Toyota Tundra -or- Toyota Tacoma -or- Ford F150?

MX558
Posts
1980
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
3/28/2024 1:53am
CDA331 wrote:
Idk about anything about trucks except when I see one I like I go siiick!    My mechanic who’s worked on my cars for years told...

Idk about anything about trucks except when I see one I like I go siiick! 
 

My mechanic who’s worked on my cars for years told me if I get a ford, take it somewhere else, he hates working on them and refuses it. Always sending my articles on how unreliable they are compared to chevys and Toyotas. 
 

Thats all I got 🤙

Timo wrote:

Ford designed and makes the transmissions for GM 😂

Yes but Ford screwed up the programming on theirs and GM didn't. 

Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
3/28/2024 8:20am
MX558 wrote:
The f150 10 speed transmissions are shit . There are recalls now for 22-23 and class action suit for previous years with the 10 speed...

The f150 10 speed transmissions are shit . There are recalls now for 22-23 and class action suit for previous years with the 10 speed . I've had Ford's my whole adult life and I'm done with them now . I'd personally get the new GM truck with the 3.0 Duramax 

If you think GM is going to be better than Ford,  you're in for a surprise. 

 

3
9
BMR179
Posts
507
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
East Texas, TX, USA
Fantasy
3/28/2024 8:32am

Prior to 2014 I was a GM guy.  Had 6 GM's and the transmission on every one of them went out somewhere between 60K and 80K.  Bought a 2013 F150 Eco that now has 108K with no trans, engine, or turbo problems...so far.  1/3 of those miles are with a 14x7 box trailer being towed.  The only problem that I have had is the throttle body giving up the ghost at 40K and 77K.  I need to buy an extra and put it in the truck.  

A new truck would be nice, but dammit son they are expensive.  I'll just re-invest in my current ride when needed.

3
fourfourone
Posts
3046
Joined
10/14/2017
Location
86oh, CT, USA
3/28/2024 9:12am
MX558 wrote:
The f150 10 speed transmissions are shit . There are recalls now for 22-23 and class action suit for previous years with the 10 speed...

The f150 10 speed transmissions are shit . There are recalls now for 22-23 and class action suit for previous years with the 10 speed . I've had Ford's my whole adult life and I'm done with them now . I'd personally get the new GM truck with the 3.0 Duramax 

Magoofan wrote:

If you think GM is going to be better than Ford,  you're in for a surprise. 

 

They both suck. 

8
3

The Shop

RockyRider
Posts
347
Joined
3/10/2016
Location
Nor Cal, CA, USA
3/28/2024 9:23am

About a year back my 6.0 decided to eat a piston and my hand was forced to buy a newer truck within a few days, I've had multiple tacomas and will never buy another. Too small and mileage is just shit for what they are. I ended up with an 18 F150 with the 2.7 Ecoboost and holy shit has this thing been enjoyable to own. Quick, ton of cab room (honestly similar space as my 250), great mileage and it drives like a car. Original plan was to sell it when i get my 250 back, but this things is staying as my daily with the diesel being the weekend queen. 

7
Kyle978
Posts
1712
Joined
10/7/2013
Location
Dirt, NM, USA
3/28/2024 11:07am Edited Date/Time 3/28/2024 11:08am

Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives. 

I've managed fleets with as many as 50 trucks used daily for various services in the West Texas oil fields. We've had trucks from Chevy, Ford, Dodge/Ram and Toyota. All of them have their pros and cons. All of them have issues at some point. 

Personally, I've had 5 new GMC/Chevy pickups in the last 12 years and have 1 year down with my Raptor (first Ford I've owned). Have not had a single issue with any of my trucks. 

You can find nightmares and success stories with every truck. There are a lot of variables. 

12
Meister
Posts
3252
Joined
3/21/2013
Location
Canton, OH, USA
3/28/2024 11:17am
Kyle978 wrote:
Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives.  I've managed fleets with as many as 50...

Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives. 

I've managed fleets with as many as 50 trucks used daily for various services in the West Texas oil fields. We've had trucks from Chevy, Ford, Dodge/Ram and Toyota. All of them have their pros and cons. All of them have issues at some point. 

Personally, I've had 5 new GMC/Chevy pickups in the last 12 years and have 1 year down with my Raptor (first Ford I've owned). Have not had a single issue with any of my trucks. 

You can find nightmares and success stories with every truck. There are a lot of variables. 

I feel the same. Im not necessarily a fan boy of any brand but doing my research as to what will work best for me and provide creature comforts i like, i keep landing back in a ford. We have two 10 speed tranny trucks and no problems from either yet. It does seem to pair better with my dads 6.7 but I've got no complaints with my 3.5. 

 

Yes, all things suck compared to the olden days, but its what we got. People used to think cars were dead at 100k. Now they're way up there. My f150 will probably make 100k on stock brakes. That wasnt happening 20 years ago. 

2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
3/28/2024 11:20am
SLAPAHO wrote:
Well, I don’t drive a lifted truck, sooooo. You can stop thinking about my dick now.  Or can you?   Keep going with the negative posts...

Well, I don’t drive a lifted truck, sooooo. You can stop thinking about my dick now. 
Or can you?  
Keep going with the negative posts, it just confirms that what everyone here thinks about you. 
 

You just keep running with that narrative in your head if it gets you thru the day. 

 

10
TeamGreen
Posts
37098
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
3/28/2024 11:23am
Kyle978 wrote:
Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives.  I've managed fleets with as many as 50...

Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives. 

I've managed fleets with as many as 50 trucks used daily for various services in the West Texas oil fields. We've had trucks from Chevy, Ford, Dodge/Ram and Toyota. All of them have their pros and cons. All of them have issues at some point. 

Personally, I've had 5 new GMC/Chevy pickups in the last 12 years and have 1 year down with my Raptor (first Ford I've owned). Have not had a single issue with any of my trucks. 

You can find nightmares and success stories with every truck. There are a lot of variables. 

Meister wrote:
I feel the same. Im not necessarily a fan boy of any brand but doing my research as to what will work best for me and...

I feel the same. Im not necessarily a fan boy of any brand but doing my research as to what will work best for me and provide creature comforts i like, i keep landing back in a ford. We have two 10 speed tranny trucks and no problems from either yet. It does seem to pair better with my dads 6.7 but I've got no complaints with my 3.5. 

 

Yes, all things suck compared to the olden days, but its what we got. People used to think cars were dead at 100k. Now they're way up there. My f150 will probably make 100k on stock brakes. That wasnt happening 20 years ago. 

Funny...

There's only -1- thing my old '67 Bronco does better than my new one: it sounds better. Period. Cool

EVERYTHING ELSE is BETTER on my new one. EVERYTHING Laughing

3
flatspin
Posts
96
Joined
1/6/2024
Location
Washington D.C., WA, USA
3/28/2024 11:25am

Ram TRX. They can do awd donuts on dry pavement. (Aka flat spin.)  That’s a big selling point for me, personally

3
3
Kyle978
Posts
1712
Joined
10/7/2013
Location
Dirt, NM, USA
3/28/2024 11:44am
flatspin wrote:

Ram TRX. They can do awd donuts on dry pavement. (Aka flat spin.)  That’s a big selling point for me, personally

Well, some can do donuts. Not everyone lol. 

 

 

2
ARM670
Posts
2227
Joined
12/11/2020
Location
Napoleon, OH, USA
3/28/2024 12:16pm
Ford trucks .  and twice in Tuesday....  We've had a few,  and never disappointed... our present F150 has 332,000 Miles in it and original sans radiator...

Ford trucks .  and twice in Tuesday....  We've had a few,  and never disappointed... our present F150 has 332,000 Miles in it and original sans radiator, alt, one steering hose..  even the auto trans is original...  you as a consumer and assumedly a citizen..  why cut a check to the same country that required Ford assembly plants to re-tool and build B-29s...  and other equipment TO defend our lives in the USA from same country...  I honestly can't fathom buying a product, a huge cash drop, that a domestic company makes a great example of, from an Asian company...   Bad enough nIce had to buy Hondas.... as stated ..  what's the domestic choice in bikes?   And "assembled in Tennessee" is no answer...  its a con job to avoid terrifs...

Magoofan wrote:
I love these "buy American" vehicle arguments.... There are no more American car manufacturers.  It's a global economy....parts are sourced globally and generally the lowest bidder...

I love these "buy American" vehicle arguments....

There are no more American car manufacturers.  It's a global economy....parts are sourced globally and generally the lowest bidder.

Let's not even get into the UAW and bailouts bullshit. 

Holding a grudge against Japan for a war 80+ years ago is beyond ridiculous.     That's like blaming todays white folks for slavery.

To discuss this any further, we'll need to move it non-moto.  

 

The German and Japanese vehicles we own now are/have been the best cars we've ever owned.   Hands down.

 

Motoxdoc wrote:
No, since you solicited it, I would like to get into the “UAW bailout and bullshit”…non-moto would be fine…for starters, do you realize the UAW paid...

No, since you solicited it, I would like to get into the “UAW bailout and bullshit”…non-moto would be fine…for starters, do you realize the UAW paid back that “bailout” with interest?  What if private individuals had to do that?  I can think of a certain orange person who filed bankruptcy and the LARGEST LOSSES IN THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, FOR AN INDIVIDUAL OR CORPORATION, 10 YEARS IN A ROW!…. if he was held responsible for his losses/actions, do you think he would’ve become president?  What would’ve happened to the UAW and ALL THOSE HARD WORKING AMERICANS AND THEIR JOBS if Romney became president?

At least you’re not trying to be patriotic while dissing America, but you are smearing the name of a certain MX hero. 

Sorry but GM did not pay back the bailout. The American taxpayer lost over $10 billion on the bailout.  

5
2
Timo
Posts
1445
Joined
1/9/2021
Location
Wichita, KS, USA
3/28/2024 12:28pm
MX558 wrote:

Yes but Ford screwed up the programming on theirs and GM didn't. 

I was a Chrysler/Ford mechanic back when the 5-6 speed trans were coming out and I'll say this, people don't like the transmissions to shift. It's more common when there's a tachometer, but any shifting while driving is considered an issue by some drivers who don't understand engine torque curves. Yes it downshifts on hills, or when you push the accelerator down. They also like to push on the gas during a drive to reverse or reverse to drive shift and get mad it jerks. A lot more people than you think shift to neutral while on the highway to save gas and accidentally go to reverse, or try to manually go from drive to 3rd and go to far and end up in 1st. They'll bitch about it being a POS, when it's user error. I had a lady come in with a minivan knocking like crazy. Put it on the lift and the oil pan was collapsed and the crank was hitting it. I asked what she ran over and the only thing she could think of was a jack rabbit....

I've also had to remove fluid from transmissions because people check and fill them cold above the max level because more fluid is better. A lot of issues are caused by the end user, blamed on the equipment, and repeated in online eco chambers because someone likes one brand more than the other. 25% actual issues, 25% bad luck, 50% people are dumb.

2
1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
3/28/2024 12:35pm
Motoxdoc wrote:
No, since you solicited it, I would like to get into the “UAW bailout and bullshit”…non-moto would be fine…for starters, do you realize the UAW paid...

No, since you solicited it, I would like to get into the “UAW bailout and bullshit”…non-moto would be fine…for starters, do you realize the UAW paid back that “bailout” with interest?  What if private individuals had to do that?  I can think of a certain orange person who filed bankruptcy and the LARGEST LOSSES IN THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, FOR AN INDIVIDUAL OR CORPORATION, 10 YEARS IN A ROW!…. if he was held responsible for his losses/actions, do you think he would’ve become president?  What would’ve happened to the UAW and ALL THOSE HARD WORKING AMERICANS AND THEIR JOBS if Romney became president?

At least you’re not trying to be patriotic while dissing America, but you are smearing the name of a certain MX hero. 

Tyler D wrote:
i recently purchased my first domestic vehicle ever. sticker price over 50.  by far the WORST paint i've ever seen in my life. there are literal...

i recently purchased my first domestic vehicle ever. sticker price over 50. 

by far the WORST paint i've ever seen in my life. there are literal splotches of clear coat pools all over the underside of the trunk and in the door jambs that look like cum stains. 

I PROUDLY ripped the UAW sticker off the door frame day 1. 

I missed your response yesterday.    Got some bad news my friend.  My niece, the one with the 100K mile 2020 Suburban that needs an $8k transmission job, the paint is all faded/peeling on the top of it.   

As for the guy you quoted....that post of his says all you need to know.  Wink

 

1
5
blu450rider
Posts
6
Joined
1/29/2024
Location
fallbrook, CA, USA
3/28/2024 1:21pm

Toyota for the win always, except the new Tundra. just dog shit in my opinion. Stick with the 5.7 Crewmax Tundra, platinum or limited models.  Tacoma has shifting issues always looking for a gear, so this sucks when driving across state. Tacoma bed size sucks for dirt bike too. Buy a ford, ppl will judge you. stay away from the eco boost having cam phaser issues. just buy a 5.0 f150 and call it a day. chevy is real nice and comfortable. You failed to tell us what your using the truck for too... just track days? off road use? grocery getter?? Good luck with your choice. 

1
1
KennyT
Posts
4394
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Vista, CA, USA
Fantasy
3/28/2024 1:47pm
Kyle978 wrote:
Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives.  I've managed fleets with as many as 50...

Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives. 

I've managed fleets with as many as 50 trucks used daily for various services in the West Texas oil fields. We've had trucks from Chevy, Ford, Dodge/Ram and Toyota. All of them have their pros and cons. All of them have issues at some point. 

Personally, I've had 5 new GMC/Chevy pickups in the last 12 years and have 1 year down with my Raptor (first Ford I've owned). Have not had a single issue with any of my trucks. 

You can find nightmares and success stories with every truck. There are a lot of variables. 

I am as far from a brand loyalist as it gets. I was trying to think of all the trucks have had over the last 20 years. I came up with :

3 Ford F150’s (2005 - 2010 - 2017) 

Rams : 2014 and a 2020

Chevy Silverado’s: 2018 and my current truck 2020

Jeep Gladiator : 2022

Toyota Tacoma : 2016

out of all those trucks i was most disappointed in the Toyota. Not because it’s a bad truck, it just didn’t fulfill my pleasures as far as luxury, interior room, power and it got worse gas mileage than my full size trucks. I’m sure it would have gone 400,000 miles but for someone who has never put over 75,000 miles on one of them, longevity isn’t an issue. 
 

out of all those vehicles I never did anything but standard maintenance, I rarely had one out of warranty. I have zero brand loyalty, if I like the way something looks/rides I really don’t care what emblem is on it. 

4
ARM670
Posts
2227
Joined
12/11/2020
Location
Napoleon, OH, USA
3/28/2024 2:01pm Edited Date/Time 3/28/2024 2:03pm

Last 20 years.... 1988 F250, 1989 F250, 1994 F250, 1998 F150, 2007 F150, 2010 F150, 2017 F250. I still have 88,89 and 2017. 1998 When I got rid of it it had 270,000 miles on the 4.6, still ran like a dream just body was getting rough. 2007 was over 200,000 on a 5.4. 2010 had 250,000 on a 5.4. I had really good luck with the 5.4 just do cam phasers and timing set around 175,000. 2017 I have 120,000 on a 6.2. Really like this truck, other than gas mileage. 

1
Oldschool
Posts
1558
Joined
8/29/2006
Location
USA
3/28/2024 9:50pm

I ran a F250 , and an F150 run into

The ground and then scrapped them20220828 102330 0...

 But these days...every dollar counts..

Nissan for my tow vehicles 

and Hyundai for my econo $hitbox run around stuff...

Toyota is the best but out of my price range.

 

2
CRFracer117
Posts
541
Joined
12/4/2007
Location
Beaumont, TX, USA
3/29/2024 4:21am

Sorry I’d avoid the new tundra, and that’s coming from some one who drove just Toyotas only.  The fit and finish and the stories I hear from the techs at the dealer was enough for me to say no.  

fourfourone
Posts
3046
Joined
10/14/2017
Location
86oh, CT, USA
3/29/2024 4:47am
Kyle978 wrote:
Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives.  I've managed fleets with as many as 50...

Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives. 

I've managed fleets with as many as 50 trucks used daily for various services in the West Texas oil fields. We've had trucks from Chevy, Ford, Dodge/Ram and Toyota. All of them have their pros and cons. All of them have issues at some point. 

Personally, I've had 5 new GMC/Chevy pickups in the last 12 years and have 1 year down with my Raptor (first Ford I've owned). Have not had a single issue with any of my trucks. 

You can find nightmares and success stories with every truck. There are a lot of variables. 

But how many miles have you put on all of these trucks you have owned? Looks like you buy a new truck every 2ish years. Much less probability of having issues if you get rid of your trucks every 2 years...Even most vehicles rated with poor reliability can make it a few years trouble free. 

4
1
Brad460
Posts
4469
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI, USA
Fantasy
3/29/2024 5:15am

Late to the game here, but as a former F150 owner and then long time Tundra owner- the current Ram 1500 hands down best 1/2 ton out there. One test drive is all it takes…

So no Tundra or Tacoma…

4
4
Yzf916
Posts
735
Joined
10/13/2011
Location
USA
3/29/2024 5:57am Edited Date/Time 3/29/2024 6:21am

Gonna be hard not to buy another Nissan Frontier. My current 2010 has over 330,000 miles now. And perfect Moto hauler. Can load two bikes, tailgate down. And fit in my garage completely loaded the night before a ride. Love the look of the new Chevy Colorado Trail Boss. And may consider after some long term reviews come in. 

3
Yzf916
Posts
735
Joined
10/13/2011
Location
USA
3/29/2024 5:59am

IMG 6308 1

3
Yzf916
Posts
735
Joined
10/13/2011
Location
USA
3/29/2024 6:00am

IMG 9821

2
Yzf916
Posts
735
Joined
10/13/2011
Location
USA
3/29/2024 6:00am

IMG 3286 0

1
FGR01
Posts
6116
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
Fantasy
3/29/2024 7:49am

As stated above, yeah if you buy a new truck every 2-3 years longevity and durability are not in the equation and you can't really speak to it.   You're never owning a truck out of warranty so that's not a a factor at all.   If you're going to buy a new truck every 2-3 like that, since longevity is not in the decision, just get whatever truck has the best features or looks you like.

On that same note, my decision to have a Tundra and keep it 20 years is influenced by living in AZ and the fact that rust is not a consideration.  If I lived in the salt-belt I'd probably change out trucks more often since any truck will be rotted to the ground long before it wears out.

2
1
TaxpayerTroy
Posts
42
Joined
3/15/2024
Location
Bozeman, MT, USA
3/29/2024 9:47am

IMG 5022 02017 Chevy Colorado, 2 inch level kit with BFG KO2 tires. Truck can carry 3 bikes max and has been super reliable. I know tundras/tacomas are super reliable but I just like American trucks! My truck just hit 100k miles and feels like it can go another 100 easy

4
Radical
Posts
2888
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
3/29/2024 10:37am
Magoofan wrote:

Turbo'd motors in a full size truck (not talking diesels).... or really any vehicle.   No freaking thanks.     

Supporting the UAW....pass.

I'd say Tacoma. 

 

Motoxdoc wrote:
Why the hell wouldn’t you support the UAW’s?  You say that like you’re proud. With the climate in this country these days, I would be embarrassed...

Why the hell wouldn’t you support the UAW’s?  You say that like you’re proud. With the climate in this country these days, I would be embarrassed to diss an American staple.  I guess you’re one of those people that think Romney was right in wanting to kick that industry to the curb. Go Japan!

As said earlier, American cars aren't fully made in the U.S.  We're in a global economy, and American vehicles aren't only sold in the U.S., so it's fair that some of the jobs are in the other countries the vehicles are sold in.  Ford Rangers from 1993 - 2011 use Mazda transmissions.  Half the bolts on it are metric, and I imagine many parts are sourced internationally.  As a matter of fact, my metric sockets are all that I need to fix just about anything on the Ranger.  And the sockets fit.  They're not loose.

My issue with unions is when they get too greedy, and also make it impossible to get rid of bad employees.  It's bad for everyone, and can cause the demise of the companies they work for.  They once were very much needed, but today, not so much.

For the record, over the years I've bought both American and foreign vehicles.  I currently have a 350z and an older Ranger.

The older Rangers, with the 4.0L are awesome, especially the 4 door!  Good power, decent gas mileage, and very robust.  I got 324k miles out of my 1993 and would've gotten much more, but I blew a freeze plug instantaneously, and the coolant drained out so fast, that the temp gauge never went to hot.  My current Ranger is rock solid.

I like the look of the new Tundras.  It seems I may be the only one.  I've also looked at Tacomas for a long while, but the new Rangers look pretty awesome too!  For what I use them for, I simply don't need a big truck.  My Datsun pickups, Chevy Luvs were actually the right size.  The older Tacomas, 2 generations ago, are about the same size.  That's all I really need.

The Rangers are a good compromise in size, especially with the 4 door.

I like the size of the Maverick, but something about unibody in a truck just doesn't cut it for me. 

I'm going to stick with my Ranger for a few more years, then re-evaluate.  We'll see what the new $20k Toyota has to offer.

1
1
Kyle978
Posts
1712
Joined
10/7/2013
Location
Dirt, NM, USA
3/29/2024 1:12pm
Kyle978 wrote:
Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives.  I've managed fleets with as many as 50...

Idk what's more annoying...a dude overly loyal to his sports team or the brand of truck he drives. 

I've managed fleets with as many as 50 trucks used daily for various services in the West Texas oil fields. We've had trucks from Chevy, Ford, Dodge/Ram and Toyota. All of them have their pros and cons. All of them have issues at some point. 

Personally, I've had 5 new GMC/Chevy pickups in the last 12 years and have 1 year down with my Raptor (first Ford I've owned). Have not had a single issue with any of my trucks. 

You can find nightmares and success stories with every truck. There are a lot of variables. 

But how many miles have you put on all of these trucks you have owned? Looks like you buy a new truck every 2ish years. Much...

But how many miles have you put on all of these trucks you have owned? Looks like you buy a new truck every 2ish years. Much less probability of having issues if you get rid of your trucks every 2 years...Even most vehicles rated with poor reliability can make it a few years trouble free. 

I got those trucks up to 60-100k, sitting at 20k on my Raptor. 
 

I agree that isn’t a fair indication of the full life of the vehicle. However now days a fair amount of vehicles have issues at low mileage. We’ve had a handful of Ford turbos (diesel and gas motors) go bad before 20k miles. Tranny went bad on a Ford 1/2 ton at 7k. Chevy front ends rattle apart at 60-80k.
 

Trucks aren’t built to last IMO. That’s why I replace them frequently. 

1

Post a reply to: Toyota Tundra -or- Toyota Tacoma -or- Ford F150?

The Latest