Give a privateer a chance

brettmx
Posts
221
Joined
12/7/2017
Location
San Luis Obispo, CA, USA
Edited Date/Time 1/4/2019 3:56pm
I've been giving this a little bit of thought- mind you maybe not great thoughts, but thoughts none-the-less.

As Supercross season is getting ready to start are there some simple ways to give privateers at least a fighting chance against the factory bikes. I already get it that the factory riders are factory riders because they are the best, but put those best riders on the best bikes and the privateer doesn't stand a chance.

There are some simple things that would help. Not in any particular order.

1. No "development" tires. All riders have access to the same manufacturer tire whether it's Bridgestone, Dunlop, Pirelli, etc. All the tires a production models.

2. No more PRO6 VP fuel- it's too expensive (15 gallon drum is $588) and that fuel probably allows the factories to build an engine that is way more powerful than what the privateer can afford/manage. Everyone runs T4.

3. All entered riders are allowed on press day practice.

4. Maximum of 3 motors per team that are sealed. You're penalized points if you need additional motors. Doesn't include clutches.

6
12
|
500guy
Posts
12468
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
12/26/2018 6:10pm
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it , a rider would be better off staying home an extra day and training on a real track.

3 engines per rider or Team ? that is a non issue I doubt they change engines that often on race days in SX.
12/26/2018 6:12pm
There's usually privateers who ride press day and it doesn't really give them an advantage come race day, especially since it's just a section of the track like an SX triple and a rhythm.
lostboy819
Posts
12803
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
12/26/2018 6:13pm
Talent shines through even on a non factory bike. The rules you suggest wont make any difference. Racing is not a poor mans sport. The bikes the "privateers" are riding are not holding them back and have you seen some of the rigs and set ups the "privateers" are taking to the races ? No need to feel sorry for them. If they have what it takes the factorys already know about them.
5
lostboy819
Posts
12803
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
12/26/2018 6:17pm
How much you wanna make a bet I can throw a football over them mountains?... Yeah... Coach woulda put me in fourth quarter, we would've been state champions. No doubt. No doubt in my mind.
8
2

The Shop

lostboy819
Posts
12803
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
12/26/2018 6:21pm
I tried to give my posts a thumbs down but it wont let me.
3
lumpy790
Posts
11857
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
12/26/2018 6:26pm
The 4 AM press ride sucks for every rider that has to do it.
brettmx
Posts
221
Joined
12/7/2017
Location
San Luis Obispo, CA, USA
12/26/2018 7:43pm
500guy wrote:
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it...
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it , a rider would be better off staying home an extra day and training on a real track.

3 engines per rider or Team ? that is a non issue I doubt they change engines that often on race days in SX.
3 engines per rider for the whole series (17 races 450), 2 engines per West/East Coast Lites series.
12/26/2018 7:51pm
The fuel retail price limits would be a good idea honestly.
1
ML512
Posts
17125
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
12/26/2018 7:53pm Edited Date/Time 12/26/2018 7:54pm
500guy wrote:
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it...
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it , a rider would be better off staying home an extra day and training on a real track.

3 engines per rider or Team ? that is a non issue I doubt they change engines that often on race days in SX.
brettmx wrote:
3 engines per rider for the whole series (17 races 450), 2 engines per West/East Coast Lites series.
Sealed engines or limited engines for a season in Moto in my opinion are a horrible idea. In car racing it’s fine because when it blows up you’re not going to get hurt. In Moto most privateers are going to struggle to build a competitive engine that doesn’t grenade after that many hours, they’re going to get hurt with a rule like that when it lets go at a bad time. Believe it or not, most of the top 250 teams have engine combos that will wreck privateers and still go 15 operating hours without a problem. Privateers have engine builders with so much less R&D time they’re struggling to make that kind of power and keep it that reliable. At that point, I believe you’re putting a privateer in larger danger than a factory rider.

However, I totally agree with fuel and tire rules. I’ve posted many times myself that I want a production tire rule and a much cheaper spec fuel. Maybe something with lesser aditivies so teams with large amounts of dyno and R&D time can’t perfect an ECU to take advantage of great fuel.
13
Jrewing
Posts
2863
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
AU
12/26/2018 8:02pm
I’m with Mike Lindsay here. Tyres and fuel yes, engines no.
2
drt410
Posts
2075
Joined
3/18/2017
Location
Boston, MA, USA
12/26/2018 8:12pm
U really want privateers to have a shot? 250 2 strokes in the 250f class /thread..
9
2
12/26/2018 8:28pm
I agree with you on the tires aspect, that's probably WAY bigger of a benefit than most people realize.
T-Fish
Posts
3267
Joined
12/14/2009
Location
Sparta, WI, USA
12/26/2018 9:17pm
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but make them ride the same suspension as Joe Blow.


Remember the IROC races in NASCAR? Everyone got the same equipment. Why can’t that be a thing for moto? For moto, everyone rides a production bike. May the best manufacturer win (and we all benefit from that because we would probably end up with even better bikes).
3
RB624
Posts
19
Joined
10/28/2013
Location
Corona, CA, USA
12/26/2018 9:39pm
500guy wrote:
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it...
press day practice is not set up for more than a few riders and normally they don't use the whole track, not much advantage to it , a rider would be better off staying home an extra day and training on a real track.

3 engines per rider or Team ? that is a non issue I doubt they change engines that often on race days in SX.
brettmx wrote:
3 engines per rider for the whole series (17 races 450), 2 engines per West/East Coast Lites series.
ML512 wrote:
Sealed engines or limited engines for a season in Moto in my opinion are a horrible idea. In car racing it’s fine because when it blows...
Sealed engines or limited engines for a season in Moto in my opinion are a horrible idea. In car racing it’s fine because when it blows up you’re not going to get hurt. In Moto most privateers are going to struggle to build a competitive engine that doesn’t grenade after that many hours, they’re going to get hurt with a rule like that when it lets go at a bad time. Believe it or not, most of the top 250 teams have engine combos that will wreck privateers and still go 15 operating hours without a problem. Privateers have engine builders with so much less R&D time they’re struggling to make that kind of power and keep it that reliable. At that point, I believe you’re putting a privateer in larger danger than a factory rider.

However, I totally agree with fuel and tire rules. I’ve posted many times myself that I want a production tire rule and a much cheaper spec fuel. Maybe something with lesser aditivies so teams with large amounts of dyno and R&D time can’t perfect an ECU to take advantage of great fuel.
100% agree on Tires. This is the only professional motor sport without spec tires.
Johnny Ringo
Posts
8217
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ, USA
12/26/2018 10:28pm
T-Fish wrote:
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but...
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but make them ride the same suspension as Joe Blow.


Remember the IROC races in NASCAR? Everyone got the same equipment. Why can’t that be a thing for moto? For moto, everyone rides a production bike. May the best manufacturer win (and we all benefit from that because we would probably end up with even better bikes).
yeah we’d get a great production bike, for 20k.
3
bvm111
Posts
10194
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV, USA
12/26/2018 10:39pm
I prefer to see the top riders on amazing motorcycles, why limit what they can do? Tires and fuel I’ll give you but everything else is a go for me, nothing like a full built factory motorcycle!
yz133rider
Posts
5026
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA, USA
12/26/2018 10:40pm
T-Fish wrote:
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but...
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but make them ride the same suspension as Joe Blow.


Remember the IROC races in NASCAR? Everyone got the same equipment. Why can’t that be a thing for moto? For moto, everyone rides a production bike. May the best manufacturer win (and we all benefit from that because we would probably end up with even better bikes).
yeah we’d get a great production bike, for 20k.
Yeah, no it wouldnt work that way lol.
1
1983YZ125
Posts
383
Joined
2/18/2018
Location
Gulf Shores, AL, USA
12/27/2018 8:16am
$588 for 15 gallons isn't that bad when you put it in perspective.
$39.2 per gallon.

How many gallons do you go thru in a weekend between practices & the races?
I suspect in the long game, fuel is a very minor expense.


You don't have to put in a production tire rule, just that all tires are accessible to all riders in the series.
RTDRacing
Posts
119
Joined
8/14/2018
Location
CA
12/27/2018 8:26am
How about a Go Fund Me page? Could start an entire team of privateers, using the dollars raised!
1
Mr. Info
Posts
1671
Joined
5/3/2010
Location
Perris, CA, USA
12/27/2018 8:52am
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show.
We have seen a privateer excel when the factory has to fill in a spot with a better bike setup and better practice sessions away from the races during the week.
It helps quite a bit to bring them up another level in the results and maybe another chance for a seat the following year.
That’s why only a small percentage make it.
1
500guy
Posts
12468
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
12/27/2018 9:01am
Mr. Info wrote:
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show. We have seen a...
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show.
We have seen a privateer excel when the factory has to fill in a spot with a better bike setup and better practice sessions away from the races during the week.
It helps quite a bit to bring them up another level in the results and maybe another chance for a seat the following year.
That’s why only a small percentage make it.
There is only a small percentage that have all the pieces to be there, you can blame what ever you want.
1
12/27/2018 4:48pm Edited Date/Time 12/27/2018 5:09pm
Seems like a good place to make an offer (without clogging the board with more threads).

If you're a true privateer and want to race the Florida National on June 22nd, we have a place for you - if you need support. We have two spare rooms, a private bathroom, private practice track, and North Florida MX (3 miles from here). We also have a 30 amp hook up for your camper - should you so desire. We will charge you nothing and provide meals, showers, clothes washing machines, etc. As I said above, there are two spare bedrooms. In one, there's a queen bed for a couple. In the other is a futon for your mechanic or friend. PM here if you're interested. We are located about forty minutes from WW.

No, we're not serial killers or twisted freaks - just quiet folks that love moto and love to support the backbone of pro racing - privateers.
9
KennyT
Posts
4423
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Vista, CA, USA
12/27/2018 4:59pm
Make the mains 5 laps and hope to god they can get a decent start. Do you notice the back half of the field towards the end of a SX Main event? It looks like they can barely make it around the track after 10 laps. Blame it on whatever you want but the reality is the factory riders are the fastest and in the best shape. They deserve the best equipment
motogrady
Posts
3931
Joined
1/27/2008
Location
USA
12/27/2018 5:31pm

No factory mechanics at the first turn or spotters on the track.
Starting positions by lottery out of a hat right before the Moto.
No provisional crap. You don't make the main, you don't make the main.
1
lostboy819
Posts
12803
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
12/27/2018 6:14pm Edited Date/Time 12/27/2018 6:24pm
Mr. Info wrote:
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show. We have seen a...
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show.
We have seen a privateer excel when the factory has to fill in a spot with a better bike setup and better practice sessions away from the races during the week.
It helps quite a bit to bring them up another level in the results and maybe another chance for a seat the following year.
That’s why only a small percentage make it.
Woohoo Woohoo Woohoo So which privateers really excelled when he was giving a factory fill in spot ? The only true privateer I ever saw get a factory bike for a race was Scott Champion and it didn't make much difference. You could give me the best guitar ever made and I still couldn't play it. You either have it or you don't and a factory bike and private test track might help a little but wont make you win unless you have the talent and only a few can get to the top step.
APLMAN99
Posts
13071
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
12/27/2018 6:17pm
Probably should just hand out equal-sized participation trophies before the races even start and give everyone the same purse payout as well..........
1
1
motogrady
Posts
3931
Joined
1/27/2008
Location
USA
12/27/2018 7:00pm

I dunno guys, all these bits and pieces, imho, won't change much.
The thing the top guys have is consistency. Every week, good equipment. Every week, a solid training routine.
Every week, a paycheck. Every week, riding as much as they want. Every week a flight to the track. Every week
mechanics keeping your bikes in top shape.

Sure, a really good rider might have a good day every now and then. But, there is so much to do, so much to look after
at that level, it's no wonder Johnny Average rarely pops a good finish. I think that's what Reeds problem was when he was running his own show.

Agreed, there are a few that come down the pike now and then that have so much talent they will make the grade no matter what. McGrath. RC. Stewart to name a few. But, given the factory treatment, unless you are a never will squid,
I believe there are a lot of guys that could make the top.

That's what I think anyway.
Sully
Posts
9661
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
12/27/2018 10:37pm
Mr. Info wrote:
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show. We have seen a...
Remember the rules are set up to protect the factory teams and the privateers are the fillers to make it a show.
We have seen a privateer excel when the factory has to fill in a spot with a better bike setup and better practice sessions away from the races during the week.
It helps quite a bit to bring them up another level in the results and maybe another chance for a seat the following year.
That’s why only a small percentage make it.
lostboy819 wrote:
:woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo: So which privateers really excelled when he was giving a factory fill in spot ? The only true privateer I ever saw get...
Woohoo Woohoo Woohoo So which privateers really excelled when he was giving a factory fill in spot ? The only true privateer I ever saw get a factory bike for a race was Scott Champion and it didn't make much difference. You could give me the best guitar ever made and I still couldn't play it. You either have it or you don't and a factory bike and private test track might help a little but wont make you win unless you have the talent and only a few can get to the top step.
Freddy Noren comes to mind. But other than that, your whole post is correct.

Old Blood, you really shouldn’t drink and post. It never works out well for you.
1
1
brettmx
Posts
221
Joined
12/7/2017
Location
San Luis Obispo, CA, USA
12/29/2018 2:33pm
The "Nuclear" option. Bring back the claim rule.
1
GeorgiePorgie
Posts
8379
Joined
3/4/2012
Location
USA
12/29/2018 5:04pm
T-Fish wrote:
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but...
How about limiting suspension? Aside from the engine, isn’t that what separates the Factory boys from everyone else? Let the Factory guys have their engines, but make them ride the same suspension as Joe Blow.


Remember the IROC races in NASCAR? Everyone got the same equipment. Why can’t that be a thing for moto? For moto, everyone rides a production bike. May the best manufacturer win (and we all benefit from that because we would probably end up with even better bikes).
This idea is where the 2 stroke production class should come into play.

Run this class at the pro nationals. Stepping stone class. Feeder for the lights.....

Post a reply to: Give a privateer a chance

The Latest