Who is the best American ?

Wandell
Posts
7780
Joined
12/17/2008
Location
Cairo, GA US
4/26/2026 7:10pm
SoCalMX70 wrote:

US citizen Ken Roczen, obviously.

IVE ALWAYS WONDERED ABOUT THIS. SEEMS IF YOU ARE A LEGAL CITIZEN OF A COUNTRY, YOU SHOULD BE ELIGABE TO REPRESENT IT.

2
3
agn5008
Posts
1886
Joined
3/8/2021
Location
PA, PA US
Fantasy
4/26/2026 7:16pm Edited Date/Time 4/26/2026 7:17pm
agn5008 wrote:
Deegan is the best we have. Unless Tomac can get back to his early season speed. It ain’t looking good for US born racers, other than Deegan...

Deegan is the best we have. Unless Tomac can get back to his early season speed. 

It ain’t looking good for US born racers, other than Deegan. Whether anyone wants to admit it or not, the current crop of riders in the 250 class is not good. I can’t think of anyone who is capable of battling for future top 5’s in the 450s other than Deegan and Davies. 

rogers wrote:

ummm...battling for only a top 5 position does not make ANYONE the best US rider we have, LOL.

Ummmm read what I said. I said other than Deegan and Davies, I don’t see anyone else currently in the 250 class battling for future top 5’s in the 450 class. LOL

2
Sully
Posts
9158
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
4/26/2026 7:18pm
agn5008 wrote:
Deegan is the best we have. Unless Tomac can get back to his early season speed. It ain’t looking good for US born racers, other than Deegan...

Deegan is the best we have. Unless Tomac can get back to his early season speed. 

It ain’t looking good for US born racers, other than Deegan. Whether anyone wants to admit it or not, the current crop of riders in the 250 class is not good. I can’t think of anyone who is capable of battling for future top 5’s in the 450s other than Deegan and Davies. 

rogers wrote:

ummm...battling for only a top 5 position does not make ANYONE the best US rider we have, LOL.

agn5008 wrote:
Ummmm read what I said. I said other than Deegan and Davies, I don’t see anyone else currently in the 250 class battling for future top...

Ummmm read what I said. I said other than Deegan and Davies, I don’t see anyone else currently in the 250 class battling for future top 5’s in the 450 class. LOL

Did you watch des Nations last year? Jo will absolutely be battling for top fives. 

1
2
agn5008
Posts
1886
Joined
3/8/2021
Location
PA, PA US
Fantasy
4/26/2026 7:40pm
rogers wrote:

ummm...battling for only a top 5 position does not make ANYONE the best US rider we have, LOL.

agn5008 wrote:
Ummmm read what I said. I said other than Deegan and Davies, I don’t see anyone else currently in the 250 class battling for future top...

Ummmm read what I said. I said other than Deegan and Davies, I don’t see anyone else currently in the 250 class battling for future top 5’s in the 450 class. LOL

Sully wrote:

Did you watch des Nations last year? Jo will absolutely be battling for top fives. 

Yeah, I did. But I prefer to judge based off an entire body of work rather than one race. I love Jo, and I hope he proves me wrong, but he has like 3 SX wins in 5+ years of racing professionally. That doesn’t strike me as someone who will be battling for top 5’s against the likes of Hunter, Jett, Cooper, Chase, Eli (hopefully), Haiden, Kenny, etc. I believe Jo will collect some random top 5’s in the 450 class, but I don’t see him consistently battling with those guys. 

2
3

The Shop

MXMattii
Posts
4975
Joined
3/6/2010
Location
BE
4/26/2026 7:45pm
CPR wrote:
Deegan may turn out to be your best rider, but not sure how you can declare that when he hasn’t even competed in the premier class...

Deegan may turn out to be your best rider, but not sure how you can declare that when he hasn’t even competed in the premier class yet?

Overall I’d say Tomac, but you could argue Sexton before this year. 
Interesting to note that the last five East SX championships have been won by non-Americans. Other than Deegan the up and comers don’t fill you with much confidence.

Yes, could be time for our American friends to start looking at their systems. I note DB and Matthes also said Star are looking to sign...

Yes, could be time for our American friends to start looking at their systems. I note DB and Matthes also said Star are looking to sign a young Australian - in Australia -  who's still only 14 and on superminis...

They know where to look.

If that is Blake Bohannon, the other teams are really a sleep on the wheel.

2
2
Phil109
Posts
636
Joined
7/7/2019
Location
Montgomery, TX US
4/26/2026 7:49pm

Tomac-Deegs-Sexton in that order. 

Thank you for your attention to this matter 😂😂

5
1
CPR
Posts
6590
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
4/26/2026 7:53pm
I'm pretty sure I speak for most when I say Haiden Deegan, and you can extend that well past America to include those third world countries...

I'm pretty sure I speak for most when I say Haiden Deegan, and you can extend that well past America to include those third world countries like France, Belgium, Australia and the Netherlands. Does Australia even have running water and paved roadways? 







 

We have running water when it floods, which is rare, hence Hunter's mud skills or lack there of.

As for our paved roads, they resemble ama sx whoops, hence we're whooping your ass! 😂

8
SoCalMX70
Posts
3459
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA US
4/26/2026 7:54pm
SoCalMX70 wrote:

US citizen Ken Roczen, obviously.

Wandell wrote:

IVE ALWAYS WONDERED ABOUT THIS. SEEMS IF YOU ARE A LEGAL CITIZEN OF A COUNTRY, YOU SHOULD BE ELIGABE TO REPRESENT IT.

Ask Jeff Ward.

1
ShipLap
Posts
1529
Joined
8/15/2018
Location
Moab, UT US
4/26/2026 8:18pm
I'm pretty sure I speak for most when I say Haiden Deegan, and you can extend that well past America to include those third world countries...

I'm pretty sure I speak for most when I say Haiden Deegan, and you can extend that well past America to include those third world countries like France, Belgium, Australia and the Netherlands. Does Australia even have running water and paved roadways? 







 

CPR wrote:
We have running water when it floods, which is rare, hence Hunter's mud skills or lack there of.As for our paved roads, they resemble ama sx...

We have running water when it floods, which is rare, hence Hunter's mud skills or lack there of.

As for our paved roads, they resemble ama sx whoops, hence we're whooping your ass! 😂

Well played, sir.

☺☺

4
ShipLap
Posts
1529
Joined
8/15/2018
Location
Moab, UT US
4/26/2026 8:28pm
Most who saw RV or Dungey coming up as amateurs, probably wouldn't have thought they'd be as good as they ended up being.  RV played second...

Most who saw RV or Dungey coming up as amateurs, probably wouldn't have thought they'd be as good as they ended up being.  RV played second fiddle to Alessi in the amateurs, and Dungey was good but not great. Whoever pulled Dungey up and out of the amateurs needs a raise, but I guarantee you that there are some diamonds in the rough like RV and Dungey that will light up when they go pro.

Take away the Lawrence brothers, and it looks entirely different.  We just got smacked with two brothers that happen to be next level elite riders, with one being generational.  Add to that an aging 450 class and 250 guys who haven't made the successful jump to the 450 class, and I can see why Ricky Johnson is saying what he's saying, but I don't think it is as dire as some people are making it out to be.

"Whoever pulled Dungey up and out of the amateurs needs a raise"

That would be Roger DeCoster.

Another aspect to ponder about American riders, is many of our fast ones are mentally weak.  Consider Sexton, and Tomac at times. Fast, but chronic overthinkers.  RV said he never overthought racing.  RC - same way. Stewart did sometimes, but was speedy enough to rise above it.

1
3
Motofinne
Posts
11371
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
4/27/2026 12:11am Edited Date/Time 4/27/2026 1:13am
  1. Tomac
  2. Webb
  3. Sexton

Deegan will most likely be number 1 within a year or two.

But i think this is an interesting discussion. America still produces elite talent but the talentpool after the Deegans and Sextons of the world is really not great. Some will bring up Kitchen, the guy is 25 years old. Hammaker 26. The riders next in line after Deegan are relatively speaking old. And the young ones around 19-22 do not impress me at all. I have high hopes for Drew Adams but there has been a few too many hiccups with injuries. 

 

4
1
4/27/2026 2:32am Edited Date/Time 4/27/2026 2:35am
Spoonguy wrote:
The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The...

The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The USA's population, wealth, and access to riding areas dwarf other nations, yet in our indoor premier championship the top two were not born here. As said earlier, regional 250 champs are often foreign born. Our amateur system is built to separate parents from dollars, not build winners. And the training facilities do not seem to be a positive. Kids need gate drops, not more money spent on the bikes, and they need to get their ass kicked too. They need to know how to chase success, work hard, pass....

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and haven’t completed school past 7th grade isn’t working.


And don’t tell me homeschooling is working for them.  The pros in our sport are 28 and can’t predicate a noun or differentiate between 3 words that end in the same suffix so they use the wrong word interchangeably.  

8
1
cwel11
Posts
2577
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA US
4/27/2026 2:37am

The best American rider at this moment is Eli 450 and was Deegan 250. How Deegan adjusts to 450 racing remains to be seen. Sexton could be in the mix if he gets himself and the bike sorted but I’m in the camp he may never figure any of it out. As for the future, I’m sure we will get another great at some point but I don’t see any on the horizon. The amateur system cash cow and kids living in facilities has proved it doesn’t work. We end up with a lot of kids who have a self inflated ego with not a lot of grit. Injuries will play a huge part as well. 

7
Spoonguy
Posts
3373
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
4/27/2026 5:39am
Spoonguy wrote:
The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The...

The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The USA's population, wealth, and access to riding areas dwarf other nations, yet in our indoor premier championship the top two were not born here. As said earlier, regional 250 champs are often foreign born. Our amateur system is built to separate parents from dollars, not build winners. And the training facilities do not seem to be a positive. Kids need gate drops, not more money spent on the bikes, and they need to get their ass kicked too. They need to know how to chase success, work hard, pass....

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and...

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and haven’t completed school past 7th grade isn’t working.


And don’t tell me homeschooling is working for them.  The pros in our sport are 28 and can’t predicate a noun or differentiate between 3 words that end in the same suffix so they use the wrong word interchangeably.  

They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of the current regional supercross riders will ever be decent 450 racers, besides Deegan and Davies? They need to know how to pass, chase riders, get beat by other riders, race shitty tracks, ride a shitty bike, camp out the night before a race - not in a motorhome, they need to knw what it feels like to drive overnight to get to a race.

3
3
Johnny Ringo
Posts
7951
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ US
4/27/2026 5:41am
Spoonguy wrote:
The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The...

The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The USA's population, wealth, and access to riding areas dwarf other nations, yet in our indoor premier championship the top two were not born here. As said earlier, regional 250 champs are often foreign born. Our amateur system is built to separate parents from dollars, not build winners. And the training facilities do not seem to be a positive. Kids need gate drops, not more money spent on the bikes, and they need to get their ass kicked too. They need to know how to chase success, work hard, pass....

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and...

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and haven’t completed school past 7th grade isn’t working.


And don’t tell me homeschooling is working for them.  The pros in our sport are 28 and can’t predicate a noun or differentiate between 3 words that end in the same suffix so they use the wrong word interchangeably.  

Spoonguy wrote:
They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of...

They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of the current regional supercross riders will ever be decent 450 racers, besides Deegan and Davies? They need to know how to pass, chase riders, get beat by other riders, race shitty tracks, ride a shitty bike, camp out the night before a race - not in a motorhome, they need to knw what it feels like to drive overnight to get to a race.

It’s well documented that most 450 champions are also good at camping

4
1
Johnny Ringo
Posts
7951
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ US
4/27/2026 6:17am

Sexton isn’t even the best Kawasaki rider at the moment 

2
4
Not hillbilly
Posts
1022
Joined
6/8/2024
Location
Gaithersburg, MD US
4/27/2026 6:20am
Spoonguy wrote:
The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The...

The unspoken truth we all hate to state is our amateur system is broken. We don't have many fast pro 450 riders compared to Europe. The USA's population, wealth, and access to riding areas dwarf other nations, yet in our indoor premier championship the top two were not born here. As said earlier, regional 250 champs are often foreign born. Our amateur system is built to separate parents from dollars, not build winners. And the training facilities do not seem to be a positive. Kids need gate drops, not more money spent on the bikes, and they need to get their ass kicked too. They need to know how to chase success, work hard, pass....

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and...

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and haven’t completed school past 7th grade isn’t working.


And don’t tell me homeschooling is working for them.  The pros in our sport are 28 and can’t predicate a noun or differentiate between 3 words that end in the same suffix so they use the wrong word interchangeably.  

Both of you guys make excellent points 

3
Spoonguy
Posts
3373
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
4/27/2026 12:00pm
Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and...

Less homeschooling and facilities, more big regional weekends and putting money into local tracks.  Spitting out dozens of kids a year who won’t make it and haven’t completed school past 7th grade isn’t working.


And don’t tell me homeschooling is working for them.  The pros in our sport are 28 and can’t predicate a noun or differentiate between 3 words that end in the same suffix so they use the wrong word interchangeably.  

Spoonguy wrote:
They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of...

They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of the current regional supercross riders will ever be decent 450 racers, besides Deegan and Davies? They need to know how to pass, chase riders, get beat by other riders, race shitty tracks, ride a shitty bike, camp out the night before a race - not in a motorhome, they need to knw what it feels like to drive overnight to get to a race.

It’s well documented that most 450 champions are also good at camping

My point is they need to struggle, they need hardship. We can talk about it on our podcast.

3
1
Johnny Ringo
Posts
7951
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ US
4/27/2026 4:23pm
Spoonguy wrote:
They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of...

They spend too many years in amateurs cherry picking classes to get podiums, then too many years in regional supercross. Seriously does anyone think any of the current regional supercross riders will ever be decent 450 racers, besides Deegan and Davies? They need to know how to pass, chase riders, get beat by other riders, race shitty tracks, ride a shitty bike, camp out the night before a race - not in a motorhome, they need to knw what it feels like to drive overnight to get to a race.

It’s well documented that most 450 champions are also good at camping

Spoonguy wrote:

My point is they need to struggle, they need hardship. We can talk about it on our podcast.

Good topic idea

1
karsmakers
Posts
757
Joined
5/24/2013
Location
Yuba City, CA US
4/27/2026 4:47pm

Sexton on a KTM or Honda

Deegan next year

Tomac this year on one of his "good days"

1
1
BossWool2800
Posts
297
Joined
10/25/2025
Location
Jackson , TX US
4/27/2026 7:40pm

I don’t like him, but probably Deegan

1
2
Not hillbilly
Posts
1022
Joined
6/8/2024
Location
Gaithersburg, MD US
4/27/2026 9:11pm

The one willing to rep the US at the MXoN…

4
Juck
Posts
1884
Joined
5/23/2019
Location
AU
Fantasy
4/28/2026 3:59am
Motofinne wrote:
TomacWebbSextonDeegan will most likely be number 1 within a year or two.But i think this is an interesting discussion. America still produces elite talent but the...
  1. Tomac
  2. Webb
  3. Sexton

Deegan will most likely be number 1 within a year or two.

But i think this is an interesting discussion. America still produces elite talent but the talentpool after the Deegans and Sextons of the world is really not great. Some will bring up Kitchen, the guy is 25 years old. Hammaker 26. The riders next in line after Deegan are relatively speaking old. And the young ones around 19-22 do not impress me at all. I have high hopes for Drew Adams but there has been a few too many hiccups with injuries. 

 

I thought Dudney showed good speed when he was racing, and Gordon has also been impressive. 

Pierce Brown could also be good if he can stay healthy, although he's older than Jett.

Spoonguy
Posts
3373
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
4/28/2026 4:49am

It should be an embarrassment to the people who control the sport in this country, Coombs/ the AMA, that we are the largest, wealthiest, most tracks, most dealers, largest aftermarket, and we cannot win our own championships. The system simply doesn't develop complete pro racers, it simply transfers money from parents to promoters and "facilities". We don't even have all the announcers at our supercross races.

4
2
Johnny Ringo
Posts
7951
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ US
4/28/2026 4:58am
Motofinne wrote:
TomacWebbSextonDeegan will most likely be number 1 within a year or two.But i think this is an interesting discussion. America still produces elite talent but the...
  1. Tomac
  2. Webb
  3. Sexton

Deegan will most likely be number 1 within a year or two.

But i think this is an interesting discussion. America still produces elite talent but the talentpool after the Deegans and Sextons of the world is really not great. Some will bring up Kitchen, the guy is 25 years old. Hammaker 26. The riders next in line after Deegan are relatively speaking old. And the young ones around 19-22 do not impress me at all. I have high hopes for Drew Adams but there has been a few too many hiccups with injuries. 

 

Juck wrote:
I thought Dudney showed good speed when he was racing, and Gordon has also been impressive. Pierce Brown could also be good if he can stay healthy...

I thought Dudney showed good speed when he was racing, and Gordon has also been impressive. 

Pierce Brown could also be good if he can stay healthy, although he's older than Jett.

Pierce turned pro the same year as Jett, I think they are close ish in age. Maybe a couple months difference 

DJS721
Posts
147
Joined
1/1/2014
Location
Slip Window, OH US
4/28/2026 5:03am

Rick Melon, gotta be part of the discussion. I mean, he even builds his own bikes!

image 2938
2
1
4/28/2026 5:13am
CPan wrote:

I don’t even like Webb and it’s crazy he’s not in this discussion. 

Why would he be? Hes not even a podium threat on an outdoor track 

2
super_fan_38
Posts
257
Joined
9/25/2025
Location
Oak Harbor, WA US
1 day ago
Spoonguy wrote:
It should be an embarrassment to the people who control the sport in this country, Coombs/ the AMA, that we are the largest, wealthiest, most tracks...

It should be an embarrassment to the people who control the sport in this country, Coombs/ the AMA, that we are the largest, wealthiest, most tracks, most dealers, largest aftermarket, and we cannot win our own championships. The system simply doesn't develop complete pro racers, it simply transfers money from parents to promoters and "facilities". We don't even have all the announcers at our supercross races.

What do you mean we can't win our own championships?  In the last ten seasons, Americans have won the majority of outdoor titles, both 450 and 250, and the majority of 450 sx titles, as well as the majority of the 250 lites titles.  This is expected since the majority of the racers have been Americans, but you need to look at the bigger picture here.  

The last few years have seen the dominance of Jett Lawrence, and now his older brother has taken huge steps forward after winning the 250 outdoor and 250 E regional titles in 2023.  Aside from Jett winning when he's not out injured, the results vary.  Tom Vialle won 2 regional sx titles in Dungey-esque fashion through consistency, but then failed, as a 2 time World Champion and outdoor specialist, to win an outdoor title. Cole Davies just won the 250 E regional sx title, but in the first two shootouts was no match for Deegan.  

None of this is unusual.  Fast foreign riders have always crossed the pond and done well.  Kenny Roczen came over, won a regional title and 2 450 outdoor titles. Dylan Ferrandis came over and won a regional sx title and then the 450 outdoor title.  You can go even further back to Jean-Michel Bayle, who came over and dominated in 1991 winning the 250 sx (then the premier class) title, the 250 outdoor title, and the 500 outdoor title.  No one did it before or since (though that format no loner exists). He would have likely won the 125 title in 1990 if not for a broken wrist at Washougal.

Plenty of other foreign riders could be named as well.  The point is that even if we had a good amateur system (and I agree with you that ours needs help), there would still be very fast foreign riders that would cross the pond and win.  We dominated in the 80s because until JMB, no foreign riders came over and gave it a serious go.  The older GP guys like Malherbe, Thorpe, Jobe, and the like had no interest in supercross, and their styles weren't very adaptive to the tight, technical supercross tracks of the time. 

It wasn't until the younger generation expressed interest that riders started coming to the States to try sx.  Even Stefan Everts came over for a few rounds in 92, and a few years after that, we started seeing racers like Mickael Pichon and Stephane Roncada.  Then we got the Reeds, and Roczen's, and now a lot of the younger racers want to come to America to race sx, so it should be expected that as the talent pool gets deeper, we will have winners from alll over the globe.

3
5
The Wolf Man
Posts
395
Joined
12/18/2025
Location
Suburb, NSW AU
1 day ago
CPan wrote:

I don’t even like Webb and it’s crazy he’s not in this discussion. 

Why would he be? Hes not even a podium threat on an outdoor track 

Yes, it seems like it's that time of year again.

Welcome to the 'Cooked Webb is not even in the Top 10 Outdoors' segment.

Jett, Hunter, Eli, Chase, Prado, Deegan, AP, JCoop, Barcia, Ferrandis........Webb

Also, as he does every single year, he either will reveal he's 'banged up' just before outdoors begins and not show up...or he'll be 'banged up' or suffering from 'Epstein Barr' within a few rounds and off to the local McDonalds. 

3

Post a reply to: Who is the best American ?

The Latest