US MX bike

FreshTopEnd
Posts
13316
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:25pm
P wrote:
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come...
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come out the manufacture seems to kill itself trying to make it "different." I say just follow the blueprint that it out there.

Either way, I think that right about now might be a good time for someone to take another shot at it.


P
What's the production run, and what do they actually make in house?
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13316
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:29pm



BTW, people like AJ and those who put other exotics like together are the proper heirs of legends like the Rickman Brothers and Eric Cheney.

TerryB
Posts
2836
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Cambridge, MN, USA
3/18/2009 4:29pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 10:59pm
While I understand the logistics and timing say it's not feasible, I agree with you P. I'd love to see an American company build a serious MXer. I believe Cobra or Polaris would have the best shot at it. Throw some Ohlins suspenders on it to forego the r&d expense there (ok, so it's not 100% American made) and concentrate on the rest of the package.

I am, and always have been into stuff that's a little different, or one-off. Always wanted to own a Mugen (not like I had the skills to utilize what it had to offer) or Cagiva back in the day. Current interests include the Husqvarna 125 or or 250f (if God forbid I bought a four-stroke), or a TM144.

I know, just a pipe dream, but it'd be cool.

Back to bashing P's fantasy. Commence.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13316
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:30pm
Slow ~ Pro wrote:
I was on the ground level with Cannondale, actually sold a few. I rode them, I liked them. I thought the suspension was flawless. Heavy, slow...
I was on the ground level with Cannondale, actually sold a few. I rode them, I liked them. I thought the suspension was flawless.


Heavy, slow ?


Funny, but I don't remember them feeling heavy, or slow...

In 1997, there wasn't anything else to compare it with...The Yamaha, (YZ400F) came out in 1998.


I do remember it making a lot of engine noise, due to the plastic side cases.
Ohlins, right?

The Shop

TerryB
Posts
2836
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Cambridge, MN, USA
3/18/2009 4:33pm
Rupert X wrote:
Sean from COBRA was planning on mass-producing a pretty cool 2 stroke CR-250- like product called the "REV" - anybody remember that ? Sean told me...

Sean from COBRA was planning on mass-producing a pretty cool 2 stroke

CR-250- like product called the "REV" - anybody remember that ?

Sean told me recently it's parked at the Cobra factory.

Pretty sure he and a few other ex-Detroit automobile engineers started

the project and the REV company - it was a pretty cool bike actually, with

many high-quality components, if I recall correctly.....

Yes - It was to be AMERICAN MADE.

* I wish NASA would build an mx bike. With Chip Foose.

Yeah, I remember the Rev. Good idea in a fantasy world, but not much market for it, sad to say. Everybody wants a cookie-cutter thumper nowdays. Look at the struggle KTM has.
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:38pm
Okay, everyone over to the homepage...I built a poll where you can pick whether or not you'd buy a U.S.-made bike. Smile
DrSweden
Posts
6761
Joined
8/30/2008
Location
Stockholm, SE
3/18/2009 4:39pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 10:59pm
I wish someone stole the CR250 baking tin and stared mass produce those suckers in China or whatever. Maybe upgrade the suspension some. Some bling rims and gold details. Make it look factory, cool name etc.


This four stroke attempt is a dead fish. Focus on a cheap two stroke with cool looks and reliable engine is the key to stardom for me.


But I know shit.
Slow ~ Pro
Posts
3834
Joined
3/27/2008
Location
Capistrano Beach, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:44pm
Slow ~ Pro wrote:
I was on the ground level with Cannondale, actually sold a few. I rode them, I liked them. I thought the suspension was flawless. Heavy, slow...
I was on the ground level with Cannondale, actually sold a few. I rode them, I liked them. I thought the suspension was flawless.


Heavy, slow ?


Funny, but I don't remember them feeling heavy, or slow...

In 1997, there wasn't anything else to compare it with...The Yamaha, (YZ400F) came out in 1998.


I do remember it making a lot of engine noise, due to the plastic side cases.
Ohlins, right?
Correct...real shinny ones !
Rupert X
Posts
11045
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Newark, OH, USA
3/18/2009 4:46pm

Dammit -I thoroughly Googled but alas, found no pics of the REV ! motocross bike - if

anybody has pics, please put 'em up.
Slow ~ Pro
Posts
3834
Joined
3/27/2008
Location
Capistrano Beach, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:48pm
P wrote:
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come...
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come out the manufacture seems to kill itself trying to make it "different." I say just follow the blueprint that it out there.

Either way, I think that right about now might be a good time for someone to take another shot at it.


P
What's the production run, and what do they actually make in house?
Aren't these just a cross breed between Yamaha, and KTM ?

They make the exhaust brackets in house !
englishman
Posts
2817
Joined
3/7/2008
Location
England, GB
3/18/2009 4:52pm
P wrote:
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come...
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come out the manufacture seems to kill itself trying to make it "different." I say just follow the blueprint that it out there.

Either way, I think that right about now might be a good time for someone to take another shot at it.


P
What's the production run, and what do they actually make in house?
Slow ~ Pro wrote:
Aren't these just a cross breed between Yamaha, and KTM ?

They make the exhaust brackets in house !
Yeah man , like I said back on page 2 just build your own frame then slap someone elses stuff on it . Instant British made CCM Laughing
calimxer91
Posts
5077
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Lancaster, CA, USA
3/18/2009 4:53pm
Basically a frame manufacturer.If you look at the frame close up its trick.
freeh
Posts
800
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
3/18/2009 5:28pm
Ozzy wrote:
Sure, your 100% correct, I do have a lot to say, but for now I won't. I'm saving it for an interview. Not to bash, but...
Sure, your 100% correct, I do have a lot to say,
but for now I won't.
I'm saving it for an interview.
Not to bash, but the gods honest truth of it all!
But until then, no, we're not over-paid!
We're not this,
& not that.......
But there are issues & other things
that ruin it all, & then there's the
key thing, money & support!
So until such time, dream on!!!!!!!!!!
Dave O.Wink
I suppose I could add to this thread, but I am trying to forget my whole buell experience. The shame of it all is that we could have been competitive. It really is not rocket science.

Dave, remember the phrase "copy the _____ and we'll be good?"

Or what about that seat idea? Holy funk was that one dumb.
Tiki
Posts
10651
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
Corona, CA, USA
Fantasy
3/18/2009 5:29pm
P wrote:
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come...
Why is it that with America at the top of the MX/SX hill that we still can't manufacture a decent MX bike? Whenever something does come out the manufacture seems to kill itself trying to make it "different." I say just follow the blueprint that it out there.

Either way, I think that right about now might be a good time for someone to take another shot at it.


P
That bike is Sexy!
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
3/18/2009 7:01pm
The idea is nice in theory but in reality we should be focusing IMO on

1) Land and track closure issues. It won't matter where the bike is made if we have no place to ride.

2) Getting more people riding and racing. Absence of a 125 two stroke focus is seriously hurting our growth.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/18/2009 7:31pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 10:59pm
Jeez, this is sad. I just realized how we've fallen behind other manufacturing nations. Back in the 1980's, the US tried making a manufacturing come-back. Deming tried to bring an understanding of quality into our system, but it never stuck. It was strange. I was trained on GD&T (largely an effort of the aerospace industry), but few vendors understood it or knew its benefits. Quality through statistics was theoretically understood, but more a showpiece in the consumer field. I'd see development team in the auto industry get choked by feature creep while being held responsible for the implementation of best quality practice, which was a job in itself.

And now, it seems many have forgotten manufacturing quality, because so little manufacturing exists here. I received a first article report of new parts from a local vendor today. They supplied some process capability numbers (Cp and Cpk). The quality manager from the customer had no idea what Cp and Cpk meant. The vendor who supplied it couldn't differentiate between the two, and didn't understand that 1.0 is barely acceptable and 1.33 as a minimum is desirable.

We've forgotten because we don't manufacture. Even if we somehow could get back the manufacturing business, I'd doubt we'd stand a chance being competitive, because we're forgetting what's important.
Craze
Posts
1412
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Sin City, NV, USA
3/18/2009 8:02pm Edited Date/Time 3/18/2009 8:04pm
DrSweden wrote:
I wish someone stole the CR250 baking tin and stared mass produce those suckers in China or whatever. Maybe upgrade the suspension some. Some bling rims...
I wish someone stole the CR250 baking tin and stared mass produce those suckers in China or whatever. Maybe upgrade the suspension some. Some bling rims and gold details. Make it look factory, cool name etc.


This four stroke attempt is a dead fish. Focus on a cheap two stroke with cool looks and reliable engine is the key to stardom for me.


But I know shit.
It would probably have too much lead content in it to import....You know all the little kids would be chewing on the cable ends and related lead parts, just like they do all over the United States now!!!
BobbyM
Posts
21436
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
3/18/2009 8:49pm
[img]http://www.servicehonda.com/images/models/bailey%20af/leftside.jpg[/img] [img]http://www.servicehonda.com/images/models/kx500af/2009/leftwb600.jpg[/img] BTW, people like AJ and those who put other exotics like together are the proper heirs of legends like the Rickman Brothers and Eric...



BTW, people like AJ and those who put other exotics like together are the proper heirs of legends like the Rickman Brothers and Eric Cheney.

I got three words for you guvnor....DMS!

Smile
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13316
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
3/18/2009 9:51pm
Hometown, baby!!



DoubleDeuces
Posts
15
Joined
1/25/2009
Location
Folsom, CA, USA
3/18/2009 10:05pm
just go buy a Cobra
SPYGUY
Posts
2174
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
3/18/2009 10:08pm
Slow ~ Pro wrote:
Good point Gibby... The American "Cannondale" went for $8995.00 in 1997. So 12 year later, I would venture the guess of an American bike around $15,000.00...
Good point Gibby...

The American "Cannondale" went for $8995.00 in 1997.

So 12 year later, I would venture the guess of an American bike around $15,000.00

Cannondale parts were promised all day long...None available, but a really nice promise was made.
You're a few years off. The Cannondale didn't come out until late 2001 or so.
Slow ~ Pro
Posts
3834
Joined
3/27/2008
Location
Capistrano Beach, CA, USA
3/18/2009 11:24pm Edited Date/Time 3/18/2009 11:26pm
Slow ~ Pro wrote:
Good point Gibby... The American "Cannondale" went for $8995.00 in 1997. So 12 year later, I would venture the guess of an American bike around $15,000.00...
Good point Gibby...

The American "Cannondale" went for $8995.00 in 1997.

So 12 year later, I would venture the guess of an American bike around $15,000.00

Cannondale parts were promised all day long...None available, but a really nice promise was made.
SPYGUY wrote:
You're a few years off. The Cannondale didn't come out until late 2001 or so.
You know ?
You're right, I am lost. I apologize...I mixed my employment up, and got confused.

Age...It's a bitch !
Ozzy
Posts
1115
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Santa Clarita, CA, USA
3/19/2009 12:43am Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 10:59pm
"FREEH".......yo yo hello pal.Woohoo
Glad your still here.Woohoo
I love reading all this.
The good, bad & the ugly!
Miss ya & the project too.
Forgetting is what it is & I fully
understand, but for me I can't.
Take it easy.Woohoo
Dave O.Wink
BM255
Posts
465
Joined
8/1/2008
Location
Auckland, NZ
3/19/2009 3:25am
AJ wrote:
"Made in USA" and desgned engineered in USA , without reinventing the wheel seems like drawing a fine line in the sand while in the sahara...
"Made in USA"


and desgned engineered in USA , without reinventing the wheel

seems like

drawing a fine line in the sand while in the sahara.


either its redesigned . and engineered from the ground up..

or its a copy??



like any Ford or Chevy "made in the USA"

so are all of Service Powersports current 12 model line up..


we are using parts sourced from Japan , and basing it off a proven design with some refinements for the particular chassis or engine combination.

i could make complet eframes almost as easily and sometimes easier than the modifications it takes for some models,
sznd i could source suspension,brakes, wheels, and other parts from the same vendors the current Japaneses OEMS do..

but there is no good reason to (and good reasons not to with added cost actually in lower evolumes les sthan 10,000 units)

Wink


but i understand where you are coming from Paul.

.

i just dont think you will see any american company jump into a full from the ground up

MX bike ? not the time or place to do so ,at all.



You would be far more likely to see the various Japaneses OEMs stangant thier current MX models , or drop them


and you WILL see some various off road models

(that the public likeky thinks are successful and will be surprised)

dropped by some of the OEMS for 2010..

if my crystal ball is working well

(typically it does ok, other than for lotto numbers)



Hi AJ,
What did you think of the article I sent you? I'm curious to know what differences you noticed between your bikes and the one in the article.

Cheers
croom mx
Posts
1964
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
miami, FL, USA
3/19/2009 5:24am Edited Date/Time 3/19/2009 6:54am
In reality the USA could build the best MX bikes in the world, but investors invest money on projects that make money not lose money. Corporations like Honda, Yamaha, Suzuki, Kawasaki already have assembly lines building thousands of other types of bikes so they dont have to invest huge sums of money to start a MX prototype. The infrastructure already exists and does not have to purchased again.
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
3/19/2009 7:32am
P wrote:
I guess the glass is half empty.


P
GuyB wrote:
If you say so. I still haven't seen where you said you'd lay down your cash for one if it was available. Trying to entice someone...
If you say so. I still haven't seen where you said you'd lay down your cash for one if it was available.

Trying to entice someone to lay out millions of dollars just because, "It'd be cool to see an American brand in motocross," is not much incentive.

Here's one more what-if...spare parts.
I guess you don't read my replies then. I believe that I said in an earlier post that I would if it was on par with what is current available and I think that is possible. If every test that I've read there isn't a perfect bike out there.

Either way, it looks like this thread didn't turn out so bad.


P
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
3/19/2009 7:37am
englishman wrote:
Hey do what we do in England . Design a frame then buy a bunch of other peoples stuff and slap it on there BINGO good...
Hey do what we do in England . Design a frame then buy a bunch of other peoples stuff and slap it on there BINGO good to go.

( C.C.M in case you didn't know what I was blathering about)



Yamaha motor , KTM suspension thier own frame.
That's the kind of thing that I'm talking about. It seems like that is done quite a bit in other countries, but no one seems to really care about doing that here, at leas not with enough units to make it a legal "production" bike. It would be nice to see something like that out on the track, but with a KTM motor and Yamaha suspension.Wink Smile


P
WORCSRacer
Posts
2295
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Clovis, CA, USA
3/19/2009 8:28am
jtomasik wrote:
Jeez, this is sad. I just realized how we've fallen behind other manufacturing nations. Back in the 1980's, the US tried making a manufacturing come-back. Deming...
Jeez, this is sad. I just realized how we've fallen behind other manufacturing nations. Back in the 1980's, the US tried making a manufacturing come-back. Deming tried to bring an understanding of quality into our system, but it never stuck. It was strange. I was trained on GD&T (largely an effort of the aerospace industry), but few vendors understood it or knew its benefits. Quality through statistics was theoretically understood, but more a showpiece in the consumer field. I'd see development team in the auto industry get choked by feature creep while being held responsible for the implementation of best quality practice, which was a job in itself.

And now, it seems many have forgotten manufacturing quality, because so little manufacturing exists here. I received a first article report of new parts from a local vendor today. They supplied some process capability numbers (Cp and Cpk). The quality manager from the customer had no idea what Cp and Cpk meant. The vendor who supplied it couldn't differentiate between the two, and didn't understand that 1.0 is barely acceptable and 1.33 as a minimum is desirable.

We've forgotten because we don't manufacture. Even if we somehow could get back the manufacturing business, I'd doubt we'd stand a chance being competitive, because we're forgetting what's important.
John John John... how in the world do you expect a country full of people who will pay $300 for a pair of ripped and scuffed jeans with holes in them to understand quality? Cool

Truth is this is a country spending trillions of dollars on crap from all over the world at the local Megamart and considers Mickey D's and Taco Bell food staples. John you are correct, Americans don't understand quality nor do they understand having an entrepreneurial spirit. IMO it falls back to our educational system which, because its now run by politicians, doesn't teach trades but instead teaches kids to pass the proficiency tests mandated by the state. Sure its done with the hope of no child being left behind and that everyone should be taught the same way but unfortunately it doesn't work. I know plenty of people, myself included, who hate "school" but love to learn. America of the 50's was far more innovative than the America of the 21st century and this thread is a perfect example of what's not so healthy in America anymore. The only thing it seems anyone considers anymore is "let's not do it because we won't make a shit load of money" .
Foster576
Posts
1166
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
El Paso, TX, USA
3/19/2009 9:32am
Foster576 wrote:
Anyone ever try to ride one of the Cannondales? It was a heavy slow turd.
Tiki wrote:
It had a lot of support. Cannondale was on the right idea, trying to re-invent the wheel on the initial outing isn't as easy as it...
It had a lot of support. Cannondale was on the right idea, trying to re-invent the wheel on the initial outing isn't as easy as it turned out.

If an american company came out with another heavy slow turd that actually made it to market, I would buy it. Check out all the support for Gas Gas, Husaberg et,al.

The old Husabergs never made it to the finish line, now they seem to have it fixed.
Slow ~ Pro wrote:
I was on the ground level with Cannondale, actually sold a few. I rode them, I liked them. I thought the suspension was flawless. Heavy, slow...
I was on the ground level with Cannondale, actually sold a few. I rode them, I liked them. I thought the suspension was flawless.


Heavy, slow ?


Funny, but I don't remember them feeling heavy, or slow...

In 1997, there wasn't anything else to compare it with...The Yamaha, (YZ400F) came out in 1998.


I do remember it making a lot of engine noise, due to the plastic side cases.
Ah yea I rode one in 2003 that a guy had at a local track. Just got off a 03 YZ450 on to a cannondale and it didnt impress me. I agree about the suspension, it was awesome.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13316
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
3/19/2009 9:36am
There sure were a ton of Ohlins forks and shock flying around ebay after the liquidation.

Post a reply to: US MX bike

The Latest