Shorty's 350 does not look that fast

AussieParaMX
Posts
1724
Joined
7/30/2009
Location
Mount Waverley, VIC, AU
Edited Date/Time 1/24/2012 10:13pm
compared to Canards 450 on the same track





It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy

i think the lap times will be similar but making passes will be hard, one mess up in a corner, will ruin a tricky section (where a 450 will just Braaaap over anything from a standstill), squaring up out of corners will be harder, Whoops? if he dont get a good run onto them, will he be able to build speed through them like a fourfiddy would?

Starts will be neither here nor there IMO, its the rest of the track in a race situation that could be an issue.
|
72kiteboarder
Posts
4645
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
90 MILES SOUTH-ISH, FL, USA
12/11/2010 11:20pm
compared to Canards 450 on the same track [embed]http://motocross.transworld.net/1000104659/videos/transworld-mx-raw-trey-canard/[/embed] [embed]http://www.youtube.com/user/AndrewShortMX29#p/u/3/18QsvIQuiKY[/embed] It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy i think the lap times...
compared to Canards 450 on the same track





It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy

i think the lap times will be similar but making passes will be hard, one mess up in a corner, will ruin a tricky section (where a 450 will just Braaaap over anything from a standstill), squaring up out of corners will be harder, Whoops? if he dont get a good run onto them, will he be able to build speed through them like a fourfiddy would?

Starts will be neither here nor there IMO, its the rest of the track in a race situation that could be an issue.
450's do not Braaap, just FYI.
cjxrider125
Posts
22
Joined
12/4/2007
Location
Lake Forest, CA, USA
12/11/2010 11:27pm
apples to oranges
AussieParaMX
Posts
1724
Joined
7/30/2009
Location
Mount Waverley, VIC, AU
12/11/2010 11:30pm
apples to oranges
apples racing oranges
mmcmx
Posts
2280
Joined
8/31/2008
Location
Perafita, Catalunya, PE
12/12/2010 12:46am
Yeah, the rider has nothing to do with it.

The Shop

kongols
Posts
24230
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/12/2010 1:47am
mmcmx wrote:
Yeah, the rider has nothing to do with it.
Are you crazy! Of cource not. And that is actually their race speed.
AussieParaMX
Posts
1724
Joined
7/30/2009
Location
Mount Waverley, VIC, AU
12/12/2010 4:01am
mmcmx wrote:
Yeah, the rider has nothing to do with it.
i sense sarcasm.

im not commenting on the rider and his influence on the bike or how the riders skills affect the bike. Im saying the 450 surges forward out of corners and through rhythm sections more dramatically than the 350.

Its not to say he cant win on it or get a start on it, But i just saw a drastic difference on the same track between the two bikes. It will go around a track equally as fast as a 450 but in a heated battle, the power disadvantage will be very noticeable.

NB. This argument is nullified if the bike actually does ride like a 250f, the factory bike does make as much power as a 450, and if shorty and Allessi ride it like a 125 on the limiter, which neither of them do.
AussieParaMX
Posts
1724
Joined
7/30/2009
Location
Mount Waverley, VIC, AU
12/12/2010 4:04am
450's do not Braaap, just FYI.
debatable, out of corners they Braaap IMHO

any other time they go daddadadadadada - well at least Barcia's does
12/12/2010 4:13am
funny that, cairoli's 350 looks pretty fast!
have a look at lierop on freecaster, race one cairoli is last on the first lap, passes nearly everyone to finish 3rd (despite crashing 3 times) moto 2 he wins by about a minute! And that is on the knarliest deep sand track in the world!
mccread
Posts
5934
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/12/2010 5:00am
No one in the world could beat Cairoli there not even Stewart... they guy is unreal in that stuff.
Freddy
Posts
379
Joined
11/18/2010
Location
SE
12/12/2010 6:04am
mmcmx wrote:
Yeah, the rider has nothing to do with it.
i sense sarcasm. im not commenting on the rider and his influence on the bike or how the riders skills affect the bike. Im saying the...
i sense sarcasm.

im not commenting on the rider and his influence on the bike or how the riders skills affect the bike. Im saying the 450 surges forward out of corners and through rhythm sections more dramatically than the 350.

Its not to say he cant win on it or get a start on it, But i just saw a drastic difference on the same track between the two bikes. It will go around a track equally as fast as a 450 but in a heated battle, the power disadvantage will be very noticeable.

NB. This argument is nullified if the bike actually does ride like a 250f, the factory bike does make as much power as a 450, and if shorty and Allessi ride it like a 125 on the limiter, which neither of them do.
When watching roczen pass 450 guys @ mxon i didnt notice any power diff. Except for when the 450's hit the quad and Roczen didnt.
Your right though, the 450 does look like it hits harder. But then, after some laps on a sx track and you find your self in a battle, would you still have energy enough to ride that 450 aggressive when somebody is battleing with you?
DBerg
Posts
361
Joined
10/10/2010
Location
San Marcos, TX, USA
12/12/2010 6:05am
Watching the MXdN, Cairoli looked faster than Dungey too, obviously that wasn't the case. A rider's style has a lot to do with how fast someone looks, but not necessarily how fast someone is. If you think about it, TC and Short are probably within a second or 2 of each other on the track, so the difference through one corner might be just a fraction of a second and while that is important, it's a pretty difficult thing to eye ball in 2 separate videos, from different angles, and say one is clearly faster than another, but hey then again, it might be true too.
kongols
Posts
24230
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/12/2010 6:15am
DBerg wrote:
Watching the MXdN, Cairoli looked faster than Dungey too, obviously that wasn't the case. A rider's style has a lot to do with how fast someone...
Watching the MXdN, Cairoli looked faster than Dungey too, obviously that wasn't the case. A rider's style has a lot to do with how fast someone looks, but not necessarily how fast someone is. If you think about it, TC and Short are probably within a second or 2 of each other on the track, so the difference through one corner might be just a fraction of a second and while that is important, it's a pretty difficult thing to eye ball in 2 separate videos, from different angles, and say one is clearly faster than another, but hey then again, it might be true too.
Nonsense. You could clearly see that TC was exactly 1.61 sec. faster than Short.
Faceaz
Posts
1364
Joined
7/28/2008
Location
Glendale, AZ, USA
12/12/2010 6:32am
I don't think you can tell shit between the 2 on those videos. Oh maybe so - one's red & one's orange.
jleews6
Posts
2304
Joined
8/3/2008
Location
Hardy, VA, USA
12/12/2010 6:57am
Those motors are making the max HP per CC no matter what brand they are so when your down 100 CCs your going to be down on power. No one will convince me otherwise.
Im sure this is not as much of a factor in supercross but motocross it is. I'm not saying that a 450 will be 3 seconds a lap faster I'm just saying that they will have more power and even though they may not use all the power all the time there is some places where that extra power can make a section faster.
sharkey
Posts
2446
Joined
7/28/2008
Location
Marysville, WA, USA
12/12/2010 8:38am
jleews6 wrote:
Those motors are making the max HP per CC no matter what brand they are so when your down 100 CCs your going to be down...
Those motors are making the max HP per CC no matter what brand they are so when your down 100 CCs your going to be down on power. No one will convince me otherwise.
Im sure this is not as much of a factor in supercross but motocross it is. I'm not saying that a 450 will be 3 seconds a lap faster I'm just saying that they will have more power and even though they may not use all the power all the time there is some places where that extra power can make a section faster.
so true. look at alessi last year. nothing like when he was on the suzuki. and alessi has spent alot of time on ktms before so if anyone could adapt to those bikes quick it should be him. i wonder if those guys will be givin a choice on what they can ride
Cygnus
Posts
14845
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Hanover, CO, USA
12/12/2010 8:42am
If Short doesn't get on the podium will the KTM fanbois admit the bike still needs work?
Karma
Posts
871
Joined
9/14/2009
Location
CA
12/12/2010 8:44am Edited Date/Time 12/12/2010 8:45am
Faceaz wrote:
I don't think you can tell shit between the 2 on those videos. Oh maybe so - one's red & one's orange.
I don't think you can tell shit between the 2 on those videos. Oh maybe so - one's red & one's orange.
What you could tell was AC was cracking his nuts every freakn lap on the the des nations quad...He is the new squeakySilly
RaceFace
Posts
1608
Joined
8/15/2010
Location
USA
12/12/2010 9:18am
Cygnus wrote:
If Short doesn't get on the podium will the KTM fanbois admit the bike still needs work?
Nope, they will say it is Short AND Alessi that now suck. I don't think the bike needs more work, I just think there is only so much you can do with 100cc less. Short wasn't likely getting any podiums in 2011 SX even on his Honda, so it will be worse on the 350.

People point to Roczen at MXoN, Villopoto at Budds Creek MXdN...you can even point to O'Mara 1986 MXdN. These are instances of very unlikely results. Does O'Mara's performance prove that 125's were at no disadvantage to 500's? Yet, Roczen at MXoN somehow correlates to the 350 not being a disadvantage in the long haul? No, it just means Roczen was on it that day.
kongols
Posts
24230
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/12/2010 9:34am
Cygnus wrote:
If Short doesn't get on the podium will the KTM fanbois admit the bike still needs work?
Was he a definite podium before he went to KTM?
RACERX69
Posts
1175
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
12/12/2010 9:35am
mccread wrote:
No one in the world could beat Cairoli there not even Stewart... they guy is unreal in that stuff.
Bet RC would of!
kongols
Posts
24230
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/12/2010 9:36am
Cygnus wrote:
If Short doesn't get on the podium will the KTM fanbois admit the bike still needs work?
RaceFace wrote:
Nope, they will say it is Short AND Alessi that now suck. I don't think the bike needs more work, I just think there is only...
Nope, they will say it is Short AND Alessi that now suck. I don't think the bike needs more work, I just think there is only so much you can do with 100cc less. Short wasn't likely getting any podiums in 2011 SX even on his Honda, so it will be worse on the 350.

People point to Roczen at MXoN, Villopoto at Budds Creek MXdN...you can even point to O'Mara 1986 MXdN. These are instances of very unlikely results. Does O'Mara's performance prove that 125's were at no disadvantage to 500's? Yet, Roczen at MXoN somehow correlates to the 350 not being a disadvantage in the long haul? No, it just means Roczen was on it that day.
Alessi has never been the same after those two crashes. He needs a real good trainer to get his head straight again.
robkinuk
Posts
4295
Joined
5/16/2007
Location
Ashbourne, GB
12/12/2010 9:46am
It's really funny how people who have bought into the Japanese big 450 bikes, have to try and slag off the KTM 350cc at every opportunity to somehow justify their purchase and prop up their flagging ego's.

Cubic CC's mean fuck all, it's how you ride it that counts as Tony Cairoli demonstrated all season in the GP's on his 3fifty rocket ship!
lafawnduh
Posts
76
Joined
10/13/2010
Location
USA
12/12/2010 10:01am
compared to Canards 450 on the same track [embed]http://motocross.transworld.net/1000104659/videos/transworld-mx-raw-trey-canard/[/embed] [embed]http://www.youtube.com/user/AndrewShortMX29#p/u/3/18QsvIQuiKY[/embed] It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy i think the lap times...
compared to Canards 450 on the same track





It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy

i think the lap times will be similar but making passes will be hard, one mess up in a corner, will ruin a tricky section (where a 450 will just Braaaap over anything from a standstill), squaring up out of corners will be harder, Whoops? if he dont get a good run onto them, will he be able to build speed through them like a fourfiddy would?

Starts will be neither here nor there IMO, its the rest of the track in a race situation that could be an issue.
Well there you have it... Shorts season is a bust.. Maybe Short was trying settings out???

Where the F do you guys come from??? Really??



Slow
Posts
449
Joined
9/29/2009
Location
Watsonville, CA, USA
12/12/2010 10:24am
Cygnus wrote:
If Short doesn't get on the podium will the KTM fanbois admit the bike still needs work?
No because short would have a hard time making the podium on the Honda this year! The class is stacked.
Cook441
Posts
1700
Joined
5/30/2009
Location
Tacoma, WA, USA
Fantasy
12/12/2010 10:28am Edited Date/Time 12/12/2010 10:30am
compared to Canards 450 on the same track [embed]http://motocross.transworld.net/1000104659/videos/transworld-mx-raw-trey-canard/[/embed] [embed]http://www.youtube.com/user/AndrewShortMX29#p/u/3/18QsvIQuiKY[/embed] It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy i think the lap times...
compared to Canards 450 on the same track





It just doesn't surge hard out of corners like the fourfiddy

i think the lap times will be similar but making passes will be hard, one mess up in a corner, will ruin a tricky section (where a 450 will just Braaaap over anything from a standstill), squaring up out of corners will be harder, Whoops? if he dont get a good run onto them, will he be able to build speed through them like a fourfiddy would?

Starts will be neither here nor there IMO, its the rest of the track in a race situation that could be an issue.
i just happen to have a stop watch some time and thought id share-


Trey 48.23

Short 47.730

for what its worth
kongols
Posts
24230
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/12/2010 10:33am
Cook441 wrote:
i just happen to have a stop watch some time and thought id share-


Trey 48.23

Short 47.730

for what its worth
Are you saying that somebody`s been misleading us here on forum? No way!!
Barrett57
Posts
2270
Joined
8/31/2010
Location
GB
12/12/2010 10:36am
mccread wrote:
No one in the world could beat Cairoli there not even Stewart... they guy is unreal in that stuff.
RACERX69 wrote:
Bet RC would of!
not at lierop,not on that day.
Cook441
Posts
1700
Joined
5/30/2009
Location
Tacoma, WA, USA
Fantasy
12/12/2010 10:37am
im not saying anything just posting some facts..i let the speculation come from elseware-

Post a reply to: Shorty's 350 does not look that fast

The Latest