Making too much money (taxes)

woodsrider427
Posts
127
Joined
12/11/2014
Location
Wake Forest, NC US
12/5/2018 3:58pm
You and your wife need to max out your 401k. Both need to put 18,500 in it per year. That lowers your effective rate by $37,000...
You and your wife need to max out your 401k. Both need to put 18,500 in it per year. That lowers your effective rate by $37,000.

Charitable donations. Calculate if giving the church $2000 can save you $2500. If so. Do it. (Example only)


If you plan on having kids consider a college savings If your state allows. In Ohio we can put away before tax money into a college savings. That lowers your rate even more. And seriously you should do this anyway because a college education is probably going to be 250,000+ in 18 years. Or it’s gonna fall flat on its face. Who knows. But might as well get the tax savings now.

Spend the money and see a CPA/financial consultant.

Calculate what you spend in healthcare put it in a HSA.

Can you put money in a Roth IRA if you’ve met your maximum 18,500 contribution in a 401k (if
You can max that out too. I’m not sure about the Roth. Considering starting one of those this year)
MX915 wrote:
Don't you pay tax on a Roth though? I believe your contributions aren't pre tax like a company 401k.
That's right, IRA withdrawals come out after taxes, it's a good way to set money aside. Since it has already been taxed I don't think it...
That's right, IRA withdrawals come out after taxes, it's a good way to set money aside. Since it has already been taxed I don't think it gets taxed as heavily as a 401k is. Aren't taxes great?

I am able to avoid a lot of taxes as a travel nurse. The bad part is that I can't use my non taxed money to qualify for a loan, so I'm kind of screwed. But luckily my wife has a full time non traveling job.
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered the same way, Traditional and Roth. So it depends on what you think your tax bracket will be when you retire (or what taxes in general will be in the future, I'm guessing higher knowing the government) versus what your tax bracket is now. If your income is above a certain threshold you are ineligible to do a Roth, but you can do a traditional and later do a "back door Roth" conversion.

I was always told to contribute to your 401K only up to what your employer matches first, then max out an IRA, then go back and contribute more to your 401K if you have any extra funds left. I am self-employed so no 401K here, but this is what we have done for my wife in the past.

Like was said above though, you only pay the extra 2% on the amount crossing the threshold, so it's not so bad.
2
APLMAN99
Posts
12474
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
12/5/2018 8:00pm
Markee wrote:
Me and my wife are in a unique situation this year. We both work for the same company in the steel industry. My pay is performance...
Me and my wife are in a unique situation this year. We both work for the same company in the steel industry. My pay is performance based bonus, so if we produce more tons, we make more money. Well last year I passed my last technical evaluation for top pay in my department (maintenance mechanic). This has been a record year for the company, so I've made more money in tons and more by evaluation increase leading into the problem...

The problem is being pushed just nearly over into a 2% increase in federal income tax. As of next year, we can max out 401k contributions at 11% a piece from our standard 5% we did this year to help, but that doesn't help me now.

Other than that can you guys think of anything else we can do?

We have no children.
If you're just barely over into the next tax bracket and the difference is only 2%, you're probably worrying a little too much. For example, if you go over into that higher bracket by $5,000, you'll owe a whopping $100 extra in income tax. Go over by $10,000 and your tax bill will be $200 higher. As has been mentioned, our tax rates are marginal, so you only pay the higher percentage on the income above that level.

That being said, any time you can save money and reduce your tax bill it's probably a good idea......
Goofy Foot
Posts
293
Joined
5/1/2018
Location
SoCal, CA US
12/5/2018 9:35pm
Eh well they can’t go to Vegas and buy alcohol with them but....ok. Lol. Not everyone on assistance is a leach. There are some genuinely good...
Eh well they can’t go to Vegas and buy alcohol with them but....ok. Lol. Not everyone on assistance is a leach. There are some genuinely good people needing it. WIC etc....

I guess Roth IRA is after tax. So can’t see the benefit in that besides saving long term and knowing your getting exactly what’s in that account in the end....I think I’m gonna have another sit down with financial guy see what my options are now. It’s been a few years.
EBT cards have abused and used for cigarettes, booze, and strippers...research it. Unfortunately, I've been funding these scum balls with the taxes I'm paying. There might be a few who need assistance, but the majority are working the system to live off taxpayer's money.
12/5/2018 9:49pm
*tooTongue

My brother is a subcontractor in the sign industry and makes pretty damn good money. Complains about tax and has nothing to show for all the hours and income.

Going on a holiday to Dubai just after chrissy.Laughing

Cry me a fucken river bro (talking about my brother)...Wink
2

The Shop

12/8/2018 6:17am
“Only 2%”

2% is 2%. I’m trying to keep as much as I earn!
2
XXVoid MainXX
Posts
8105
Joined
5/25/2012
Location
Schenectady, NY US
12/8/2018 6:29am
I know how to solve this. Ask for a pay cut to put you back into the lower tax bracket. Smile
71Fish
Posts
1794
Joined
11/29/2011
Location
Ogden, UT US
12/8/2018 6:51am
I make too much money, my wife is too pretty, and I have too much fun. There's a country song in there somewhere.
1
XXVoid MainXX
Posts
8105
Joined
5/25/2012
Location
Schenectady, NY US
12/8/2018 7:09am
No, that's a rock and roll song. The country song is I don't make enough money, my wife is ugly and my dog ran off. Smile
2
12/8/2018 11:26am
71Fish wrote:
I make too much money, my wife is too pretty, and I have too much fun. There's a country song in there somewhere.
It's been done...it's called "Too Much Fun" by Daryl Singletary
Markee
Posts
3658
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA US
12/8/2018 5:29pm
Thanks for all the insight and laughs boys!

Good to know its 2% earned over into the next bracket. Thought for a second it was 2% taxed added to gross income.

But your right Georgie, 2% is 2%. I'll have to adjust my 401k contributions.
APLMAN99
Posts
12474
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
12/9/2018 10:13am
“Only 2%”

2% is 2%. I’m trying to keep as much as I earn!
If you’re quoting me, you’re certainly taking it out of context......

Snipping 2 words out of any sentence tends to do that.
1
12/9/2018 10:29am Edited Date/Time 12/9/2018 10:32am
“Only 2%”

2% is 2%. I’m trying to keep as much as I earn!
APLMAN99 wrote:
If you’re quoting me, you’re certainly taking it out of context......

Snipping 2 words out of any sentence tends to do that.
Oh get off it. I was just saying I don’t care if it’s $0.01 If I can keep it I’m going to.

How many of you moto boys buy bikes outta state ? To save a couple hundred bucks. What’s that % ? Holier than thou’s won’t admit to that.

How many shopped at Rocky Mountain just for the free shipping? (ABout that no tax at the bottom of the receipt)

How many loved amazon.....before the tax hooks sunk into it ?
APLMAN99
Posts
12474
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
12/9/2018 11:56am
“Only 2%”

2% is 2%. I’m trying to keep as much as I earn!
APLMAN99 wrote:
If you’re quoting me, you’re certainly taking it out of context......

Snipping 2 words out of any sentence tends to do that.
Oh get off it. I was just saying I don’t care if it’s $0.01 If I can keep it I’m going to. How many of you...
Oh get off it. I was just saying I don’t care if it’s $0.01 If I can keep it I’m going to.

How many of you moto boys buy bikes outta state ? To save a couple hundred bucks. What’s that % ? Holier than thou’s won’t admit to that.

How many shopped at Rocky Mountain just for the free shipping? (ABout that no tax at the bottom of the receipt)

How many loved amazon.....before the tax hooks sunk into it ?
Again, if you're going to quote someone, try to at least quote a complete sentence.

I don't see anyone saying that the OP shouldn't try to minimize his tax bill. Some of the rational folks were merely pointing out that his increase in tax wasn't going to be as large as he thought that it was going to be, which was confirmed by his response.

In the end, if he's $10K into the next bracket at a 2% increase, spending more than $200 to try to not pay that extra tax makes it a money losing proposition. Now if he can defer that tax through some sort of retirement savings, that's an obvious win.
1
12/9/2018 1:41pm
That’s what we are all saying. I don’t know why you think there’s some big conspiracy or me trying to forcibly misquote you.
mikec265
Posts
1668
Joined
10/19/2015
Location
Edinboro, PA US
12/9/2018 7:13pm
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and rise in value with inflation. Those same write offs will also make me more money. I really wish I could just blow it all on motocross instead of shit I don't need to make more money. The amount of tax I pay on things during the year is crazy, but I usually don't pay income tax. Other government fees, registrations, and permits might as well be reworded as taxes.
Even without paying income tax, the government/irs is still winning big time. There's no way to really win against them.
gt80rider
Posts
7040
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO US
12/10/2018 1:15pm
Aways be thankful for having such a good problem....
1
12/10/2018 2:36pm
There is no such thing as making too much money Wink My wife and I had nice incomes and were married for ten years before we had kids and it sucks how much we paid in taxes. When we had kids ( two boys) it really help us keep a big chunk of what was going to the tax man but now that they are 17 and 19 kids are EXPENSIVE $$$$$$. Now I buy 3 gaming computers and 3 radio controlled trucks and 3 new cell phones and insurance on two more cars etc etc. I have have been poor and I have had money, and having money beats being broke every time. Cool
ns503
Posts
4585
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies CA
12/10/2018 3:53pm
mikec265 wrote:
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and...
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and rise in value with inflation. Those same write offs will also make me more money. I really wish I could just blow it all on motocross instead of shit I don't need to make more money. The amount of tax I pay on things during the year is crazy, but I usually don't pay income tax. Other government fees, registrations, and permits might as well be reworded as taxes.
Even without paying income tax, the government/irs is still winning big time. There's no way to really win against them.
Write offs aren't write offs unless they fall in value.
mx617
Posts
1614
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Trail CA
12/10/2018 10:08pm
mikec265 wrote:
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and...
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and rise in value with inflation. Those same write offs will also make me more money. I really wish I could just blow it all on motocross instead of shit I don't need to make more money. The amount of tax I pay on things during the year is crazy, but I usually don't pay income tax. Other government fees, registrations, and permits might as well be reworded as taxes.
Even without paying income tax, the government/irs is still winning big time. There's no way to really win against them.
ns503 wrote:
Write offs aren't write offs unless they fall in value.
Write offs purely for write offs are a waste of money. No one with a basic understanding of math would spend a dollar to save forty cents.

If it's something you otherwise need then fine.
ns503
Posts
4585
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies CA
12/11/2018 4:07am
mikec265 wrote:
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and...
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and rise in value with inflation. Those same write offs will also make me more money. I really wish I could just blow it all on motocross instead of shit I don't need to make more money. The amount of tax I pay on things during the year is crazy, but I usually don't pay income tax. Other government fees, registrations, and permits might as well be reworded as taxes.
Even without paying income tax, the government/irs is still winning big time. There's no way to really win against them.
ns503 wrote:
Write offs aren't write offs unless they fall in value.
mx617 wrote:
Write offs purely for write offs are a waste of money. No one with a basic understanding of math would spend a dollar to save forty...
Write offs purely for write offs are a waste of money. No one with a basic understanding of math would spend a dollar to save forty cents.

If it's something you otherwise need then fine.
Yes, exactly.

And if you sell something for more than its 'written off' value, then you need to do a recapture.

Puff puff pass pass.....
mxracer317
Posts
60
Joined
12/13/2008
Location
Bluffdale, UT US
12/11/2018 5:22pm
Markee wrote:
Me and my wife are in a unique situation this year. We both work for the same company in the steel industry. My pay is performance...
Me and my wife are in a unique situation this year. We both work for the same company in the steel industry. My pay is performance based bonus, so if we produce more tons, we make more money. Well last year I passed my last technical evaluation for top pay in my department (maintenance mechanic). This has been a record year for the company, so I've made more money in tons and more by evaluation increase leading into the problem...

The problem is being pushed just nearly over into a 2% increase in federal income tax. As of next year, we can max out 401k contributions at 11% a piece from our standard 5% we did this year to help, but that doesn't help me now.

Other than that can you guys think of anything else we can do?

We have no children.
Pay your taxes now. We are in a historic tax low. Taxes WILL go up in the future, quite a bit more. I’m a wealth advisor and all my clients are doing Roth IRA conversions right now. DM me if you have any personal questions.
mxracer317
Posts
60
Joined
12/13/2008
Location
Bluffdale, UT US
12/11/2018 5:24pm
SPYGUY wrote:
When you move into a new tax bracket, you only pay the higher tax rate on the income that is above the new, higher threshold. It...
When you move into a new tax bracket, you only pay the higher tax rate on the income that is above the new, higher threshold. It does not mean you will pay 2% more tax across the board.
Right. It’s call marginal tax. The combined amount is your effective tax rate.
DPR250R
Posts
2182
Joined
9/14/2006
Location
NJ US
12/14/2018 4:14am Edited Date/Time 12/14/2018 4:16am
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered...
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered the same way, Traditional and Roth. So it depends on what you think your tax bracket will be when you retire (or what taxes in general will be in the future, I'm guessing higher knowing the government) versus what your tax bracket is now. If your income is above a certain threshold you are ineligible to do a Roth, but you can do a traditional and later do a "back door Roth" conversion.

I was always told to contribute to your 401K only up to what your employer matches first, then max out an IRA, then go back and contribute more to your 401K if you have any extra funds left. I am self-employed so no 401K here, but this is what we have done for my wife in the past.

Like was said above though, you only pay the extra 2% on the amount crossing the threshold, so it's not so bad.
My advisor told me to max out my 401K first then come back to talk to him if I have any extra. Wonder what the difference in thought is?

As for the OP... I would second the advice of maxing out your 401K to 18,500 a year.

Also, who does your taxes? If you are concerned it might be a good idea to speak to a professional. Should just be a couple hundred for a tax accountant.
APLMAN99
Posts
12474
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
12/14/2018 5:54am
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered...
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered the same way, Traditional and Roth. So it depends on what you think your tax bracket will be when you retire (or what taxes in general will be in the future, I'm guessing higher knowing the government) versus what your tax bracket is now. If your income is above a certain threshold you are ineligible to do a Roth, but you can do a traditional and later do a "back door Roth" conversion.

I was always told to contribute to your 401K only up to what your employer matches first, then max out an IRA, then go back and contribute more to your 401K if you have any extra funds left. I am self-employed so no 401K here, but this is what we have done for my wife in the past.

Like was said above though, you only pay the extra 2% on the amount crossing the threshold, so it's not so bad.
DPR250R wrote:
My advisor told me to max out my 401K first then come back to talk to him if I have any extra. Wonder what the difference...
My advisor told me to max out my 401K first then come back to talk to him if I have any extra. Wonder what the difference in thought is?

As for the OP... I would second the advice of maxing out your 401K to 18,500 a year.

Also, who does your taxes? If you are concerned it might be a good idea to speak to a professional. Should just be a couple hundred for a tax accountant.
He may have been meaning to max it to the employer match level and not been very clear about it. I’ve seen that from a couple of people in the financial business who assume that everyone knows what they mean, but forgets that the general public only thinks about this stuff a few times a year.

Or it’s also possible that his recommendation is based on locking in a systematic savings plan that takes a little bit of effort to cancel or change, meaning that it’s more likely to be followed or continued during small periods of tough cash flow, etc.
APLMAN99
Posts
12474
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
12/14/2018 5:58am
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered...
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered the same way, Traditional and Roth. So it depends on what you think your tax bracket will be when you retire (or what taxes in general will be in the future, I'm guessing higher knowing the government) versus what your tax bracket is now. If your income is above a certain threshold you are ineligible to do a Roth, but you can do a traditional and later do a "back door Roth" conversion.

I was always told to contribute to your 401K only up to what your employer matches first, then max out an IRA, then go back and contribute more to your 401K if you have any extra funds left. I am self-employed so no 401K here, but this is what we have done for my wife in the past.

Like was said above though, you only pay the extra 2% on the amount crossing the threshold, so it's not so bad.
Actually a traditional is “tax deferred”, a Roth is tax free at withdrawal.
1
DPR250R
Posts
2182
Joined
9/14/2006
Location
NJ US
12/14/2018 6:07am
APLMAN99 wrote:
He may have been meaning to max it to the employer match level and not been very clear about it. I’ve seen that from a couple...
He may have been meaning to max it to the employer match level and not been very clear about it. I’ve seen that from a couple of people in the financial business who assume that everyone knows what they mean, but forgets that the general public only thinks about this stuff a few times a year.

Or it’s also possible that his recommendation is based on locking in a systematic savings plan that takes a little bit of effort to cancel or change, meaning that it’s more likely to be followed or continued during small periods of tough cash flow, etc.
Makes sense.. even I should have been clear saying that my adviser meant to max MY contribution then come talk to him. Meaning... after my contribution is maxed at 18,500... regardless of the employer match.
woodsrider427
Posts
127
Joined
12/11/2014
Location
Wake Forest, NC US
12/14/2018 6:17am Edited Date/Time 12/14/2018 6:21am
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered...
You can do an IRA as a Traditional or a Roth. Traditional is tax deductible now and a Roth is deferred. 401K's I believe are offered the same way, Traditional and Roth. So it depends on what you think your tax bracket will be when you retire (or what taxes in general will be in the future, I'm guessing higher knowing the government) versus what your tax bracket is now. If your income is above a certain threshold you are ineligible to do a Roth, but you can do a traditional and later do a "back door Roth" conversion.

I was always told to contribute to your 401K only up to what your employer matches first, then max out an IRA, then go back and contribute more to your 401K if you have any extra funds left. I am self-employed so no 401K here, but this is what we have done for my wife in the past.

Like was said above though, you only pay the extra 2% on the amount crossing the threshold, so it's not so bad.
APLMAN99 wrote:
Actually a traditional is “tax deferred”, a Roth is tax free at withdrawal.
Yes, I worded that wrong. A contribution to a traditional is tax deductible now and you pay taxes on withdrawal and the Roth is contributed to with after taxed money and tax free upon withdrawal. Like someone said above, pay the taxes now and use the Roth because it's likely taxes will be higher in the future. But everyone's tax situation is different and best to consult a professional.
I really wish they would go with a flat tax system and get rid of all this garbage, so confusing and overwhelming sometimes.
1
mikec265
Posts
1668
Joined
10/19/2015
Location
Edinboro, PA US
12/16/2018 7:07pm
mikec265 wrote:
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and...
I want to keep as much money as I legally can. I buy write offs for my niche in a common business that hold value and rise in value with inflation. Those same write offs will also make me more money. I really wish I could just blow it all on motocross instead of shit I don't need to make more money. The amount of tax I pay on things during the year is crazy, but I usually don't pay income tax. Other government fees, registrations, and permits might as well be reworded as taxes.
Even without paying income tax, the government/irs is still winning big time. There's no way to really win against them.
ns503 wrote:
Write offs aren't write offs unless they fall in value.
I can buy certain widgets used for $30,000 cash. New ones are $70,000. Typically they never drop below the value of $30,000 in today's funds. Every one I buy makes me more money. I'll probably keep doing this a long time. My money is hidden legally and rises in value with inflation. When $30k is worth 15k in 30 years, my widgets will be worth $60k each. By that time new widgets will be worth $140k.
I can work these widgets, rent them, sell them. Buy cheap, fix, and sell. Typically I just keep and work them.

Write offs don't have to decrease in value. If I buy a $30k widget with cash ( Which I bought 3 more in 2018),current tax laws allow a 100% depreciation aka write off. If I bought a new one widget for $70k it would lose value to $30k in 20 years. Buying new widgets in my niche would be stupid until the business is larger.

I just wish I could make good money from motocross and have a lot of free time. I don't love my widgets, but they've been good to me and my family.
ns503
Posts
4585
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies CA
12/17/2018 3:50am
Write offs don't have to decrease in value. If I buy a $30k widget with cash ( Which I bought 3 more in 2018),current tax laws allow a 100% depreciation aka write off.

Depreciation = 'write off' = decrease in value.

If there is no decrease in value, there is no depreciation. No 'write off'.

You're talking in contradictory circles.
1
mikec265
Posts
1668
Joined
10/19/2015
Location
Edinboro, PA US
12/17/2018 5:42am
ns503 wrote:
[i][b]Write offs don't have to decrease in value. If I buy a $30k widget with cash ( Which I bought 3 more in 2018),current tax laws...
Write offs don't have to decrease in value. If I buy a $30k widget with cash ( Which I bought 3 more in 2018),current tax laws allow a 100% depreciation aka write off.

Depreciation = 'write off' = decrease in value.

If there is no decrease in value, there is no depreciation. No 'write off'.

You're talking in contradictory circles.
Are you a tax professional? I've had 3 different accountants. All 3 have done it this way. Everyone in the same business as myself does it that way.

In conclusion you must be one smart sob since all of us are wrong. I will now tell my dentist that his new used chair is not a write off. I will tell the farmer the $30,000 used tractor does not come off his earned income. The excavating companies can no longer write off the good deal on a used dozer.
A trucking company can no longer write off the purchase of a used trailer. All because this ns503 figured out things proving every tax professional we've ever met to be wrong. You are the re-incarnation of Albert Einstein! Tax advise on Vital is the best! Thank you. Thank you very much!

Post a reply to: Making too much money (taxes)

The Latest