claim rule

klein8
Posts
91
Joined
4/12/2008
Location
Waterloo, IA, USA
Edited Date/Time 1/27/2012 1:30pm
Is there a claim rule in AMA pro mx and whats your guys opinion on a claim rule? (engine or bike)
|
englishman
Posts
2817
Joined
3/7/2008
Location
England, GB
7/8/2009 12:43pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 12:49am
There was back in the day 'till a guy named John Roeder tried to claim a factory Honda, I think, then it got tossed.

That's my understanding, could be wrong though !
BobbyM
Posts
21436
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
7/8/2009 12:51pm
englishman wrote:
There was back in the day 'till a guy named John Roeder tried to claim a factory Honda, I think, then it got tossed. That's my...
There was back in the day 'till a guy named John Roeder tried to claim a factory Honda, I think, then it got tossed.

That's my understanding, could be wrong though !
not try...but got.
englishman
Posts
2817
Joined
3/7/2008
Location
England, GB
7/8/2009 12:58pm
englishman wrote:
There was back in the day 'till a guy named John Roeder tried to claim a factory Honda, I think, then it got tossed. That's my...
There was back in the day 'till a guy named John Roeder tried to claim a factory Honda, I think, then it got tossed.

That's my understanding, could be wrong though !
BobbyM wrote:
not try...but got.
Ah right on I can't remember who's it was , Warren Reids maybe ?
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
7/8/2009 1:00pm
Tripes' bike

There is claiming in AMA Amateur
There is not in AMA Pro

Micky Boone was also known for attempting to claim, but never successfully

The Shop

flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
7/8/2009 1:02pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 12:49am
Oh, forgot to answer the question portion

I am fine with the claiming rule, especially in amateur competition. I think it keeps some costs down as people will be less willing to build works bikes if they can be claimed.

As for pro, I am on the fence. I'd like to see it in order to level the playing field some, same as amateur. At the same time, claiming in pro racing could hinder R&D.
CamP
Posts
6826
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Colleyville, TX, USA
7/8/2009 1:07pm
There is a full page on Tripe's bike on the Vintage Factory website. Scroll down near the bottom of the index on the left side of the page to "Tripe's RC250 Found".

Tripe's RC250 Found

mxdad
Posts
482
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
7/8/2009 1:10pm
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
7/8/2009 1:14pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
HAHAHAHAHA,,,,

YEAH, OK....



Ing
Posts
3654
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Spring Hill, FL, USA
7/8/2009 1:15pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
Yea, right.
jeffro756
Posts
751
Joined
4/20/2008
Location
Sycamore, IL, USA
7/8/2009 1:17pm Edited Date/Time 7/8/2009 1:29pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
Seriously? Josh Grant's bike is no better than a local vet rider? Really?

Don't suspension guys just adjust the clickers?
CamP
Posts
6826
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Colleyville, TX, USA
7/8/2009 1:22pm
Why is it that anyone with "dad" in their screen name clueless?
Short 43
Posts
363
Joined
1/12/2009
Location
Germantown, TN, USA
7/8/2009 1:27pm
I'm not sure if I'm right, but I believe you can claim any bike in ama amateur competition for only $5500. Most any bike is going to be worth a hell of alot more than that. I think they should raise it to $10,000.
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
7/8/2009 1:35pm
Short 43 wrote:
I'm not sure if I'm right, but I believe you can claim any bike in ama amateur competition for only $5500. Most any bike is going...
I'm not sure if I'm right, but I believe you can claim any bike in ama amateur competition for only $5500. Most any bike is going to be worth a hell of alot more than that. I think they should raise it to $10,000.
You're not right

F. Claiming
1. All sanctioned motocross and youth meets are claiming
meets. The claiming price shall be 30% over
manufacturers suggested retail price using the Black Book
AMA Official Motorcycle Value guide, Kelly Blue Book or
NADA appraisal guide and include the complete
motorcycle or minicycle. Vintage and ATV class equipment
will be excluded from the claiming rule.
2. Any rider (claimant) may enter a claim for a motorcycle (or
minicycle) ridden in an event in which the claimant has
competed. A claim must be entered with the referee after
the meet has been completed, but no later than 30-
minutes afterward. The referee then notifies the owner of
the claimed motorcycle and may take possession of it.
3. Cash, certified check or bank draft must accompany a
claim. The owner of the claimed machine must
immediately deliver it intact, along with a clear title or bill of
sale.
4. If more than one claim is received for the same
motorcycle, the meet referee will hold a drawing to
determine the successful claimant.
5. If a rider whose motorcycle is claimed refuses to comply,
he must forfeit his trophy, is disqualified from the meet and
will be suspended for one year.
6. A rider may not enter a claim on his own equipment.
teggers
Posts
3719
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Winter Park, FL, USA
7/8/2009 1:43pm
So...it's like 17 grand this year!
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX, USA
7/8/2009 1:55pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
Hall Of Fame material.
googs
Posts
444
Joined
2/1/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
7/8/2009 2:00pm
i never really understood this....what if ya don't wanna sell the bike???..if your'e racing in the modified class and its all tricked up then your'e not cheating anyway so why have a claim rule?

I can see how it would work in a 'stock' class if guys were over boring etc and doing some serious mod work (ie. cheating)...great deterrent.

didn't one of m alessi early hondas get claimed or was it the other way round.?
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
7/8/2009 2:32pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 12:49am
googs wrote:
i never really understood this....what if ya don't wanna sell the bike???..if your'e racing in the modified class and its all tricked up then your'e not...
i never really understood this....what if ya don't wanna sell the bike???..if your'e racing in the modified class and its all tricked up then your'e not cheating anyway so why have a claim rule?

I can see how it would work in a 'stock' class if guys were over boring etc and doing some serious mod work (ie. cheating)...great deterrent.

didn't one of m alessi early hondas get claimed or was it the other way round.?
If you refuse, you lose your license for one year


It's not about catching cheaters, it's about keep costs down and leveling the field.


If Multi-millionaire can afford to buy johnny the best of everything and build him a Heisser Tin-can, that's not fair to the rest. So the claim rule leaves that fear of losing a bike you spent mega dollars on in the back of your mind so you spend less.


There's been rumors that some PC riders don't race some bikes at AMA events, for fear of claiming.

True? I don't know

But possible


and that is it's point and use


Adam Chatfield claimed Mike Alessi's Supermini from his final mini sized class LL's race....some say it was revenge/payback from Ponca the week before more than anything
dosparks
Posts
28
Joined
6/17/2009
Location
Golden, CO, USA
7/8/2009 2:39pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 12:49am
The point is to help level the playing field between those with next to unlimited funds and those with limited funding. In theory it is supposed to deter somebody from putting tons of money into their bike to gain an advantage.


One thing to remember about the rule is that you claim the bike for 30% above suggested resale value. So that means that unless you have done that amount of modification to it you will end up ahead. Lets take a 2009 CRF450 for example. KBB lists the value as $6225. So for somebody to claim the bike they would have to put up $8092. This allows someone to do about $1870 of performance modifications before they risk losing money by getting their bike claimed.


And to answer your question about what if you don't want to sell the bike, that is simple... Don't sell it. See flarider's post section 5.


This rule is not meant to deter against cheating. There are separate rules for that. For example if you think a competitor is running an overbored bike you may inform the referee that you would like that inspected. You then pay a fee that covers the cost of a teardown and that competitors' bike is inspected.


I remember reading a claiming rule (not sure if it pertained to motocross or other racing) that said if you claimed a competitors vehicle you would then have to use it in the next event... Does this apply to motocross or am I mixing stuff up and also if it does apply, can the original owner then reclaim his bike?
7/8/2009 2:46pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
flarider wrote:
HAHAHAHAHA,,,,

YEAH, OK....



I was laughing so hard at mxdads post that I couldnt see straight.
teggers
Posts
3719
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Winter Park, FL, USA
7/8/2009 2:54pm
There are networks of parents that will also file a claim on lil' Johnny's bike if someone were to try. Try claiming a big riders' bike at a Am Nat. - 5 "other's" will also put up the money and try to get the bike. 85% chance lil Johnny gets his bike back!

It is not looked at very well from racers parents.

See rule 4.
Jabjr222
Posts
1364
Joined
4/17/2008
Location
Seattle, WA, USA
7/8/2009 3:19pm
I think any claim rule is bullshit... just look how often bikes are claimed. At best it is an antiquated rule that needs to be dropped. I don't see how it keeps costs down. Sure, in theory but in reality, everyone is going to dump as much into their bikes as possible.
7/8/2009 3:20pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
Crack Kills.
oldx
Posts
3046
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Camano Island, WA, USA
7/8/2009 3:29pm
mxdad wrote:
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts...
There is no reason for a claiming rule in AMA Pro Motocross. The "no works bike" rule took care of that. Other than a few parts (suspension) most pro bikes are less trick than your average local A class or Vet race.
flarider wrote:
HAHAHAHAHA,,,,

YEAH, OK....



lostboy819 wrote:
I was laughing so hard at mxdads post that I couldnt see straight.
Yep, that was a great post.
andymoto
Posts
4771
Joined
11/28/2007
Location
Carmichael, CA, USA
7/8/2009 3:39pm
flarider wrote:
HAHAHAHAHA,,,,

YEAH, OK....



lostboy819 wrote:
I was laughing so hard at mxdads post that I couldnt see straight.
oldx wrote:
Yep, that was a great post.
Much agreed.....Laughing Laughing Laughing
ASH510
Posts
640
Joined
2/11/2009
Location
USA
7/8/2009 3:45pm
screw reed's or short's bikes i want some unknown vet riders bike that is the best bikes that are at any track
shaner708
Posts
631
Joined
5/27/2009
Location
Export, PA, USA
7/8/2009 8:33pm
What if say the person being claimed hadnt paid the bike off yet, or the bike is a demo given to them by a shop to ride for the season. How can they give up a bike thats not theirs?
teggers
Posts
3719
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Winter Park, FL, USA
7/8/2009 8:52pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 12:49am
shaner708 wrote:
What if say the person being claimed hadnt paid the bike off yet, or the bike is a demo given to them by a shop to...
What if say the person being claimed hadnt paid the bike off yet, or the bike is a demo given to them by a shop to ride for the season. How can they give up a bike thats not theirs?
Good point. What if you can't furnish a title?


My guess is that you would refer to rule #5.

5. If a rider whose motorcycle is claimed refuses to comply, he must forfeit his trophy, is disqualified from the meet and will be suspended for one year.


Ultimately, if you choose to race an AMA race, you better be ready to follow the rules. It's up to yourself to be ready to comply....
MX-Files
Posts
989
Joined
8/19/2006
Location
USA
7/9/2009 6:45am
Fellas,

If you haven't already read it, check out Part 2 (You'll like Part 1 too) of Terry Good's story on the 1976 125cc Nationals. Probably the best story about Mickey Boone trying to claim Hannah's H2o bike. Pretty dramatic and a fun read.

http://www.mxworksbike.com/1976_125_Nationals_part_2a.htm

Enjoy!

Todd
7/9/2009 7:12am
alotta riders owe money on their bikes (more then their worth in some-most cases) therefore no titles, plus if you have the title who brings them to the track??? i know i don't.

flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
7/9/2009 7:16am
They give you time to produce the title.
You receive the claim money, so you go home, pay off the bike and send the title
But you MUST surrender the bike that day or risk losing the trophy, title and license for one year.

Post a reply to: claim rule

The Latest