David and Goliath, Stark and KTM

SinbadTheRider
Posts
6
Joined
1/17/2024
Location
Marseilles, IL, USA

I'm writing some words here because I don't want to copy paste the whole thing to a forum post 🫠

https://open.substack.com/pub/sinbadtherider/p/david-and-goliath-stark-…

 

Poll

wack?

Choices
2
17
|
vdrsnk04
Posts
2355
Joined
9/5/2018
Location
USA
1/17/2024 4:22pm

Uhhh that was something anyway.

we went from Purdue Pharma opioids to KTM and kyb followed by stark. 

2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/17/2024 4:59pm

5 years from now, Stark will be in the trash bin of history. 

 

13
24
Titan1
Posts
9482
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
1/17/2024 5:29pm

You lost me at “Today we are talking about the pinnacle of the existing sport of motocross, Stark Future.”

They haven’t even delivered a thousand bikes…and you call them the pinnacle of motocross?  Ha!

20
1/17/2024 5:29pm

Seems like a ploy to direct traffic to your story...

11

The Shop

JM485
Posts
5826
Joined
10/1/2013
Location
Davis, CA, USA
1/17/2024 6:28pm
Magoofan wrote:

5 years from now, Stark will be in the trash bin of history. 

 

Care to place a wager on that?

4
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/17/2024 9:17pm

Seems like a ploy to direct traffic to your story...

Yup.  Did not click

 

1
2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/17/2024 9:26pm

From Non-moto...  Grinning

 

Electric Shit

11
12
OW38B
Posts
3619
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Coto de Caza, CA, USA
1/17/2024 9:37pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2024 9:39pm

Is there a point to this that I'm missing?

Maybe you could summarize and make it more forum concise.

 

RACING
Posts
1996
Joined
6/9/2023
Location
Waddafeuque, FR
1/17/2024 11:04pm
Titan1 wrote:
You lost me at “Today we are talking about the pinnacle of the existing sport of motocross, Stark Future.” They haven’t even delivered a thousand bikes…and...

You lost me at “Today we are talking about the pinnacle of the existing sport of motocross, Stark Future.”

They haven’t even delivered a thousand bikes…and you call them the pinnacle of motocross?  Ha!

Anton said it's the best motocross bike in the world and he can't prove it just because all the OEMS are lobbying against him so he can't race since they're trembling in fear and I know it's the truth 'cause it's Beagle who told me.

 

1
3
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
1/18/2024 12:11am Edited Date/Time 1/18/2024 12:17am
RACING wrote:
Anton said it's the best motocross bike in the world and he can't prove it just because all the OEMS are lobbying against him so he...

Anton said it's the best motocross bike in the world and he can't prove it just because all the OEMS are lobbying against him so he can't race since they're trembling in fear and I know it's the truth 'cause it's Beagle who told me.

 

To play devil's advocate and bearing in mind that anyone who knows me is aware of, and likely bored to death by, my dislike of battery vehicles, besides kids toys and golf carts.... 

Stark have only lined up in two stadiums against the major manufacturers offerings... Once they were sent home (endurocross) and once they won (UK Arenacross).

"Endurocross doesn't count."

"UK Arenacross is a pitbike track."

Those are the usual comebacks and I totally agree neither is a true test of the outright big-show AMA Supercross capability of the bike... But to me it would give some merit to people speaking in Starks favour if, if I was unbiased... 

5
2
Beagle
Posts
1948
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse, FR
1/18/2024 2:07am

See racing, now you're starting to make sense bro Silly

Seriously though, sure, I want to see Stark race, I want to see what they are capable of against the best, why not? Stark wants to show if they can live up to the hype, some federations have already agreed to let them race, some others are still waiting, fine.

Racing (not you, real racing Tongue) should do the talking, if electrics are shit so be it, let them get ridiculed and forgotten, if they're good enough to compete that's great, more choice for us, if they're too good for the competition sure make them race in their own class, the option to have faster bikes could only be good news no?

I'm excited to see Stark racing in UK, France, Australia, Spain and so on, just like I'm excited to see Ducati entering the sport in Italy with possible MXGP wildcards very soon.

I love fast bikes.

3
2
1/18/2024 3:37am
Magoofan wrote:

5 years from now, Stark will be in the trash bin of history. 

 

JM485 wrote:

Care to place a wager on that?

Good chance they will if they can’t continue to fund their burn rate. Will take a long, long time to turn a profit. 

1
2
Silas444
Posts
653
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
Mid-state, ME, USA
1/18/2024 5:45am Edited Date/Time 1/18/2024 5:49am
Magoofan wrote:

5 years from now, Stark will be in the trash bin of history. 

 

JM485 wrote:

Care to place a wager on that?

Good chance they will if they can’t continue to fund their burn rate. Will take a long, long time to turn a profit. 

They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked. And Stark took that 50 mil to fund an enormous, state-of-the-art production facility, as they had no idea the demand for the Varg would be what it is.

So you and Magoofan and whoever else can hold your breath waiting for them to go belly-up if you want to, just be prepared to hold that breath long past the point of discomfort. After all, what none of us know - including all the OEMs - is what Stark is secretly developing now.

I think maybe I'll play my broken record again. After all, it's been a while. So here goes: for any of you who loathe the idea of electric motocross bikes and hope they somehow all go away: this is the calm before the storm. This is the time when you still ruled the kingdom. This is the time when your opinion still had relevance. So cherish this time.

5
8
1/18/2024 6:03am

If electric catches on and the big players develop a bike for competition Stark will not keep up with those companies.  If given a choice to purchase an electric bike made by Honda or one made by Stark who do you think the vast majority of people are going to pick? What about Yamaha, KTM, Kawasaki, etc.. They are doing well for now because there is no other competition.  If/ when the big hitters get involved that company folds like a cheap lawn chair. 

3
1/18/2024 6:19am
JM485 wrote:

Care to place a wager on that?

Good chance they will if they can’t continue to fund their burn rate. Will take a long, long time to turn a profit. 

Silas444 wrote:
They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if...

They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked. And Stark took that 50 mil to fund an enormous, state-of-the-art production facility, as they had no idea the demand for the Varg would be what it is.

So you and Magoofan and whoever else can hold your breath waiting for them to go belly-up if you want to, just be prepared to hold that breath long past the point of discomfort. After all, what none of us know - including all the OEMs - is what Stark is secretly developing now.

I think maybe I'll play my broken record again. After all, it's been a while. So here goes: for any of you who loathe the idea of electric motocross bikes and hope they somehow all go away: this is the calm before the storm. This is the time when you still ruled the kingdom. This is the time when your opinion still had relevance. So cherish this time.

😂😂😂😂😂you can play your broken record all you want. They are a start up. Their risk of failure is high. I’ve been involved in enough well funded start ups that went tits up to understand that. 
You seem awfully defensive and it sounds like you’re assuming “I loathe” the idea of an electric offroad bike. You really need to get a grip pal and get off the Stark nut hugger train and face some reality. It’s like you have some kind of complex that everyone is out to get you and Stark. 

2
7
1/18/2024 6:35am

And also with Eicher taking a board seat and a 10% stake the chances are Stark will become an electric scooter/MC company and not concentrate on offroad platforms in a niche market. A lot of hedging on Electric being the future and having reliable infrastructure to support it. Still lots of risk. 

1
2
Alarmist101
Posts
49
Joined
1/14/2023
Location
Cortez, CO, USA
1/18/2024 6:47am
Magoofan wrote:
From Non-moto...    

From Non-moto...  Grinning

 

Electric Shit

FB IMG 1702844436940

7
3
Beagle
Posts
1948
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse, FR
1/18/2024 6:53am
And also with Eicher taking a board seat and a 10% stake the chances are Stark will become an electric scooter/MC company and not concentrate on...

And also with Eicher taking a board seat and a 10% stake the chances are Stark will become an electric scooter/MC company and not concentrate on offroad platforms in a niche market. A lot of hedging on Electric being the future and having reliable infrastructure to support it. Still lots of risk. 

Of course it's a lot of risk, another reason why I'm rooting for start-up Davids against industry giants Goliaths, it takes balls and a lot of work to do what they do.

Yeah it's no secret there is little money to be made in MX, 80 000 bikes a year is such a niche market, of course eventually they want to go towards road-homologated bikes to expand their customer base.

Starting with MX makes sense though because with the current tech it's probably the only market where electrics can be truly competitive in professional racing. Also because for off-road, compared to road bikes, there are much more obvious advantages to have a quiet bike. And because the founders love MX and know the market well (they previously founded 24MX, the largest MX online store in Europe).

2
2
1/18/2024 7:01am
And also with Eicher taking a board seat and a 10% stake the chances are Stark will become an electric scooter/MC company and not concentrate on...

And also with Eicher taking a board seat and a 10% stake the chances are Stark will become an electric scooter/MC company and not concentrate on offroad platforms in a niche market. A lot of hedging on Electric being the future and having reliable infrastructure to support it. Still lots of risk. 

Beagle wrote:
Of course it's a lot of risk, another reason why I'm rooting for start-up Davids against industry giants Goliaths, it takes balls and a lot of...

Of course it's a lot of risk, another reason why I'm rooting for start-up Davids against industry giants Goliaths, it takes balls and a lot of work to do what they do.

Yeah it's no secret there is little money to be made in MX, 80 000 bikes a year is such a niche market, of course eventually they want to go towards road-homologated bikes to expand their customer base.

Starting with MX makes sense though because with the current tech it's probably the only market where electrics can be truly competitive in professional racing. Also because for off-road, compared to road bikes, there are much more obvious advantages to have a quiet bike. And because the founders love MX and know the market well (they previously founded 24MX, the largest MX online store in Europe).

It’s just Anton, I didn’t think Stefan and Daniel were involved. 

1
2
Titan1
Posts
9482
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
1/18/2024 7:22am Edited Date/Time 1/18/2024 7:26am
JM485 wrote:

Care to place a wager on that?

Good chance they will if they can’t continue to fund their burn rate. Will take a long, long time to turn a profit. 

Silas444 wrote:
They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if...

They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked. And Stark took that 50 mil to fund an enormous, state-of-the-art production facility, as they had no idea the demand for the Varg would be what it is.

So you and Magoofan and whoever else can hold your breath waiting for them to go belly-up if you want to, just be prepared to hold that breath long past the point of discomfort. After all, what none of us know - including all the OEMs - is what Stark is secretly developing now.

I think maybe I'll play my broken record again. After all, it's been a while. So here goes: for any of you who loathe the idea of electric motocross bikes and hope they somehow all go away: this is the calm before the storm. This is the time when you still ruled the kingdom. This is the time when your opinion still had relevance. So cherish this time.

“They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked.”

 

How do you know they “would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked”?  Have they said that publicly?  Or do you have insider knowledge?

1
1
Silas444
Posts
653
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
Mid-state, ME, USA
1/18/2024 7:24am Edited Date/Time 1/18/2024 7:27am
If electric catches on and the big players develop a bike for competition Stark will not keep up with those companies.  If given a choice to...

If electric catches on and the big players develop a bike for competition Stark will not keep up with those companies.  If given a choice to purchase an electric bike made by Honda or one made by Stark who do you think the vast majority of people are going to pick? What about Yamaha, KTM, Kawasaki, etc.. They are doing well for now because there is no other competition.  If/ when the big hitters get involved that company folds like a cheap lawn chair. 

Ever heard of Tesla? They came from nowhere, and now have a market cap bigger than G.M., Ford, and Stellantis (owner of Dodge) combined. I could go on. Microsoft versus IBM, Apple versus Microsoft, K-Mart versus Target, Nike versus Converse. Power has no guarantee of permanence, not for anyone or anything.

My guess is, Stark is now very close to unveiling an 85cc/112cc equivalent bike. When they do that, they will be well on their way to creating a loyalty to their brand. If you're young, whatever seems established also often seems stale, so opportunity knocks for Stark, and I doubt they'll be sheepish about kicking down that door. They're being trifled with by those who wield the power, and indignation makes an excellent fuel for ambition.

The future belongs to those willing to seize upon it and bend it to their will without a moment's concern regarding tradition.

As it should.

2
5
Silas444
Posts
653
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
Mid-state, ME, USA
1/18/2024 7:25am
Titan1 wrote:
“They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if...

“They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked.”

 

How do you know they “would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked”?  Have they said that publicly?  Or do you have insider knowledge?

It was public knowledge, yes.

4
Titan1
Posts
9482
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
1/18/2024 7:26am
Titan1 wrote:
“They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if...

“They sold 10% of the company for 50 million to an entity that has enormous cash value and would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked.”

 

How do you know they “would gladly acquire a greater ownership stake if asked”?  Have they said that publicly?  Or do you have insider knowledge?

Silas444 wrote:

It was public knowledge, yes.

Public knowledge that would gladly take more equity?

Silas444
Posts
653
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
Mid-state, ME, USA
1/18/2024 7:32am
Titan1 wrote:

Public knowledge that would gladly take more equity?

That's a fair point. It was stated between the lines in an interview with Anton Weiss. He did not state it explicitly. At least, not to my best recollection.

Just so I know - do I need a lawyer?

 

2
3
Titan1
Posts
9482
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
1/18/2024 7:37am
Titan1 wrote:

Public knowledge that would gladly take more equity?

Silas444 wrote:
That's a fair point. It was stated between the lines in an interview with Anton Weiss. He did not state it explicitly. At least, not to...

That's a fair point. It was stated between the lines in an interview with Anton Weiss. He did not state it explicitly. At least, not to my best recollection.

Just so I know - do I need a lawyer?

 

No…it was just a bold claim, and one I hadn’t heard…that’s why I was asking if it was speculation on your part, or if they’d stated it publicly…

Also, having it implied by Anton is less credible than if it was implied by someone at Eichers.  Anton is obviously and understandably biased on the issue.

1
Silas444
Posts
653
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
Mid-state, ME, USA
1/18/2024 7:43am
😂😂😂😂😂you can play your broken record all you want. They are a start up. Their risk of failure is high. I’ve been involved in enough well...

😂😂😂😂😂you can play your broken record all you want. They are a start up. Their risk of failure is high. I’ve been involved in enough well funded start ups that went tits up to understand that. 
You seem awfully defensive and it sounds like you’re assuming “I loathe” the idea of an electric offroad bike. You really need to get a grip pal and get off the Stark nut hugger train and face some reality. It’s like you have some kind of complex that everyone is out to get you and Stark. 

You've got less than a dozen posts, Hoss, so take a breath and take a number. I've pooped bigger men than you.

If you've been around more than a couple start-ups that went tits-up, maybe it's time to start making better choices?

Regarding my "grip" - as I've stated before, my only dog in this hunt is a little kid who deserves a chance at falling in love with motocross and having it change his life for the better - like it did mine way back when. And unless you've got your head where something else should be, you know electric gives that kid the best shot, because it's what will allow the sport to live on despite the world's rather upside-down priorities. 

Stark has earned my support by taking all these slings and arrows and persevering. I admire them for having blazed a difficult path, a path that all of us will benefit from in the future. I hug no one's nut.

3
5
Silas444
Posts
653
Joined
5/23/2015
Location
Mid-state, ME, USA
1/18/2024 7:44am
Titan1 wrote:
No…it was just a bold claim, and one I hadn’t heard…that’s why I was asking if it was speculation on your part, or if they’d stated...

No…it was just a bold claim, and one I hadn’t heard…that’s why I was asking if it was speculation on your part, or if they’d stated it publicly…

Also, having it implied by Anton is less credible than if it was implied by someone at Eichers.  Anton is obviously and understandably biased on the issue.

Well said.

1
Beagle
Posts
1948
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse, FR
1/18/2024 7:47am Edited Date/Time 1/18/2024 7:49am

It’s just Anton, I didn’t think Stefan and Daniel were involved. 

My bad you're right, Wass is the only one from 24MX founders involved in Stark Future, whose co-founder is Paul Soucy.

2
1/18/2024 7:55am
😂😂😂😂😂you can play your broken record all you want. They are a start up. Their risk of failure is high. I’ve been involved in enough well...

😂😂😂😂😂you can play your broken record all you want. They are a start up. Their risk of failure is high. I’ve been involved in enough well funded start ups that went tits up to understand that. 
You seem awfully defensive and it sounds like you’re assuming “I loathe” the idea of an electric offroad bike. You really need to get a grip pal and get off the Stark nut hugger train and face some reality. It’s like you have some kind of complex that everyone is out to get you and Stark. 

Silas444 wrote:
You've got less than a dozen posts, Hoss, so take a breath and take a number. I've pooped bigger men than you. If you've been around...

You've got less than a dozen posts, Hoss, so take a breath and take a number. I've pooped bigger men than you.

If you've been around more than a couple start-ups that went tits-up, maybe it's time to start making better choices?

Regarding my "grip" - as I've stated before, my only dog in this hunt is a little kid who deserves a chance at falling in love with motocross and having it change his life for the better - like it did mine way back when. And unless you've got your head where something else should be, you know electric gives that kid the best shot, because it's what will allow the sport to live on despite the world's rather upside-down priorities. 

Stark has earned my support by taking all these slings and arrows and persevering. I admire them for having blazed a difficult path, a path that all of us will benefit from in the future. I hug no one's nut.

You’re first paragraph speaks volumes. 
You’re emotional investment also speaks volumes. 
Hard to take you serious after that. 
90% of start ups fail, if you’ve been around long enough in that type of business it’s expected you’ll be part of a few. Even Anton is gonna tell you that Hoss. Keep on shitting out men pal, I’m sure you’re a real Billy Bad ass. 

2
Hollywood009
Posts
477
Joined
10/13/2020
Location
Dallas, TX, USA
1/18/2024 8:18am

There is no doubt that the industry is going electric... Sooner then later Stark will have competition from KTM, Honda, Yamaha, and all the other manufactures.  Those other manufactures already have dealer networks, logistics, parts suppliers, and customer finance options in place.  The big manufactures could also undercut pricing, sell them at a loss, to gain bigger piece of the market, and it would barely impact their company.  

 

1
1

Post a reply to: David and Goliath, Stark and KTM

The Latest