Opinion on future e-bike racing

Zycki11
Posts
7675
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
10/7/2023 12:30pm
Andrew314 wrote:
The climate change death cult are the most genocidal maniacs we’ve ever encountered. The death count will make Hitler, Mao, and Stalin look like child’s play...

The climate change death cult are the most genocidal maniacs we’ve ever encountered. The death count will make Hitler, Mao, and Stalin look like child’s play. They will kill billions to “save the planet”. This whole move to electric will be the death of everything we love. 

crt32 wrote:

Electric is easier to control aka shut down. I wish people would see that. 

davis224 wrote:
I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I...

I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I can't refine crude oil into gasoline off grid. You're completely dependent on multiple governments for gas.

So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down? Or do you go with the gasoline route?

 

Often I wonder if people forget that they will start charging the crap out of consumers to charge the vehicles. 

3
davis224
Posts
7340
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
10/7/2023 2:18pm
crt32 wrote:

Electric is easier to control aka shut down. I wish people would see that. 

davis224 wrote:
I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I...

I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I can't refine crude oil into gasoline off grid. You're completely dependent on multiple governments for gas.

Zycki11 wrote:
So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down...

So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down? Or do you go with the gasoline route?

 

Often I wonder if people forget that they will start charging the crap out of consumers to charge the vehicles. 

If we're gonna go there, no difference in remotely shutting down a gas powered vehicle than an electric one charged off grid, if "they" have that capability.

1
1
mbw479
Posts
523
Joined
12/5/2021
Location
Daytona, FL US
10/7/2023 2:31pm

I am keen to see how the Stark goes in a combined race. Theres been a lot of claims that most people will be faster on a Stark, it should be easy to tell once they start racing. Lets see if the riders pick up a few positions to where they would normally finish.

1
1
10/7/2023 5:42pm
Itchy858 wrote:
When everyone has to race e-bikes in the near future, how are you going to feel about coming off a nice quiet e race, exhausted, hot...

When everyone has to race e-bikes in the near future, how are you going to feel about coming off a nice quiet e race, exhausted, hot, maybe frustrated about your finish or sore from a crash, to sit in your chair and try to relax before your next moto only to have the sound off hundreds of Fuel powered generators charging bikes and breathing the exhaust of them all crammed together Everywhere around you. Quiet track/race, extremely noisy hard to breathe pits. IMG 8616

What’s your thoughts?

I'll be staying home....

1

The Shop

10/7/2023 5:45pm
You just have a portable battery bank.  Charge at home or Solar etc.  Pretty simple solution besides generators running.    Also, orange extension cord can work...

You just have a portable battery bank. 
Charge at home or Solar etc. 

Pretty simple solution besides generators running. 
 

Also, orange extension cord can work to. 🙃

TeamGreen wrote:
Wait a second? Charging a battery from…A BATTERY! What is this dark-web-trickery you are discussing? 

Wait a second? Charging a battery from…A BATTERY!
What is this dark-web-trickery you are discussing? 

Laughing

I'll be working OT at my fossil fueled power Plant so they can charge all those "green" bikes and cars...

7
1
eddie
Posts
3020
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Bragg Creek, AB CA
10/7/2023 5:59pm
Zycki11 wrote:
Hey kids, look how exciting that bike that sounds like a bee is going around and around. I can’t tell how hard he is on the...

Hey kids, look how exciting that bike that sounds like a bee is going around and around. I can’t tell how hard he is on the throttle because the chain is just as loud but look at him go. How exciting! I’m out when electric tries it’s hand. No longer hearing and feeling the excitement. I like to compare it to listening to music through your phone or through surround sound. 

 

Food for thought. Those dirt bikes are so noisy, we may as well start making all guitars acoustic because electric is damaging the environment by tapping the grids and also noise pollution. 

Way more people listen to music through their phones than surround sound . Just sayin your experience might not be the average . Electric AX would open up the possibility of a lot more venues . 

3
1
Zycki11
Posts
7675
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
10/7/2023 6:35pm
davis224 wrote:
I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I...

I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I can't refine crude oil into gasoline off grid. You're completely dependent on multiple governments for gas.

Zycki11 wrote:
So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down...

So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down? Or do you go with the gasoline route?

 

Often I wonder if people forget that they will start charging the crap out of consumers to charge the vehicles. 

davis224 wrote:
If we're gonna go there, no difference in remotely shutting down a gas powered vehicle than an electric one charged off grid, if "they" have that...

If we're gonna go there, no difference in remotely shutting down a gas powered vehicle than an electric one charged off grid, if "they" have that capability.

Lol got it, you sound very informed.  

2
Zycki11
Posts
7675
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
10/7/2023 6:35pm Edited Date/Time 10/7/2023 6:37pm
Zycki11 wrote:
Hey kids, look how exciting that bike that sounds like a bee is going around and around. I can’t tell how hard he is on the...

Hey kids, look how exciting that bike that sounds like a bee is going around and around. I can’t tell how hard he is on the throttle because the chain is just as loud but look at him go. How exciting! I’m out when electric tries it’s hand. No longer hearing and feeling the excitement. I like to compare it to listening to music through your phone or through surround sound. 

 

Food for thought. Those dirt bikes are so noisy, we may as well start making all guitars acoustic because electric is damaging the environment by tapping the grids and also noise pollution. 

eddie wrote:
Way more people listen to music through their phones than surround sound . Just sayin your experience might not be the average . Electric AX would...

Way more people listen to music through their phones than surround sound . Just sayin your experience might not be the average . Electric AX would open up the possibility of a lot more venues . 

Your missing the entire point. Venues for who? The fan base will not be the same. No kidding more people listen through their phone because it is easier. Doesn’t mean it is better 

1
1
BigRedMachine
Posts
692
Joined
1/29/2023
Location
Grants Pass, OR US
10/7/2023 8:07pm

If Supercross and Motocross go 100% electric, that will OFFICIALLY kill the sport. Nobody's going to pay money to go to a supercross race and listen to a bunch of whining electric engines, while you can hear the God awful slapping of the rear tire against the Whoops. 

5
7
Zycki11
Posts
7675
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
10/8/2023 5:53am
If Supercross and Motocross go 100% electric, that will OFFICIALLY kill the sport. Nobody's going to pay money to go to a supercross race and listen...

If Supercross and Motocross go 100% electric, that will OFFICIALLY kill the sport. Nobody's going to pay money to go to a supercross race and listen to a bunch of whining electric engines, while you can hear the God awful slapping of the rear tire against the Whoops. 

Imagine the sweet sound of a 125 or 250f blitzing whoops and then substitute an electric bike. I bet people will come in droves to see that lol.

I also can’t wait for a bike failure… Ricky can you walk us through what happened? “ those orange yamahas have been fast all year,  but this looks mechanical guys” James “it looks like an electrical failure Ricky, they don’t have engines, tough break he should of tucked the front”

2
bluesmoke
Posts
183
Joined
1/30/2023
Location
Lakeworth, TX US
10/8/2023 6:36am
crt32 wrote:
So every kid will ride the same with e-bike racing? No longer a Kenny or Jett who ride in a higher gear vs a Deegan who...

So every kid will ride the same with e-bike racing? No longer a Kenny or Jett who ride in a higher gear vs a Deegan who revs it to the moon. No more Tomac who abuses a clutch vs a Kenny who never uses a clutch. If E-bike racing takes over kids who spent their younger years at the BMX track are going to dominate, the clutch and shifting are one of the hardest parts of transitioning from a BMX to MX. But the sport will not increase in viewership and attendance will drop. Panic revs, whoops, and 20/40 guys on a start add to the excitement, the racing at times for a spectator is actually really boring. Remove all that and just buzzing and no creativity in riding style and no aftermarket support, ya you can kiss the sport goodbye. And btw that battery will die, it happens to your cell phone, your laptop, and your car battery. And when it does, when what happens, where do you take it, do you drop $7k for another? Electric for motocross is a novelty, and works for certain applications like Stacyc around the house, but long term is not sustainable, and not cost-effective. But it's coming and our sport will be going away, sad truth, I hate it, and will just focus on enjoying the current moments. 

They can bury all the dead batteries with all the dead windmill blades in Sweetwater texas.

3
1
MotoMan12345
Posts
1701
Joined
12/22/2014
Location
Alpine, UT US
10/8/2023 7:55am

Not sure what the issue is..just because theres e-bikes doesnt mean everyone will just buy them..we are a LONG LONG LONG ways away until you see more e-bikes over gas at a track.

3
1
8500rpm
Posts
513
Joined
12/31/2020
Location
SE
10/8/2023 9:26am
Not sure what the issue is..just because theres e-bikes doesnt mean everyone will just buy them..we are a LONG LONG LONG ways away until you see...

Not sure what the issue is..just because theres e-bikes doesnt mean everyone will just buy them..we are a LONG LONG LONG ways away until you see more e-bikes over gas at a track.

Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that.

I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters, I think they like Moto but the grease engine and the motor maintenance might be off-putting. Maybe we start to see more Porsche Taycans pulling e-bikes in the pit in the future?

Maybe we will lose 25% of 'core Moto ppl' but we gain 35% from some other direction?

 

1
2
crt32
Posts
946
Joined
4/20/2015
Location
Oklahoma City, OK US
10/8/2023 1:17pm
8500rpm wrote:
Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that. I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters...

Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that.

I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters, I think they like Moto but the grease engine and the motor maintenance might be off-putting. Maybe we start to see more Porsche Taycans pulling e-bikes in the pit in the future?

Maybe we will lose 25% of 'core Moto ppl' but we gain 35% from some other direction?

 

I highly doubt that, especially when MTB Jimmy gets whisky throttle at 80HP, launches a double at 65 mph and over jumps it by 200 feet. Moto is dangerous and a niche sport and expensive and time consuming. All electric will kill the outdoors and supercross. Want to add another class to the already 30 available fine, but full on replacement will be the end of moto as we currently know it. Thats not doom and gloom, thats just my honest opinion and many others. 

2
3
kapaa10
Posts
363
Joined
5/9/2019
Location
Vista, CA US
10/8/2023 1:39pm

I have a battery bank I built out of bird scooter batteries, Im able to charge my sons ktm ebike and all our buddies bikes(3-4) as many times as I want at the track for 2 days without recharging them.  They fit in a home depot toolbox.  The generator argument is so boring, you dont need one, battery banks are where its at.  This stuff is progressing so quickly in 5 years it wont even be a discussion.  

8
1
Beagle
Posts
1755
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse FR
10/8/2023 1:57pm

I do not understand how we go from "here is the first truly competitive electric dirt bike available to the masses" to "all electric will kill the sport"?

Electric dirt bikes reached the market, if you like it you can buy it, if you don't you can look at it with disdain all day long, no problem.

Now I'm entering the realm of speculations and fantaisies to try to get some logic into this argument. Say one day in 10, 20 or 50 years your government bans ICE dirtbikes. Does anyone seriously think it will have anything to do with a turtleneck-loving CEO? On this hypothetical fateful day, either dirtbikes cease to exist or the sport survives thanks to alternative means of propulsion.

Electric dirtbikes are just another option to have fun on 2 wheels and do not remove anything from anyone.

6
1
10/9/2023 1:43pm
Not sure what the issue is..just because theres e-bikes doesnt mean everyone will just buy them..we are a LONG LONG LONG ways away until you see...

Not sure what the issue is..just because theres e-bikes doesnt mean everyone will just buy them..we are a LONG LONG LONG ways away until you see more e-bikes over gas at a track.

8500rpm wrote:
Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that. I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters...

Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that.

I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters, I think they like Moto but the grease engine and the motor maintenance might be off-putting. Maybe we start to see more Porsche Taycans pulling e-bikes in the pit in the future?

Maybe we will lose 25% of 'core Moto ppl' but we gain 35% from some other direction?

 

I would say that somebody who quits riding over the sound the machine makes is NOT "core".   Sound while riding is only a part of the experience.

I have a hard time believing that many of the people who say they will quit riding, than ride electric  even ride now. 

I've watched SX races without any volume on and they have been exciting still.  For me the noise of the crowd getting excited brings the level of excitement up more than the engine sounds . 

 

1
3
10/9/2023 1:47pm
8500rpm wrote:
Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that. I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters...

Pure guess, like everyone else...but not so sure of that.

I believe there is a lot of money in the MTB crowd and the Sur-ron youngsters, I think they like Moto but the grease engine and the motor maintenance might be off-putting. Maybe we start to see more Porsche Taycans pulling e-bikes in the pit in the future?

Maybe we will lose 25% of 'core Moto ppl' but we gain 35% from some other direction?

 

crt32 wrote:
I highly doubt that, especially when MTB Jimmy gets whisky throttle at 80HP, launches a double at 65 mph and over jumps it by 200 feet...

I highly doubt that, especially when MTB Jimmy gets whisky throttle at 80HP, launches a double at 65 mph and over jumps it by 200 feet. Moto is dangerous and a niche sport and expensive and time consuming. All electric will kill the outdoors and supercross. Want to add another class to the already 30 available fine, but full on replacement will be the end of moto as we currently know it. Thats not doom and gloom, thats just my honest opinion and many others. 

Downhill MTB's are just as dangerous if not more than MX. You can turn the power down on an EMX bike .  Both sports can be as dangerous as You make them. 

3
1
10/9/2023 1:50pm

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

8
Falcon
Posts
12170
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
10/10/2023 9:46am

I don't think e-bikes will be the only option. At least, not any more so than 4-strokes are the "only" option right now. ICE bikes will simply not be competitive enough, and that may happen soon or it may take decades. Either way, you'll ride an e-bike because it's better, or you'll ride an ICE bike because you like it more - just like I prefer 2-strokes. Nobody, not even I, claims that a 250 2-stroke is "better" for Motocross than a 450 these days. 

3
10/10/2023 3:10pm

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging needs. Wanting to go green is not enough. 

4
10/10/2023 4:40pm

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging...

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging needs. Wanting to go green is not enough. 

How about wanting to ride the most powerful, easiest to ride dirt bike?

1
10/10/2023 5:13pm

Just had a crazy idea as I drove by a golf course. Golf courses could build MX tracks around and though the fairways and greens. E-MX Bikes could be ridden and raced just just about every town. There’s already parking, infrastructure for charging (golf carts), bar, restaurants, commercial space for sale of gear/parts (pro shop), water, equipment for maintenance, and just about everything.

 

Of course not every golf course would be on board but maybe a few would. 

2
2
Ob917
Posts
1033
Joined
9/29/2021
Location
Cardiff, CA US
10/10/2023 5:22pm

Have you guys seen the aftermarket performance bicycle parts industry? They don’t have motors either. Seems like it’s rolling along pretty well. 

3
1
10/10/2023 5:35pm

I will never buy a ticket to sx or mx to watch electric bikes. 100 times no for watching on tv. 

3
3
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
10/10/2023 6:05pm Edited Date/Time 10/10/2023 6:05pm

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

That's just the first step.    The end goal is to kill off-roading all together....ya know...desert tortoise, erosion issues and all. 

1
6
Radical
Posts
2820
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA US
10/10/2023 11:12pm
davis224 wrote:
I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I...

I see the argument for that, but few people also consider the fact that you can build your own generator and have electricity off grid. I can't refine crude oil into gasoline off grid. You're completely dependent on multiple governments for gas.

Zycki11 wrote:
So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down...

So how do you get around then? Do you use the electricity you stored to pump it into a new vehicle that they can shut down? Or do you go with the gasoline route?

 

Often I wonder if people forget that they will start charging the crap out of consumers to charge the vehicles. 

davis224 wrote:
If we're gonna go there, no difference in remotely shutting down a gas powered vehicle than an electric one charged off grid, if "they" have that...

If we're gonna go there, no difference in remotely shutting down a gas powered vehicle than an electric one charged off grid, if "they" have that capability.

That capability was just approved by the Biden administration.  It's BS that the government will be able to control your car remotely.

Radical
Posts
2820
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA US
10/10/2023 11:20pm

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging...

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging needs. Wanting to go green is not enough. 

And they aren't green.  I'm not talking about carbon.  I'm talking about the scarcity of rare earth minerals, and the fact that solar panels are very difficult to recycle.

I believe with an all electric future, we would run out of rare earth minerals far before we'd run out of fossil fuels.

To be green, everything needs to be recyclable.

It'll be great when we're no longer depleting resources from one generation to the next, but there's a lot that needs to happen before electric powered vehicles are more sustainable that ICE.

I'll be racing my 125 for a long, long time.  Then we'll see what's available.

Who knows, maybe hydrogen dirt bikes will come around.  And the side effect is that tracks will be automatically watered.

1
10/11/2023 11:13am

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging...

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging needs. Wanting to go green is not enough. 

How about wanting to ride the most powerful, easiest to ride dirt bike?

Absolutely,  I haven't ridden one, but they appear to be pretty awesome by most accounts. The world just isn't ready to go all in yet. 

10/11/2023 11:14am

Unfortunately Electric bikes will be our only option, and not that far out.

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging...

EV bikes and cars taking over will not be as soon as quite a few think. We do not have the infrastucture for supporting the charging needs. Wanting to go green is not enough. 

Radical wrote:
And they aren't green.  I'm not talking about carbon.  I'm talking about the scarcity of rare earth minerals, and the fact that solar panels are very...

And they aren't green.  I'm not talking about carbon.  I'm talking about the scarcity of rare earth minerals, and the fact that solar panels are very difficult to recycle.

I believe with an all electric future, we would run out of rare earth minerals far before we'd run out of fossil fuels.

To be green, everything needs to be recyclable.

It'll be great when we're no longer depleting resources from one generation to the next, but there's a lot that needs to happen before electric powered vehicles are more sustainable that ICE.

I'll be racing my 125 for a long, long time.  Then we'll see what's available.

Who knows, maybe hydrogen dirt bikes will come around.  And the side effect is that tracks will be automatically watered.

I agree completely. 

Post a reply to: Opinion on future e-bike racing

The Latest