Homeschooling

ML512
Posts
17121
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
7/3/2019 10:33pm
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! Laughing

Personally, I was more socially awkward in traditional schools. I didn’t have the best of luck with bullying and overall lack of acceptance from other students...or teachers/staff who cared very little to help out with these problem children. Going to independent studies and being able to focus on things I cared for without the negatives honestly helped in so many ways. At the rate I was going in traditional school systems, I don’t want to know where I would’ve ended up. By the later part of 7th and 8th grade I was becoming a fairly depressed kid.
7
EZZA 95B
Posts
9681
Joined
11/3/2010
Location
AU
7/3/2019 10:59pm
ML512 wrote:
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! :laugh: Personally, I was more...
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! Laughing

Personally, I was more socially awkward in traditional schools. I didn’t have the best of luck with bullying and overall lack of acceptance from other students...or teachers/staff who cared very little to help out with these problem children. Going to independent studies and being able to focus on things I cared for without the negatives honestly helped in so many ways. At the rate I was going in traditional school systems, I don’t want to know where I would’ve ended up. By the later part of 7th and 8th grade I was becoming a fairly depressed kid.
An almost identical story/experience here ML!

My brother and sister (older) were formally educated.
1
Markee
Posts
3669
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA, USA
7/4/2019 11:56am
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
2
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/4/2019 12:12pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area is a great example.

https://www.spsk12.net/programs/cte

The Shop

7/4/2019 1:43pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
APLMAN99 wrote:
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area...
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area is a great example.

https://www.spsk12.net/programs/cte
You come across like an academic stuck in his ivory tower.
2
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/4/2019 2:08pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
APLMAN99 wrote:
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area...
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area is a great example.

https://www.spsk12.net/programs/cte
You come across like an academic stuck in his ivory tower.
For posting a link to a great vocational and technical system in the town of the poster who says that schools no longer offer vocational education?

You sound like someone afraid of the truth and actual facts, who’d much rather just wallow in bits of confirmation bias of your preconceived notions.
1
1
OldYZRider1
Posts
847
Joined
7/10/2009
Location
Bushnell, IL, USA
7/4/2019 2:52pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
I had a real good friend go through a building trades program in high school. Kids from some of the smaller towns like ours would be bussed down to a larger towns high school every afternoon. Several different occupational trades would be taught at what amounted to a regional trade school. For his building trades class the school would go out into the local city and build a single level home over the course of the year. It really helped kids build skills After graduation my friend came to work in our family owned construction business that I’d worked at since I was 13. He had a really good set of skills and was much better than a lot of the other older skilled guys we had working at the time.

Of course I doubt a public school could ever do anything like that today due to liablity concerns. I guess schools get around liability issues with their sports programs so maybe there could be a way yet today. The programs around here were dismantled decades ago. Labor laws really restrict what young people are allowed to do these days and theres been way, way too much emphasis on kids getting a college education. The young guys we bring in today are really inexperienced and work brittle compared to what I remember back when I was young.
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/4/2019 3:02pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
I had a real good friend go through a building trades program in high school. Kids from some of the smaller towns like ours would be...
I had a real good friend go through a building trades program in high school. Kids from some of the smaller towns like ours would be bussed down to a larger towns high school every afternoon. Several different occupational trades would be taught at what amounted to a regional trade school. For his building trades class the school would go out into the local city and build a single level home over the course of the year. It really helped kids build skills After graduation my friend came to work in our family owned construction business that I’d worked at since I was 13. He had a really good set of skills and was much better than a lot of the other older skilled guys we had working at the time.

Of course I doubt a public school could ever do anything like that today due to liablity concerns. I guess schools get around liability issues with their sports programs so maybe there could be a way yet today. The programs around here were dismantled decades ago. Labor laws really restrict what young people are allowed to do these days and theres been way, way too much emphasis on kids getting a college education. The young guys we bring in today are really inexperienced and work brittle compared to what I remember back when I was young.
Still available in your area....

http://wacsefe265.com/programsandclasses.html
Jarid332
Posts
5360
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Somewhere north of Toronto, CA
7/4/2019 5:29pm
ML512 wrote:
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! :laugh: Personally, I was more...
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! Laughing

Personally, I was more socially awkward in traditional schools. I didn’t have the best of luck with bullying and overall lack of acceptance from other students...or teachers/staff who cared very little to help out with these problem children. Going to independent studies and being able to focus on things I cared for without the negatives honestly helped in so many ways. At the rate I was going in traditional school systems, I don’t want to know where I would’ve ended up. By the later part of 7th and 8th grade I was becoming a fairly depressed kid.
"I turned out fine"


depends on who you ask....



jkjk
3
Markee
Posts
3669
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA, USA
7/4/2019 5:42pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
APLMAN99 wrote:
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area...
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area is a great example.

https://www.spsk12.net/programs/cte
What they are referring to is the Pruden Vocational programs that are located off site from Suffolk public schools. Pruden has not been running in years.. I don't spend my time researching the subject, so if they are firing it back up, that's a great thing. I know I'm commenting with a broad brush.

APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/4/2019 6:03pm
Markee wrote:
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public. As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we...
I was having this conversation the other day about school in general. Not Home vs Public.

As kids to young adults (Grades 1 - 12) we are taught Jeopardy trivia question material for the most part. It's just pathetic that most of that material we learn in school and those questions asked in the video will have zero use in actually obtaining a job with the means to support yourself.

Public schools have gone away with the one educational tool that was extremely useful and something I don't believe every home school has... That's vocational programs for real world jobs and trades.

I have MX to think for my career. It was the real world interest in design and mechanics as a kid that kept me learning and developing a skill set that made me attractive to employers, very little came from anything taught in a class room..
APLMAN99 wrote:
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area...
Actually schools are investing more and more into vocational instruction. They are developing entire programs that teach far more than they used to. Your own area is a great example.

https://www.spsk12.net/programs/cte
Markee wrote:
What they are referring to is the Pruden Vocational programs that are located off site from Suffolk public schools. Pruden has not been running in years...
What they are referring to is the Pruden Vocational programs that are located off site from Suffolk public schools. Pruden has not been running in years.. I don't spend my time researching the subject, so if they are firing it back up, that's a great thing. I know I'm commenting with a broad brush.

It’s listed as a Suffolk Public School facility. Not meaning to be directly insulting, but it definitely seems like most of the people who claim that there is no more vocational education don’t seem to realize what is actually offered. They hear that schools are doing away with it, it sounds believable to them, and they treat it as fact.

Vocational programs have actually gotten better in the 30 years since I went to high school, and it has a lot to do with schools pooling their resources so that they can offer better training to students interested instead of just having the old wood and metal shop classes.
gnarwhip
Posts
1969
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
7/4/2019 8:01pm
I went from private school to public, and public school is trash. But there’s more hot chicks. Just get your grades up to get into a good college.
1
Markee
Posts
3669
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA, USA
7/4/2019 9:40pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
It’s listed as a Suffolk Public School facility. Not meaning to be directly insulting, but it definitely seems like most of the people who claim that...
It’s listed as a Suffolk Public School facility. Not meaning to be directly insulting, but it definitely seems like most of the people who claim that there is no more vocational education don’t seem to realize what is actually offered. They hear that schools are doing away with it, it sounds believable to them, and they treat it as fact.

Vocational programs have actually gotten better in the 30 years since I went to high school, and it has a lot to do with schools pooling their resources so that they can offer better training to students interested instead of just having the old wood and metal shop classes.
For generations, the focus has been to go to college, get a degree and in doing so you will ensure a brighter future with more access to employment. School systems started focusing on academic instruction, but left behind the notion of work-force education. Teaching trade education over the last 20 years has been on the back burner. Maybe its because of student interest and social pressure that "if you don't go to college you'll be a loser".

I remember in high school I started asking teachers to explain to me the practical application of any particular subject I myself thought was "useless". Normally the answers were pathetic and in reference to "you'll need this in college".
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/4/2019 9:53pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
It’s listed as a Suffolk Public School facility. Not meaning to be directly insulting, but it definitely seems like most of the people who claim that...
It’s listed as a Suffolk Public School facility. Not meaning to be directly insulting, but it definitely seems like most of the people who claim that there is no more vocational education don’t seem to realize what is actually offered. They hear that schools are doing away with it, it sounds believable to them, and they treat it as fact.

Vocational programs have actually gotten better in the 30 years since I went to high school, and it has a lot to do with schools pooling their resources so that they can offer better training to students interested instead of just having the old wood and metal shop classes.
Markee wrote:
For generations, the focus has been to go to college, get a degree and in doing so you will ensure a brighter future with more access...
For generations, the focus has been to go to college, get a degree and in doing so you will ensure a brighter future with more access to employment. School systems started focusing on academic instruction, but left behind the notion of work-force education. Teaching trade education over the last 20 years has been on the back burner. Maybe its because of student interest and social pressure that "if you don't go to college you'll be a loser".

I remember in high school I started asking teachers to explain to me the practical application of any particular subject I myself thought was "useless". Normally the answers were pathetic and in reference to "you'll need this in college".
Preparing students to be able to go to college is a good thing, as there's no reason to limit someone so early in life. It's natural for young people to believe that what they are being taught is useless, they know everything at that young age!

But the notion that school systems have abandoned vocational education is a myth. They've changed it, and it isn't quite like the old days of showing up in wood shop to get the easy A like it used to be, obviously. Vocational education has improved greatly, but it takes some effort on the part of students and parents to take advantage of the opportunities. That's probably the biggest difference, it isn't quite as spoon fed as it was before. There are more vocational programs being offered than ever before, yet people don't take the time to even know what is available in their own school districts.
captmoto
Posts
5925
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
7/4/2019 10:06pm
swtwtwtw wrote:
Retired teacher here, and my advise to today’s parents is begin homeschooling from fifth grade on. At this point in California I believe that there is...
Retired teacher here, and my advise to today’s parents is begin homeschooling from fifth grade on. At this point in California I believe that there is zero constructive learning happening in the classroom beyond fourth grade.
Wow. That's huge. Do you think it applies in all schools across the state?
captmoto
Posts
5925
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
7/4/2019 10:11pm
Markee wrote:
For generations, the focus has been to go to college, get a degree and in doing so you will ensure a brighter future with more access...
For generations, the focus has been to go to college, get a degree and in doing so you will ensure a brighter future with more access to employment. School systems started focusing on academic instruction, but left behind the notion of work-force education. Teaching trade education over the last 20 years has been on the back burner. Maybe its because of student interest and social pressure that "if you don't go to college you'll be a loser".

I remember in high school I started asking teachers to explain to me the practical application of any particular subject I myself thought was "useless". Normally the answers were pathetic and in reference to "you'll need this in college".
Yup, creating rocket scientists and then we have no one to build the rockets.
1
captmoto
Posts
5925
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
7/4/2019 10:16pm Edited Date/Time 7/4/2019 10:18pm
There was a vocational high school program here locally for masonry. Kids learned from retired masons. It was all encompassing and kids ended up raising their grades in most other classes. When they had to learn how to write bids and calculate for materials, loads and so on they ended up paying more attention to in math, science and english classes. It was a win all around but some very short sighted "educators" canned it for more "core classes". There were a couple kids that said that vocational class was the only reason they went to school. Totally stupid.
1
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/4/2019 11:14pm
captmoto wrote:
There was a vocational high school program here locally for masonry. Kids learned from retired masons. It was all encompassing and kids ended up raising their...
There was a vocational high school program here locally for masonry. Kids learned from retired masons. It was all encompassing and kids ended up raising their grades in most other classes. When they had to learn how to write bids and calculate for materials, loads and so on they ended up paying more attention to in math, science and english classes. It was a win all around but some very short sighted "educators" canned it for more "core classes". There were a couple kids that said that vocational class was the only reason they went to school. Totally stupid.
Looks like that's still available too. That's 3 complaints about lack of vocational programs that actually do exist.

https://cjuhsd-ca.schoolloop.com/pf4/cms2/view_page?d=x&group_id=130356…
sandtrack315
Posts
2871
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
7/5/2019 7:36am
ML512 wrote:
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! :laugh: Personally, I was more...
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! Laughing

Personally, I was more socially awkward in traditional schools. I didn’t have the best of luck with bullying and overall lack of acceptance from other students...or teachers/staff who cared very little to help out with these problem children. Going to independent studies and being able to focus on things I cared for without the negatives honestly helped in so many ways. At the rate I was going in traditional school systems, I don’t want to know where I would’ve ended up. By the later part of 7th and 8th grade I was becoming a fairly depressed kid.
Yes, this was more or less my experience going from publish school to independent study.
OldYZRider1
Posts
847
Joined
7/10/2009
Location
Bushnell, IL, USA
7/5/2019 7:59am
APLMAN99 wrote:
Still available in your area....

http://wacsefe265.com/programsandclasses.html
Yes that program is out there. I wasn’t aware of it and my freind who was in that sort of program wasn’t either. One of my young guys whose been out of high school a couple of years was actually in it for a year. He said it cost the families money to attend and that students weren’t readily made aware of it; he had to talk to the school counseler to find out that it even existed. He did say that our community got kicked out of it after a student lit one of the bus seats on fire and damaged the bus. Maybe we’re in it again now.

Vocational programs do tend to attract some students who’ll work pretty hard to get out of other schoolwork and I suppose some of the ADD, ADHD kids may gravitate to it too. Around here they’re gonna get a bus drive to another school every day so there’s mischief that will occur. I guess if an instructor doesn’t feel he can handle many of those types in his class then that’d be a reason not to advertise the program. I also know its funded by grants and a lot of the small school districts like ours make a concerted effort to go after grant money. If they can collect the money and not have accountability showing they’re spending it for its intended purpose; they’ll use the money for other things.
DL
Posts
2627
Joined
8/20/2006
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
7/5/2019 9:25am
ML512 wrote:
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! :laugh: Personally, I was more...
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! Laughing

Personally, I was more socially awkward in traditional schools. I didn’t have the best of luck with bullying and overall lack of acceptance from other students...or teachers/staff who cared very little to help out with these problem children. Going to independent studies and being able to focus on things I cared for without the negatives honestly helped in so many ways. At the rate I was going in traditional school systems, I don’t want to know where I would’ve ended up. By the later part of 7th and 8th grade I was becoming a fairly depressed kid.
Michael attended On Track School which is not a home school, it’s a distance learning private school developed primarily for kids that have interests that make it difficult to attend public schools. My wife, Andrea, developed the school. She’s an amazing person and is passionate about education. On Track has graduated many top racers and is the school of choice for racers and families that chose to focus on their racing and school.
1
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/5/2019 9:39am
There can be "materials fees", just like we used to pay for our materials in woodshop, metalshop, drafting, etc. But those are waived for students without the ability to pay, at least here.

But again, this reveals a couple of the real issues with the misconceptions of current vocational education. People tend to believe rumors of things that back up their preconceptions, and they don't have the desire to educate themselves on what the reality truly is. It was easy for me to find this program from a couple thousand miles away, yet a resident of the area claims that the program was shut down decades ago and there is no vocational education for students in their area.

We've gotten to the point in this country that unless someone puts the info directly in front of our face we feel that we aren't being informed, there's no responsibility on us to seek out solutions. We simply parrot the complaints that we want to believe as fact, and wallow in our own disgust for the "reality" that we've constructed in our own mind.

Another thing I've noticed, most people that I know who complain about schools today won't even take the time to attend a single school board meeting or get involved with helping shape the goals and direction of their educational system. It's less convenient than just repeating negativity and rumors.....
7/5/2019 9:43am
ML512 wrote:
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! :laugh: Personally, I was more...
I was in independent studies for all of high school, graduated graduated around 14 months early actually...I turned out just fine! Laughing

Personally, I was more socially awkward in traditional schools. I didn’t have the best of luck with bullying and overall lack of acceptance from other students...or teachers/staff who cared very little to help out with these problem children. Going to independent studies and being able to focus on things I cared for without the negatives honestly helped in so many ways. At the rate I was going in traditional school systems, I don’t want to know where I would’ve ended up. By the later part of 7th and 8th grade I was becoming a fairly depressed kid.
I did independent studies throughout high school as well, and looking back I'm not sure if I would have changed it. I was teased throughout elementary school and early middle school, but finally started to get in with the "cool kids" of my school in my final year, then I started racing a lot and did independent studies. I definitely feel like I missed out on a lot of shit growing up, but at the same time I got to experience a lot of things normal kids don't get to do. I do think I'd probably know more if I went to public school than doing independent studies, and I don't really have a lot of friends outside of racing so there's that problem with independent studies, too, but that can just be a personal problem.
OldYZRider1
Posts
847
Joined
7/10/2009
Location
Bushnell, IL, USA
7/5/2019 2:55pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
There can be "materials fees", just like we used to pay for our materials in woodshop, metalshop, drafting, etc. But those are waived for students without...
There can be "materials fees", just like we used to pay for our materials in woodshop, metalshop, drafting, etc. But those are waived for students without the ability to pay, at least here.

But again, this reveals a couple of the real issues with the misconceptions of current vocational education. People tend to believe rumors of things that back up their preconceptions, and they don't have the desire to educate themselves on what the reality truly is. It was easy for me to find this program from a couple thousand miles away, yet a resident of the area claims that the program was shut down decades ago and there is no vocational education for students in their area.

We've gotten to the point in this country that unless someone puts the info directly in front of our face we feel that we aren't being informed, there's no responsibility on us to seek out solutions. We simply parrot the complaints that we want to believe as fact, and wallow in our own disgust for the "reality" that we've constructed in our own mind.

Another thing I've noticed, most people that I know who complain about schools today won't even take the time to attend a single school board meeting or get involved with helping shape the goals and direction of their educational system. It's less convenient than just repeating negativity and rumors.....
Well from what I hear our school apparently does not promote this vocational option to their own students like I'm sure they do for every after school activity or club. I guess I'd think they'd promote it better if they truly endorse it. I did move away from the area for a decade (like most of our young people that head off to college do) and I honestly thought the program that ran here had been dismantled. And I'm somewhat surprised that anything still occurs considering the dismal financial situation in our state and several of the small school districts. Unlike most who leave, I came back 25 years ago to take over our families active construction business and didn't know there was any sort of program still in existence till now. I'd heard they shut down some of the shop areas at the school where these classes were held decades ago. Where and how they currently hold classes I don't know but maybe they're co-opting some with the community colleges courses. No clue on the content of the classes these days. And I've never had a job applicant indicate they've been in the program, not even the one I currently employ.

My wife and I are fans of Mike Rowe's shows and he really pushes for an increased presence of vocational school programs and enrollment. I'd think that with our declining workforce, the required shift to technology solutions to attempt to make-up for the lost manpower should surely drive demand for service techs, machine operators and programmers. Hopefully the US stays engaged to cover these areas. As for construction work, a lot of that has already shifted to Mexican tradesmen; they welcome the work and can tolerate the heat. We've employed some in the past both legal and illegal; they'll work every available hour we'll let them work and do every job we ask them to do. If they are complaining like the US kids sometimes do, I don't hear it as I don't speak the language Smile .
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/5/2019 3:26pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
There can be "materials fees", just like we used to pay for our materials in woodshop, metalshop, drafting, etc. But those are waived for students without...
There can be "materials fees", just like we used to pay for our materials in woodshop, metalshop, drafting, etc. But those are waived for students without the ability to pay, at least here.

But again, this reveals a couple of the real issues with the misconceptions of current vocational education. People tend to believe rumors of things that back up their preconceptions, and they don't have the desire to educate themselves on what the reality truly is. It was easy for me to find this program from a couple thousand miles away, yet a resident of the area claims that the program was shut down decades ago and there is no vocational education for students in their area.

We've gotten to the point in this country that unless someone puts the info directly in front of our face we feel that we aren't being informed, there's no responsibility on us to seek out solutions. We simply parrot the complaints that we want to believe as fact, and wallow in our own disgust for the "reality" that we've constructed in our own mind.

Another thing I've noticed, most people that I know who complain about schools today won't even take the time to attend a single school board meeting or get involved with helping shape the goals and direction of their educational system. It's less convenient than just repeating negativity and rumors.....
Well from what I hear our school apparently does not promote this vocational option to their own students like I'm sure they do for every after...
Well from what I hear our school apparently does not promote this vocational option to their own students like I'm sure they do for every after school activity or club. I guess I'd think they'd promote it better if they truly endorse it. I did move away from the area for a decade (like most of our young people that head off to college do) and I honestly thought the program that ran here had been dismantled. And I'm somewhat surprised that anything still occurs considering the dismal financial situation in our state and several of the small school districts. Unlike most who leave, I came back 25 years ago to take over our families active construction business and didn't know there was any sort of program still in existence till now. I'd heard they shut down some of the shop areas at the school where these classes were held decades ago. Where and how they currently hold classes I don't know but maybe they're co-opting some with the community colleges courses. No clue on the content of the classes these days. And I've never had a job applicant indicate they've been in the program, not even the one I currently employ.

My wife and I are fans of Mike Rowe's shows and he really pushes for an increased presence of vocational school programs and enrollment. I'd think that with our declining workforce, the required shift to technology solutions to attempt to make-up for the lost manpower should surely drive demand for service techs, machine operators and programmers. Hopefully the US stays engaged to cover these areas. As for construction work, a lot of that has already shifted to Mexican tradesmen; they welcome the work and can tolerate the heat. We've employed some in the past both legal and illegal; they'll work every available hour we'll let them work and do every job we ask them to do. If they are complaining like the US kids sometimes do, I don't hear it as I don't speak the language Smile .
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or maybe not, if the goal is just to complain about the “lack of vocational education “ available these days. I’m betting that they’d absolutely love having local industry input and you’d have a chance to help improve your local workforce at the same time.

I like Mike Rowe’s folksy schtick too. But I view it more as entertainment. There’s a reason why he studied communications and works in entertainment. He has had the means to become a tradesman for quite some time, yet still hasn’t ever actually done it. He is great at portraying a character, though, and he’s convincing to many as someone who works with his hands and such.

I don’t know if he has children or not, but it’d be interesting if he did and he discouraged them from a college education or not.
Markee
Posts
3669
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA, USA
7/5/2019 5:08pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or...
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or maybe not, if the goal is just to complain about the “lack of vocational education “ available these days. I’m betting that they’d absolutely love having local industry input and you’d have a chance to help improve your local workforce at the same time.

I like Mike Rowe’s folksy schtick too. But I view it more as entertainment. There’s a reason why he studied communications and works in entertainment. He has had the means to become a tradesman for quite some time, yet still hasn’t ever actually done it. He is great at portraying a character, though, and he’s convincing to many as someone who works with his hands and such.

I don’t know if he has children or not, but it’d be interesting if he did and he discouraged them from a college education or not.
You posted that Pruden center that is 2 miles from my house. For years its been shutdown, I pass it every other weekend going to my local moto spot. It being closed is a pretty good indicator of the intent of the City of Suffolk school system.

I don't have Kids, we are not having any either. I'm not going to a school board meeting to tell some wankers how to do their job. I'll just work 80 hours like I'm doing this week and complain about it on Vital! Laughing
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/5/2019 5:17pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or...
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or maybe not, if the goal is just to complain about the “lack of vocational education “ available these days. I’m betting that they’d absolutely love having local industry input and you’d have a chance to help improve your local workforce at the same time.

I like Mike Rowe’s folksy schtick too. But I view it more as entertainment. There’s a reason why he studied communications and works in entertainment. He has had the means to become a tradesman for quite some time, yet still hasn’t ever actually done it. He is great at portraying a character, though, and he’s convincing to many as someone who works with his hands and such.

I don’t know if he has children or not, but it’d be interesting if he did and he discouraged them from a college education or not.
Markee wrote:
You posted that Pruden center that is 2 miles from my house. For years its been shutdown, I pass it every other weekend going to my...
You posted that Pruden center that is 2 miles from my house. For years its been shutdown, I pass it every other weekend going to my local moto spot. It being closed is a pretty good indicator of the intent of the City of Suffolk school system.

I don't have Kids, we are not having any either. I'm not going to a school board meeting to tell some wankers how to do their job. I'll just work 80 hours like I'm doing this week and complain about it on Vital! Laughing
It may very well be shut down on weekends. A lot schools are. 🙄

But it's pretty obvious that the school itself is still functioning and serving students. Here's a story talking about a grant it received just 2 months ago.

https://www.suffolknewsherald.com/2019/05/03/pruden-receives-state-gran…

And I'm definitely not surprised about someone complaining about a nonexistent problem not wanting to be part of a "solution". That's pretty standard, even if there actually were a problem.....
OldYZRider1
Posts
847
Joined
7/10/2009
Location
Bushnell, IL, USA
7/5/2019 5:52pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or...
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or maybe not, if the goal is just to complain about the “lack of vocational education “ available these days. I’m betting that they’d absolutely love having local industry input and you’d have a chance to help improve your local workforce at the same time.

I like Mike Rowe’s folksy schtick too. But I view it more as entertainment. There’s a reason why he studied communications and works in entertainment. He has had the means to become a tradesman for quite some time, yet still hasn’t ever actually done it. He is great at portraying a character, though, and he’s convincing to many as someone who works with his hands and such.

I don’t know if he has children or not, but it’d be interesting if he did and he discouraged them from a college education or not.
Yes I guess I could contact them but I personally know the person listed on the contact page in the link you sent. He was our school superintendent for years. He retired three years ago and moved away from the area so I’m afraid I won’t be able to talk to him about this matter. Can you help??

I posted in this thread to defend homeschooling and highlight that things aren’t perfect in the public school world either. I, as others here, feel vocational education is a weak area in our society possibly as a result of US educational policy and that needs rectified.
APLMAN99
Posts
13053
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
7/5/2019 6:11pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or...
Sounds like you now have a great opportunity to reach out to this program to get more info, advise on targeted outcomes for participants, etc. Or maybe not, if the goal is just to complain about the “lack of vocational education “ available these days. I’m betting that they’d absolutely love having local industry input and you’d have a chance to help improve your local workforce at the same time.

I like Mike Rowe’s folksy schtick too. But I view it more as entertainment. There’s a reason why he studied communications and works in entertainment. He has had the means to become a tradesman for quite some time, yet still hasn’t ever actually done it. He is great at portraying a character, though, and he’s convincing to many as someone who works with his hands and such.

I don’t know if he has children or not, but it’d be interesting if he did and he discouraged them from a college education or not.
Yes I guess I could contact them but I personally know the person listed on the contact page in the link you sent. He was our...
Yes I guess I could contact them but I personally know the person listed on the contact page in the link you sent. He was our school superintendent for years. He retired three years ago and moved away from the area so I’m afraid I won’t be able to talk to him about this matter. Can you help??

I posted in this thread to defend homeschooling and highlight that things aren’t perfect in the public school world either. I, as others here, feel vocational education is a weak area in our society possibly as a result of US educational policy and that needs rectified.
Not sure which person you are talking about, but it you're actually interested in being involved I'd think you could start at your school district main offices on Monday.

And I replied to your thoughts about the lack of vocational education because it is contrary to what is actually happening. You reached your thoughts without even doing the most basic of investigations to see what is available in your local area, and compounded that by projecting those feelings nationwide.

I'll look forward to seeing how you work with your local vocational education school to help fix the "problem". You can affect an awful lot of good in your local area and beyond, Or just blame it on some vague "US educational policy" and call it good.
Kneeherts
Posts
5
Joined
2/28/2019
Location
Burlington, CT, USA
7/5/2019 6:38pm
Its a directive from the US Dept of Education that in theory is to provide similar timing on curriculum nationwide so that students will be studying...
Its a directive from the US Dept of Education that in theory is to provide similar timing on curriculum nationwide so that students will be studying the same material everywhere in the country at approximately the same time. If a student moves elsewhere then they should pick up there schooling where they were at before the move. Sounds logical but it puts the federal government with more control when they really shouldn’t have any. States and local communities need to determine what works best for them and their communities.

Also as curriculum gets tailored for this nationwide learning I feel it’ll be dumbed down to accomodate a lower level of student ability. I think this is already being shown to be happening based on student test scores.
RichieW13 wrote:
In your original comment you said: [i]"We pulled our youngest out of the public schools after the change to the "common core" curriculum. That system over...
In your original comment you said:

"We pulled our youngest out of the public schools after the change to the "common core" curriculum. That system over time is just going to migrate teaching methods and materials to the lowest common denominator student."

What are some examples of things that you think your youngest would have missed out on, had they remained in a Common Core school?

States and local communities need to determine what works best for them and their communities.

Can you think of an example for why a local community should have a different standard for what grade their students should be expected to learn algebra?
Not local communities but States. Before the federal department of edumacation was created the States controlled education within their borders. The Fed being so intent on erasing the 10th amendment created yet another tax payer money sucking enterprise the PRC is jealous of.

Post a reply to: Homeschooling

The Latest