MOTUL oil

12/25/2022 8:26am

Most of us are defending our oils based on emotions not facts, I don’t know the facts behind motul, every mechanic/engine guy says motul, that’s why I use it, I had plenty of 250fs torn down for a rebuild when mom and dad were paying for bikes and parts, dad used bel ray and the insides always looked perfect, for what it’s worth. 

3
soggy
Posts
8755
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
UT US
12/25/2022 12:22pm
crusher773 wrote:
Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different...

Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different ones over the years also.  It has made a believer out of me in a short time, enough that I started being a dealer after seeing the results.  It absolutely does not get blown away by Motorex and I have 2 customers that the husband runs Amsoil and the wife ran Motul.  He runs his harder than she does and guess what? Her bike blew up and his is still going strong.  Both were rebuilt at the same time.  Now she is running Amsoil also.  Proof is in the pudding.  I don't try and force it on anyone but it's good stuff and a company that is very focused on putting quality stuff out there.

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

5
1
bingerfang
Posts
59
Joined
1/24/2019
Location
La Habra, CA US
12/25/2022 3:09pm
soggy wrote:

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

Exactly, lol. 

12/25/2022 3:31pm

Widely regarded as the most advanced and highest performing motorcycle engine oil available today the Motul 7100 line of oils uses the same lubrication technology derived from technical partnerships with racing teams both on and off-road.

100% Synthetic Ester based motorcycle lubricant for high-performance, sport, off-road, endure, and trial bikes fitted with 4-stroke engines, integrated or non-integrated gearbox, wet or dry clutch.

Use of 100% Synthetic Ester material with anti-wear additives results in improved shear resistance for increased gear protection and engine reliability.

Compatible with modern emission regulation technology including exhaust gas after treatment systems such as catalytic converters and air injection into the exhaust pipe.

Features & details

Meets the following standards: API SL/SH/SG and JASO MA

Recommended for all 4-stroke motorcycles with catalytic converters

Ester technology improves engine response

Proprietary extreme pressure formula to protect the gearbox

Low sulfur and phosphorus formula for bikes fitted with catalytic converters

 Oil group information: https://www.machinerylubrication.com/Read/29113/base-oil-groups

The Shop

Tonynz
Posts
847
Joined
9/21/2014
Location
NZ
12/25/2022 3:43pm

Stocked up this morning

 

2
1
captmoto
Posts
5866
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA US
12/25/2022 4:25pm Edited Date/Time 12/25/2022 4:27pm
Most of us are defending our oils based on emotions not facts, I don’t know the facts behind motul, every mechanic/engine guy says motul, that’s why...

Most of us are defending our oils based on emotions not facts, I don’t know the facts behind motul, every mechanic/engine guy says motul, that’s why I use it, I had plenty of 250fs torn down for a rebuild when mom and dad were paying for bikes and parts, dad used bel ray and the insides always looked perfect, for what it’s worth. 

Probably had as much to do with oil change interval as anything else.

Having said that, I have a friend with a KTM 450SX that swears by Amsoil. He isn't anal about his service intervals but he stays on it. He sent his motor our for a teardown and rebuild at 140 or so hours. The mechanic called and asked him if he was sure it had never been worked on because the insides looked immaculate. Piston and rings were in spec. 

Take it for what it's worth.

 

2
2
12/25/2022 6:25pm
Amsoil base stock at one time was Mobil1. There are a few quality American brands mentioned in this thread. Take John Klotz. First to develop 2...

Amsoil base stock at one time was Mobil1.

There are a few quality American brands mentioned in this thread.

Take John Klotz. First to develop 2 stroke synthetic in the early 1960s.

Born and bred American brand. Sponsored Indycars to the winners circle, moto and SX. Sizzler Noleen Yamahas.  Jet Ski racers.  Offshore, F1 Champ and Outboard Drag boats.

Klotz is a go to brand. We tested our OEM blends against many of their products when we were blending oils.

 

remote image

remote image

remote image

remote image

remote image

When my son was racing, we had Redline Oils as a sponsor. One of the trade offs was that we were asked to send in the old oils for analysis with hours logged. We used everything from suspension fluids, motor oils, trans and even the oil/trans and differential fluids in my truck. 
 

Since Redline hadn’t been brought up yet, I’m curious if you have any experience with them. They sponsor all forms of racing and it is fairly expensive to buy. 
I’ve switched to Maxima, with the exception of motorex as my premix and have been very happy with it. 

1
MX558
Posts
1976
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
12/25/2022 8:13pm

I ran motorex in my 22ktm , it shifted very hard and notchy. I switched to the Motul and it shifts way better now 

2
2
12/26/2022 2:56am

ive only ever run motul trans and motul 800 in my yz 125, i bought it new in 2003 and lost count of the hours id raced on it after 2005, still goin strong on it now, i break it down every year and it always looks great, apart from bearings, its only ever had a outer clutch basket in the bottom from new, the down side is its mega expensive compared to other mx oils that are in most shops here like putoline, silkolene etc    

1
bigsal
Posts
301
Joined
6/21/2017
Location
CO US
12/26/2022 11:40am

 I have found Motul products are a step above most any other oil I have used or seen across the board 2T or 4T. As a rider/racer/ engine builder I was happy with my brand years ago...however when I would get full race engines in for service etc and they were at new spec's and had a coating of lube as slick as syrup it was Motul 8002T the owners were using, when I switched I noticed my bike was a blip or two on the throttle from being clean and ready to rip when you start in staging to the gate (30 pro, 40 ex, 50 ex now 60+). when I service /build 4T race engines (GSXR750 etc..) they were perfect inside with Motul as well. Other oils may work as well but Motul always works for me 

2
crusher773
Posts
2017
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Coweta, OK US
12/26/2022 12:45pm
crusher773 wrote:
Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different...

Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different ones over the years also.  It has made a believer out of me in a short time, enough that I started being a dealer after seeing the results.  It absolutely does not get blown away by Motorex and I have 2 customers that the husband runs Amsoil and the wife ran Motul.  He runs his harder than she does and guess what? Her bike blew up and his is still going strong.  Both were rebuilt at the same time.  Now she is running Amsoil also.  Proof is in the pudding.  I don't try and force it on anyone but it's good stuff and a company that is very focused on putting quality stuff out there.

soggy wrote:

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes sense.

1
2
12/28/2022 5:29pm
crusher773 wrote:
Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different...

Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different ones over the years also.  It has made a believer out of me in a short time, enough that I started being a dealer after seeing the results.  It absolutely does not get blown away by Motorex and I have 2 customers that the husband runs Amsoil and the wife ran Motul.  He runs his harder than she does and guess what? Her bike blew up and his is still going strong.  Both were rebuilt at the same time.  Now she is running Amsoil also.  Proof is in the pudding.  I don't try and force it on anyone but it's good stuff and a company that is very focused on putting quality stuff out there.

soggy wrote:

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

crusher773 wrote:
So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes...

So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes sense.

We purposely ran ATF, Gear Oil, and 2 stroke oils in 4 stroke crankcases, and also ATF, Gear Oil, and regular car oil in small 2 strokes.

Believe it or not, it is almost impossible to blame an engine failure on oil. While not ideal, and some surely stink, engines are pretty tough.

Keep this in mind. back in the early days, 2 strokes used basically 30 wt car oil.

4 stroke Speedway bikes run Castrol R30 or R40(or similar oils like Klotz or Blendzall castor oils) just the same as a 2 stroke does. That's why methanol speedway bikes smell so good.

 

soggy
Posts
8755
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
UT US
12/28/2022 5:33pm
crusher773 wrote:
Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different...

Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different ones over the years also.  It has made a believer out of me in a short time, enough that I started being a dealer after seeing the results.  It absolutely does not get blown away by Motorex and I have 2 customers that the husband runs Amsoil and the wife ran Motul.  He runs his harder than she does and guess what? Her bike blew up and his is still going strong.  Both were rebuilt at the same time.  Now she is running Amsoil also.  Proof is in the pudding.  I don't try and force it on anyone but it's good stuff and a company that is very focused on putting quality stuff out there.

soggy wrote:

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

crusher773 wrote:
So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes...

So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes sense.

The anecdote you provided was about two dirtbikes. 

1
1
12/28/2022 5:47pm Edited Date/Time 12/28/2022 5:54pm
Amsoil base stock at one time was Mobil1. There are a few quality American brands mentioned in this thread. Take John Klotz. First to develop 2...

Amsoil base stock at one time was Mobil1.

There are a few quality American brands mentioned in this thread.

Take John Klotz. First to develop 2 stroke synthetic in the early 1960s.

Born and bred American brand. Sponsored Indycars to the winners circle, moto and SX. Sizzler Noleen Yamahas.  Jet Ski racers.  Offshore, F1 Champ and Outboard Drag boats.

Klotz is a go to brand. We tested our OEM blends against many of their products when we were blending oils.

 

remote image

remote image

remote image

remote image

remote image

Langhammx wrote:
When my son was racing, we had Redline Oils as a sponsor. One of the trade offs was that we were asked to send in the...

When my son was racing, we had Redline Oils as a sponsor. One of the trade offs was that we were asked to send in the old oils for analysis with hours logged. We used everything from suspension fluids, motor oils, trans and even the oil/trans and differential fluids in my truck. 
 

Since Redline hadn’t been brought up yet, I’m curious if you have any experience with them. They sponsor all forms of racing and it is fairly expensive to buy. 
I’ve switched to Maxima, with the exception of motorex as my premix and have been very happy with it. 

Other than the various car oils( all good stuff) the only 2 we looked at when blending oils for some OEMs was their Allsport(or something like that) and the watercraft oil.  Both robust oils.

Now before people say boat oil bla bla bla, the most stressed 2 stroke engines are high revving shifter karts(pick any cc class) and 9-14,000 RPM race outboards, mostly the Offshore guys or the F1 Champ boat kind. WFO for very long times and the Super Stock 2.5s run at 9,000.....save for the Unlimited Outboard Drags running up to 14K. A failure can be 20-30 grand. 50 grand for billet powerheads.

I can say Redline has a huge faithful crowd in Karting and those same race boats. Same for Klotz(probably the most popular, and Motul in their also.)

I would have loved to get some labs done on their racing oil, but from how many run it with good success, it has to be good.  Tons swear by it.

 

 

 

 

2
1
12/28/2022 8:02pm
Langhammx wrote:
When my son was racing, we had Redline Oils as a sponsor. One of the trade offs was that we were asked to send in the...

When my son was racing, we had Redline Oils as a sponsor. One of the trade offs was that we were asked to send in the old oils for analysis with hours logged. We used everything from suspension fluids, motor oils, trans and even the oil/trans and differential fluids in my truck. 
 

Since Redline hadn’t been brought up yet, I’m curious if you have any experience with them. They sponsor all forms of racing and it is fairly expensive to buy. 
I’ve switched to Maxima, with the exception of motorex as my premix and have been very happy with it. 

So your post got me to thinking....

Redline MSDS sheets now refer to Phillip's 66. They did not show that way back.  That would make me think prior they were getting their base oils and add packs from them. 

Old schoolers will remember the 3 blends of Trick Racing Gas. That was Phillip's 66 B series fuels.

Phillip's is quality, especially anything coming out of the Borger facility(Av Gas etc.)

Most know that Yamalube is or was many years ago a Citgo blended product and also the same as Citgo Sea and Snow or labeled Mystik, Citgos retail brand. 

Also, many years ago(up until about 5 or so and probably still), Maxima 927 MSDS sheet was virtually identical to Castrol A747 with almost identical % amounts of Castor etc. It also looked and smelled identical.

Esso blended Euro Yamalube for that market years ago. Maybe still.

Non refinery brands buy their stuff from someone and maybe blend in additional additives etc.. If Redline was sourcing Phillps 66 all these years, that explains why it's got such a good following.

Another thing I noted was their racing oil and Kart oil is advertised as the same chemistry with a different label. If it can keep screaming shifter karts and strung out 2 stroke outboards lubed in the 9,000 RPM and up range (that is stock RPM for a 2.5 Drag or S3000 F1 stock class champ boat) it's good stuff.  And knowing Phillip's products for 40+ years and way longer with fuels(they supplied AvGas to many race fuel companies way back) I'd run it.  All those racers can't be wrong.  

3
12/28/2022 8:54pm
So your post got me to thinking.... Redline MSDS sheets now refer to Phillip's 66. They did not show that way back.  That would make me...

So your post got me to thinking....

Redline MSDS sheets now refer to Phillip's 66. They did not show that way back.  That would make me think prior they were getting their base oils and add packs from them. 

Old schoolers will remember the 3 blends of Trick Racing Gas. That was Phillip's 66 B series fuels.

Phillip's is quality, especially anything coming out of the Borger facility(Av Gas etc.)

Most know that Yamalube is or was many years ago a Citgo blended product and also the same as Citgo Sea and Snow or labeled Mystik, Citgos retail brand. 

Also, many years ago(up until about 5 or so and probably still), Maxima 927 MSDS sheet was virtually identical to Castrol A747 with almost identical % amounts of Castor etc. It also looked and smelled identical.

Esso blended Euro Yamalube for that market years ago. Maybe still.

Non refinery brands buy their stuff from someone and maybe blend in additional additives etc.. If Redline was sourcing Phillps 66 all these years, that explains why it's got such a good following.

Another thing I noted was their racing oil and Kart oil is advertised as the same chemistry with a different label. If it can keep screaming shifter karts and strung out 2 stroke outboards lubed in the 9,000 RPM and up range (that is stock RPM for a 2.5 Drag or S3000 F1 stock class champ boat) it's good stuff.  And knowing Phillip's products for 40+ years and way longer with fuels(they supplied AvGas to many race fuel companies way back) I'd run it.  All those racers can't be wrong.  

I really appreciate your posting, lots of knowledge being given in this thread. 
yes, I remember when Kelly sold to Phillips 66. 
When we were using it, we used every single product they sold. The suspension fluids were coming out cleaner than any other product we’d used and RG3 was surprised at how well it looked at 20 hours. 
the clutch side of our ‘05 CRF450 had a special blend gear oil that he developed for Tom Morgan who was sponsoring Josh Grant at the time. Kelly told me that I could run that stuff until I replaced the clutch. Tom was doing our motors as well and told me to leave it in until we did a top end. It came out the same color as when we put it  in the bike. That was 40 hours… 

it stuck to the metal like a glue. When I took off the clutch cover, it covered the entire clutch even after 40 hours and the motor was cold. 
 

used their gear oil in my Dodge truck rear end and Kelly said it would double the service intervals. Pretty amazing stuff. 

1
1
1/17/2023 8:23am
DY259 wrote:
Worked at MOTUL for two years now and have loved every minute of it. Really trying to immerse the brand back into Moto ala the glory...

Worked at MOTUL for two years now and have loved every minute of it. Really trying to immerse the brand back into Moto ala the glory days of the 90's and early 2000's. Any questions about the products, I frequent the site, just ask Wink  

 

Cheers 

I would like to know why the high end racing oils from Motul don't have Jaso MA etc. And when people write here that it comes...

I would like to know why the high end racing oils from Motul don't have Jaso MA etc.

And when people write here that it comes out as clean as it gets in, why is that good? Always thougt that it's the job of an oil to keep the particle "swimming" so they get out with an oil change.

DY259 wrote:
I want to provide this to all of you guys as resourceful information - that's all I am here for. Not intending on turning this into...

I want to provide this to all of you guys as resourceful information - that's all I am here for. Not intending on turning this into another oil comparison thread. There are a lot of great oil companies out there, here are just a few highlights on the MOTUL brand specifically.

 

Our ESTER Core patented technology allows the oil to adhere to cylinder walls even when the engine is cold, preventing the wear and tear on a motor that is caused by a cold engine starts (metal-to-metal friction). Think of it as providing a thin layer of oil film on your motor components (piston, rod, cylinder, cams, gears, etc...) that serve as a magnet - sticking to these phosphorus metals. Once again, no metal-to-metal friction when starting your bike.

Now to answer your question, as to why MOTUL does not break down as quickly or lose consistency and or color. Heat and age, serve as the main contributors to the degradation of any oil. Oils operating at extremely high temperatures can begin to crack thermally. The high temperatures can sheer/crack the oil molecules into smaller molecules, which causes a decrease in viscosity. It can break down chemically from contamination by combustion byproducts and moisture accumulation. Now if you have a product that can withstand these conditions because of the formulation, overall quality selection of base oils, and a superior additives package, it ultimately combats all of those things. It doesn't stop it, every oil breaks down eventually, but you will see that ours is able to withstand heat, contamination, and moisture for a lengthier period. Hence why it is nearly the same color when you drain it as when you put it in. 

 

She explains it here at the 1:15 mark 

 

 

The chart below shows an oil analysis we ran at one of the most enduring races on earth - the ROLEX 24HR in Daytona. Yes this is a car race, but same rule applies to two wheels. This test was run on a PORSCHE GT3 that raced Rolex 24,  you will see that after 24 Hrs of racing, the engine oil did not present any problems or concerns. 

 stress:

 

 

 

Hope that answers your question man, shoot me a PM if you want to try any of the products out. 

 
 

Merry Christmas y'all

 

 

 

Good info, sent you a PM with some questions.

Teej317
Posts
888
Joined
4/30/2010
Location
Colstrip, MT US
1/17/2023 8:44am

Motul 800. Period.

mjones7212
Posts
164
Joined
8/5/2021
Location
Oildale, CA US
1/17/2023 9:45am

MOTUL has the best brake fluid on the market 

FGR01
Posts
6094
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
AZ US
Fantasy
1/17/2023 10:16am
DY259 wrote:
Worked at MOTUL for two years now and have loved every minute of it. Really trying to immerse the brand back into Moto ala the glory...

Worked at MOTUL for two years now and have loved every minute of it. Really trying to immerse the brand back into Moto ala the glory days of the 90's and early 2000's. Any questions about the products, I frequent the site, just ask Wink  

 

Cheers 

Best oil for a 450? 

DY259 wrote:
I would recommend either our 300V (green) or our 7100 (red) Synthetic product line for your bike. Depending on what brand of bike you have, our...

I would recommend either our 300V (green) or our 7100 (red) Synthetic product line for your bike. Depending on what brand of bike you have, our 7100 10W40 is a flagship product for us that does really well in both the Dirt and Road segments. If you're on an Austrian bike, then up viscosity to a 15W50 or 10W50 as that is what KTM, Husky, and Gas Gas call for typically.  I am attaching a graphic to show you the different tiers of products we have and how they differentiate from one another. 

 

If you want, shoot me a PM with your info.

 

Currently trying out 800T in my Husky TC125 and 300V in my Husky FC350.  Both seem great.

Interesting note - KTM/Husky call for 10w-50 which is not a weight available of 300V.  So it is actually the "new" 300V2 I am using in 10w-50.  It is not green in color as people say.  Just looks normal amber/uncolored.  Anything else to know about 300V2 versus 300V ?

 

fourfourone
Posts
3045
Joined
10/14/2017
Location
86oh, CT US
1/17/2023 11:59am
crusher773 wrote:
Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different...

Yeah well I completely disagree.  I've seen it first hand in my own vehicles and bikes after switching over and using a ton of other different ones over the years also.  It has made a believer out of me in a short time, enough that I started being a dealer after seeing the results.  It absolutely does not get blown away by Motorex and I have 2 customers that the husband runs Amsoil and the wife ran Motul.  He runs his harder than she does and guess what? Her bike blew up and his is still going strong.  Both were rebuilt at the same time.  Now she is running Amsoil also.  Proof is in the pudding.  I don't try and force it on anyone but it's good stuff and a company that is very focused on putting quality stuff out there.

soggy wrote:

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

crusher773 wrote:
So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes...

So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes sense.

What difference did you notice? 

1
Kkawi
Posts
195
Joined
6/14/2014
Location
Northville, MI US
1/17/2023 12:04pm

I'm running Motul 300v in my 22 YZ250F.  I love it.  I run it in all my 4 strokes.  I'd like to run it in my truck. 

I also used to run Motul 800 in my YZ125 and its a great oil. 

1/17/2023 5:26pm
mjones7212 wrote:

MOTUL has the best brake fluid on the market 

They and many others source the fluids from only a few places. Dupont probably being the biggest.

This brand, Wilwood, Brembo, (most hi perf brake brands) and many aftermarket brands all have comparable produxts and could all be the same. 

Read the labels.  And never run DOT 5 unless your machine specifically calls for it.  Never confuse 5 with 5.1

 

Motodave15
Posts
4252
Joined
8/7/2010
Location
Temple City, CA US
1/17/2023 6:39pm

Motul thread eh, i literally just changed my oil the other day.. I Went from Amsoil 10w-50 to Motorex 10w-50.. Going to see if i notice a difference.

The Amsoil oil was still beautiful pouring out after 6 rides and roughly 8 hours in the bike .. even my wife was like that oil looks great lol.

Im Trying Motorex because its in the manual.. Hopefully it holds up as well as Amsoil.

=====

I Will give this Motul Stuff a shot when i run out of the 4 quarts of Motorex.

1/18/2023 2:58am
DY259 wrote:
I want to provide this to all of you guys as resourceful information - that's all I am here for. Not intending on turning this into...

I want to provide this to all of you guys as resourceful information - that's all I am here for. Not intending on turning this into another oil comparison thread. There are a lot of great oil companies out there, here are just a few highlights on the MOTUL brand specifically.

 

Our ESTER Core patented technology allows the oil to adhere to cylinder walls even when the engine is cold, preventing the wear and tear on a motor that is caused by a cold engine starts (metal-to-metal friction). Think of it as providing a thin layer of oil film on your motor components (piston, rod, cylinder, cams, gears, etc...) that serve as a magnet - sticking to these phosphorus metals. Once again, no metal-to-metal friction when starting your bike.

Now to answer your question, as to why MOTUL does not break down as quickly or lose consistency and or color. Heat and age, serve as the main contributors to the degradation of any oil. Oils operating at extremely high temperatures can begin to crack thermally. The high temperatures can sheer/crack the oil molecules into smaller molecules, which causes a decrease in viscosity. It can break down chemically from contamination by combustion byproducts and moisture accumulation. Now if you have a product that can withstand these conditions because of the formulation, overall quality selection of base oils, and a superior additives package, it ultimately combats all of those things. It doesn't stop it, every oil breaks down eventually, but you will see that ours is able to withstand heat, contamination, and moisture for a lengthier period. Hence why it is nearly the same color when you drain it as when you put it in. 

 

She explains it here at the 1:15 mark 

 

 

The chart below shows an oil analysis we ran at one of the most enduring races on earth - the ROLEX 24HR in Daytona. Yes this is a car race, but same rule applies to two wheels. This test was run on a PORSCHE GT3 that raced Rolex 24,  you will see that after 24 Hrs of racing, the engine oil did not present any problems or concerns. 

 stress:

 

 

 

Hope that answers your question man, shoot me a PM if you want to try any of the products out. 

 
 

Merry Christmas y'all

 

 

 

Interesting. How many miles was that? Do you happen to have a more informative analysis with New and UOA numbers to compare, similar to how a...

Interesting. How many miles was that?

Do you happen to have a more informative analysis with New and UOA numbers to compare, similar to how a Blackstone report reads with the viscosities hot and cold, TBN's etc?

Not mine but like this.

https://grassrootsmotorsports.com/media/img/projectcars/04_M3-Oil_Analy…

 

This is an old related thread.

https://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/150-motor-oils-tested,12…

Be curious to your thoughts on the test method/s of the guy at the first link. 

crusher773
Posts
2017
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Coweta, OK US
1/18/2023 6:35am
soggy wrote:

No way to prove the oil has anything to do with it. 

crusher773 wrote:
So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes...

So after a change and I immediately see a difference in a truck I've had for 20 years I can't attribute that to the oil?  Makes sense.

What difference did you notice? 

Fuel mileage went up with the oil.  When I swapped over the transmission fluid noticed a huge difference on how the truck shifts.  It has never been so smooth.

1
1/18/2023 5:07pm
DY259 wrote:
I want to provide this to all of you guys as resourceful information - that's all I am here for. Not intending on turning this into...

I want to provide this to all of you guys as resourceful information - that's all I am here for. Not intending on turning this into another oil comparison thread. There are a lot of great oil companies out there, here are just a few highlights on the MOTUL brand specifically.

 

Our ESTER Core patented technology allows the oil to adhere to cylinder walls even when the engine is cold, preventing the wear and tear on a motor that is caused by a cold engine starts (metal-to-metal friction). Think of it as providing a thin layer of oil film on your motor components (piston, rod, cylinder, cams, gears, etc...) that serve as a magnet - sticking to these phosphorus metals. Once again, no metal-to-metal friction when starting your bike.

Now to answer your question, as to why MOTUL does not break down as quickly or lose consistency and or color. Heat and age, serve as the main contributors to the degradation of any oil. Oils operating at extremely high temperatures can begin to crack thermally. The high temperatures can sheer/crack the oil molecules into smaller molecules, which causes a decrease in viscosity. It can break down chemically from contamination by combustion byproducts and moisture accumulation. Now if you have a product that can withstand these conditions because of the formulation, overall quality selection of base oils, and a superior additives package, it ultimately combats all of those things. It doesn't stop it, every oil breaks down eventually, but you will see that ours is able to withstand heat, contamination, and moisture for a lengthier period. Hence why it is nearly the same color when you drain it as when you put it in. 

 

She explains it here at the 1:15 mark 

 

 

The chart below shows an oil analysis we ran at one of the most enduring races on earth - the ROLEX 24HR in Daytona. Yes this is a car race, but same rule applies to two wheels. This test was run on a PORSCHE GT3 that raced Rolex 24,  you will see that after 24 Hrs of racing, the engine oil did not present any problems or concerns. 

 stress:

 

 

 

Hope that answers your question man, shoot me a PM if you want to try any of the products out. 

 
 

Merry Christmas y'all

 

 

 

Interesting. How many miles was that? Do you happen to have a more informative analysis with New and UOA numbers to compare, similar to how a...

Interesting. How many miles was that?

Do you happen to have a more informative analysis with New and UOA numbers to compare, similar to how a Blackstone report reads with the viscosities hot and cold, TBN's etc?

Not mine but like this.

https://grassrootsmotorsports.com/media/img/projectcars/04_M3-Oil_Analy…

 

dirtwalker wrote:

This is an old related thread.

https://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/150-motor-oils-tested,12…

Be curious to your thoughts on the test method/s of the guy at the first link. 

Every few years I end up on that guys page and read updates on the top 20 or 30..  I don't know how accurate his info is on alot of those brands listed, but much is consistent with known info and I would agree with.

Also, a few of the popular name brand oils that he doesn't give that good of a rating too is also consistant.

I did notice alot of the better oils in the list are the marine version of oils.  This is also consistant with top quality "car" oils.  Basically,  imagine driving your truck at 75 MPH in 3rd gear at redline for 40 miles.  That works an oil.   

I wish he would post NOA labs from  Blackstone or similar on all those oils.  That would be interesting reading.

A decent reputable site is Petroleum Quality Institute site. You can search most popular consumer oils and see if they are meeting specs.

Post a reply to: MOTUL oil

The Latest