the way to do so, as well.

And, strip the entire frame of paint, and check Every section of it.

I do a fair few frame repairs, and, I'm yet to have to do one like that - though, It certainly is a high stress tube section with regards to that area of the KTM frame - well, All frames.

But such severe damage, really makes me think a new, or very lightly used frame might be the safest way forward.

When you say your bike is Plush, have you been severely bottoming it  through that plushness? I've a mate that Always sets up his bikes that way, whilst being blazingly fast, with little mechanical sympathy. Works for Him, but he does damage Frames, Swingarms,  Shocks and wheels, quite often, and in Quite Unique ways. And I'm the mug that fixes it all.........

3
6/4/2024 7:26am
ToolMaker wrote:
I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that...

I'm the odd man out here, I'm going with tig it and an overlay plate. Do regular inspections. I can't imagine a catastrophic failure doing that. He's been riding it completely broken like this and didn't even notice it and doesn't even know how long it's been like that. It also really depends on how you ride too though.

AJ565 wrote:
This is the direction I’ve been leaning. We have some 1/8” chromoly plate at the shop that I can fab a back plate out of. Actually...

This is the direction I’ve been leaning. We have some 1/8” chromoly plate at the shop that I can fab a back plate out of. Actually I think I can get two strips on the back and front of that inside section. I send it off big jumps and it hasn’t catastrophically ended my day yet. 

Just out of curiosity. Can you tell us what led to this point? 

What kind of riding?

How many hours?

Speed level?

Stuff like that

Post a reply to: 250sx frame

The Latest