Friese Penalty

Anyone see it? Must have been really bad/blatant considering half the field was exiting and reentering the track all over.

1
|
Bill_Carroll
Posts
5051
Joined
9/15/2010
Location
Falcon, CO US
1/13/2024 9:15pm

Penalty by association 

Hunter Lawrence was doing the same thing. Don't know if he got penalized?

7
30
aeffertz
Posts
12472
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI US
1/13/2024 9:20pm Edited Date/Time 1/13/2024 9:22pm

Apparently Vince gained a position when he went off track and got back on. 
 

And come to think of it, I swear we seen him do something like that just a couple months ago!

28
3
CPR
Posts
6677
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/13/2024 9:40pm

Penalty by association 

Hunter Lawrence was doing the same thing. Don't know if he got penalized?

Association with what? His own misdemeanours and track record?

As for Hunter, I didn’t watch live so I couldn’t comment on all the ridiculous outcry in the Race Thread about him skipping the whoops and making up time 😂

They showed him do it twice; first occasion he went off track over a tuff block. Second time we didn’t get to see the reason why he was off the track, but he lost two positions. Love to know how he was making up time by going over a tuff block and losing two positions?!
 

10
15
MxMickyV
Posts
121
Joined
10/5/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA US
1/13/2024 10:02pm

He did it right in front of me. He skipped the whole rhythm section! Then I seen Deano after  moto and he said he transferred direct because they docked the prick. Deano is a tall mfr! Cool dude tho.

 

22
3

The Shop

1/13/2024 10:15pm

I thought Barcia might be in trouble for the 1st lap of the lcq as he passed Cade Clason off the track,  2 place penalty would have still put him in the main tho, 

4
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
1/13/2024 10:29pm

Penalty by association 

Hunter Lawrence was doing the same thing. Don't know if he got penalized?

Hunter was completely bypassing the whoops several times.  That's gaining time.   No penalty.

What a crock of shite....

18
54
CPR
Posts
6677
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/13/2024 11:11pm

Penalty by association 

Hunter Lawrence was doing the same thing. Don't know if he got penalized?

Magoofan wrote:

Hunter was completely bypassing the whoops several times.  That's gaining time.   No penalty.

What a crock of shite....

Please read my comment, two comments above yours and tell me how Hunter gained time by going over a tuff block one time and losing two positions another?

11
12
Tumic
Posts
2782
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall SE
1/13/2024 11:11pm
Magoofan wrote:

Hunter was completely bypassing the whoops several times.  That's gaining time.   No penalty.

What a crock of shite....

I guess that you were okay when Webb did it a couple of years ago. Fell in the turn before the whoops, rode straight of the track instead of going through them and gained time without a penalty. 

3
7
1/13/2024 11:36pm
aeffertz wrote:
Apparently Vince gained a position when he went off track and got back on.    And come to think of it, I swear we seen him...

Apparently Vince gained a position when he went off track and got back on. 
 

And come to think of it, I swear we seen him do something like that just a couple months ago!

Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track.

Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no penalty was given.

 

14
10
Tumic
Posts
2782
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall SE
1/14/2024 12:44am
Boomslang wrote:
Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track. Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no...

Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track.

Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no penalty was given.

 

I never buy in to the ”gain an advantage” thing.

the same second you get off the track and earn a tenth doing it you have gained an advantage even if you kept your position.

in US people seem to focus on the position when riders go of the track, not time gained/lost. Against the other riders on track that went through the section as you should.

 

8
2
pdub187
Posts
765
Joined
1/28/2013
Location
AU
1/14/2024 12:48am
Magoofan wrote:

Hunter was completely bypassing the whoops several times.  That's gaining time.   No penalty.

What a crock of shite....

Wah wah wahhhhhhhhhhhhhh

5
20
1/14/2024 12:49am

Actually if you have ever read the ama rulebook you see it clearly defined. You can gain an advantage without gaining a position. It clearly delineates it. You're correct.

1
aeffertz
Posts
12472
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI US
1/14/2024 12:51am
Boomslang wrote:
Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track. Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no...

Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track.

Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no penalty was given.

 

Tumic wrote:
I never buy in to the ”gain an advantage” thing. the same second you get off the track and earn a tenth doing it you have...

I never buy in to the ”gain an advantage” thing.

the same second you get off the track and earn a tenth doing it you have gained an advantage even if you kept your position.

in US people seem to focus on the position when riders go of the track, not time gained/lost. Against the other riders on track that went through the section as you should.

 

You’re telling me you can’t tell the difference between a rider going off track and reentering in the same position vs. a rider going off track, skipping obstacles and making a pass?  You’re the only person mentioning “an advantage”. 

4
4
Tumic
Posts
2782
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall SE
1/14/2024 1:19am
aeffertz wrote:
You’re telling me you can’t tell the difference between a rider going off track and reentering in the same position vs. a rider going off track...

You’re telling me you can’t tell the difference between a rider going off track and reentering in the same position vs. a rider going off track, skipping obstacles and making a pass?  You’re the only person mentioning “an advantage”. 

In saying that you should re-enter the track where you got off (if possible) not ride beside it and re-enter it and not get a penalty just because ju re enter in the same position as you were when you got of track, but possible gained two seconds in time.

you can either try to understand or try to misunderstand. It’s clear that you choose the later one.

4
6
Yz450fkid
Posts
316
Joined
11/18/2023
Location
Toronto, ON CA
1/14/2024 2:02am
Boomslang wrote:
Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track. Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no...

Exactly, Friese gained a position whilst cutting the track.

Hunter went off the side of the whoops twice and never gained position or time. So no penalty was given.

 

Tumic wrote:
I never buy in to the ”gain an advantage” thing. the same second you get off the track and earn a tenth doing it you have...

I never buy in to the ”gain an advantage” thing.

the same second you get off the track and earn a tenth doing it you have gained an advantage even if you kept your position.

in US people seem to focus on the position when riders go of the track, not time gained/lost. Against the other riders on track that went through the section as you should.

 

Yup.

The issue I have is if you fuck up. Your ment to lose time. Riders ride along the track side and re-enter just behind where they are. So they only lose 2 seconds of time instead of 30.

The biggest case of this happening was mxon Italy a couple years ago. Alessandro lupino came into the 1st corner about 7th had a massive moment. Went off track and re-entered in the 3rd corner in 6th and got a tiny penalty. He should have come out in last. He negated his mistake by cutting the track and returning in his position. To me that's gaining an advantage coz he should have been last.

We need stop boxes or something so you actually lose time when going off track.

If you exit the track you either have to re-enter where you left. 

Or you have to come to a complete stop for like 3 seconds before re-entering. 

So often you see guys cruise a whole section so they don't lose time from there mistake.

13
2
Jdog2221
Posts
520
Joined
12/27/2021
Location
Burgettstown, PA US
1/14/2024 2:23am

IMG 1207 0.jpeg?VersionId=AbDVnbbjpt NvrIxZGfwjJj

4
3
Tumic
Posts
2782
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall SE
1/14/2024 2:57am
Yz450fkid wrote:
Yup. The issue I have is if you fuck up. Your ment to lose time. Riders ride along the track side and re-enter just behind where...

Yup.

The issue I have is if you fuck up. Your ment to lose time. Riders ride along the track side and re-enter just behind where they are. So they only lose 2 seconds of time instead of 30.

The biggest case of this happening was mxon Italy a couple years ago. Alessandro lupino came into the 1st corner about 7th had a massive moment. Went off track and re-entered in the 3rd corner in 6th and got a tiny penalty. He should have come out in last. He negated his mistake by cutting the track and returning in his position. To me that's gaining an advantage coz he should have been last.

We need stop boxes or something so you actually lose time when going off track.

If you exit the track you either have to re-enter where you left. 

Or you have to come to a complete stop for like 3 seconds before re-entering. 

So often you see guys cruise a whole section so they don't lose time from there mistake.

F1 have got this. If you go of track in some places ypu need to follow a certain route through a chicane and if you don’t do that you will end up with a time penalty.

2
1/14/2024 3:53am

Dangerous racer and a multiple cheat. 
He must be the dumbest fucker ever, cause he never learns. 

6
6
davistld01
Posts
9233
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Springfield, MO US
1/14/2024 5:13am

Dangerous racer and a multiple cheat. 
He must be the dumbest fucker ever, cause he never learns. 

If you absolutely don’t GAF, how would you ever “learn”? 

1
2
1/14/2024 5:18am
aeffertz wrote:
You’re telling me you can’t tell the difference between a rider going off track and reentering in the same position vs. a rider going off track...

You’re telling me you can’t tell the difference between a rider going off track and reentering in the same position vs. a rider going off track, skipping obstacles and making a pass?  You’re the only person mentioning “an advantage”. 

Tumic wrote:
In saying that you should re-enter the track where you got off (if possible) not ride beside it and re-enter it and not get a penalty...

In saying that you should re-enter the track where you got off (if possible) not ride beside it and re-enter it and not get a penalty just because ju re enter in the same position as you were when you got of track, but possible gained two seconds in time.

you can either try to understand or try to misunderstand. It’s clear that you choose the later one.

Exactly, all the talk about wear and tear on the bikes. Energy saved by skipping whoops twice must have been nice. They removed the whoops because they were too tough to do for the mains. I like how RC said Hunter needed to find a new line thru the whoops because he kept going off track...pshhhh Hunter found the fastest line ha. 

7
1
Jack_4196
Posts
256
Joined
7/22/2015
Location
Franklin, MA US
1/14/2024 6:50am

Love that for Vince 

1
1
EuroGuy39
Posts
332
Joined
7/19/2014
Location
FI
1/14/2024 7:04am

Friese has scored 0 points this year, yikes

731chopper
Posts
4224
Joined
1/2/2015
Location
DFW, TX US
1/14/2024 7:11am
Yz450fkid wrote:
Yup. The issue I have is if you fuck up. Your ment to lose time. Riders ride along the track side and re-enter just behind where...

Yup.

The issue I have is if you fuck up. Your ment to lose time. Riders ride along the track side and re-enter just behind where they are. So they only lose 2 seconds of time instead of 30.

The biggest case of this happening was mxon Italy a couple years ago. Alessandro lupino came into the 1st corner about 7th had a massive moment. Went off track and re-entered in the 3rd corner in 6th and got a tiny penalty. He should have come out in last. He negated his mistake by cutting the track and returning in his position. To me that's gaining an advantage coz he should have been last.

We need stop boxes or something so you actually lose time when going off track.

If you exit the track you either have to re-enter where you left. 

Or you have to come to a complete stop for like 3 seconds before re-entering. 

So often you see guys cruise a whole section so they don't lose time from there mistake.

I agree with you whole heartedly.

1
1/14/2024 7:39am

Maybe they should change the rule that you cannot re-enter the track before at least 1 person passes you, or a flat 3 seconds added to your overall race time. However IF you were forced off the track by another rider it does not apply. Clearly we can all agree you're not supposed to go off the track and going off the track is a mistake. We can all agree a mistake should mean you're not as fast as if you're mistake free. 

4
1
OldPro277
Posts
1875
Joined
11/9/2009
Location
Avonmore, PA US
1/14/2024 7:49am

Dangerous racer and a multiple cheat. 
He must be the dumbest fucker ever, cause he never learns. 

Oh, Vince has  “learned “— he’s learned that he usually gets away with it.  After all these years of pulling sketchy, dangerous shit , he STILL has a ride and gets paid. 

4
3
7eleven
Posts
655
Joined
8/20/2012
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
1/14/2024 7:54am
aeffertz wrote:
Apparently Vince gained a position when he went off track and got back on.    And come to think of it, I swear we seen him...

Apparently Vince gained a position when he went off track and got back on. 
 

And come to think of it, I swear we seen him do something like that just a couple months ago!

He made some off track passes at the GH 2 stroke national 10 years ago. The DQ’ed him for the day, it was great. 

1
plowboy
Posts
14173
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS US
1/14/2024 8:01am
EuroGuy39 wrote:

Friese has scored 0 points this year, yikes

But does the "rule" say he will be in "B" group next week?WoohooSilly

3
1
rstaichi
Posts
259
Joined
1/4/2009
Location
Everett, WA US
1/14/2024 8:18am

If I was team guy that got 5th in 450 lcq I would have complained about #51. He passed two guys when he went off the track and got back on. 
even though RC said “ he did that perfectly and got back on with out passing anyone “😂

3
1
1/14/2024 8:30am

Did Hunta get a penalty? He apparently doesn't like whoops. I figure the AMA will have a "revised" rulebook by the end of the year to accommodate the royal Lawrence family.

Some guy on Instagram said they said "Jett" over 600 times in both Race day and the actual broadcast....WTH 

9
7

Post a reply to: Friese Penalty

The Latest