AMA Pro Motocross Series Rumored to Add Starting Grates

southeast
Posts
195
Joined
2/24/2023
Location
clearwater, FL, USA
2/28/2023 3:40pm
To truly make the starts and racing more interesting...  Draw numbers for the gate pick. I'm not saying it should be that way or the racers...

To truly make the starts and racing more interesting...  Draw numbers for the gate pick.

I'm not saying it should be that way or the racers would want it that way, but... f#ck man, it would make for some exciting races and level the playing field into the first turn.

Allot of local races do this. You draw straws for first gate. Second gate is off of finish in first.  Always kept it real.

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
2/28/2023 3:50pm
It’s not about skill. It’s about consistency. With grates it’s the same every time, at every gate and at every track. Just takes away from the...

It’s not about skill. It’s about consistency. With grates it’s the same every time, at every gate and at every track. Just takes away from the dynamics. and that being said; it is about skill. The skill needed to know what kind of dirt your starting on, as well as gate pick with the subtleties in the existing rut that’s there. Whether or not your mechanic repacks your gate, the rut that’s there before definitely has an impact. 

Magoofan wrote:
Consistency sure is fun to watch isn't it.... [img]https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--SYMMEHoH--/c_fit%2cfl_progressive%2cq_80%2cw_636/ogdmx18kjqzlm3vrk5st.gif[/img]   I guess we should start using regulation dirt on all tracks too.        

Consistency sure is fun to watch isn't it....

 

I guess we should start using regulation dirt on all tracks too.    

 

I think maybe you did not comprehend my post. I am agreeing with you, grates a stupid.

I got that.   I was just being sarcastic.  Wink

 

1
1
southeast
Posts
195
Joined
2/24/2023
Location
clearwater, FL, USA
2/28/2023 4:12pm
Magoofan wrote:
Consistency sure is fun to watch isn't it.... [img]https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--SYMMEHoH--/c_fit%2cfl_progressive%2cq_80%2cw_636/ogdmx18kjqzlm3vrk5st.gif[/img]   I guess we should start using regulation dirt on all tracks too.        

Consistency sure is fun to watch isn't it....

 

I guess we should start using regulation dirt on all tracks too.    

 

I think maybe you did not comprehend my post. I am agreeing with you, grates a stupid.

Magoofan wrote:

I got that.   I was just being sarcastic.  Wink

 

Mongo lives

1
Juck
Posts
2080
Joined
5/23/2019
Location
AU
Fantasy
2/28/2023 4:37pm
Magoofan wrote:
Consistency sure is fun to watch isn't it.... [img]https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--SYMMEHoH--/c_fit%2cfl_progressive%2cq_80%2cw_636/ogdmx18kjqzlm3vrk5st.gif[/img]   I guess we should start using regulation dirt on all tracks too.        

Consistency sure is fun to watch isn't it....

 

I guess we should start using regulation dirt on all tracks too.    

 

Actually I just sat there for a few minutes watching that robot gif. He's a funny looking feller

1

The Shop

Leave Us To
Posts
1141
Joined
10/21/2015
Location
Rocky River, OH, USA
2/28/2023 5:37pm
McG194 wrote:
I prefer dirt starts but I voted pro-grate. They use them in SX and MXGP so they might as well do the same as the other...

I prefer dirt starts but I voted pro-grate. They use them in SX and MXGP so they might as well do the same as the other top series do. 

So if everyone else is jumping off a cliff, you'd jump to?  :-)  Following the crowd has never been a motivation for me to change so SX and MXGP using starting gates, is not a reason for the Nationals to do the same.

If it ain't broke, don't fix it so unless someone can point to a problem with the current way, "we don't need no stinkin' grates."  

Leave Us To
Posts
1141
Joined
10/21/2015
Location
Rocky River, OH, USA
2/28/2023 5:40pm
To truly make the starts and racing more interesting...  Draw numbers for the gate pick. I'm not saying it should be that way or the racers...

To truly make the starts and racing more interesting...  Draw numbers for the gate pick.

I'm not saying it should be that way or the racers would want it that way, but... f#ck man, it would make for some exciting races and level the playing field into the first turn.

So no qualifying just draw for gate picks?   No way, Jose.

ProKawi24
Posts
2146
Joined
2/20/2018
Location
Herald, CA, USA
2/28/2023 6:23pm

When it comes to starts I'm old school. I just want a simple gate, bike on dirt, nothing else. No holeshot device, no cement pad, no starting grate, no engine mapping or RPM adjuster, no bells whistles and lights to tell you what RPM to be in.  Pick your gate based on 1) Best angle to 1st turn. 2) The rut behind the gate for best traction.  3) The rut in front of the gate to be straight.

5
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
2/28/2023 6:34pm
ProKawi24 wrote:
When it comes to starts I'm old school. I just want a simple gate, bike on dirt, nothing else. No holeshot device, no cement pad, no...

When it comes to starts I'm old school. I just want a simple gate, bike on dirt, nothing else. No holeshot device, no cement pad, no starting grate, no engine mapping or RPM adjuster, no bells whistles and lights to tell you what RPM to be in.  Pick your gate based on 1) Best angle to 1st turn. 2) The rut behind the gate for best traction.  3) The rut in front of the gate to be straight.

Hell yeah....and let's go back to 2-strokes.    They took real skill to ride (powerband).   

 

3
1
2/28/2023 6:48pm Edited Date/Time 2/28/2023 7:01pm

Forget about the starts for a second.  If the goal is to level the playing field should the tracks be made harder or easier?  If they shave down the whoops and take out all the potential quads, what would the racing look like?  Would someone else be leading points now besides Tomac?

Because if your answer is no then I have a hard time supporting the musings of this thread.  The starts should be left traditional.

Convince me why the first turn will be better with a start grate.  I don't see why it logically would be.  I think it would be worse, having a more consistent roster of who is getting the holeshots.  Anyone who claims they want to see the same top 5 people come around the first turn in every race is full of sh!t.   

ProKawi24
Posts
2146
Joined
2/20/2018
Location
Herald, CA, USA
2/28/2023 7:09pm
ProKawi24 wrote:
When it comes to starts I'm old school. I just want a simple gate, bike on dirt, nothing else. No holeshot device, no cement pad, no...

When it comes to starts I'm old school. I just want a simple gate, bike on dirt, nothing else. No holeshot device, no cement pad, no starting grate, no engine mapping or RPM adjuster, no bells whistles and lights to tell you what RPM to be in.  Pick your gate based on 1) Best angle to 1st turn. 2) The rut behind the gate for best traction.  3) The rut in front of the gate to be straight.

Magoofan wrote:

Hell yeah....and let's go back to 2-strokes.    They took real skill to ride (powerband).   

 

If I had a nickel for each time I damn near did a backflip from dumping the clutch with it wide open as a little kid.  I practiced starts at least an hour every day at practice to get it right. But that's part of the whole skill...learning how much throttle to use and not looking at a light, learning how to clutch it just enough, nearly kissing the front fender to keep the front end down while sliding your ass to the rear fender for traction. 

Honestly what bothers me more than the grates are the holeshot devices and the RPM lights to tell them the perfect RPM to be at for the start. Keeping the front end down enough, traction control, knowing the right RPM or gear to start in....to me those are all "skills" essential to be a pro and get a holeshot. 

3
BobbyMyers
Posts
475
Joined
1/25/2023
Location
Aj, AZ, USA
2/28/2023 7:18pm
McG194 wrote:
I prefer dirt starts but I voted pro-grate. They use them in SX and MXGP so they might as well do the same as the other...

I prefer dirt starts but I voted pro-grate. They use them in SX and MXGP so they might as well do the same as the other top series do. 

A can of this and 1 holeshot coming up... Or 1 loop out.

190701-Product-00

 

1
loftyair
Posts
2904
Joined
7/3/2009
Location
riverside, CA, USA
2/28/2023 7:18pm

Pretty sure all true motocross is pure dirt. In other words, if it's not dirt...

 

It's NOT motocross.

1
1
Crutcher
Posts
265
Joined
1/12/2023
Location
Lawrence, KS, USA
3/1/2023 8:54am

It’s okay to have change, guys. 

6
-MAVERICK-
Posts
66882
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario, CA
3/1/2023 9:07am
Crutcher wrote:

It’s okay to have change, guys. 

It's also okay to leave things the way they are. 

If it's not broken, don't fix it. 

11
3/1/2023 9:19am

Yeah your rt. We should also b allowed to bring our own gate also.  For entertainment & promoting the sport. We should hv teams of gate prepers. I,ll hv a team of 8 Asian chics. All dressed in team tube tops. 

1
1
Motoxdoc
Posts
2711
Joined
11/8/2009
Location
Steamboat Springs, CO, USA
3/1/2023 9:31am Edited Date/Time 3/1/2023 9:32am

If all the other riders have smooth starting gates, no ruts behind the gate, start devices, traction, control, and launch control….does that make it easier for you?

I don’t even understand the question. if they add more people on the line, how does that take away from the professionalism or the starting technique required?  Oh ffs… did you mean they’re switching to grates behind the start gate or did you mean they’re adding gates? 

1
Falcon
Posts
12456
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
3/1/2023 9:48am

From the standpoint of someone who is very confident in his starting abilities... bring it. 

If I were a pro who gets good starts, I wouldn't care. I'm still gonna smoke you guys to the first turn. Grate, dirt, concrete, peanut butter or ice, it doesn't matter, as long as all the gates are the same. 

Also don't forget that the grate is only behind the gate. There will still be some strategy with gate pick due to the condition of the rut ahead of the gate, as well as the line to the first turn. 

3/1/2023 9:57am

Sneak  a  mobile wireless remote activated system , electric magnet under the grate. Direct the beam at the top of the gate. As a bonus it should make near by bikes miss fire. Hole shot city. 

2
BobPA
Posts
8333
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
USA
3/1/2023 10:19am Edited Date/Time 3/1/2023 10:20am
ProKawi24 wrote:
If I had a nickel for each time I damn near did a backflip from dumping the clutch with it wide open as a little kid. ...

If I had a nickel for each time I damn near did a backflip from dumping the clutch with it wide open as a little kid.  I practiced starts at least an hour every day at practice to get it right. But that's part of the whole skill...learning how much throttle to use and not looking at a light, learning how to clutch it just enough, nearly kissing the front fender to keep the front end down while sliding your ass to the rear fender for traction. 

Honestly what bothers me more than the grates are the holeshot devices and the RPM lights to tell them the perfect RPM to be at for the start. Keeping the front end down enough, traction control, knowing the right RPM or gear to start in....to me those are all "skills" essential to be a pro and get a holeshot. 

To be fair, quite a bit of testing would go into the setup to find the "perfect start".it is not like they just guessed at what works. I'm sure it is ever changing too.

 

I can take or leave the grates. If they do go with grates I would like to see them do a random gate pick order for the first motos. Let the top 20 in points be seeded and have a random order for gate pick. The bottom 20 would get into the field by qualifying times and their gate pick would be determined by qualifying time. 

 

I'd bet some different lines would shape up if not everyone was rushing to put in a quick qualifying time... 

3
1
3/1/2023 10:44am

The grates r loaded up & transported. Probably bent some. Are they all the same height behind the gate ? I never saw any survey equipment to check this. If your gate is 1/4 in higher you hv an advantage 

1
5
Jeff alessi
Posts
915
Joined
10/28/2011
Location
Victorville, CA, USA
3/1/2023 11:52am

Keep it dirt, some riders are better on clay and some have the loam better figured out. A great starter can find the right rpm on any dirt and fine tune that with how far down they put the holeshot device. It’s a great strategy I would say they should keep in. It also doesn’t allow everyone to shoot out the gate at rocket speed being more closely spaced which keeps the first corner a safer place. The only places I would tell tracks to get a grate would be sandy starts that get foot peg deep ruts but even then you see the ama fixing those ruts before getting to deep. 

6
NSP139
Posts
1256
Joined
5/6/2021
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
3/1/2023 12:18pm

The first turn on most tracks is the most dangerous part of the race! Making it easier for everybody to get a good start isn't the answer!  They are dirt bikes they should start in the dirt lol

1
southeast
Posts
195
Joined
2/24/2023
Location
clearwater, FL, USA
3/1/2023 2:18pm
Yeah your rt. We should also b allowed to bring our own gate also.  For entertainment & promoting the sport. We should hv teams of gate...

Yeah your rt. We should also b allowed to bring our own gate also.  For entertainment & promoting the sport. We should hv teams of gate prepers. I,ll hv a team of 8 Asian chics. All dressed in team tube tops. 

I'm so with you on this. Next time you should slip on your red mini skirt the one you wore while racing your tricked out CR125 in the Super Allstars Pro Race and prep the rails.

2
holeshot413
Posts
688
Joined
2/24/2008
Location
Prosperity, SC, USA
3/1/2023 4:10pm

What’s next ? Concrete mx and supercross  tracks like BMX?

Alex814
Posts
1235
Joined
12/18/2014
Location
USA
3/1/2023 7:48pm

Why? Leave it dirt.

Easier to paint the grates black and green than it is dirt I suppose. 

Crutcher
Posts
265
Joined
1/12/2023
Location
Lawrence, KS, USA
3/2/2023 2:45am
-MAVERICK- wrote:

It's also okay to leave things the way they are. 

If it's not broken, don't fix it. 

We’re both not wrong here. And that’s totally fine. 

1
motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
3/2/2023 8:43pm
BobPA wrote:
To be fair, quite a bit of testing would go into the setup to find the "perfect start".it is not like they just guessed at what...

To be fair, quite a bit of testing would go into the setup to find the "perfect start".it is not like they just guessed at what works. I'm sure it is ever changing too.

 

I can take or leave the grates. If they do go with grates I would like to see them do a random gate pick order for the first motos. Let the top 20 in points be seeded and have a random order for gate pick. The bottom 20 would get into the field by qualifying times and their gate pick would be determined by qualifying time. 

 

I'd bet some different lines would shape up if not everyone was rushing to put in a quick qualifying time... 

You hit on a very interesting point regarding different lines developing during "timedqualifyingpractice" if it were like the old days and truly just practice.

1
enketchum
Posts
4397
Joined
2/6/2012
Location
Pasadena, CA, USA
3/2/2023 9:42pm

Did Glen Helen remove their concrete pad? I forget 

1
RaceFace232
Posts
259
Joined
8/6/2021
Location
Northampton, MA, USA
3/3/2023 12:00pm

It’s a bit odd to me that anyone is against eliminating the potential for one gate having an advantage over another gate.  This makes it an even start surface across the whole line.  On dirt you will have better spots to start from, dirt that will pack better here vs there, all creating the potential for one riders gate to be an advantage over another’s.  I want the the guy who gets he best jump out of the gate to get to the front as opposed to the guy who didn’t have the best jump but had a better patch of dirt to get a better drive from.  

1

Post a reply to: AMA Pro Motocross Series Rumored to Add Starting Grates

The Latest