Could wearing a chest heart rate monitor be dangerous in a crash?

cucumber20
Posts
1
Joined
11/16/2026
Location
Helsingør, DK

I've been wondering whether wearing a chest heart rate monitor, such as the Garmin HRM 600 or Polar H10, could pose an additional risk during a motocross crash.

My concern is that the hard sensor in the middle of the chest strap could concentrate the impact force on a smaller area, rather than allowing the force to be distributed evenly across the chest protector.

In a hard crash, could the sensor be pushed into the chest and potentially cause injuries to the sternum or ribs, even when wearing a chest protector?

1
|
ThePizzaCobra
Posts
748
Joined
12/1/2018
Location
@sundaymotos, NJ, USA
23 hours ago

While it seems extremely unlikely, RJ Hampshire was hurt from his HRM exactly as you described

9
AJ565
Posts
2360
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
21 hours ago

I've worn a H10 for years with a chest protector and have had no issues. 

1
1
Lentz197
Posts
188
Joined
7/9/2024
Location
FXBG, VA, USA
21 hours ago

I have thought about this when putting the HRM on but once its on i forget about it so quickly and dont feel it under my tech air chest pro so i dont stress.

downonmonday
Posts
639
Joined
2/14/2012
Location
Cornfields, IL, USA
21 hours ago Edited Date/Time 21 hours ago

I'm not worried about it. If I was, I shouldn't be riding. 

3
11

The Shop

BoxcarWilly
Posts
1315
Joined
10/5/2023
Location
Thunder Bay, ON, CA
19 hours ago

There are probably 10,000 other things to worry about while riding before you get to this. 

9
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
19 hours ago

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

1
ZinAZ
Posts
339
Joined
10/11/2022
Location
boston, MA, USA
19 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

to remind yourself how fat you are

14
19 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

Tracking fitness. Seeing where you're at now versus where you were at in the past. Also can be useful info for your Dr when you visit

 

1
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
18 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

Tracking fitness. Seeing where you're at now versus where you were at in the past. Also can be useful info for your Dr when you visit

 

How are you determining a change in heart rate is fitness related?  
There are many other variables that effect heart rate; track condition, how the race plays out, whether you have a pucker moment or not.
 

11
OwenJakes
Posts
1818
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY, USA
18 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

none. people will tell you all kinds of things but really nothing. 

I only use mine so that I can keep up with load and adjust my running stuff if needed. 

1
14
Lentz197
Posts
188
Joined
7/9/2024
Location
FXBG, VA, USA
18 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

To get a more accurate reading of your heart rate at different zones. Most people that wear a HRM also use a smart watch to track their activities and the smartwatch sensors are not as accurate and the chest HRM.

2
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
18 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

Lentz197 wrote:
To get a more accurate reading of your heart rate at different zones. Most people that wear a HRM also use a smart watch to track...

To get a more accurate reading of your heart rate at different zones. Most people that wear a HRM also use a smart watch to track their activities and the smartwatch sensors are not as accurate and the chest HRM.

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

13
BoxcarWilly
Posts
1315
Joined
10/5/2023
Location
Thunder Bay, ON, CA
18 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a...

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

16
GrapeApe
Posts
9135
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
18 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a...

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

Intentionally obtuse should be his next user name

10
zippytech
Posts
1532
Joined
9/8/2018
Location
Bethesda, OH, USA
17 hours ago

I would be more worried about foot pegs and levers.

1
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
17 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a...

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. 

I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a user their fitness level, as claimed. 

Seems like the people wearing them just enjoy the smugness of recording their pulse.   

11
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
16 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a...

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

GrapeApe wrote:

Intentionally obtuse should be his next user name

I bought this one from the original owner and plan on keeping it going for a while

1
Tim507
Posts
3492
Joined
6/8/2010
Location
Oregon City, OR, USA
16 hours ago

I started using a HM when I started riding and racing mtn bikes decades ago. I used it primarily to train my awareness of my heart and self. One example is how fast I could reduce my heart rate after a climb. This was done by watching the rate drop and leaning to incorporate breath work. Same for a severe downhill. Same for MX, however MX taught me about fear generated spikes and that led me to leave a 450 for the younger riders. I achieved a favorable heart rate when I ride smaller and lighter bikes – 2strokes😊   From spikes over 200 to an average of 145 to 160 and minimal to no spikes. Never ride with one all the time as I became “Aware” 

6
GrapeApe
Posts
9135
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
16 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a...

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

3strokemx wrote:
I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a...

I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. 

I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a user their fitness level, as claimed. 

Seems like the people wearing them just enjoy the smugness of recording their pulse.   

OP didn't specify during a MX race. I track HR during a race just for curiosity, I'm obviously not going to alter my pace/effort regardless. I assume OP is talking more about on the bike HR training, but I don't know for sure and don't really care because that's not the point of the thread.

I've never associated a HR strap with smugness, sounds like some sort of complex on your end.

2
1
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
16 hours ago Edited Date/Time 16 hours ago
You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

3strokemx wrote:
I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a...

I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. 

I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a user their fitness level, as claimed. 

Seems like the people wearing them just enjoy the smugness of recording their pulse.   

GrapeApe wrote:
OP didn't specify during a MX race. I track HR during a race just for curiosity, I'm obviously not going to alter my pace/effort regardless. I...

OP didn't specify during a MX race. I track HR during a race just for curiosity, I'm obviously not going to alter my pace/effort regardless. I assume OP is talking more about on the bike HR training, but I don't know for sure and don't really care because that's not the point of the thread.

I've never associated a HR strap with smugness, sounds like some sort of complex on your end.

idk man, HRM without a purpose is a lot like wearing a tool belt and team shirt to spectate a pro national.   Seems pretty smug to me.  

12
mooch
Posts
1871
Joined
2/16/2008
Location
USA
15 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a...

I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. 

I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a user their fitness level, as claimed. 

Seems like the people wearing them just enjoy the smugness of recording their pulse.   

GrapeApe wrote:
OP didn't specify during a MX race. I track HR during a race just for curiosity, I'm obviously not going to alter my pace/effort regardless. I...

OP didn't specify during a MX race. I track HR during a race just for curiosity, I'm obviously not going to alter my pace/effort regardless. I assume OP is talking more about on the bike HR training, but I don't know for sure and don't really care because that's not the point of the thread.

I've never associated a HR strap with smugness, sounds like some sort of complex on your end.

3strokemx wrote:
idk man, HRM without a purpose is a lot like wearing a tool belt and team shirt to spectate a pro national.   Seems pretty smug...

idk man, HRM without a purpose is a lot like wearing a tool belt and team shirt to spectate a pro national.   Seems pretty smug to me.  

While you're trying to spot smug behavior...look no further than taking a look in the mirror.   

6
OwenJakes
Posts
1818
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY, USA
15 hours ago

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

1
9
Tiki
Posts
10705
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
Corona, CA, USA
14 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

To hold your panties up when you are riding your tricycle. 

What do you think the benefits could be? Establishing a baseline while riding so you could replicate it for your off bike training. Measure recovery times between motos, track improvements in conditioning, and understand the cause and effect of sleep, diet, hydration, and scheduled training. Add lap times and you could start identifying how fatigue and performance. Monitor your pace while holding a heart rate so you know when you can pour on energy. Comparing race-day adrenaline vs practice. Basically taking the guesswork out of training. 

8
GrapeApe
Posts
9135
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
14 hours ago
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally receive from wearing a HR monitor? lol

Some people know what they're doing, some don't, some are trying to learn, who cares? None of that has to do with the OP's question anyway.

 

2
ando
Posts
4640
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth, AU
14 hours ago
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

Instead of being a dick perhaps you could consider offering some suggestions; you are certainly implying that you are highly knowledgeable on the subject.

themx11
Posts
274
Joined
6/7/2025
Location
Atlanta, GA, USA
14 hours ago

Don’t they have those ring things now? I’m even weird about wearing a necklace when I ride. 

3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
14 hours ago Edited Date/Time 12 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:

What is the benefit of wearing a HRM?

Tiki wrote:
To hold your panties up when you are riding your tricycle. What do you think the benefits could be? Establishing a baseline while riding so you could...

To hold your panties up when you are riding your tricycle. 

What do you think the benefits could be? Establishing a baseline while riding so you could replicate it for your off bike training. Measure recovery times between motos, track improvements in conditioning, and understand the cause and effect of sleep, diet, hydration, and scheduled training. Add lap times and you could start identifying how fatigue and performance. Monitor your pace while holding a heart rate so you know when you can pour on energy. Comparing race-day adrenaline vs practice. Basically taking the guesswork out of training. 

Tim507 identified the only benefit I can see,

Using HR monitor is a great tool for learning your own physiological awareness. But you can't learn it on a dirtbike, it's much too dynamic and the adrenaline elevates your HR. 

Evaluating recovery and sleep, can be useful in more endurance oriented sports (cycling/running/rowing), But too much going on in MX/HS for HR to tell a reliable story.

 Anyway, for recovery demand it's much simpler and more accurate to evaluate the time it takes to catch your breath after a hard effort.  (If it feels longer than usual you are fatigued).
 

1
3
3strokemx
Posts
3406
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
14 hours ago
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

GrapeApe wrote:
Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally...

Perhaps your post was downvoted because you said there is no benefit to wearing a HR monitor then immediately proceeded to name the benefits you personally receive from wearing a HR monitor? lol

Some people know what they're doing, some don't, some are trying to learn, who cares? None of that has to do with the OP's question anyway.

 

I thought he was saying there was a benefit to him as a Runner, not as a MX rider.   

Do I need to take away my thumbs up?

2
Brad460
Posts
4622
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI, USA
13 hours ago Edited Date/Time 13 hours ago

I like to see what my heart rate was after running from Gate F to Gate C at the Chicago airport..and compare to the turbulence landing in a wind storm..

1
Preston412
Posts
1001
Joined
10/5/2012
Location
Saint Augustine, FL, USA
12 hours ago Edited Date/Time 12 hours ago
OwenJakes wrote:
Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. The majority of people...

Tons of downvotes but most people have no idea what to even do with HR information, let alone as it relates to motocross. 

The majority of people interested in fitness merely have data fascination and conflate possession of information with success. Flame away guys. 

 

If heart rate monitors have no value when wearing them, then why are you wearing one at all?  You say there is no benefit and most people have a data fascination is absurd. I am married to a Cardiology Nurse Practitioner and monitoring your heart beat and evaluating the data can be life saving especially for older riders.  It is not healthy for your heart to be in zones 4 and 5 for a long duration without the ability of your heart to have a fairly quick recovery rate and having that data can help you know when enough is enough for the day.  Its a hot day and you have been riding with buddies and now you are relaxing at the trailer or truck and you feel faint, you have your heart rate monitor on and look at your watch and see your heart rate increasing, well that could be mean you are starting to have a heat stroke if you don't start to cool your self down. 

My point is, the answer of "Nothing" is a ridiculous answer to give to his question.

 

To the OP, Chest protectors were nothing more than a roost/rock protector with no padding in the chest area back then and I am sure the monitors were not slim like they are these days.

You will get the most out of the heart rate monitor when using it for physical training to monitor your heart rate for zone training which you would want to be Zone 1 and 2.  Zone 3 and 4 training is for sprint intervals and can be beneficial but endurance training should be done in zone 1 and the lower part of zone 2 to build a strong base foundation for your heart. The benefit to that is when you start pushing your heart rate up, it will climb to the higher zones at a slower rate then if you constantly trained in zone 3 and 4 (zone 5 is not recommended at all) giving you the ability to push harder for a longer period of time before you max out in zone 5 and feel like you are going to die racing your buddy after 3 laps. It will also help your heart rate recovery more quickly back to zone 1.  This is what you see on the podium after 30 minutes plus 2 and they are breathing normal within a minute or two. 

When using it while riding, obviously it lets you know what your heart rate went up to, how quick did it get there and for how long. Most polar and garmin watches will calculate your recovery rate when you stop recording, it takes two minutes to calculate.  Analyzing the date can up you determine if you are breathing properly while riding or are you training properly at the gym and importantly you can look at your heart rate on the watch and make sure you are giving yourself enough rest before going back out for a heater or just got enough in you to just go have some fun laps. 

3

Post a reply to: Could wearing a chest heart rate monitor be dangerous in a crash?

The Latest