Class Warfare

Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/3/2023 1:16pm
TDeath21 wrote:
Let me simplify this for you even more. Would you be okay with anyone in college paying 0 taxes whatsoever until they hit the 20K threshold...

Let me simplify this for you even more. Would you be okay with anyone in college paying 0 taxes whatsoever until they hit the 20K threshold of their own money they got to keep by not paying taxes? That’s my entire point. It’s the EXACT SAME result. I’m not sure how you don’t understand that. You are arguing semantics about this and it’s all redundant.

I agree we spend way too much on a lot of things and we could drastically reduce spending and cut taxes for everyone. But wouldn’t you agree it’s super dumb to give the biggest tax breaks to the top 1%? That’s what that point was about.

What year did you do that in? How much have college prices increases relative to general inflation since then? That’s hardly doable anymore.

18 year olds rarely know what they want to do. They often figure that out in college or even in their 20s, 30s, 40s, so forcing all 18 year olds to answer that question and give aid accordingly or deny entry if needed would not work and would 100% be abused and would allow higher income earners to be the ones with a higher chance of going to college.

Titan1 wrote:
I would significantly prefer tax cuts so people can pay for college (or whatever else they freely choose to do with THEIR money), vs. higher taxes...

I would significantly prefer tax cuts so people can pay for college (or whatever else they freely choose to do with THEIR money), vs. higher taxes and then using that tax revenue to pay for student loan (or ppp) forgiveness for people who knowingly took out a loan. 

it's not semantics...at all...one is keep your money...the other is the government taking it and giving it to someone else.  How is that semantics? 

But again, the government is the reason for high tuition rates to begin with (so kids can't work through school any more) because of the risk free, government guaranteed student loans tuition rates have out paced inflation by almost 200%....the government is the problem...and the solution sure as heck isn't more government (higher taxes, government funded student loan forgiveness, etc. etc.).  The solution is to get the government out of student loans...let all the tuition money dry up, and colleges will be forced to reduce tuition rates...then suddenly kids can afford to work their way through school.  

College isn't to help someone figure out what they want to do with their life...if they can't answer that question, I'd advise them to wait to enroll in college until they know what they want to do.  Then if they absolutely NEED college, start at a community college, utilize scholarships and other financial aid, work a job, and if needed borrow as an absolute last resort.  

Anyway...I've said this as slowly, and clearly and as many times as I'm going to say it...if you don't understand it by now you never will...peace!

TDeath21 wrote:
It is definitely semantics. The government deficit is the exact same whether they give huge tax cuts to the ultra wealthy or help out some low-middle...

It is definitely semantics. The government deficit is the exact same whether they give huge tax cuts to the ultra wealthy or help out some low-middle income Americans with just a little relief … so the economy will continue to boom like it currently is. And they already set a precedent about loans with PPP loan forgiveness. Now for the tuition loan forgiveness, only a small amount, 10-20K, one side of the aisle is digging their heels in now. After being perfectly fine with the tax cuts to the top 1% and the PPP loan forgiveness.

The government loans was an attempt to help find a minor solution to a major problem. But without regulation to go along with it, yeah they’re gonna raise tuition and maximize profits. They have to be regulated.

College literally does exactly that for millions of people. Millions of people realize during their gen eds what their passion is and then follow it. Denying that opportunity to millions of lower income Americans seems extremely wrong to me.

What your idea does is force middle and lower income Americans to do X Y Z as well as go to school full time to get through college. While the higher income Americans focus solely on college. The government loans were an attempt to even the playing field, but colleges saw opportunity for profits and took it.

A higher educated society is a better society. Crime drastically decreases as the education level rises. That’s why taxes go to fund public schools. The return of investment is well worth it.

Bye.

Again and again people ignore there is much student aid and grants for poor people as well. Income prevents nobody from going to college in this country. Loan forgiveness is for the people too wealthy to get student aid, not smart enough to get a good paying degree, and not enough foresight to recognize tomorrow's expenses.

2
5
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA US
7/3/2023 1:41pm

Spoon guy what color spoon were you born with in your mouth? Can you see the ground from that high horse you're on?

5
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/3/2023 1:50pm
colintrax wrote:

Spoon guy what color spoon were you born with in your mouth? Can you see the ground from that high horse you're on?

No offense intended friend. I was born quite poor if it matters to you.

1
1
7/3/2023 2:42pm
Spoonguy wrote:

I never went to college, I couldn't grasp the expense. I have done ok.

ToolMaker wrote:
Not the point. The country needs engineers and if you only let kids from well to do families go to college because it's expensive the pool...

Not the point. The country needs engineers and if you only let kids from well to do families go to college because it's expensive the pool of talent goes in the shitter. And quite frankly, you don't know why a kid didn't get a scholarship like your kid. The fact that you were able to pay for your kids expenses over and above what the college paid for, is not the yard stick to measure people by. IF you are even half telling the truth, your kid's time in sports and academics most likely consumed any time that your kid would have had available to work for their first car. There are other life experiences that are important too. But this is not about you and your kid, it's about the idea that if other people don't have your son's recourses they should forgo college. And yes, there are many jobs that will support a comfortable lifestyle. Based on your idea that only wealthy people should go to college, maybe we should start a program that when people are 12 we just tell them they can't ever go to college to chase their dreams, no matter how smart they are, because they don't come from an elitist family that does not have enough $$s

A better idea might be that we stop letting the universities steal so much money from the kids. Does it really cost them $200 per quarter to let the kids park close enough to walk the rest of the way. Fuck them!!!!! That's what they charge. My wife's business is near a university. The university literally had no parking signs put up all around the area so the kids had to pay to park on university parking. Was parking a problem? No, but the university could make more money doing that.

cheers

edited to add a missing word

TDeath21 wrote:
Something must be wrong because we are agreeing. I am not one of those people that believes all college should be free, but any public university...

Something must be wrong because we are agreeing.

I am not one of those people that believes all college should be free, but any public university should 100% be regulated with their tuition fees. Private schools should be able to charge whatever they want. But as a public university, using public tax payer dollars to fund your services, yeah you then accept that the same organization (government) can regulate your profits made off of your tuition prices.

Saying if you can’t afford it don’t go is silly. Should we tell every inner city adolescent in poverty to just stick to being a retail manager or go into a trade? Just eliminated a huge portion of potential future doctors or engineers who are vital to our nation’s future. Not everyone is fortunate enough to have great parents to pay for their college, or be gifted athletically to get it paid for that way, and scholarships are extremely competitive and not everyone who deserves one gets it.

"Something must be wrong because we are agreeing"

Now I have to rethink my entire existence Wink

1
1

The Shop

TeamGreen
Posts
36770
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA US
7/3/2023 9:50pm
TDeath21 wrote:
That’s exactly the point though. The government walked past the mom with a starving child and threw a few hundred dollar bills at the guy as...

That’s exactly the point though. The government walked past the mom with a starving child and threw a few hundred dollar bills at the guy as he pulled his Ferrari into his vacation home. You can try to claim they’re different if you want to but no rational person can think that’s okay. Help none fine. Help both fine. If you’re only going to help one though, it’s obvious what the choice is.

You’re right I’m sure it’s all coincidence that right when Reagan slashed taxes for the top 1%, the wealth gap immediately started widening, now to rates we have not seen since the Gilded Age, and middle class wages stopped keeping up with inflation like they had the previous few decades. Which of course means it’s complete coincidence more people had to take out loans to go to college. All coincidence. Economics 101 bro.

You must be in the top 1% then. Congrats! Either that or you just love being thrown table scraps on the floor for you to eat while the top 1% and major corporations have their all you can eat feast at the dinner table.

Titan1 wrote:
You are getting way off in the weeds... Tax cuts, and government bailouts/handouts aren't the same.  No matter how many times you say it.  One is...

You are getting way off in the weeds...

Tax cuts, and government bailouts/handouts aren't the same.  No matter how many times you say it.  One is keeping money you earn, the other is taking money from one person and giving it to another. 

So to stay on topic, answer this...do you believe the risk free, endless student loans have an affect on tuition rates?  Yes or No? 

Even if middle class wages had kept up with inflation, it wouldn't make a difference when tuition costs are out pacing inflation by 100X's.....Why do you think tuition costs outpace inflation by so much?

TDeath21 wrote:
You are arguing semantics. It’s the exact same result. Would it make you feel better if everyone attending college got an extra 10-20K back on their...

You are arguing semantics. It’s the exact same result. Would it make you feel better if everyone attending college got an extra 10-20K back on their taxes over the course of the next 5-10 years? Or if everyone attending college got an extra 10-20K given to them upon initial enrollment? Or you show your tuition payments and get that money back from the government? (I.e. keeping the money you initially earned)

Yes loans will cause universities to raise prices, which is why I’ve stated multiple times that more needs to be done. Things like regulating how much public universities who get tax payer money can charge in tuition.

But given your other opinions, you would likely be against that as well and the government be hands off. What do you think an 18 year old who can’t pay for college, but wants to go, should do? Loans is their only option currently, unless they are fortunate enough to get a scholarship of some kind. What’s your solution? College only for the rich?

What the actual fuq? 

Is it just me or is this dude in dire need of a fucking mirror? 
Laughing

 

4
6
Joey Bridges
Posts
9358
Joined
1/19/2022
Location
Kingston, TN US
7/4/2023 3:16am
TeamGreen wrote:
What the actual fuq?  Is it just me or is this dude in dire need of a fucking mirror?   

What the actual fuq? 

Is it just me or is this dude in dire need of a fucking mirror? 
Laughing

 

He's got a helluva lot more wrong with him than TDS. 

Hell, maybe it's what they refer to as, long TDS. 

 

It's funny watching him flip and flop around.

Makes a lot of noises, all of it indecipherable.

1
5
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/4/2023 4:23am

Perhaps the student loans are not the real problem but a symptom of a much larger problem. The financial illiteracy of most citizens of this country.

5
4
TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
7/4/2023 6:41am
TeamGreen wrote:
What the actual fuq?  Is it just me or is this dude in dire need of a fucking mirror?   

What the actual fuq? 

Is it just me or is this dude in dire need of a fucking mirror? 
Laughing

 

He's got a helluva lot more wrong with him than TDS.  Hell, maybe it's what they refer to as, long TDS.    It's funny watching him...

He's got a helluva lot more wrong with him than TDS. 

Hell, maybe it's what they refer to as, long TDS. 

 

It's funny watching him flip and flop around.

Makes a lot of noises, all of it indecipherable.

Joe Biden, I told you to stop talking. Seriously dude, you’re making yourself look worse with each letter you attempt to type. Not a good look.

1
12
7/4/2023 9:03am

until the gov stops printing money and we go back to sound money..expect more of this dystopian nonsense

 

5
2
Beazrad
Posts
16
Joined
12/12/2018
Location
Escondido, CA US
7/4/2023 1:49pm

Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books from schools promoting campus life and the “college experience”. Very little information about academics and nothing about career post college. It’s literally marketed like a spring break trip. 
 

When it comes to paying tuition there is an option instead of paying you can automatically add it to a loan. There is zero information on the loan and what it will end up costing them. Colleges should be required to tell kids what their ROI is for their specific degree based on previous graduates at different time points. 
 

If people feel like their loan should be forgiven they should be holding the school accountable, not the taxpayers. 

6
2
7/4/2023 3:09pm
Beazrad wrote:
Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books...

Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books from schools promoting campus life and the “college experience”. Very little information about academics and nothing about career post college. It’s literally marketed like a spring break trip. 
 

When it comes to paying tuition there is an option instead of paying you can automatically add it to a loan. There is zero information on the loan and what it will end up costing them. Colleges should be required to tell kids what their ROI is for their specific degree based on previous graduates at different time points. 
 

If people feel like their loan should be forgiven they should be holding the school accountable, not the taxpayers. 

Soooo spot on. Hold the university responsible not the tax payer.

TM

1
1
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/4/2023 7:00pm
Beazrad wrote:
Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books...

Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books from schools promoting campus life and the “college experience”. Very little information about academics and nothing about career post college. It’s literally marketed like a spring break trip. 
 

When it comes to paying tuition there is an option instead of paying you can automatically add it to a loan. There is zero information on the loan and what it will end up costing them. Colleges should be required to tell kids what their ROI is for their specific degree based on previous graduates at different time points. 
 

If people feel like their loan should be forgiven they should be holding the school accountable, not the taxpayers. 

ToolMaker wrote:

Soooo spot on. Hold the university responsible not the tax payer.

TM

Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to their progress. Let's make the world totally antiseptic to dangers for them. Despite the previous generation saving the world from facism, we should focus on protecting and isolating today's 18-45 year olds from responsibility and any danger. Whatever you do don't make them responsible for their decisions. Let's attack grandma and grandpa's saving so todays kids can "chase their dreams". Since the dawn of time predators have been tempting dipshit kids magic beans for the family cow. If these dumb asses don't waste their money on forensic science degrees it would be spring break, elaborate weddings/ honeymoons, good weed, cool concerts, or "finding themselves". Good lord, let's create perpetual cribs for extended childhoods where nobody pays property tax or any other responsibility until they suffer macular degeneration. Good grief. These poor kids/ young adults/ 40 somethings. So helpless.

1
4
7/4/2023 9:32pm
Beazrad wrote:
Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books...

Having a daughter go to college last year it was eye opening how predatory these colleges were recruiting kids. We were getting hard cover fully color books from schools promoting campus life and the “college experience”. Very little information about academics and nothing about career post college. It’s literally marketed like a spring break trip. 
 

When it comes to paying tuition there is an option instead of paying you can automatically add it to a loan. There is zero information on the loan and what it will end up costing them. Colleges should be required to tell kids what their ROI is for their specific degree based on previous graduates at different time points. 
 

If people feel like their loan should be forgiven they should be holding the school accountable, not the taxpayers. 

ToolMaker wrote:

Soooo spot on. Hold the university responsible not the tax payer.

TM

Spoonguy wrote:
Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to...

Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to their progress. Let's make the world totally antiseptic to dangers for them. Despite the previous generation saving the world from facism, we should focus on protecting and isolating today's 18-45 year olds from responsibility and any danger. Whatever you do don't make them responsible for their decisions. Let's attack grandma and grandpa's saving so todays kids can "chase their dreams". Since the dawn of time predators have been tempting dipshit kids magic beans for the family cow. If these dumb asses don't waste their money on forensic science degrees it would be spring break, elaborate weddings/ honeymoons, good weed, cool concerts, or "finding themselves". Good lord, let's create perpetual cribs for extended childhoods where nobody pays property tax or any other responsibility until they suffer macular degeneration. Good grief. These poor kids/ young adults/ 40 somethings. So helpless.

Did someone piss in your cornflakes this week?

When a kid goes to school they pay money for a product. That product is an education. If the product is a lemon, there should be something called a breach of contract. A civil issue between the buyer and seller. We give loans to people to buy cars so they can get a job and pay for the car. If you buy a car and it's a lemon, it's between you and the dealer. The government does not wipe out your loan. Good God, where did you get such a resentment for other people that want to better themselves? I'm happy you did well but real successful people want educated kids because large companies need new talent to grow their company and wealth.

1
2
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/5/2023 4:21am
ToolMaker wrote:

Soooo spot on. Hold the university responsible not the tax payer.

TM

Spoonguy wrote:
Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to...

Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to their progress. Let's make the world totally antiseptic to dangers for them. Despite the previous generation saving the world from facism, we should focus on protecting and isolating today's 18-45 year olds from responsibility and any danger. Whatever you do don't make them responsible for their decisions. Let's attack grandma and grandpa's saving so todays kids can "chase their dreams". Since the dawn of time predators have been tempting dipshit kids magic beans for the family cow. If these dumb asses don't waste their money on forensic science degrees it would be spring break, elaborate weddings/ honeymoons, good weed, cool concerts, or "finding themselves". Good lord, let's create perpetual cribs for extended childhoods where nobody pays property tax or any other responsibility until they suffer macular degeneration. Good grief. These poor kids/ young adults/ 40 somethings. So helpless.

ToolMaker wrote:
Did someone piss in your cornflakes this week? When a kid goes to school they pay money for a product. That product is an education. If...

Did someone piss in your cornflakes this week?

When a kid goes to school they pay money for a product. That product is an education. If the product is a lemon, there should be something called a breach of contract. A civil issue between the buyer and seller. We give loans to people to buy cars so they can get a job and pay for the car. If you buy a car and it's a lemon, it's between you and the dealer. The government does not wipe out your loan. Good God, where did you get such a resentment for other people that want to better themselves? I'm happy you did well but real successful people want educated kids because large companies need new talent to grow their company and wealth.

So the world doesn't need masons, electricians, plumbers, hivac techs, mechanics, and the thousands and thousands of other good paying jobs that don't need a degree? In my world there are tons of degreed people not able to find jobs in their field, and the majority of the trades are wanting for help desperately. My son is getting his doctorate in engineering soon and teaches, my daughter is a charge nurse in a cardiac ICU, both got through college on academic scholarships with no debt, they state often though what a scam college is for the majority of kids and their coworkers. You and I seem to agree on that point. Judging by enrollments, it seems kids are learning that as well. We seem to disagree on whose responsibility it is to pay for the mistakes made by others though. Thousands and thousands of times a day businessmen and women agree to contracts, if they misjudge their calculations it is their tough shit, and may cost them their business. Life is full of risks people take every day, financial decisions people make that are wrong, do you really think it is societies responsibility to pick and choose which bad decisions to support or fund? Do you really think people who have no student debt, never went to college, never had kids, are retired, veterans, or already employ people they are helping through college should help pay off loans for someone who flunked out of college and is living in mom's basement, chose to pay to live in a dorm rather than commute from home, or chose a college that was twice as expensive as another for the same degree? If not under what conditions do you propose paying off someone else's debt? Whose money do you propose taking to give to whom?

1
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/5/2023 4:24am
ToolMaker wrote:

Soooo spot on. Hold the university responsible not the tax payer.

TM

Spoonguy wrote:
Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to...

Good lord yes, hold anybody accept those that applied for the loans responsible. Lord knows young people shouldn't be prepared or made aware of predators to their progress. Let's make the world totally antiseptic to dangers for them. Despite the previous generation saving the world from facism, we should focus on protecting and isolating today's 18-45 year olds from responsibility and any danger. Whatever you do don't make them responsible for their decisions. Let's attack grandma and grandpa's saving so todays kids can "chase their dreams". Since the dawn of time predators have been tempting dipshit kids magic beans for the family cow. If these dumb asses don't waste their money on forensic science degrees it would be spring break, elaborate weddings/ honeymoons, good weed, cool concerts, or "finding themselves". Good lord, let's create perpetual cribs for extended childhoods where nobody pays property tax or any other responsibility until they suffer macular degeneration. Good grief. These poor kids/ young adults/ 40 somethings. So helpless.

ToolMaker wrote:
Did someone piss in your cornflakes this week? When a kid goes to school they pay money for a product. That product is an education. If...

Did someone piss in your cornflakes this week?

When a kid goes to school they pay money for a product. That product is an education. If the product is a lemon, there should be something called a breach of contract. A civil issue between the buyer and seller. We give loans to people to buy cars so they can get a job and pay for the car. If you buy a car and it's a lemon, it's between you and the dealer. The government does not wipe out your loan. Good God, where did you get such a resentment for other people that want to better themselves? I'm happy you did well but real successful people want educated kids because large companies need new talent to grow their company and wealth.

How  about a more direct question, my kids got through college without debt. Do you think they should have to pay for other kid's debt? Yes or no?

2
7/5/2023 6:22am

Did anyone here suggest we didn't need trades people? Because your kids had their expenses paid by you is not indicative of "normal". Your son obviously has some smarts. If he grew up in the house next door without your resources, should he have been a plumber? Because he didn't have time to apply himself through high-school since he had to work a job? Your kids still incurred costs, those costs were just paid for by you.

In response to your "direct question" about something that's already been answered, I'll repost for your convenience, 

"Disclosure, I was and am against student debt write off. I did however tell my kids do NOT pay on your loans this period because if they are going to hand out money to everyone else you may as well take it too p. Here's the thing, what makes you more valuable than a roofer that has the same struggles? Why should we give you $10k or $20k and not the roofer? What about the parent who worked the last 20 years to save and pay for their kid? Also, most of the money would be given to upper income families anyway. It's pretty disingenuous to argue student loans are bad and then still promote them. Convince me I'm wrong on that. If you want to claim you didn't get your money's worth, make the university refund your debt. They are the ones who took your money. Why should I pay for you? I already ponnied up a shit ton of hard earned $$s for the kids my wife and I brought into this world and call our own."

TM

Now, you answer, should your son have been a plumber because he didn't have your resources to pay his expenses?

1
1
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX US
7/5/2023 6:35am
colintrax wrote:

Spoon guy what color spoon were you born with in your mouth? Can you see the ground from that high horse you're on?

Spoonguy wrote:

No offense intended friend. I was born quite poor if it matters to you.

family with 25,000 acres poor, or parents skipping meals so the chilren can eat poor?

1
APLMAN99
Posts
12288
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
7/5/2023 6:51am

I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as academic learning. 
 

As for the question of whether someone who made it through college without debt should pay for someone else’s debt, I think that is a false perspective. I think that we should all help advance the education of our populace, just like those of us who may not have ever used the services of our local fire department help fund those departments for those who have needed them multiple times. 

2
2
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/5/2023 6:58am
ToolMaker wrote:
Did anyone here suggest we didn't need trades people? Because your kids had their expenses paid by you is not indicative of "normal". Your son obviously...

Did anyone here suggest we didn't need trades people? Because your kids had their expenses paid by you is not indicative of "normal". Your son obviously has some smarts. If he grew up in the house next door without your resources, should he have been a plumber? Because he didn't have time to apply himself through high-school since he had to work a job? Your kids still incurred costs, those costs were just paid for by you.

In response to your "direct question" about something that's already been answered, I'll repost for your convenience, 

"Disclosure, I was and am against student debt write off. I did however tell my kids do NOT pay on your loans this period because if they are going to hand out money to everyone else you may as well take it too p. Here's the thing, what makes you more valuable than a roofer that has the same struggles? Why should we give you $10k or $20k and not the roofer? What about the parent who worked the last 20 years to save and pay for their kid? Also, most of the money would be given to upper income families anyway. It's pretty disingenuous to argue student loans are bad and then still promote them. Convince me I'm wrong on that. If you want to claim you didn't get your money's worth, make the university refund your debt. They are the ones who took your money. Why should I pay for you? I already ponnied up a shit ton of hard earned $$s for the kids my wife and I brought into this world and call our own."

TM

Now, you answer, should your son have been a plumber because he didn't have your resources to pay his expenses?

My kids have had jobs since they were 14, as did I. I have fatherless high school kids working for me grossing over a grand a week. Your notion that young people are powerless with out help from their parents displays your perspective of the topic. 

Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/5/2023 7:00am
APLMAN99 wrote:
I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as...

I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as academic learning. 
 

As for the question of whether someone who made it through college without debt should pay for someone else’s debt, I think that is a false perspective. I think that we should all help advance the education of our populace, just like those of us who may not have ever used the services of our local fire department help fund those departments for those who have needed them multiple times. 

Doesn't a large part of our tax money go to education now? 

2
Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/5/2023 7:05am
colintrax wrote:

Spoon guy what color spoon were you born with in your mouth? Can you see the ground from that high horse you're on?

Spoonguy wrote:

No offense intended friend. I was born quite poor if it matters to you.

family with 25,000 acres poor, or parents skipping meals so the chilren can eat poor?

I don't know if my upbringing is germain to the topic, but your question is. If somebody had ever had any advantage in life it should be confiscated for the greater good because it is unfair is what you are implying. And the definition of advantage can be liquid and a moving target.

1
7/5/2023 7:16am
ToolMaker wrote:
Did anyone here suggest we didn't need trades people? Because your kids had their expenses paid by you is not indicative of "normal". Your son obviously...

Did anyone here suggest we didn't need trades people? Because your kids had their expenses paid by you is not indicative of "normal". Your son obviously has some smarts. If he grew up in the house next door without your resources, should he have been a plumber? Because he didn't have time to apply himself through high-school since he had to work a job? Your kids still incurred costs, those costs were just paid for by you.

In response to your "direct question" about something that's already been answered, I'll repost for your convenience, 

"Disclosure, I was and am against student debt write off. I did however tell my kids do NOT pay on your loans this period because if they are going to hand out money to everyone else you may as well take it too p. Here's the thing, what makes you more valuable than a roofer that has the same struggles? Why should we give you $10k or $20k and not the roofer? What about the parent who worked the last 20 years to save and pay for their kid? Also, most of the money would be given to upper income families anyway. It's pretty disingenuous to argue student loans are bad and then still promote them. Convince me I'm wrong on that. If you want to claim you didn't get your money's worth, make the university refund your debt. They are the ones who took your money. Why should I pay for you? I already ponnied up a shit ton of hard earned $$s for the kids my wife and I brought into this world and call our own."

TM

Now, you answer, should your son have been a plumber because he didn't have your resources to pay his expenses?

Spoonguy wrote:
My kids have had jobs since they were 14, as did I. I have fatherless high school kids working for me grossing over a grand a...

My kids have had jobs since they were 14, as did I. I have fatherless high school kids working for me grossing over a grand a week. Your notion that young people are powerless with out help from their parents displays your perspective of the topic. 

I see you conveniently avoided the question. Should your son have become a plumber had he not had your resources?

1
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX US
7/5/2023 7:19am Edited Date/Time 7/5/2023 7:20am
Spoonguy wrote:

No offense intended friend. I was born quite poor if it matters to you.

family with 25,000 acres poor, or parents skipping meals so the chilren can eat poor?

Spoonguy wrote:
I don't know if my upbringing is germain to the topic, but your question is. If somebody had ever had any advantage in life it should...

I don't know if my upbringing is germain to the topic, but your question is. If somebody had ever had any advantage in life it should be confiscated for the greater good because it is unfair is what you are implying. And the definition of advantage can be liquid and a moving target.

I'm not implying shit, and i'm not even posting about the original thread topic.

 

Earlier you said Bezos came from nothing, which he in fact, did not.

So when you say you also came from nothing, it raises some doubt. 

 

Im just trying to better understand your definition of poor

Spoonguy
Posts
3429
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
7/5/2023 7:22am

Honestly if my kids didn't have scholarships, what is wrong with being a plumber? I am certain neither of my kids would have minded the trades. But they received scholarships and went to college. I am certain they would have chosen a trade if it meant no debt. Who knows, life brings twists, they still might.

2
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA US
7/5/2023 8:06am

How did we get to this notion plumbers didn't go to school after high school?

https://www.shamrockplumbing.net/2020/12/do-you-need-a-college-degree-t…

 

Any trade that pays well is going to be "skilled labor." Which generally means a trade school or 2 year program with some sort of apprenticeship.

 

So again, there's still student loans and debt that come from this.

Titan1
Posts
9410
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
7/5/2023 8:18am
APLMAN99 wrote:
I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as...

I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as academic learning. 
 

As for the question of whether someone who made it through college without debt should pay for someone else’s debt, I think that is a false perspective. I think that we should all help advance the education of our populace, just like those of us who may not have ever used the services of our local fire department help fund those departments for those who have needed them multiple times. 

We already do that in America…k-12 is “free” for any and all children.

 

Do you think Associates degrees should also be free? Bachelors? Masters? Doctorates?  Why do you think “free” k-12 isn’t enough?

2
1
7/5/2023 8:18am
Spoonguy wrote:
Honestly if my kids didn't have scholarships, what is wrong with being a plumber? I am certain neither of my kids would have minded the trades...

Honestly if my kids didn't have scholarships, what is wrong with being a plumber? I am certain neither of my kids would have minded the trades. But they received scholarships and went to college. I am certain they would have chosen a trade if it meant no debt. Who knows, life brings twists, they still might.

See, you didn't answer the question again. So I just have to call Bull Shit on everything you post.

You made it their choice what to do. You couldn't even answer the question and stay consistent with

your own drivel.

TM

1
7/5/2023 8:29am
APLMAN99 wrote:
I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as...

I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as academic learning. 
 

As for the question of whether someone who made it through college without debt should pay for someone else’s debt, I think that is a false perspective. I think that we should all help advance the education of our populace, just like those of us who may not have ever used the services of our local fire department help fund those departments for those who have needed them multiple times. 

Titan1 wrote:
We already do that in America…k-12 is “free” for any and all children.   Do you think Associates degrees should also be free? Bachelors? Masters? Doctorates...

We already do that in America…k-12 is “free” for any and all children.

 

Do you think Associates degrees should also be free? Bachelors? Masters? Doctorates?  Why do you think “free” k-12 isn’t enough?

I think community college is enough of the free. During that time period they can figure out which direction they want to go. But, if they've done decent marks in CC and need financial help to go further, (not free but help) we need to have a path forward. Our country will not be the super power we are in the future with and abundance of plumbers and a shortage of engineers. Why not incentivize a business to sponsor a kid (like Manny's company did), there are many solutions but right now we just give out money like candy. That has to stop. If we give a loan, what's the plan to pay it back? Why do we LET the colleges rip off the kids?

TM

2
2
APLMAN99
Posts
12288
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
7/5/2023 8:39am
APLMAN99 wrote:
I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as...

I look at education, including vocational education, as an investment in our society. I think that we should be investing in apprenticeship programs as well as academic learning. 
 

As for the question of whether someone who made it through college without debt should pay for someone else’s debt, I think that is a false perspective. I think that we should all help advance the education of our populace, just like those of us who may not have ever used the services of our local fire department help fund those departments for those who have needed them multiple times. 

Titan1 wrote:
We already do that in America…k-12 is “free” for any and all children.   Do you think Associates degrees should also be free? Bachelors? Masters? Doctorates...

We already do that in America…k-12 is “free” for any and all children.

 

Do you think Associates degrees should also be free? Bachelors? Masters? Doctorates?  Why do you think “free” k-12 isn’t enough?

That's the difficult part, where do we set the level at?  Either way, it's going to be an arbitrary level.  I don't have a hard and firm answer and obviously there should be some sort of requirement to make meaningful progress towards a finish of some kind.  

I do think that there are areas of the arts and sciences, especially, that may not have as much financial upside as an MBA does but are very beneficial to society as a whole.  In a 'perfect world' scenario, we would do the things we can to make those areas possible for study because of the benefits to society, even if they are harder to measure than your 401K balance, your toilet not being clogged, etc.  

It's definitely not a topic that can be whittled down into a simple 'gotcha' question on a message board, that's for sure.  

3

Post a reply to: Class Warfare

The Latest