Yz250f "mini 450 torque feeling"?

mike44
Posts
120
Joined
8/20/2022
Location
FR

Hi everyone,

Lot of  of Rider or shootout says that this bike is really strong down low and that the power IS almost like a mini 450! For some It has great high end and for other you have to shift really quickly (quite confusing...).

I ran a Gear ratio online calculator to compare it to a 250 SXF (2024) and found that the Yamaha IS crazy short geared comparedto the KTM.

I did a math mistake or Is It really so short geared?

Ps: the main difference between the two Brans seems to Come from the primary Gear ratio.

 

2
|
11/23/2023 3:41am

The straight shot intake definitely helps with the torque factor. 

1
2
grunkster
Posts
442
Joined
12/2/2014
Location
Rochester, MN, USA
11/23/2023 5:58am

Where the heck are the 24's?! (Or ANY yams really) at the dealers?! They seem to have lost their way.

2
mike44
Posts
120
Joined
8/20/2022
Location
FR
11/23/2023 10:06am
Rickyisms wrote:

The straight shot intake definitely helps with the torque factor. 

Yes but when you look AT dyno data the Yamaha is one of thé 250f with less power and torque....

3
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
11/23/2023 10:43am
Rickyisms wrote:

The straight shot intake definitely helps with the torque factor. 

mike44 wrote:

Yes but when you look AT dyno data the Yamaha is one of thé 250f with less power and torque....

So is the super short gearing just masking this and another bike geared like this would be even more 'mini 450' than a Yam? Presumably why the Yam signs off early and needs a fair amount of shifting? The KTM revs out all day by comparison right?

I remember running an 2.5 BMW engine with a 1.8 4 cylinder gearbox and rear end and it felt wayyy torque-ier than a regular 2.5, due to it pulling so easily with the crazy low gearing.

The Shop

mike44
Posts
120
Joined
8/20/2022
Location
FR
11/23/2023 1:58pm Edited Date/Time 11/23/2023 2:40pm
Rickyisms wrote:

The straight shot intake definitely helps with the torque factor. 

mike44 wrote:

Yes but when you look AT dyno data the Yamaha is one of thé 250f with less power and torque....

Richy wrote:
So is the super short gearing just masking this and another bike geared like this would be even more 'mini 450' than a Yam? Presumably why...

So is the super short gearing just masking this and another bike geared like this would be even more 'mini 450' than a Yam? Presumably why the Yam signs off early and needs a fair amount of shifting? The KTM revs out all day by comparison right?

I remember running an 2.5 BMW engine with a 1.8 4 cylinder gearbox and rear end and it felt wayyy torque-ier than a regular 2.5, due to it pulling so easily with the crazy low gearing.

Not sure but It seems that a weaker engine that feel stronger on the dirt do not make sense ...i used this : https://www.blocklayer.com/rpm-gear-bikes

I Will try with other brand. 

wrc777
Posts
3211
Joined
5/21/2020
Location
Greenwood, IN, USA
Fantasy
11/23/2023 3:43pm

Ktm has 14/51 sprockets stock. You need 13/49 to get 3rd gear close to the Yamaha. Someone would have to test both back to back to tell for sure. The ktm (and Honda and Kawasaki) have higher rev limits than the Yamaha so that plus the gearing will let it rev out further. 

JB 19
Posts
4342
Joined
3/8/2009
Location
Marion, OH, USA
11/23/2023 3:58pm

The yamaha 250F power advantage isn't what it used to be.   Other brands have caught up.   

3
11/23/2023 4:39pm

I'll comment FWIW - i have a 23 450 yz and for shits and giggles (I'm getting older) just bought YZ250f for the days i don't feel like getting my arms stretched..... 2nd gear is strong AF but it's short for sure, 2nd rips but u need to be ready for 3rd real quick. Having said this - i'm a big guy 6'7" so not light by any means and this little 250'f can get around corners in 3rd....with the odd flick of the clutch required. I only have a few months on it but for sure i want to try one down on the rear. But if i had to guess on gut feeling........the OP 1st post is correct, the other bikes would maybe feel the same way if geared like the YZ. I'm curious what the majority run for gearing - stock is short for sure right up to 5th  

1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
11/23/2023 6:12pm

Dyno's do not indicate part throttle performance.

5
2
FGR01
Posts
6129
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
Fantasy
11/23/2023 7:59pm

Comparing gearing between bikes.....

There's this thing called a transmission,  Perhaps you've heard of it.

5
mike44
Posts
120
Joined
8/20/2022
Location
FR
11/24/2023 1:40am
FGR01 wrote:

Comparing gearing between bikes.....

There's this thing called a transmission,  Perhaps you've heard of it.

In the software you enter the primary transmission ratio,  Gears ratio AND secondary transmission ratio.

Between SXF and yzf the most drastic change IS in the primary one that you Can t even match by chaging your sprockets...

Heavyhitter
Posts
346
Joined
3/20/2023
Location
Machias, WA, USA
11/24/2023 2:57pm

A bike on the rollers and a bike under you on the dirt are two totally different things. 

The yzf intake setup along with the way the throttle response feels very torquey 

I would go ride one, the dyno graph doesn't mean a whole lot to us average joes lol

4
Bboyce536
Posts
28
Joined
11/30/2022
Location
Jackson, MI, USA
11/24/2023 11:38pm

Had a 21 yz250f and went to a 22.5 rockstar husky. The husky is stronger everywhere. I had to shift the yz all the time compared to the austrian bike. Off idle on the yam was aggressive and snappy which gave it an exciting character, but as a race engine, it was lacking. 

1
Xracer
Posts
527
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/25/2023 6:00am Edited Date/Time 11/25/2023 6:04am

I went from a KTM 350SX to a new YZ250F and the first thing I noticed was how short the gearing is. The first 3 gears..you almost can't shift fast enough. 5th on the Yamaha is like 3rd on the KTM. But it handles nice, has nice forks. Looks way more roached at 25 hours than the KTM looked at 100 and KTM air filter maintenance instantly wrecked it for everyone else, but I still like the blue bike. I wish Yamaha would build a 350 with KTM's magic mix of rev ceiling, torque & gearing. I'd just give my yamaha card to the local dealer and tell them to deliver me one every spring. 

2
user760a
Posts
1206
Joined
9/15/2008
Location
Shelby, NC, USA
11/25/2023 6:23pm Edited Date/Time 11/25/2023 6:24pm
Xracer wrote:
I went from a KTM 350SX to a new YZ250F and the first thing I noticed was how short the gearing is. The first 3 gears..you...

I went from a KTM 350SX to a new YZ250F and the first thing I noticed was how short the gearing is. The first 3 gears..you almost can't shift fast enough. 5th on the Yamaha is like 3rd on the KTM. But it handles nice, has nice forks. Looks way more roached at 25 hours than the KTM looked at 100 and KTM air filter maintenance instantly wrecked it for everyone else, but I still like the blue bike. I wish Yamaha would build a 350 with KTM's magic mix of rev ceiling, torque & gearing. I'd just give my yamaha card to the local dealer and tell them to deliver me one every spring. 

Oh No no no. 

We cannot have a Japanese 350. it would ruin 450 sales, right??

The Japanese are just too smart to build a 350. Forget that it is what people want, and sells huge for the market leader, KTM.

 

a side note- if the 350 actually does hurt 450 sales a great deal, is that not proof enough that it is a viable product with considerable demand?????

adamw21
Posts
224
Joined
12/14/2020
Location
Martin, TN, USA
11/25/2023 8:20pm

I bought a 22 yz250f and came from a 21 kx250 that was +1 on the rear. I felt the same as most in this thread. 1-3 is way to short on the yz. Went to 14/50 on the yz and wow !! Whole new bike. You can actually ride in 2-3 now. Turned the 3 speed bike into a 4 speed bike 

1
MXer391
Posts
427
Joined
2/10/2014
Location
Altoona, PA, USA
11/27/2023 9:26am

I catch heat for this but every time I ride a YZ250F,  I really don't like the motor because I have to shift so much. I ride 350's so I'm used to taller gearing and long pulling power. I've tried to talk myself into one several times but I can't get around how quick you blow through the gears. Going to a 14 countershaft sprocket is an interesting change.

1
AH387
Posts
1668
Joined
8/29/2019
Location
Bridgeville, PA, USA
11/27/2023 9:37am

There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared feel. Also, it just doesn't seem to rev as sharply, but it does pull forever and is a rocket up top. 350s are similar. So I do think there is something to that. However,  there is no denying the reverse-head w that intake also add to it. Even on the stand, you can just feel how touchy and responsive the bike is. At the Factory level, I'd imagine no stone goes un-turned and it can't be coincidence how that bike shot to the front of the pack w/ Star in '14 (when the engine changed.) It can't just be a gearing thing or it would never transfer over at the Factory level. But it's clear those bikes still have the ability to hit anything out of a corner, but still pull up top with the Redbull KTMs.

1
MXer391
Posts
427
Joined
2/10/2014
Location
Altoona, PA, USA
11/27/2023 11:09am
AH387 wrote:
There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared...

There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared feel. Also, it just doesn't seem to rev as sharply, but it does pull forever and is a rocket up top. 350s are similar. So I do think there is something to that. However,  there is no denying the reverse-head w that intake also add to it. Even on the stand, you can just feel how touchy and responsive the bike is. At the Factory level, I'd imagine no stone goes un-turned and it can't be coincidence how that bike shot to the front of the pack w/ Star in '14 (when the engine changed.) It can't just be a gearing thing or it would never transfer over at the Factory level. But it's clear those bikes still have the ability to hit anything out of a corner, but still pull up top with the Redbull KTMs.

I know it's not an apples to apples comparison but I wonder what gearing Star and ClubMX use.

adamw21
Posts
224
Joined
12/14/2020
Location
Martin, TN, USA
11/28/2023 6:03am
AH387 wrote:
There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared...

There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared feel. Also, it just doesn't seem to rev as sharply, but it does pull forever and is a rocket up top. 350s are similar. So I do think there is something to that. However,  there is no denying the reverse-head w that intake also add to it. Even on the stand, you can just feel how touchy and responsive the bike is. At the Factory level, I'd imagine no stone goes un-turned and it can't be coincidence how that bike shot to the front of the pack w/ Star in '14 (when the engine changed.) It can't just be a gearing thing or it would never transfer over at the Factory level. But it's clear those bikes still have the ability to hit anything out of a corner, but still pull up top with the Redbull KTMs.

MXer391 wrote:

I know it's not an apples to apples comparison but I wonder what gearing Star and ClubMX use.

Last bike check I seen viral do on haidens sx bike this year was 14/50 it’s what I use and I will say if you have a yz trying the 14 front is well worth the 14$ way cheaper then changing a rear and to me made the bike feel so much better no more having to shift all the time or rev the bike and be out of the power. With the 14 it stays in the low/mid and works great 

2
mike44
Posts
120
Joined
8/20/2022
Location
FR
11/28/2023 2:07pm

Litlle update : i  did run the soft again and i probably did a mistake the first time....there is almost no difference in the gearing  of an yzf vs the sxf....Sideways.So except the little  highter rpm range of the KTM, theoretically nothing explain this "short gearing feeling" neither this crazy down low torque.

Maybe the shootout dyno run are bullshit ?Whistling

brocsdad
Posts
922
Joined
8/9/2010
Location
Thompsons Station, TN, USA
11/28/2023 3:02pm
grunkster wrote:

Where the heck are the 24's?! (Or ANY yams really) at the dealers?! They seem to have lost their way.

My son drove from TN to MS and picked his up 3 weeks ago. 8999 OTD

It has a little less low end (depending on maps) and better mid thru top. The forks are not as good as the previous so we had FC re-valve them at Mini O's. The motor is still king of the 250F class but you need to change the maps.

24 YZ 250F.jpg?VersionId=whHI

2
DB505
Posts
731
Joined
12/5/2013
Location
Rowlett, TX, USA
11/28/2023 3:25pm
AH387 wrote:
There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared...

There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared feel. Also, it just doesn't seem to rev as sharply, but it does pull forever and is a rocket up top. 350s are similar. So I do think there is something to that. However,  there is no denying the reverse-head w that intake also add to it. Even on the stand, you can just feel how touchy and responsive the bike is. At the Factory level, I'd imagine no stone goes un-turned and it can't be coincidence how that bike shot to the front of the pack w/ Star in '14 (when the engine changed.) It can't just be a gearing thing or it would never transfer over at the Factory level. But it's clear those bikes still have the ability to hit anything out of a corner, but still pull up top with the Redbull KTMs.

MXer391 wrote:

I know it's not an apples to apples comparison but I wonder what gearing Star and ClubMX use.

I’m sure they use a works tranny

JonnyQuest
Posts
75
Joined
5/4/2011
Location
Jacksonville, FL, USA
9/7/2024 8:57am
AH387 wrote:
There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared...

There is probably something to the OPs claim as the YZF does go through the gears quick. A KTM 250SXF, by comparison,  has a very long-geared feel. Also, it just doesn't seem to rev as sharply, but it does pull forever and is a rocket up top. 350s are similar. So I do think there is something to that. However,  there is no denying the reverse-head w that intake also add to it. Even on the stand, you can just feel how touchy and responsive the bike is. At the Factory level, I'd imagine no stone goes un-turned and it can't be coincidence how that bike shot to the front of the pack w/ Star in '14 (when the engine changed.) It can't just be a gearing thing or it would never transfer over at the Factory level. But it's clear those bikes still have the ability to hit anything out of a corner, but still pull up top with the Redbull KTMs.

MXer391 wrote:

I know it's not an apples to apples comparison but I wonder what gearing Star and ClubMX use.

DB505 wrote:

I’m sure they use a works tranny

Not to drum up an old thread, but from what I'm told is that Yamaha contracts out their tranny's from the same company that makes transmissions for F1 and MotoGP teams. Around $10,000 per transmission. 

A stock trans would probably last about 5 laps ridden by Haiden.

Post a reply to: Yz250f "mini 450 torque feeling"?

The Latest