What highly regarded musician or group did you just not ‘get’?

APLMAN99
Posts
13109
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA

Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have to hear any of his stuff again it wouldn’t bother me. 

Yours? 

1
|
Spurdo
Posts
483
Joined
12/26/2016
Location
FI
1 day ago

Rush and Pink Floyd. My work is trying to take me to the 'Rush 50' concert, and I flat out refused, not even a consideration. The only decent Pink Floyd song I've ever heard is "Echo's", and the lyrics aren't even that good - Gilmour's guitar playing is what makes it. 

2
5
Moto Nomad
Posts
1293
Joined
1/19/2021
Location
Grass Valley, CA, USA
1 day ago

Grateful Dead.

That can't sing or play guitar that great (unless in you're on LSD). Their songs are boring. They are uninteresting individuals. I actually went to a two-day concert and left at the end of day one because it was so lame. I feel like they only got a following so dudes could hit on tripping hippie chicks.

8
NorCal1975
Posts
614
Joined
12/27/2019
Location
Northern California, CA, USA
1 day ago

Prince, I don't like a single Prince song, haha

4
1
ATKpilot99
Posts
10526
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI, USA
1 day ago

The Doors . And going a little more recent  , Nirvana . 

3
3

The Shop

Sandusky26
Posts
3555
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC, USA
22 hours ago
ATKpilot99 wrote:

The Doors . And going a little more recent  , Nirvana . 

Nirvana changed the world, I do agree on the Doors though.

4
3
ATKpilot99
Posts
10526
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI, USA
22 hours ago
ATKpilot99 wrote:

The Doors . And going a little more recent  , Nirvana . 

Sandusky26 wrote:

Nirvana changed the world, I do agree on the Doors though.

Yep Nirvana is highly regarded ... I just could never understand why , lol .

1
Nairb#70
Posts
4461
Joined
2/25/2020
Location
Ivoryton, CT, USA
22 hours ago Edited Date/Time 21 hours ago

Aerosmith, after their "Done with Mirrors" album in 1985 they just became the biggest sellout band in the history of Rock n Roll. Kiss too, after "Love Gun" in 1978 they weren't worth a shit. The 1980's was a decade full of some of the best and some of the worst music ever made.

1
1
borg
Posts
7083
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
20 hours ago

By "did" you not get, I am taking that to mean, in my music awakening years. Say 13 to 30. Some started earlier and some are still going but in that era, it was Zappa.  There were a few that I didn't get into because I didn't hear them that much. Rush was one of those. 

1
early
Posts
10127
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
20 hours ago

Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.

I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if she ever heard them she said no I played her a song and she thought I was messing with her she didn't think that they sounded like what they do, she couldn't believe anyone would actually listen to them.

AJ565
Posts
2362
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
20 hours ago

U2, Smashing Pumpkins, and DMB. I don't get they hype and would me fine never hearing any of them again.

4
ShellyMX
Posts
1824
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
19 hours ago

Nirvana for sure and dire straits.

Not saying nirvana didn’t have some decent songs and Dave Grohl is incredible in foo fighters but Alice In Chains, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, and STP blew them away.

1
Flatliner
Posts
4422
Joined
11/3/2009
Location
CA
19 hours ago

Autotune, mumble rap.

2
APLMAN99
Posts
13109
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
19 hours ago Edited Date/Time 19 hours ago
early wrote:
Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if...

Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.

I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if she ever heard them she said no I played her a song and she thought I was messing with her she didn't think that they sounded like what they do, she couldn't believe anyone would actually listen to them.

One of my wife’s friends and I were talking about music about 15 years ago, and she had a theory that I still think about. She said that you can use 2 questions to put people into a 4 box grouping and tell a lot about their basic personality. First question is whether you prefer the Grateful Dead or Pink Floyd. Second question is whether you prefer James Taylor or Jimmy Buffet. 

I told her that I’m a Pink Floyd/James Taylor myself, but she would never tell me what that was supposed to mean!!! 

1
1
APLMAN99
Posts
13109
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
19 hours ago
borg wrote:
By "did" you not get, I am taking that to mean, in my music awakening years. Say 13 to 30. Some started earlier and some are...

By "did" you not get, I am taking that to mean, in my music awakening years. Say 13 to 30. Some started earlier and some are still going but in that era, it was Zappa.  There were a few that I didn't get into because I didn't hear them that much. Rush was one of those. 

I’d agree with Zappa. Not sure why, but it just never made me want to listen to. Don’t dislike him or anything, just ambivalent I suppose. 

1
ShellyMX
Posts
1824
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
18 hours ago
APLMAN99 wrote:

I’d agree with Zappa. Not sure why, but it just never made me want to listen to. Don’t dislike him or anything, just ambivalent I suppose. 

Not my cup of tea either, but an incredible musician who surrounded himself with equally incredible musicians.

APLMAN99
Posts
13109
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
18 hours ago

It’s kind of fascinating to hear that some people just don’t like some music that others absolutely love, even if it’s in the same basic genre of many of their favorites. 

At one time in my life I might have thought that anyone who didn’t like Pink Floyd had mental issues, now I get that we all have slightly different imprints from life that make us prefer different sounds. 

2
1
TAUTOG
Posts
1850
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
18 hours ago
APLMAN99 wrote:
Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have...

Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have to hear any of his stuff again it wouldn’t bother me. 

Yours? 

Lou Reed solo is pretty boring but have you listened to the Velvet underground?

TAUTOG
Posts
1850
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
18 hours ago

U2 is the most overrated band of all time

11
18 hours ago
TAUTOG wrote:

U2 is the most overrated band of all time

I had U2 typed in before Bruce but changed my mind on who sucks worse. 

4
early
Posts
10127
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
18 hours ago
early wrote:
Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if...

Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.

I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if she ever heard them she said no I played her a song and she thought I was messing with her she didn't think that they sounded like what they do, she couldn't believe anyone would actually listen to them.

APLMAN99 wrote:
One of my wife’s friends and I were talking about music about 15 years ago, and she had a theory that I still think about. She...

One of my wife’s friends and I were talking about music about 15 years ago, and she had a theory that I still think about. She said that you can use 2 questions to put people into a 4 box grouping and tell a lot about their basic personality. First question is whether you prefer the Grateful Dead or Pink Floyd. Second question is whether you prefer James Taylor or Jimmy Buffet. 

I told her that I’m a Pink Floyd/James Taylor myself, but she would never tell me what that was supposed to mean!!! 

I guess I would be in the Floyd-Buffet quadrant, but I don't know what that means either!

bonseff
Posts
2141
Joined
3/29/2011
Location
Frisco, TX, USA
18 hours ago

Smashing Pumpkins, less of I didnt get them and more of I couldnt stand them. And I couldnt get away from them with my circle of friends in college. 

ShellyMX
Posts
1824
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
18 hours ago

I didn’t appreciate David Gilmour until much later in life. Love his playing.

Having said that my friends and I used to equate Pink Floyd with stoners and for good reason.

1
Falcon
Posts
12722
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
18 hours ago

I am a classically trained musician and a guitarist, so I love almost all the guitar greats and can respect their contributions. However, I've never understood the Eric Clapton hype. I guess you had to be there in the '60s or something. 

 

My best friend doesn't like Bowie or Radiohead and I think he's insane. Also, Spurdo and Borg are now dead to me for not liking Rush. 😔 Haha, J/K guys.

5
TAUTOG
Posts
1850
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
18 hours ago
early wrote:
Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if...

Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.

I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if she ever heard them she said no I played her a song and she thought I was messing with her she didn't think that they sounded like what they do, she couldn't believe anyone would actually listen to them.

Did you play farmhouse for her? lol

Play this instead:

What Phish sounds like to non Phish fans lmao

ShellyMX
Posts
1824
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
18 hours ago

These guys do a pretty decent job.

1
LoudLove
Posts
3027
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
USA
17 hours ago
Falcon wrote:
I am a classically trained musician and a guitarist, so I love almost all the guitar greats and can respect their contributions. However, I've never understood...

I am a classically trained musician and a guitarist, so I love almost all the guitar greats and can respect their contributions. However, I've never understood the Eric Clapton hype. I guess you had to be there in the '60s or something. 

 

My best friend doesn't like Bowie or Radiohead and I think he's insane. Also, Spurdo and Borg are now dead to me for not liking Rush. 😔 Haha, J/K guys.

Agree on Clapton. World’s best cover band guitarist. 

3
early
Posts
10127
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
17 hours ago
early wrote:
Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if...

Pink Floyd, Grateful Dead, Phish never been into hippie stuff.

I was watching a show with my wife and they talked about Phish I asked her if she ever heard them she said no I played her a song and she thought I was messing with her she didn't think that they sounded like what they do, she couldn't believe anyone would actually listen to them.

TAUTOG wrote:

Did you play farmhouse for her? lol

Play this instead:

What Phish sounds like to non Phish fans lmao

Played bouncing round the room and bathtub gin, I had a buddy in highschool that would play lawnboy all the time. 

U2 is over rated but I think the Joshua tree is a legitimately good album top to bottom.

ShellyMX
Posts
1824
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
16 hours ago

Agreed. Joshua Tree is their best by far.

Reese95w
Posts
239
Joined
2/7/2011
Location
Kent, WA, USA
16 hours ago
Flatliner wrote:

Autotune, mumble rap.

And Grunt Rap.

Post a reply to: What highly regarded musician or group did you just not ‘get’?

The Latest