Toy hauler?

Racer142
Posts
480
Joined
2/23/2015
Location
Byhalia, MS, USA
Edited Date/Time 12/13/2015 12:27pm
I figure this either goes here or non moto but I think it's more moto than not so here. Quick toy hauler question, what size toy haulers do most people have and what are you hauling it with? How many people do you normally have sleep in it and what's the most you think you could fit relatively comfortably? I'm thinking about getting one this year but I'm debating on size and the truck to haul it with. Right now I'm bouncing between a ram 1500 with the eco diesel rated 8k towing and the 2500. I found a pioneer 28' bumper pull toy hauler with a dry weight around 6500# which is well within the towing for the eco diesel but that's dry weight. Add in 3 bikes, a generator, gas, gear, food, and water and I think it might be pushing the limit. But that eco diesel sure rides nice and 25 plus mpg sure is alluring. So I'm just trying to gauge what other people are pulling and with what. Trust me I've searched this forum and found a few threads but not really what I was looking for. I know I can find all the physical numbers but I'm looking more at real world application.
|
MxKing809
Posts
6374
Joined
10/13/2013
Location
Big Sand Whoops, MI, USA
Fantasy
12/6/2015 9:10am
My dad hauls a 3 axle 34 foot toy hauler with a 2014 F150 long box Eco-boost 6 cylinder.
Racer142
Posts
480
Joined
2/23/2015
Location
Byhalia, MS, USA
12/6/2015 4:27pm
All the members on here and all the toy haulers I see at the track and only 1 person has any input on what they like/dislike or size or anything?
12/6/2015 4:39pm Edited Date/Time 12/6/2015 4:40pm
I have a 21 foot toy hauler that I tow with an F-150 with a 5.4 liter. I am only towing one bike usually, along with tools and things I'll need for my wife and toddler on a race weekend. A half ton truck is ok for a 21 foot toyhauer. If I was going to pull a bigger trailer or heavier load, I'd opt for a diesel.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/6/2015 4:55pm
How many bikes and people do you plan to haul? How many times do you plan to flush the toilet and take showers when you have no outside hookups at the track?

The Shop

12/6/2015 6:26pm
I have a Tundra with the 5.7 L and tow a 24FT Toyhauler. It's under 5000 lbs dry and fully loaded with gear, toys, and water, etc is about 8000 lbs. I've had a bigger and heavier 26 footer that I used to tow that when fully loaded was 9500 lbs. Tundras can tow up to 10,400 lbs. I recommend only towing up to about ~80% of your trucks max tow capacity for safety reasons. Sure, the trucks will "pull" a lot more weight easily. The issue is suspension and braking for safety purposes. Towing over your trucks max capacity is a safety risk and is irresponsible, especially if you are towing in the mountains. If you are looking at buying a half ton truck, I recommend staying at or under a 25ft toy hauler and keep the dry weight to 6000 lbs or less. If you are looking at getting a new truck along with your new toy hauler, the new Tundras and Titans are coming out with a 5L Cummins Diesel truck next year with a tow capacity of about 12,000 lbs. The trucks are said to get an average fuel economy in the low to mid 20's/gal. That's a hard bargain to beat if you ask me.


As for the size of the toy hauler, I've never been one to want it to be a house on wheels. I like the basics of nice sleeping areas that are comfortable then make sure you have the basics - a good shower/bathroom with lots of fresh water storage (so you can take a lot of showers after riding a lot), stove, microwave, frig/freezer, etc. You can always add a TV yourself. Also, I don't care for the onboard generators. No matter how "quiet" they say they are, at night with the AC running they are still load as hell IMO. Get yourself a couple Honda or Yamaha inverter generators that are super quiet and run a long time on a tank of gas.

All JMHO. Hope it helps. I've had 2 toy haulers and rented about a dozen different ones - which isn't a bad thing to do before you buy one. See what you like and what you dislike before you sink money into it.
TallCan 16
Posts
132
Joined
11/22/2011
Location
Bellingham, WA, USA
12/6/2015 6:28pm
I would suggest you test drive one if you haven't already. I did, and it felt to me like the tranny would be all over the place trying to climb a hill pulling anything significant. Would you be driving through mountain passes? If so, I would look at something else. (Opinion below based on having to travel through mountain passes). The ecodiesel is really intended to be a gas sipper around town.

I do feel like there is a gap in the market for people who want to tow a 6-10k lb trailer. My Tundra with 5.7 feels like it struggles (imo) pulling my 16ft cargo trailer loaded to approx. 6k even though it is rated much higher. However I do not need 6.7 l of diesel and 800 lb-ft of torque. I would say a half ton is not enough. But the current 3/4 tons are overkill due to the "torque wars" marketing campaign. They are geared at chest-pounding construction workers (most who need nowhere near that much torque), not weekend warriors. I feel like the Cummins 5.9 was just about a perfect balance for the weekend warrior of somewhat decent mileage in town during the week, with good power to haul on the weekend - oh well. The new Nissan 5.0 Cummins V8 truck looks interesting. I haven't heard much about the ecoboosts but basic physics and comparison would suggest they are probably a bit on the weak side.
TallCan 16
Posts
132
Joined
11/22/2011
Location
Bellingham, WA, USA
12/6/2015 6:36pm Edited Date/Time 12/6/2015 6:41pm
Tbonespop I think we pretty much said the same thing. I agree with what you have said - the Tundra will do it, don't get me wrong, but my feeling is you are greatly accelerating the wear on the vehicle.

Before my cargo trailer I had a 26' toy hauler, 8k dry, even towing it dry was waaay too much for the Tundra.
Its169
Posts
36
Joined
11/30/2015
Location
Australia and, TX, USA
12/6/2015 7:02pm
I have a 24 ft KZ mtx is just under 4000 lb dry and we load it with 2 big bikes, 2 85's, 1 50 and 2 pit bikes. Plus food, water,genny and gear for a family of 5. It is towed by 5.7 Ram and 5.4 Suburban. They do it pretty easy and I drive to the speed limit. Fuel consumption is 8mpg and 12 for the Suburban. Bedding= me and missus in queen, oldest on fold out couch and 2 other kids in a double. Its pretty tight but good family mx fun. Has a good sized shower which is awesome after riding all day. Towing can be hard on trannies so like earlier said be way under maximum load if possible. Never push it to do things that may turn out dangerous, expensive or both. What ever you get you will enjoy.
Racer142
Posts
480
Joined
2/23/2015
Location
Byhalia, MS, USA
12/6/2015 7:14pm
My personal use is most likely going to be 3-4 guys with 3-4 full size bikes. But I think that's all irrelevant as I can look up numbers all day long. I'm more looking for what people are doing real world. I've looked at a couple campers that say sleeps 6 or 8 and I guess they would physically fit as long as they don't move at night. Same with towing. I can add the weight of the camper and gear and compare to the tow rating but that doesn't make it safe both driving and on my equipment. So I was hoping to hear what people are actually using and for what. I'm not married and don't have kids so it'll be 2-6 adults trying to sleep in it.
fisher725
Posts
55
Joined
2/26/2014
Location
Mount Vernon, MO, USA
12/6/2015 7:33pm
We have a 28ft bumper pull that has a 10 ft separate shop. We use this when it is just the wife and kid. I pull it with a 3/4 GMC gas. Its Gross weight is 8700. It works well just tight on space when you start adding people. It sleeps 6 but is cramped if all 6 are up. If we have our extended racing family going with us or staying for a few days, we take a 39' 5th wheel. It has a 12ft separate shop. We pull this with a new F350 with the 6.7 Powerstroke. It has a Gross of 18k.

I would suggest finding the best deal that you can afford. I love the 5th wheel as it sleeps a ton, has 3 slide outs and feels like a home away from home but our bumper pull cost a fraction of what the 5th wheel did and serves its purpose.
captmoto
Posts
5917
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
12/6/2015 7:40pm
The biggest thing is all the toyhauler builders lie about the dry weight first. Add batteries, AC unit, propane tanks, generator, awning and a spare tire to the dry weight.
The cargo capacity gets eaten up with the weight of water. 100 gallons = 835 lbs.
I have a 23' Weekend Warrior Superlite. With the basic load of camping stuff, bedding, food etc and 50 gallons of water, 1 bike with gearbag, my trailer comes in right at 7000 lbs. The trailer is rated at 7500lbs gcvw.
The guys selling you the trailer will tell you you can pull with a half ton all day long. Somebody else posted not pulling more than 21' with a 1/2 ton, I agree.
The best thing to do is tow it down to a truck scale and weigh it for the real dry weight
12/6/2015 7:48pm
y'all must make serious cash to afford these things Unsure
shane509
Posts
160
Joined
4/18/2013
Location
Lumberton, MS, USA
12/6/2015 8:18pm
i have a 24' vintage outlaw with separate garage/living quarters. Only have had two bikes in the back along with generator, table, chairs etc. Its rated just at 10k pounds, and I pull it with a cummins 2500 with ease, gas mileage is right at 11 going 74. It has opposing couches that fold down to beds, sleeps 2 adults on each with 1 adult on a twin air mattress in the kitchen area. If you are interested in it, I actually have it for sale.
gharmon
Posts
2771
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Valley, AL, USA
12/6/2015 8:21pm
y'all must make serious cash to afford these things Unsure
Nope, I make payments. lol

I have a 2011 Del Mar 34ft bumper pull. I was told it weighed in at 7k empty. I have yet to weigh it. I have only had mine about 3 months. It has a queen up front, a fold down couch and two fulls that let down in the storage area. If you let both beds all the way down, no way a full size bike fits in their, so they would have to sit out under the awning. I pull mine with a 2013 F250 6.7 diesel (making payments on that one too). It pulls it fine but I don't know how safe I would be trying to pull it with my F150. I surely wouldn't pull it at 75.
Juss
Posts
1101
Joined
4/14/2011
Location
Bakersfield, CA, USA
12/6/2015 8:27pm
MxKing809 wrote:
My dad hauls a 3 axle 34 foot toy hauler with a 2014 F150 long box Eco-boost 6 cylinder.
I'm calling horse shit on that!
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/6/2015 8:31pm
TallCan 16 wrote:
I would suggest you test drive one if you haven't already. I did, and it felt to me like the tranny would be all over the...
I would suggest you test drive one if you haven't already. I did, and it felt to me like the tranny would be all over the place trying to climb a hill pulling anything significant. Would you be driving through mountain passes? If so, I would look at something else. (Opinion below based on having to travel through mountain passes). The ecodiesel is really intended to be a gas sipper around town.

I do feel like there is a gap in the market for people who want to tow a 6-10k lb trailer. My Tundra with 5.7 feels like it struggles (imo) pulling my 16ft cargo trailer loaded to approx. 6k even though it is rated much higher. However I do not need 6.7 l of diesel and 800 lb-ft of torque. I would say a half ton is not enough. But the current 3/4 tons are overkill due to the "torque wars" marketing campaign. They are geared at chest-pounding construction workers (most who need nowhere near that much torque), not weekend warriors. I feel like the Cummins 5.9 was just about a perfect balance for the weekend warrior of somewhat decent mileage in town during the week, with good power to haul on the weekend - oh well. The new Nissan 5.0 Cummins V8 truck looks interesting. I haven't heard much about the ecoboosts but basic physics and comparison would suggest they are probably a bit on the weak side.
Overkill torque wars? As long as fuel mileage continues to go up, how can more torque be a bad thing? I'm considering replacing my garage coach motorhome with a toy hauler type trailer and eventually will be replacing my 2001 F250 7.3 with something. Can't say I would buy another diesel but unless there is a gas powered truck that will tow something like that comfortably and get comparable mileage to a diesel I may end up going that route again. Interested in seeing how some of these 1/2 ton diesels perform. The 2017 F Series Super Duty going all aluminum will have prices through the roof.

Will continue to watch this thread and see what you get.
Juss
Posts
1101
Joined
4/14/2011
Location
Bakersfield, CA, USA
12/6/2015 8:32pm
I have a 38ft I tow loaded with 4 quads and 2 dirt bike. My 2007 Duramax tows it no problem. No way your towing it with a F150. My old 3/4 Chevy Silverado had a had time pulling hills with it.
Dtat720
Posts
1588
Joined
2/20/2015
Location
Flowood, MS, USA
12/6/2015 8:48pm
I have a damon ultrasport coach right now I'm trying to sell, looking at a 5th wheel to pull behind my f350 7.3. If you go for a toy hauler, go 5th wheel and get an air ride hitch. You will never know it is back there.

I drive the damon and either pull a trailer with the toys, or have a buddy follow in a truck. It sleeps 6 with room, full kitchen, full shower and etc. mobile sat. TV etc.

And for the dry weight numbers, its just that, dry weight. Once you fill the propane and water, etc. add a couple thou to the weight. Bumper pulls scare the heck out of me, i have seen too many scattered across highways to consider buying one.
12/6/2015 8:49pm
It sounds as if you have narrowed it down to a diesel. Good decision.
Its just a matter of choosing between the new smaller 1500 Dodge Eco Diesel V6 or the big boy 2,500 In Line 6
Have you been able to fine much real world info regarding how well the Eco Diesel actually pulls in the real world?
If the decision was mine, I would have to start searching for Eco Diesel forums and see what those guys are saying.

I pull a 30ft travel trailer with a Duramax 2500 and have plenty of power to spare.
Racer142
Posts
480
Joined
2/23/2015
Location
Byhalia, MS, USA
12/6/2015 9:12pm
I'm for sure in the diesel world. No interest in a gas burner. But right now I can get a stupid good deal on a 15 crew cab 4x4 eco diesel brand new for less than any decent low mileage crew cab 4x4 3/4 ton. But the main reason to upgrade to a truck is to pull a trailer and is hate to not be able to get the trailer I want because I got the wrong truck if that makes sense. As far 5th wheel units go I'd love to have one but not sure I can afford it. A good used 5th wheel around here is 35k I can get a brand new bumper pull 28' for 25k. I am trying to find a used toy hauler but not having the luck I would like.
Racer142
Posts
480
Joined
2/23/2015
Location
Byhalia, MS, USA
12/6/2015 9:15pm
captmoto wrote:
The biggest thing is all the toyhauler builders lie about the dry weight first. Add batteries, AC unit, propane tanks, generator, awning and a spare tire...
The biggest thing is all the toyhauler builders lie about the dry weight first. Add batteries, AC unit, propane tanks, generator, awning and a spare tire to the dry weight.
The cargo capacity gets eaten up with the weight of water. 100 gallons = 835 lbs.
I have a 23' Weekend Warrior Superlite. With the basic load of camping stuff, bedding, food etc and 50 gallons of water, 1 bike with gearbag, my trailer comes in right at 7000 lbs. The trailer is rated at 7500lbs gcvw.
The guys selling you the trailer will tell you you can pull with a half ton all day long. Somebody else posted not pulling more than 21' with a 1/2 ton, I agree.
The best thing to do is tow it down to a truck scale and weigh it for the real dry weight
See that's something I needed to know. I realized the tanks weren't full or anything in dry weight but I thought the ac refrigerator and things like that were apart of it?
Bennett
Posts
75
Joined
1/13/2013
Location
Papillion, NE, USA
12/6/2015 9:37pm Edited Date/Time 12/6/2015 9:47pm
O.K., I have to chime in here. I don't have a toy hauler, but my family and I have been camping with a Forest River 28bhg bunkhouse trailer for years, which I pull with a 2007 tahoe.

Poor choice.

Of course, when we bought the trailer, the dealer asked what we were going to pull it with, looked up our vehicle, and proclaimed that it would pull it, no problem.

Well, yes, it does pull it, but, one transmission later, and thousands of miles of pulling, I definitely would not recommend it. No fun.

What you do is throw out the manufacturers tow ratings. Right out the window. Go find the truck you like, and look at the payload sticker on the vehicle. This will tell you what you can do with the vehicle.

A bumper pull trailer needs 10% to 15% tongue weight to pull safely, so an 10,000 lb trailer will need 1,000 to 1,5000 lbs of tongue weight to pull properly and safely. Then, you add the weight of all passengers and cargo that you will have in the truck. The total should not exceed the payload capacity on the sticker.

If you do a google search on the Ram Ecodiesel payload, you will find that in certain trims they are woefully low on payload.

Words of wisdom. Go with a 3/4 ton minimum. People on the RV forums really like the 6.4 Ram hemi, but consider a diesel for maximum worry free towing pleasure.

I'm siding with Juss on the triple axle 34 foot toy hauler pulled by an Ecoboost. No way, or just plain foolish.

Captmoto has it right. Take the trailer to a scale, so you know the weights you are dealing with.
12/6/2015 9:46pm Edited Date/Time 12/6/2015 9:58pm


18' VRV Livin Lite. 2800lbs dry, rated for 7000. Hauls easily with the 5.7 Tundra.

BTW that's not my phone number, that was the day we brought it home.

Fits 3 bikes and sleeps 3 people with ease, has a drop out queen.
Rizzo
Posts
1019
Joined
2/2/2010
Location
USA
12/6/2015 10:08pm
MxKing809 wrote:
My dad hauls a 3 axle 34 foot toy hauler with a 2014 F150 long box Eco-boost 6 cylinder.
Juss wrote:
I'm calling horse shit on that!
Gotta respectfully agree on that. I thought tongue pull had a max length around 32-34 but did not exceed 2 axles, could be wrong. Doubt an Eco-6 is pullin a 3 axle loaded up toy hauler much further than the driveway, but hey stranger things have happened.
MelonFan123
Posts
1561
Joined
8/20/2006
Location
Ventura/LA County, CA, USA
12/6/2015 10:17pm
Racer142, there's been some great advice on here. I would also recommend looking for a Dodge truck forum online, I'm sure there are several out there. I just bought a new Tundra a few months back and I stumbled upon a great forum called TundraTalk that is very active and has TONS of useful info for mods etc. I want to get a trailer in the next year or two for the wife and I and the "towing" section of the Tundra forum is full of great advice on what guys tow with, weights, do's and don'ts, etc.

And a weight distributing hitch is a must for towing with any 1/2 ton. good luck!
Markopolo400
Posts
1431
Joined
7/24/2012
Location
St. Paul-ish, MN, USA
12/7/2015 7:11am
MxKing809 wrote:
My dad hauls a 3 axle 34 foot toy hauler with a 2014 F150 long box Eco-boost 6 cylinder.
Juss wrote:
I'm calling horse shit on that!
You'd be amazed at what some people pull with F150s.

The problem is that although a "Max-Tow" F150 can tow 11k lbs, the tongue weight of the trailer maxes out the trucks payload capacity, people don't realize this and load up with bed with crap and 4 people in a crew cab and are way over loaded.
Racer142
Posts
480
Joined
2/23/2015
Location
Byhalia, MS, USA
12/7/2015 7:11am
There is a lot of great info in here which is why I asked here. I've been on plenty of ram and diesel forums but get the same problem of its all numbers. That was the problem I was having originally, over inflated towing numbers with conservative dry weight numbers. The eco diesel I'm looking at max trailer weight is 8290. But that looks like I'll be stuck to 26' max probably closer to a 24 or 21. The truck has a built in trailer brake controller and I already planned on a weight distributing hitch but I don't want to be buying transmissions every time I turn around.
huck
Posts
17050
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Mountain Home, AR, USA
12/7/2015 7:18am
43' Jayco 3 axle toy hauler.
Can haul 6 bikes in the garage.
Trailer weights around 15K loaded
I pulled it with 2500 Chevy with duramax. Pulled at 80-85 mph with no issues.


kaptkaos
Posts
1087
Joined
11/17/2015
Location
Miami, FL, USA
12/7/2015 7:52am
I had a 24 ft Cargo Trailer conversion to Toy Hauler, real heavy sucker. We would put three MX ATV's in it and all of our gear. It had a Generator and AC and counters and such. The shortbed ECOBOOST F150 FX2 had plenty of power to pull it, but it was very unstable and not safe to tow at highway speeds. I pulled it with a 2006 Triton F150 4x4 and it was better. Sold that trailer and got a 28ft Forest River Toy Hauler, much heavier, way more comfortable. ECOBOOST FX2 is a deathtrap on the highway even with better tires, air bags, and a load balancing hitch. My 2500 Silverado pulls it fine. Its not so much a Diesel vs Gas thing, its the weight of the truck. You need a truck with mass to pull these things so the tail is not wagging the dog. It gets pretty dangerous at highway speeds if your not towing with an adequate vehicle. People will tell you that you dont need a dually, but trust me, there is a huge difference in safety and drivability between a dually and a 2500.

For 3-4 dudes, you can probably pack into 28ft Toy Hauler and get the job done. You wont be comfortable hanging out in there, but hopefully you are riding all day, or out under the awning, and then out by a fire until everyone goes to sleep. If you get slideouts, you can add a lot more comfort and space, but slideouts are also the biggest maintenance item on RV's and they can leak and ruin your whole rig or get stuck. I am happy with going the cheap route with a 28 ft bumper pull and load balancing hitch and passing on the slideouts but we do 3 people max just be comfortable. If I decide to upgrade I would get a 5th wheel 35+ with slideouts and be ready to shell out bucks in maintaining it. Someday i would like a motorcoach with a box trailer behind it.
12/7/2015 8:28am
Racer142 wrote:
I figure this either goes here or non moto but I think it's more moto than not so here. Quick toy hauler question, what size toy...
I figure this either goes here or non moto but I think it's more moto than not so here. Quick toy hauler question, what size toy haulers do most people have and what are you hauling it with? How many people do you normally have sleep in it and what's the most you think you could fit relatively comfortably? I'm thinking about getting one this year but I'm debating on size and the truck to haul it with. Right now I'm bouncing between a ram 1500 with the eco diesel rated 8k towing and the 2500. I found a pioneer 28' bumper pull toy hauler with a dry weight around 6500# which is well within the towing for the eco diesel but that's dry weight. Add in 3 bikes, a generator, gas, gear, food, and water and I think it might be pushing the limit. But that eco diesel sure rides nice and 25 plus mpg sure is alluring. So I'm just trying to gauge what other people are pulling and with what. Trust me I've searched this forum and found a few threads but not really what I was looking for. I know I can find all the physical numbers but I'm looking more at real world application.
I just bought a older (2002) E350 I'm converting into a Totter Home / Hauler. I started a thread about the build in the Race Shop section. Maybe this can help with some ideas? Take a look-see..

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Race-Shop,42/Ford-E350-Uhaul-to-Race-Haul…

Post a reply to: Toy hauler?

The Latest