Could wearing a chest heart rate monitor be dangerous in a crash?

bump_start
Posts
148
Joined
12/8/2022
Location
Texas, TX, USA
11/16/2026 2:55pm

I’m almost 2 seconds a lap faster when wearing one… so there’s that

5
OwenJakes
Posts
1823
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY, USA
11/16/2026 3:08pm
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

GrapeApe wrote:
Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally...

Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally receive from wearing a HR monitor? lol

Some people know what they're doing, some don't, some are trying to learn, who cares? None of that has to do with the OP's question anyway.

 

Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed session to compensate.
For mx riders alone, no I think it's a gadget for the sake of a gadget and nothing more. I do think heart rate data is relevant for running but that's a different story.

I wasn't addressing the OP anyways I was talking to 3 stroke.

2
4
Camo383
Posts
71
Joined
6/22/2025
Location
Stouffville, ON, CA
11/16/2026 3:32pm Edited Date/Time 11/16/2026 3:37pm

Somewhat related but my biggest pet peeve is seeing HR watches on the bars. I get not wearing on your wrist, but please put it ANYWHERE ELSE besides the dead center of the bar pad. Completely defeats the purpose of the cushion and unfortunately see a lot of pros doing this.

1
2
BoxcarWilly
Posts
1321
Joined
10/5/2023
Location
Thunder Bay, ON, CA
11/16/2026 4:34pm
OwenJakes wrote:
Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed...

Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed session to compensate.
For mx riders alone, no I think it's a gadget for the sake of a gadget and nothing more. I do think heart rate data is relevant for running but that's a different story.

I wasn't addressing the OP anyways I was talking to 3 stroke.

The same principles that you wear it for running also apply to MX and enduro…

2

The Shop

11/16/2026 5:26pm
3strokemx wrote:
How are you determining a change in heart rate is fitness related?  There are many other variables that effect heart rate; track condition, how the race...

How are you determining a change in heart rate is fitness related?  
There are many other variables that effect heart rate; track condition, how the race plays out, whether you have a pucker moment or not.
 

There are so many conditions one can experience in a race. I primarily raced with one in HS/GNCC. The only number I concerned myself with was the average HR. Average over 2 hours or 3+ hours gives you a pretty good idea of how much total work you did, and what your conditioning is like this time vs last time. Context matters too. I'd average 145-150BPM over 3- 3-1/2 hours at a GNCC. At a GP or MX event during that same time period I'd average 170+. So it also tells you something about your intensity. I also used it while cycling. 

1
jnickell
Posts
472
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/16/2026 5:28pm

I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to whatever situation caused it can be helpful. Maybe you hold your breath and don’t realize it. Maybe you just want to see whether your last 3 months of training display a reduction in heart rate. Lots of stuff. I wear the Polar Verity Sense. It’s not a chest strap though.  It’s an arm band that you wear between your biceps and deltoid. Very non intrusive. Additionally, you can upload your data to Polar’s website and take notes. Things like gearing, temperature, etc. 

4
11/16/2026 6:10pm Edited Date/Time 11/16/2026 6:11pm
cucumber20 wrote:
I've been wondering whether wearing a chest heart rate monitor, such as the Garmin HRM 600 or Polar H10, could pose an additional risk during a...

I've been wondering whether wearing a chest heart rate monitor, such as the Garmin HRM 600 or Polar H10, could pose an additional risk during a motocross crash.

My concern is that the hard sensor in the middle of the chest strap could concentrate the impact force on a smaller area, rather than allowing the force to be distributed evenly across the chest protector.

In a hard crash, could the sensor be pushed into the chest and potentially cause injuries to the sternum or ribs, even when wearing a chest protector?

Polar makes a band that goes higher on your arm above the elbow. I’d look into those if your someone who doesn’t get arm pump from bands on the arms (I make them leave my entry band really loose or not even wear one after breaking my wrist), I have the H10 and it definitely gave you a weird feeling after hitting your chest once. lol 

1
disbanded
Posts
7019
Joined
8/26/2007
Location
Evergreen, CO, USA
11/16/2026 6:15pm

My heart rate spikes whenever I think about my heart rate

1
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/16/2026 6:24pm Edited Date/Time 11/16/2026 6:33pm
3strokemx wrote:
How are you determining a change in heart rate is fitness related?  There are many other variables that effect heart rate; track condition, how the race...

How are you determining a change in heart rate is fitness related?  
There are many other variables that effect heart rate; track condition, how the race plays out, whether you have a pucker moment or not.
 

There are so many conditions one can experience in a race. I primarily raced with one in HS/GNCC. The only number I concerned myself with was...

There are so many conditions one can experience in a race. I primarily raced with one in HS/GNCC. The only number I concerned myself with was the average HR. Average over 2 hours or 3+ hours gives you a pretty good idea of how much total work you did, and what your conditioning is like this time vs last time. Context matters too. I'd average 145-150BPM over 3- 3-1/2 hours at a GNCC. At a GP or MX event during that same time period I'd average 170+. So it also tells you something about your intensity. I also used it while cycling. 

It's useful for cycling to keep people from going too hard.

It's much more obfuscated on a dirtbike.  Like you said, you have a higher HR when the effort is higher (GPs). When you do a harescramble how are you determining your conditioning has improved based on HR? Wouldnt lower HR just mean you put forth less effort?

3
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/16/2026 6:31pm
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

Preston412 wrote:
If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most...

If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most people have a data fascination is absurd. I am married to a Cardiology Nurse Practitioner and monitoring your heart beat and evaluating the data can be life saving especially for older riders.  It is not healthy for your heart to be in zones 4 and 5 for a long duration without the ability of your heart to have a fairly quick recovery rate and having that data can help you know when enough is enough for the day.  Its a hot day and you have been riding with buddies and now you are relaxing at the trailer or truck and you feel faint, you have your heart rate monitor on and look at your watch and see your heart rate increasing, well that could be mean you are starting to have a heat stroke if you don't start to cool your self down. 

My point is, the answer of "Nothing" is a ridiculous answer to give to his question.

 

To the OP, Chest protectors were nothing more than a roost/rock protector with no padding in the chest area back then and I am sure the monitors were not slim like they are these days.

You will get the most out of the heart rate monitor when using it for physical training to monitor your heart rate for zone training which you would want to be Zone 1 and 2.  Zone 3 and 4 training is for sprint intervals and can be beneficial but endurance training should be done in zone 1 and the lower part of zone 2 to build a strong base foundation for your heart. The benefit to that is when you start pushing your heart rate up, it will climb to the higher zones at a slower rate then if you constantly trained in zone 3 and 4 (zone 5 is not recommended at all) giving you the ability to push harder for a longer period of time before you max out in zone 5 and feel like you are going to die racing your buddy after 3 laps. It will also help your heart rate recovery more quickly back to zone 1.  This is what you see on the podium after 30 minutes plus 2 and they are breathing normal within a minute or two. 

When using it while riding, obviously it lets you know what your heart rate went up to, how quick did it get there and for how long. Most polar and garmin watches will calculate your recovery rate when you stop recording, it takes two minutes to calculate.  Analyzing the date can up you determine if you are breathing properly while riding or are you training properly at the gym and importantly you can look at your heart rate on the watch and make sure you are giving yourself enough rest before going back out for a heater or just got enough in you to just go have some fun laps. 

You should be able to determine if you feel faint or have a racing pulse without the assistance of a HRM 🤷

1
4
KurtJ99
Posts
2684
Joined
2/6/2017
Location
USA
11/16/2026 6:34pm

Not to the OP's question directly but even as a Vet rider it is interesting to compare heart rate to effort to breathing. For whatever reason - excitement, adrenaline don't know - my heart rate goes up at alot gate drop but it doesn't correspond to how tired I am or winded. In long motos it creeps up to my max and I have to slow down. 

But mountain biking it builds more slowly and seems to be tied to my breathing more reasonably; I know where my heart rate is and the monitor confirms it. I would have no idea what my heart rate is without the monitor on a dirt bike. 

1
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/16/2026 6:49pm
jnickell wrote:
I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to...

I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to whatever situation caused it can be helpful. Maybe you hold your breath and don’t realize it. Maybe you just want to see whether your last 3 months of training display a reduction in heart rate. Lots of stuff. I wear the Polar Verity Sense. It’s not a chest strap though.  It’s an arm band that you wear between your biceps and deltoid. Very non intrusive. Additionally, you can upload your data to Polar’s website and take notes. Things like gearing, temperature, etc. 

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

3
ando
Posts
4641
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth, AU
11/16/2026 6:50pm
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

GrapeApe wrote:
Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally...

Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally receive from wearing a HR monitor? lol

Some people know what they're doing, some don't, some are trying to learn, who cares? None of that has to do with the OP's question anyway.

 

OwenJakes wrote:
Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed...

Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed session to compensate.
For mx riders alone, no I think it's a gadget for the sake of a gadget and nothing more. I do think heart rate data is relevant for running but that's a different story.

I wasn't addressing the OP anyways I was talking to 3 stroke.

A rider might want to:

  1. know if their training program is resulting in measurable changes while riding/racing
  2. understand what is happening to heart rate between practice and racing
  3. Keep to a certain heart rate zone during specific practice sessions
  4. want to limit their max rate for some reason

 

5
ando
Posts
4641
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth, AU
11/16/2026 6:51pm
jnickell wrote:
I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to...

I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to whatever situation caused it can be helpful. Maybe you hold your breath and don’t realize it. Maybe you just want to see whether your last 3 months of training display a reduction in heart rate. Lots of stuff. I wear the Polar Verity Sense. It’s not a chest strap though.  It’s an arm band that you wear between your biceps and deltoid. Very non intrusive. Additionally, you can upload your data to Polar’s website and take notes. Things like gearing, temperature, etc. 

3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

Well the same potential issues could apply to cycling - not trying as hard, or the training route is easier or different.

2
ando
Posts
4641
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth, AU
11/16/2026 6:52pm
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

Preston412 wrote:
If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most...

If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most people have a data fascination is absurd. I am married to a Cardiology Nurse Practitioner and monitoring your heart beat and evaluating the data can be life saving especially for older riders.  It is not healthy for your heart to be in zones 4 and 5 for a long duration without the ability of your heart to have a fairly quick recovery rate and having that data can help you know when enough is enough for the day.  Its a hot day and you have been riding with buddies and now you are relaxing at the trailer or truck and you feel faint, you have your heart rate monitor on and look at your watch and see your heart rate increasing, well that could be mean you are starting to have a heat stroke if you don't start to cool your self down. 

My point is, the answer of "Nothing" is a ridiculous answer to give to his question.

 

To the OP, Chest protectors were nothing more than a roost/rock protector with no padding in the chest area back then and I am sure the monitors were not slim like they are these days.

You will get the most out of the heart rate monitor when using it for physical training to monitor your heart rate for zone training which you would want to be Zone 1 and 2.  Zone 3 and 4 training is for sprint intervals and can be beneficial but endurance training should be done in zone 1 and the lower part of zone 2 to build a strong base foundation for your heart. The benefit to that is when you start pushing your heart rate up, it will climb to the higher zones at a slower rate then if you constantly trained in zone 3 and 4 (zone 5 is not recommended at all) giving you the ability to push harder for a longer period of time before you max out in zone 5 and feel like you are going to die racing your buddy after 3 laps. It will also help your heart rate recovery more quickly back to zone 1.  This is what you see on the podium after 30 minutes plus 2 and they are breathing normal within a minute or two. 

When using it while riding, obviously it lets you know what your heart rate went up to, how quick did it get there and for how long. Most polar and garmin watches will calculate your recovery rate when you stop recording, it takes two minutes to calculate.  Analyzing the date can up you determine if you are breathing properly while riding or are you training properly at the gym and importantly you can look at your heart rate on the watch and make sure you are giving yourself enough rest before going back out for a heater or just got enough in you to just go have some fun laps. 

3strokemx wrote:

You should be able to determine if you feel faint or have a racing pulse without the assistance of a HRM 🤷

So whip a glove off and check pulse while floating over the triple?

2
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/16/2026 6:58pm
KurtJ99 wrote:
Not to the OP's question directly but even as a Vet rider it is interesting to compare heart rate to effort to breathing. For whatever reason...

Not to the OP's question directly but even as a Vet rider it is interesting to compare heart rate to effort to breathing. For whatever reason - excitement, adrenaline don't know - my heart rate goes up at alot gate drop but it doesn't correspond to how tired I am or winded. In long motos it creeps up to my max and I have to slow down. 

But mountain biking it builds more slowly and seems to be tied to my breathing more reasonably; I know where my heart rate is and the monitor confirms it. I would have no idea what my heart rate is without the monitor on a dirt bike. 

That's adrenaline! It's actually really helpful to work on controlling it. You can eliminate mistakes and improve coordination and timing by being more calm. 

Controlled adrenaline is one of the reasons why confidence is so helpful, makes it so adrenaline isnt released until necessary.

1
2
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/16/2026 7:02pm
Preston412 wrote:
If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most...

If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most people have a data fascination is absurd. I am married to a Cardiology Nurse Practitioner and monitoring your heart beat and evaluating the data can be life saving especially for older riders.  It is not healthy for your heart to be in zones 4 and 5 for a long duration without the ability of your heart to have a fairly quick recovery rate and having that data can help you know when enough is enough for the day.  Its a hot day and you have been riding with buddies and now you are relaxing at the trailer or truck and you feel faint, you have your heart rate monitor on and look at your watch and see your heart rate increasing, well that could be mean you are starting to have a heat stroke if you don't start to cool your self down. 

My point is, the answer of "Nothing" is a ridiculous answer to give to his question.

 

To the OP, Chest protectors were nothing more than a roost/rock protector with no padding in the chest area back then and I am sure the monitors were not slim like they are these days.

You will get the most out of the heart rate monitor when using it for physical training to monitor your heart rate for zone training which you would want to be Zone 1 and 2.  Zone 3 and 4 training is for sprint intervals and can be beneficial but endurance training should be done in zone 1 and the lower part of zone 2 to build a strong base foundation for your heart. The benefit to that is when you start pushing your heart rate up, it will climb to the higher zones at a slower rate then if you constantly trained in zone 3 and 4 (zone 5 is not recommended at all) giving you the ability to push harder for a longer period of time before you max out in zone 5 and feel like you are going to die racing your buddy after 3 laps. It will also help your heart rate recovery more quickly back to zone 1.  This is what you see on the podium after 30 minutes plus 2 and they are breathing normal within a minute or two. 

When using it while riding, obviously it lets you know what your heart rate went up to, how quick did it get there and for how long. Most polar and garmin watches will calculate your recovery rate when you stop recording, it takes two minutes to calculate.  Analyzing the date can up you determine if you are breathing properly while riding or are you training properly at the gym and importantly you can look at your heart rate on the watch and make sure you are giving yourself enough rest before going back out for a heater or just got enough in you to just go have some fun laps. 

3strokemx wrote:

You should be able to determine if you feel faint or have a racing pulse without the assistance of a HRM 🤷

ando wrote:

So whip a glove off and check pulse while floating over the triple?

"Its a hot day and you have been riding with buddies and now you are relaxing at the trailer or truck and you feel faint, you have your heart rate monitor on and look at your watch and see your heart rate increasing,"

but you would still feel if you are faint or a racing HR while you are riding, no pulse check necessary. 

2
OwenJakes
Posts
1823
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY, USA
11/16/2026 7:04pm
GrapeApe wrote:
Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally...

Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally receive from wearing a HR monitor? lol

Some people know what they're doing, some don't, some are trying to learn, who cares? None of that has to do with the OP's question anyway.

 

OwenJakes wrote:
Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed...

Yeah, if I wasnt running 70 mpw i wouldnt wear one period for mx. Basically, if my ride days are gnarly, I might modify a speed session to compensate.
For mx riders alone, no I think it's a gadget for the sake of a gadget and nothing more. I do think heart rate data is relevant for running but that's a different story.

I wasn't addressing the OP anyways I was talking to 3 stroke.

ando wrote:
A rider might want to:know if their training program is resulting in measurable changes while riding/racingunderstand what is happening to heart rate between practice and racingKeep...

A rider might want to:

  1. know if their training program is resulting in measurable changes while riding/racing
  2. understand what is happening to heart rate between practice and racing
  3. Keep to a certain heart rate zone during specific practice sessions
  4. want to limit their max rate for some reason

 

Maybe. None of that helps in any meaningful way other than just knowing it though. Motocross will always be a perception and effort sport. 

For example, your #1 would not result in a rider maintaining the same pace and lowering HR over a year. They would just ride harder. Something like  that would be way better measured in a gym on a treadmill or over a long effort like a 40 mile ride or so. A track even being rougher would ruin that experiment. 

It’s not like “rider gets arm pump at heart rate X!”. 

  
The others would require a real time display which is easy to do. Pretend your doctor said “hey man, let’s keep it below 160 until we can figure out what’s going on with you” then that’s an OBVIOUS exception to this whole discussion.

4
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/16/2026 7:06pm
jnickell wrote:
I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to...

I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to whatever situation caused it can be helpful. Maybe you hold your breath and don’t realize it. Maybe you just want to see whether your last 3 months of training display a reduction in heart rate. Lots of stuff. I wear the Polar Verity Sense. It’s not a chest strap though.  It’s an arm band that you wear between your biceps and deltoid. Very non intrusive. Additionally, you can upload your data to Polar’s website and take notes. Things like gearing, temperature, etc. 

3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

ando wrote:

Well the same potential issues could apply to cycling - not trying as hard, or the training route is easier or different.

No, the HR is the effort.

Routes can change (especially wind), but a power meter measures your force output.

Im not saying a HR monitor and power meter are necessary for cycling, but in order to do what you guys think the HR monitor does, you need the measure the output along with the effort.  

2
OwenJakes
Posts
1823
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY, USA
11/16/2026 7:09pm
jnickell wrote:
I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to...

I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to whatever situation caused it can be helpful. Maybe you hold your breath and don’t realize it. Maybe you just want to see whether your last 3 months of training display a reduction in heart rate. Lots of stuff. I wear the Polar Verity Sense. It’s not a chest strap though.  It’s an arm band that you wear between your biceps and deltoid. Very non intrusive. Additionally, you can upload your data to Polar’s website and take notes. Things like gearing, temperature, etc. 

3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach and just try to sell them something. 

on an actual serious note, for any other readers, in my running endeavors I’m interested in tracking my long term power (watts) versus HR over tight paces to indicate my running economy/efficiency. These are the kinds of things fitness tech is good for. For moto, just get a way to track your lap times. That’s where the progress is found. 

2
4
Cabin09
Posts
32
Joined
1/29/2023
Location
Rotorua, NZ
11/16/2026 7:28pm
3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

ando wrote:

Well the same potential issues could apply to cycling - not trying as hard, or the training route is easier or different.

3strokemx wrote:
No, the HR is the effort.Routes can change (especially wind), but a power meter measures your force output.Im not saying a HR monitor and power meter...

No, the HR is the effort.

Routes can change (especially wind), but a power meter measures your force output.

Im not saying a HR monitor and power meter are necessary for cycling, but in order to do what you guys think the HR monitor does, you need the measure the output along with the effort.  

And therin lies the benefit of HR for all these activities (Moto included)

The HR is the read on how the body is responding to the effort. Over time, the individual will see patterns emerge... as to how HR responds to effort. And this is then a useful indicator of whether (a) things are good, (b) body is overly fatigued, (c) potential illness (d) multitude of other options.

On the Moto the value would not be in the moment (whilst riding). But reflecting on data (generally the averages) post ride, and considered alongside percieved effort.... can be incredibly valueable in maintaining health (and therefore fitness and performance)

1
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 5:23am Edited Date/Time 11/17/2026 5:34am
ando wrote:

Well the same potential issues could apply to cycling - not trying as hard, or the training route is easier or different.

3strokemx wrote:
No, the HR is the effort.Routes can change (especially wind), but a power meter measures your force output.Im not saying a HR monitor and power meter...

No, the HR is the effort.

Routes can change (especially wind), but a power meter measures your force output.

Im not saying a HR monitor and power meter are necessary for cycling, but in order to do what you guys think the HR monitor does, you need the measure the output along with the effort.  

Cabin09 wrote:
And therin lies the benefit of HR for all these activities (Moto included)The HR is the read on how the body is responding to the effort...

And therin lies the benefit of HR for all these activities (Moto included)

The HR is the read on how the body is responding to the effort. Over time, the individual will see patterns emerge... as to how HR responds to effort. And this is then a useful indicator of whether (a) things are good, (b) body is overly fatigued, (c) potential illness (d) multitude of other options.

On the Moto the value would not be in the moment (whilst riding). But reflecting on data (generally the averages) post ride, and considered alongside percieved effort.... can be incredibly valueable in maintaining health (and therefore fitness and performance)

In the context of riding a dirtbike, there's not enough control to determine how your body is responding to effort. For example, near crashes / mistakes raise the HR but it's not fitness related. 

As a fatigued indicator, comparing resting HR would be more applicable and no HRM required.

2
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 5:37am
jnickell wrote:
I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to...

I don’t understand all the HR bashing. HR data is not only useful, but fun to analyze. Seeing where your HR spikes and correlating it to whatever situation caused it can be helpful. Maybe you hold your breath and don’t realize it. Maybe you just want to see whether your last 3 months of training display a reduction in heart rate. Lots of stuff. I wear the Polar Verity Sense. It’s not a chest strap though.  It’s an arm band that you wear between your biceps and deltoid. Very non intrusive. Additionally, you can upload your data to Polar’s website and take notes. Things like gearing, temperature, etc. 

3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

OwenJakes wrote:
Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach...

Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach and just try to sell them something. 

on an actual serious note, for any other readers, in my running endeavors I’m interested in tracking my long term power (watts) versus HR over tight paces to indicate my running economy/efficiency. These are the kinds of things fitness tech is good for. For moto, just get a way to track your lap times. That’s where the progress is found. 

You and I probably have the most time in a HRM of anyone here 😅

2
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 5:56am Edited Date/Time 11/17/2026 5:57am
KurtJ99 wrote:
Not to the OP's question directly but even as a Vet rider it is interesting to compare heart rate to effort to breathing. For whatever reason...

Not to the OP's question directly but even as a Vet rider it is interesting to compare heart rate to effort to breathing. For whatever reason - excitement, adrenaline don't know - my heart rate goes up at alot gate drop but it doesn't correspond to how tired I am or winded. In long motos it creeps up to my max and I have to slow down. 

But mountain biking it builds more slowly and seems to be tied to my breathing more reasonably; I know where my heart rate is and the monitor confirms it. I would have no idea what my heart rate is without the monitor on a dirt bike. 

3strokemx wrote:
That's adrenaline! It's actually really helpful to work on controlling it. You can eliminate mistakes and improve coordination and timing by being more calm. Controlled adrenaline is...

That's adrenaline! It's actually really helpful to work on controlling it. You can eliminate mistakes and improve coordination and timing by being more calm. 

Controlled adrenaline is one of the reasons why confidence is so helpful, makes it so adrenaline isnt released until necessary.

Here are some tips for controlling adrenaline in case anyone is interested:

Microdose adrenaline - the more you do scary stuff, the less adrenaline dump will effect you. I like riding BMX and MTB for microdosing, doesn't have to be a long session. Feeling it more frequently matters more than duration, Less risk of injury on the bicycle compared to a dirtbike. Can start small, like riding across a 2x4 lengthwise or wherever is the edge of your comfort.

Have a soundtrack of Focus music. Most commercial music isn't going to be as effective as music engineered to bring focus and clarity. You'll want to listen to this enough to get the song stuck in your head. I like Mind Amend. The music helps to prime your brain for the next step.

Awareness and breathing. Once you are aware of your heightened state, it helps to focus on controlling your breathing directing focus on the task at hand. Focus on the task at hand by mentally going through each step in slow motion, thinking about how it will feel at each step. The more you practice this, the more it becomes habit, and the better your body and mind respond.

2
OwenJakes
Posts
1823
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY, USA
11/17/2026 6:16am
3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

OwenJakes wrote:
Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach...

Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach and just try to sell them something. 

on an actual serious note, for any other readers, in my running endeavors I’m interested in tracking my long term power (watts) versus HR over tight paces to indicate my running economy/efficiency. These are the kinds of things fitness tech is good for. For moto, just get a way to track your lap times. That’s where the progress is found. 

3strokemx wrote:

You and I probably have the most time in a HRM of anyone here 😅

And the huge irony is now many endurance sports conches are going back to feel, effort based, and 3 zone training🤣

4
mx317
Posts
5428
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/17/2026 7:59am

I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I can monitor it better while riding and not dodging cars or potholes. I could see it being good in moto if you had a trainer to sort it all out after your race or ride. Most of us are pegging the old meter anyway while racing and wouldn't think to check a HR rate on a watch even strapped to the handlebars.

GrapeApe
Posts
9139
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
11/17/2026 8:03am
3strokemx wrote:
I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could...

I'm bashing because the data being collected doesn't answer the questions being asked when applied to dirtbikes. 

For instance, your example of a lower HR trend could mean you arent trying as hard, or the track is easier. It doesnt mean your fitness improved. 

Evaluating fitness would look like this: On a bicycle you have objective measures (distance, power) that will improve while effort(HR) stays constant.

 

OwenJakes wrote:
Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach...

Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach and just try to sell them something. 

on an actual serious note, for any other readers, in my running endeavors I’m interested in tracking my long term power (watts) versus HR over tight paces to indicate my running economy/efficiency. These are the kinds of things fitness tech is good for. For moto, just get a way to track your lap times. That’s where the progress is found. 

3strokemx wrote:

You and I probably have the most time in a HRM of anyone here 😅

Just to help you with the concept, this is how smug looks ^

3
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 8:08am
OwenJakes wrote:
Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach...

Bro I’m thinking we’re never going to get through to the crowd who believes that axle nut torque changes suspension dynamics. We should change our approach and just try to sell them something. 

on an actual serious note, for any other readers, in my running endeavors I’m interested in tracking my long term power (watts) versus HR over tight paces to indicate my running economy/efficiency. These are the kinds of things fitness tech is good for. For moto, just get a way to track your lap times. That’s where the progress is found. 

3strokemx wrote:

You and I probably have the most time in a HRM of anyone here 😅

GrapeApe wrote:

Just to help you with the concept, this is how smug looks ^

haha how else would I know it's smug to wear one as an accessory at the track?

5
3strokemx
Posts
3429
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 8:11am
mx317 wrote:
I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I...

I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I can monitor it better while riding and not dodging cars or potholes. I could see it being good in moto if you had a trainer to sort it all out after your race or ride. Most of us are pegging the old meter anyway while racing and wouldn't think to check a HR rate on a watch even strapped to the handlebars.

Do you have to stand while you're pegging or can you peg yourself while seated?

4
mx317
Posts
5428
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/17/2026 8:21am
mx317 wrote:
I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I...

I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I can monitor it better while riding and not dodging cars or potholes. I could see it being good in moto if you had a trainer to sort it all out after your race or ride. Most of us are pegging the old meter anyway while racing and wouldn't think to check a HR rate on a watch even strapped to the handlebars.

3strokemx wrote:

Do you have to stand while you're pegging or can you peg yourself while seated?

On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot of RPMs vs pushing a big gear. 

Post a reply to: Could wearing a chest heart rate monitor be dangerous in a crash?

The Latest