Pulp fantasy

Toste
Posts
466
Joined
5/24/2009
Location
Pahrump, NV US
Fantasy
12/31/2023 9:16am
Metz wrote:
So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look...

So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look at any other means for geolocation determination? 
Cause from what I was just googling, it seems like a lot of gambling sites use software to detect VPN location fraud

I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them.Whistling I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation to police any geolocation shenanigans by their user base? Also, as some others have mentioned, it would a real legal dilemma trying to collect on prizes.

12/31/2023 9:18am
Metz wrote:
So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look...

So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look at any other means for geolocation determination? 
Cause from what I was just googling, it seems like a lot of gambling sites use software to detect VPN location fraud

FWIW I tried (not very hard) from Canada with a VPN to California. With location services turned off it wouldn’t let me do anything, with location services turned on it says participation is unavailable due to my location. 

3
EcoSX478
Posts
319
Joined
10/15/2014
Location
Bernardston, MA US
12/31/2023 9:32am

I’m in Massachusetts, tried VPNs from acceptable states without any luck. I’m assuming geolocation is coming from GPS and not from IP address which a VPN would change.

In that case a geolocation location spoofing software is what’s needed. From what I’ve read, they were commonly used by Pokémon Go players.

Can anyone confirm that VPN alone will or will not work? Anyone actually use geo spoofing apps?

 

1
stremme12
Posts
1220
Joined
3/10/2015
Location
HA, HI US
12/31/2023 10:38am
Metz wrote:
So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look...

So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look at any other means for geolocation determination? 
Cause from what I was just googling, it seems like a lot of gambling sites use software to detect VPN location fraud

shiftmx_22 wrote:
FWIW I tried (not very hard) from Canada with a VPN to California. With location services turned off it wouldn’t let me do anything, with location...

FWIW I tried (not very hard) from Canada with a VPN to California. With location services turned off it wouldn’t let me do anything, with location services turned on it says participation is unavailable due to my location. 

Sign ups aren't open yet. 

The Shop

12/31/2023 10:45am
yak651 wrote:

lol, yeah the Indians never got screwed over, how dare they reap some benefits of being corralled onto a reservation!

LungButter wrote:
They didn't get screwed over, they lost a war.  That's the way the world works. 5-6 generations later they aren't corralled onto any reservations, they just...

They didn't get screwed over, they lost a war.  That's the way the world works.

5-6 generations later they aren't corralled onto any reservations, they just use the reservations to their benefit to do shit the rest of us can't and make huge profits off it.

If you're such a sympathizer to losers of wars should we go back and make it "right" with regards to every war in history?  Italy owes all of Europe some serious shit for what the Romans did right?  Fuckin' Mongolia better pay up too, lord knows they caused some serious fucking destruction.  Should we keep paying taxes to the British, I mean we really screwed them over by winning the Revolutionary War right?

*I'm not gonna post on this anymore and derail this thread with my hot take, I think everyone knows where I stand* Tongue

These white knights on here know only to defend Indians. They have no Idea that different Indian tribes killed and raped and murdered other Indian tribes...

These white knights on here know only to defend Indians. They have no Idea that different Indian tribes killed and raped and murdered other Indian tribes for land. They have been trained to think that if white folk do it, its bad. 

IMG 7614.jpeg?VersionId=YSzhaShyUUeBNWqy

1
17
12/31/2023 10:47am
Toste wrote:
I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them. I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation...

I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them.Whistling I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation to police any geolocation shenanigans by their user base? Also, as some others have mentioned, it would a real legal dilemma trying to collect on prizes.

I don’t care about prizes I just want an excuse to yell at Steve and Marx in the dashboard chat 

6
2
tuttle425
Posts
2152
Joined
8/5/2020
Location
Prairie Village, KS US
12/31/2023 12:38pm
Metz wrote:
So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look...

So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look at any other means for geolocation determination? 
Cause from what I was just googling, it seems like a lot of gambling sites use software to detect VPN location fraud

Toste wrote:
I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them. I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation...

I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them.Whistling I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation to police any geolocation shenanigans by their user base? Also, as some others have mentioned, it would a real legal dilemma trying to collect on prizes.

Most sites that do geofencing block known VPNs but there are ways around it. You can use an obfuscated VPN which most services offer. You can also make your own VPN on a virtual private server based in a data center in an allowed state. 
 

However, as someone mentioned before, you still have to sign up and pay and if your address is in a non permitted state you won’t be able to sign up. 

mxracer71
Posts
490
Joined
7/1/2017
Location
Queen Creek, AZ US
12/31/2023 5:50pm

Seems like way too much to play illegally. I’ve played since day one and it sucks I can’t play with all my buddies and talk shit on a sat morning. At least my wife dosent have to hear me yell and bitch at the tv or her telling me “ see I told you to pick him”! 

5
Spooner
Posts
2443
Joined
1/8/2011
Location
Kansas City, MO US
12/31/2023 8:24pm

I'm another one that doesn't care at all about the prizes and would gladly still pay.

4
1
RG437
Posts
368
Joined
2/5/2023
Location
Leicester GB
1/1/2024 3:17am
philG wrote:

Land of the Free. 

This is the most hilarious and ironic thing about this whole debacle 

8
1
1/1/2024 4:13am

For Michigan I believe its $10,000 first time license 5,000 per year after. 

Without knowing the true paid player count I cant imagine its "worth it" to just break even after dealing with the gov, server geolocating BS, ect ect, 

 

The only way I can see this working is for the crew to "Sell"  PulpMX Fantasy to a larger company that already pays the fees in all states, and have a contract with said larger company to provide promotion, maintenance, and day to day operations for the game.  Vegas Sports Inc is just one company that is registered in Michigan and I would imagine all states. 

Links:

 

https://www.michigan.gov/mgcb/-/media/Project/Websites/mgcb/Internet-Ga…

 

https://www.michigan.gov/mgcb/-/media/Project/Websites/mgcb/Internet-Ga…

4
8tensolutions
Posts
3334
Joined
11/15/2009
Location
Salt Lake City, UT US
1/1/2024 7:32am
Metz wrote:
So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look...

So I know there’s a bunch of people saying just use a VPN. Anyone confirm that it will work with just a VPN? It won’t look at any other means for geolocation determination? 
Cause from what I was just googling, it seems like a lot of gambling sites use software to detect VPN location fraud

Toste wrote:
I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them. I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation...

I would be surprised if using a VPN would work. I happen to know that DraftKings blocks using them.Whistling I imagine fantasy operators are under legal obligation to police any geolocation shenanigans by their user base? Also, as some others have mentioned, it would a real legal dilemma trying to collect on prizes.

tuttle425 wrote:
Most sites that do geofencing block known VPNs but there are ways around it. You can use an obfuscated VPN which most services offer. You can...

Most sites that do geofencing block known VPNs but there are ways around it. You can use an obfuscated VPN which most services offer. You can also make your own VPN on a virtual private server based in a data center in an allowed state. 
 

However, as someone mentioned before, you still have to sign up and pay and if your address is in a non permitted state you won’t be able to sign up. 

They don't care about your address.  It will all be based on location services at the time you pick your Team.

2
1/1/2024 9:19am
For Michigan I believe its $10,000 first time license 5,000 per year after.  Without knowing the true paid player count I cant imagine its "worth it"...

For Michigan I believe its $10,000 first time license 5,000 per year after. 

Without knowing the true paid player count I cant imagine its "worth it" to just break even after dealing with the gov, server geolocating BS, ect ect, 

 

The only way I can see this working is for the crew to "Sell"  PulpMX Fantasy to a larger company that already pays the fees in all states, and have a contract with said larger company to provide promotion, maintenance, and day to day operations for the game.  Vegas Sports Inc is just one company that is registered in Michigan and I would imagine all states. 

Links:

 

https://www.michigan.gov/mgcb/-/media/Project/Websites/mgcb/Internet-Ga…

 

https://www.michigan.gov/mgcb/-/media/Project/Websites/mgcb/Internet-Ga…

Not a terrible idea honestly. I wonder how much money they would need to accrue for a bigger company to come in and want to do business with them? 🤔 Some of those fees are no joke though, it would have to be a pretty big company who understands the business model to take that chance and work with Pulp. I would gladly pay more if that was the deciding factor. 

3
crusher773
Posts
2010
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Coweta, OK US
1/1/2024 6:30pm

Has anyone been able to sign up yet in states it's a go?  I'm in OK and I keep getting a no pricing options available at this time message.

1
Moto_Geek
Posts
1824
Joined
6/26/2007
Location
Golden, CO US
1/1/2024 9:50pm
McG194 wrote:
Can't wait to hear everyone bitching about Pulp. I'm sure they are doing everything they can to get everyone able to play. I don't think most...

Can't wait to hear everyone bitching about Pulp. I'm sure they are doing everything they can to get everyone able to play. I don't think most people realize what a cash cow PulpMX Fantasy was. Ten thousand plus people in the paid league and most prizes are donated or heavily subsidized, trust me they want it open for everyone. 

We can all speculate. But as a web app developer, I would say half of their cost is easily hosting and staff to manage the platform and prize operations. Sure the banner ads and mentions in broadcast help too. 

1
McG194
Posts
4113
Joined
9/7/2017
Location
Palm Coast, FL US
1/2/2024 5:36am Edited Date/Time 1/2/2024 5:38am
First off, Uncle  Marx is awesome, nothing against Steve and friends...that being said... ....I do not get how Pulpmxfantasy is gambling and thus falls under gambling...

First off, Uncle  Marx is awesome, nothing against Steve and friends...that being said...

....I do not get how Pulpmxfantasy is gambling and thus falls under gambling restrictions.

I pay $40 to COMPETE against other people for prizes. Its a COMPETITION.

Its no different than if I am a local pro mxer and sign up and race to compete against other pros for an mx purse! If I am an amateur and  sign up at a local track to race and all I get is a trophee, how is this different then the $40 I pay to Pulp to maybe get a set of tires?

 

EcoSX478 wrote:
Not gambling. Falls under fantasy sports which is now and has been regulated on a state by state basis for some time.   Not surprising...

Not gambling. Falls under fantasy sports which is now and has been regulated on a state by state basis for some time.
 

Not surprising . When there’s money to be made, there’s money to be collected by our government. Some politician(s) likely sent cease and desist letters out to fantasy company’s that didn’t pay the license fee to operate legally.

Unfortunately, they caught on to us.

You got one of the keys of the whole situation, once the government figures out that someone is making money, and they can get a cut you can bet they will be along shortly.

Meanwhile people are mad at Pulp and not the government.  Baaaaa baaaaa baaaa

9
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID US
1/2/2024 9:04am

4:28 seconds into the Pulp Renthal Reaction Podcast.....one of the first hurdles Steve mentions is Indian Casinos....the things that make you go hmmmmmm

2
9
Toste
Posts
466
Joined
5/24/2009
Location
Pahrump, NV US
Fantasy
1/2/2024 9:28am
LungButter wrote:

4:28 seconds into the Pulp Renthal Reaction Podcast.....one of the first hurdles Steve mentions is Indian Casinos....the things that make you go hmmmmmm

It's a shame because it's not like the casinos (Indian or otherwise) even offer a competing alternative product to Pulpfantasy. I guess it really does come down to state governments pouncing on an opportunity to charge licensing fees?

3
Spooner
Posts
2443
Joined
1/8/2011
Location
Kansas City, MO US
1/2/2024 9:38am

I wonder if they can just make it an option to play and not receive any prizes in the states that are not working?

1/2/2024 10:13am
Spooner wrote:

I wonder if they can just make it an option to play and not receive any prizes in the states that are not working?

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free. It cannot be both. 

Spooner
Posts
2443
Joined
1/8/2011
Location
Kansas City, MO US
1/2/2024 10:34am
The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free...

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free. It cannot be both. 

Right, pay to play but no prizes. Aren’t the prizes the issue?

1
1911
Posts
4953
Joined
4/2/2008
Location
LAS VEGAS, NV US
1/2/2024 10:36am
Spooner wrote:

I wonder if they can just make it an option to play and not receive any prizes in the states that are not working?

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free...

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free. It cannot be both. 

That is not what I took from the podcast. I took even if it is free, once prizes are given out, it is considered gambling. I could be wrong though?

EcoSX478
Posts
319
Joined
10/15/2014
Location
Bernardston, MA US
1/2/2024 10:40am
Spooner wrote:

I wonder if they can just make it an option to play and not receive any prizes in the states that are not working?

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free...

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free. It cannot be both. 

1911 wrote:
That is not what I took from the podcast. I took even if it is free, once prizes are given out, it is considered gambling. I...

That is not what I took from the podcast. I took even if it is free, once prizes are given out, it is considered gambling. I could be wrong though?

I believe if it’s free to enter but prizes are awarded it’s considered a sweepstakes..? Im assuming that’s how RMFantasy operates. 

1/2/2024 10:45am
The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free...

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free. It cannot be both. 

Spooner wrote:

Right, pay to play but no prizes. Aren’t the prizes the issue?

I don’t believe the prizes are the issue. It’s not mentioned on pulp fantasy’s insta post. If prizes were the issue, would RMATV still be allowed to host a fantasy game? 🤔

Spooner
Posts
2443
Joined
1/8/2011
Location
Kansas City, MO US
1/2/2024 10:47am

Yeah I understand that. I was just thinking if they did the opposite of RM and charged but gave you the option to not take prizes that maybe that would be a loophole they could explore. 

1
1/2/2024 10:50am
Spooner wrote:

I wonder if they can just make it an option to play and not receive any prizes in the states that are not working?

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free...

The way they described it on the renthal reaction podcast was they either have to be a pay to play or it has to be free. It cannot be both. 

1911 wrote:
That is not what I took from the podcast. I took even if it is free, once prizes are given out, it is considered gambling. I...

That is not what I took from the podcast. I took even if it is free, once prizes are given out, it is considered gambling. I could be wrong though?

Just did a quick re-listen to Marx explaining it. 
 

He says verbatim: “You can’t mix paid and free players and as soon as you have someone paying money into a contest to win something of monetary value in return, that contest becomes a paid contest. It doesn’t matter if someone is involved in it that did not pay.” 
 

Bit confusing but if it was free to play with prizes, it’s a sweepstakes not a contest. 

3
disbanded
Posts
6886
Joined
8/26/2007
Location
Evergreen, CO US
1/2/2024 10:57am Edited Date/Time 1/2/2024 11:03am

The fees for Colorado say it's free if under 7500 people are playing.  $7500 for more than 7500 players.

I wonder why Colorado doesn't get to play, I seriously doubt there are more than 7500 players in the state.

Edit:  could be they didn't get the licensing done in time...

 

1
1/2/2024 11:04am
disbanded wrote:
The fees for Colorado say it's free if under 7500 people are playing.  $7500 for more than 7500 players. I wonder why Colorado doesn't get to...

The fees for Colorado say it's free if under 7500 people are playing.  $7500 for more than 7500 players.

I wonder why Colorado doesn't get to play, I seriously doubt there are more than 7500 players in the state.

Edit:  could be they didn't get the licensing done in time...

 

Curious how many people were playing worldwide now? It must have been pretty high for uncle sam to come knocking on the door. Colorado has a pretty big moto scene but 7500 does seem like a lot. 

RichieW13
Posts
2419
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA US
1/2/2024 11:07am
Curious how many people were playing worldwide now? It must have been pretty high for uncle sam to come knocking on the door. Colorado has a...

Curious how many people were playing worldwide now? It must have been pretty high for uncle sam to come knocking on the door. Colorado has a pretty big moto scene but 7500 does seem like a lot. 

It looks like a little over 10,000 in 2023.

 

2022 had a little over 6,000.  Impressive growth

2
EcoSX478
Posts
319
Joined
10/15/2014
Location
Bernardston, MA US
1/2/2024 11:14am
disbanded wrote:
The fees for Colorado say it's free if under 7500 people are playing.  $7500 for more than 7500 players. I wonder why Colorado doesn't get to...

The fees for Colorado say it's free if under 7500 people are playing.  $7500 for more than 7500 players.

I wonder why Colorado doesn't get to play, I seriously doubt there are more than 7500 players in the state.

Edit:  could be they didn't get the licensing done in time...

 

Curious how many people were playing worldwide now? It must have been pretty high for uncle sam to come knocking on the door. Colorado has a...

Curious how many people were playing worldwide now? It must have been pretty high for uncle sam to come knocking on the door. Colorado has a pretty big moto scene but 7500 does seem like a lot. 

I’d assume it’s based on total players in the game. Not specific to total users in Colorado.

Post a reply to: Pulp fantasy

The Latest