Who agrees with Anderson's DQ?

hoots3pak
Profile picture for user hoots3pak
Posts
266
Joined
7/5/2008
Location
Mohave, CA, USA
hoots3pak 1/22/2017 4:26pm
1/22/2017 4:26pm
Spirit of the Law vs. Letter of the Law.
The same people bitching to their friends that they got a speeding ticket for going 68 in a 65 zone. Stop crying baby. That's the law.
No Substance.


Sometimes You Go Down........
Crush
Profile picture for user Crush
Posts
21097
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
Crush 1/22/2017 4:27pm
1/22/2017 4:27pm
scott_nz wrote:
seems like the tunnel action was the second time he had hit him Steve Matthes ‏@pulpmx 59m59 minutes ago More The Anderson DQ was determined by...
seems like the tunnel action was the second time he had hit him

Steve Matthes ‏@pulpmx 59m59 minutes ago
More
The Anderson DQ was determined by his actions by podium after race where officials say he started hitting VF in helmet, not tunnel "thing"

anyone change their view on it with more information ?
Where's the proof. Cause I bet the officials didn't see it being on the floor.

All the more reason for there to be a formal review process.
AdamWGolen 1/22/2017 4:37pm
1/22/2017 4:37pm
Seriously, you intentionally hit someone like Anderson did, automatic DQ. He could have rode the semi and made the main.
Mini Elsinore
Profile picture for user Mini Elsinore
Posts
1967
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Huntington Beach, CA, USA
Mini Elsinore 1/22/2017 4:40pm
1/22/2017 4:40pm
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish Anderson and make bank from it...just like Peick last year.

The Shop

See All »
AdamWGolen 1/22/2017 4:43pm
1/22/2017 4:43pm
Mini Elsinore wrote:
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish...
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish Anderson and make bank from it...just like Peick last year.
Of course they will. Drama sells
Brittneyb30 1/22/2017 4:46pm
1/22/2017 4:46pm
I'm probably in the minority, but I think he deserved the punishment. He and his team should have been notified though. I get he was upset, but that doesn't make it right. I didn't see what Steve tweeted about, but I was sitting right by the tunnel. I saw Vince and his mechanic coming in & Jason speed up to catch them. He had the option to ride away and come back for his semi race. Instead he hit him in the tunnel & in front of the little KTM kids. Personally I think it doesn't set the right example for the future of the sport.

I saw him come out for the semi & I was surprised after the Weston incident last year. Then a few moments later I saw him & many team members walking back.
mx836
Profile picture for user mx836
Posts
5577
Joined
4/2/2008
Location
;, BF
mx836 1/22/2017 5:01pm
1/22/2017 5:01pm
Anderson was trying to pass Vince on the outside and cut down early. What did he expect Vince to do? Roll around the inside and let him by? I don't care about the penalty either way, but I find it very funny that Anderson of all people is the one retaliating after the race. He finally got some of his own medicine as far as I see it. Sucks he got dq'd, but that's the way it goes. Should have known better. Here's to hoping he can make the remaining races interesting. We are going to need something with K-roc out and Tomac off the pace.
Dan-The-Man 1/22/2017 5:02pm
1/22/2017 5:02pm
Mini Elsinore wrote:
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish...
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish Anderson and make bank from it...just like Peick last year.
AdamWGolen wrote:
Of course they will. Drama sells
It's a bit silly they say we don't tolerate this type of behavior in the sport and then use it in every ad all year long. Good point.
colorado2day
Profile picture for user colorado2day
Posts
561
Joined
11/4/2016
Location
Colorado Springs, CO, USA
colorado2day 1/22/2017 5:04pm
1/22/2017 5:04pm
Julian wrote:
our sport should be a respectable sport - this means standards must be upheld.
This behavior is below our standards.
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you are offended by the 30 second girl ?
And I bet you voted for Hillary too !


Politically-correct-douche 1/22/2017 5:08pm
1/22/2017 5:08pm Edited Date/Time 1/22/2017 5:10pm
Julian wrote:
our sport should be a respectable sport - this means standards must be upheld.
This behavior is below our standards.
colorado2day wrote:
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you...
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you are offended by the 30 second girl ?
And I bet you voted for Hillary too !


Who is this doll Chelsea and where was she during my march yesterday....I would have liked to ride that smile all the way to D.C. !
AdamWGolen 1/22/2017 5:08pm
1/22/2017 5:08pm
Mini Elsinore wrote:
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish...
You can bet your sweet deriere that FELD will milk this on every "MON$TER SX by FELD" highlight reel for the rest of the season. Punish Anderson and make bank from it...just like Peick last year.
AdamWGolen wrote:
Of course they will. Drama sells
Dan-The-Man wrote:
It's a bit silly they say we don't tolerate this type of behavior in the sport and then use it in every ad all year long...
It's a bit silly they say we don't tolerate this type of behavior in the sport and then use it in every ad all year long. Good point.
That's pretty much how society works. Now Ralph and Jeff will hype it up for the next few rounds, forget about it and then bring it up later on in the season.
akillerwombat
Profile picture for user akillerwombat
Posts
3211
Joined
10/16/2013
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
akillerwombat 1/22/2017 5:10pm
1/22/2017 5:10pm
colorado2day wrote:
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you...
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you are offended by the 30 second girl ?
And I bet you voted for Hillary too !


Classic – has nothing of substance to say so he makes fun of a woman.
colorado2day
Profile picture for user colorado2day
Posts
561
Joined
11/4/2016
Location
Colorado Springs, CO, USA
colorado2day 1/22/2017 5:26pm
1/22/2017 5:26pm
colorado2day wrote:
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you...
What are you ? A bleeding heart ? It freaking dirt bike racing. The guy Ando slapped had on a snell dot helmet. I bet you are offended by the 30 second girl ?
And I bet you voted for Hillary too !


akillerwombat wrote:
Classic – has nothing of substance to say so he makes fun of a woman.
Hodaka guy,

I already said my piece earlier on this lovely positive subject. FO

bushman
Profile picture for user bushman
Posts
51
Joined
3/31/2016
Location
USA
bushman 1/22/2017 5:41pm
1/22/2017 5:41pm
you can take all your guys dicks who took this into the political place and add them up and you won't get a proper cock, your a bunch of fools, this thread had some steam and was getting somewhere, Bushman is out, had some fun here the last couple days however bye for now pricks, see ya and wouldn't wanna be ya's!
rancor19
Profile picture for user rancor19
Posts
570
Joined
10/15/2016
Location
Springfield, OR, USA
rancor19 1/22/2017 5:51pm
1/22/2017 5:51pm
wut
akillerwombat
Profile picture for user akillerwombat
Posts
3211
Joined
10/16/2013
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
akillerwombat 1/22/2017 5:56pm
1/22/2017 5:56pm Edited Date/Time 1/22/2017 6:02pm
colorado2day wrote:
Hodaka guy,

I already said my piece earlier on this lovely positive subject. FO

And it was just as ignorant as your last one.

As I stated before, rules are rules and Ando knows them. He chose to break them and thus got clicked with the DQ. If you don't like it then work to get the fucking rules changed but instead, what do you do? You bitch about it on an internet forum and make fun of women.

Was the DQ the right course of action in my eyes, fuck no. He should have been fined and forced to ride the LCQ but I don't make the rules.
Radical
Profile picture for user Radical
Posts
2887
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
Radical 1/22/2017 6:00pm
1/22/2017 6:00pm
A fine would be appropriate for this.

Pit Row

See All »
Hut
Profile picture for user Hut
Posts
10281
Joined
4/27/2010
Location
USA
Hut 1/22/2017 6:06pm
1/22/2017 6:06pm
burnside wrote:
Disqualify him, FINE. But then don't throw the bitch slap into all your highlight reels and market the shit out of it like they do with...
Disqualify him, FINE.

But then don't throw the bitch slap into all your highlight reels and market the shit out of it like they do with all the other fights and scraps.
Agreed
Jspazz
Profile picture for user Jspazz
Posts
159
Joined
2/1/2015
Location
CA
Jspazz 1/22/2017 6:11pm
1/22/2017 6:11pm
sign up to race, you sign up for TV and waive your rights.

AMA enforces the rules, FELD promotes the event.

no link.

Why bitch about that?
LungButter
Profile picture for user LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
LungButter 1/22/2017 6:12pm
1/22/2017 6:12pm
I agree with the DQ.

How many dudes has Anderson roughed up? Looks to me like he can't handle a little of his own medicine.
dkg
Profile picture for user dkg
Posts
1885
Joined
9/12/2010
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
dkg 1/22/2017 6:49pm
1/22/2017 6:49pm
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules and process are completely screwed up. I can see a rule where a physical altercation between riders while the race is in progress should result in immediate disqualification. On the other hand something like the JA/VF incident should require more than a simple knee jerk inquiry before the decision to disqualify takes place. For instance, the DQ does not take into account anything that was said, the severity of the altercation, the involvement of third parties ( the mechanic) it simply issues the DQ for the swipe to th back of the head. I've seen pictures on here where there appears to be simultaneous impact between JA slap to VF helmet and th mechanics pushing JA. Maybe there should have been two disqualifications. I don't know any of these answers, but, am fairly certain that none of them were explored prior to the DQ being issued. For a during the race altercation immediate response is required, for those not taking place while the event is in progress, a little more deliberation should be afforded. There is absolutely too much at stake to not allow for a reasonable inquiry.
MotoX85
Profile picture for user MotoX85
Posts
2199
Joined
10/9/2011
Location
Centralia, IL, USA
MotoX85 1/22/2017 6:55pm
1/22/2017 6:55pm Edited Date/Time 1/22/2017 6:57pm
I agree with it........but if they show it in every commercial 100 times a night than that is total bullshit. If I see that replayed over and over than Anderson needs to say aomething.

Also, that track incident was Andersons fault. Just like Stewart and Dungey incident. You can't turn down that hard, at, at that level, and not expect another rider to nor be there. I can't stand Friese and wish he'd get the hell off the track, but that was Jason's fault.
Stoneface
Profile picture for user Stoneface
Posts
325
Joined
5/21/2010
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
Stoneface 1/22/2017 7:01pm
1/22/2017 7:01pm
I would think Husqvarna would reem the team manager over letting their title contender go off the reservation like that. Where the hell were the Husky people to intercept Anderson when he came off the track? Catastrophic mistake in terms of the title chase. Anderson is fast enough to win the title this year.
Absolutely no excuses after what happened to Peick last year. SMDH
gabrielito
Profile picture for user gabrielito
Posts
783
Joined
1/16/2016
Location
Saint Paul, MN, USA
gabrielito 1/22/2017 7:02pm
1/22/2017 7:02pm
dkg wrote:
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules...
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules and process are completely screwed up. I can see a rule where a physical altercation between riders while the race is in progress should result in immediate disqualification. On the other hand something like the JA/VF incident should require more than a simple knee jerk inquiry before the decision to disqualify takes place. For instance, the DQ does not take into account anything that was said, the severity of the altercation, the involvement of third parties ( the mechanic) it simply issues the DQ for the swipe to th back of the head. I've seen pictures on here where there appears to be simultaneous impact between JA slap to VF helmet and th mechanics pushing JA. Maybe there should have been two disqualifications. I don't know any of these answers, but, am fairly certain that none of them were explored prior to the DQ being issued. For a during the race altercation immediate response is required, for those not taking place while the event is in progress, a little more deliberation should be afforded. There is absolutely too much at stake to not allow for a reasonable inquiry.
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked the other way.
Markee
Profile picture for user Markee
Posts
3661
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA, USA
Markee 1/22/2017 7:33pm
1/22/2017 7:33pm
Nope. VF sucks
tyler durden
Profile picture for user tyler durden
Posts
376
Joined
10/2/2010
Location
Dallas, TX, USA
tyler durden 1/22/2017 7:39pm
1/22/2017 7:39pm
dkg wrote:
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules...
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules and process are completely screwed up. I can see a rule where a physical altercation between riders while the race is in progress should result in immediate disqualification. On the other hand something like the JA/VF incident should require more than a simple knee jerk inquiry before the decision to disqualify takes place. For instance, the DQ does not take into account anything that was said, the severity of the altercation, the involvement of third parties ( the mechanic) it simply issues the DQ for the swipe to th back of the head. I've seen pictures on here where there appears to be simultaneous impact between JA slap to VF helmet and th mechanics pushing JA. Maybe there should have been two disqualifications. I don't know any of these answers, but, am fairly certain that none of them were explored prior to the DQ being issued. For a during the race altercation immediate response is required, for those not taking place while the event is in progress, a little more deliberation should be afforded. There is absolutely too much at stake to not allow for a reasonable inquiry.
gabrielito wrote:
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked...
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked the other way.
anderson's a bit of an asshole. most of the "stars" are not. that goes along way.
TeamGreen
Profile picture for user TeamGreen
Posts
37095
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
TeamGreen 1/22/2017 7:43pm
1/22/2017 7:43pm
dkg wrote:
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules...
Under the rules it probably was the right decision. Don't take this statement as meaning I think it was the right outcome. I think the rules and process are completely screwed up. I can see a rule where a physical altercation between riders while the race is in progress should result in immediate disqualification. On the other hand something like the JA/VF incident should require more than a simple knee jerk inquiry before the decision to disqualify takes place. For instance, the DQ does not take into account anything that was said, the severity of the altercation, the involvement of third parties ( the mechanic) it simply issues the DQ for the swipe to th back of the head. I've seen pictures on here where there appears to be simultaneous impact between JA slap to VF helmet and th mechanics pushing JA. Maybe there should have been two disqualifications. I don't know any of these answers, but, am fairly certain that none of them were explored prior to the DQ being issued. For a during the race altercation immediate response is required, for those not taking place while the event is in progress, a little more deliberation should be afforded. There is absolutely too much at stake to not allow for a reasonable inquiry.
gabrielito wrote:
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked...
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked the other way.
tyler durden wrote:
anderson's a bit of an asshole. most of the "stars" are not. that goes along way.
Really. And you know this how?
RD757
Profile picture for user RD757
Posts
113
Joined
10/5/2016
Location
Streetsboro, OH, USA
RD757 1/22/2017 8:13pm
1/22/2017 8:13pm
I'm not surprised, if Jason is mad enough to try to hit someone in the head there is no telling what kind of damage he could have done on the track.
tyler durden
Profile picture for user tyler durden
Posts
376
Joined
10/2/2010
Location
Dallas, TX, USA
tyler durden 1/22/2017 8:14pm
1/22/2017 8:14pm
gabrielito wrote:
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked...
This is just another instance where the rider gets screwed because of no policy safeguards. Had it been one of the "stars" they would have looked the other way.
tyler durden wrote:
anderson's a bit of an asshole. most of the "stars" are not. that goes along way.
TeamGreen wrote:
Really. And you know this how?
he rides like an asshole. is that better?

Post a reply to: Who agrees with Anderson's DQ?