Should AC92 been allowed to race?

hamncheeze
Posts
2427
Joined
1/13/2018
Location
British Columbia, CA
1/22/2018 9:57am
Honestly this situation reminds me a bit of Dallas 2013 when Zach Bell had that big get-off in his heat but continued racing through the night. Eddie C has already weighed in here to defend the medical crew, but I think most of us can see from the crash footage plus AC's own admission that he was dazed afterwards that he hit his head pretty hard and probably should have not been racing.
Premix
Posts
1505
Joined
1/5/2014
Location
USA
1/22/2018 9:58am
jeffro503 wrote:
That kid wants this championship. What else can you say? He was going to put in a good ride and gather as many points as he...
That kid wants this championship. What else can you say? He was going to put in a good ride and gather as many points as he could , and he didn't care how he felt. I'm sure that if he felt he was going to put other riders in danger , he would of called it.....but he didn't. He had a good race.
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole alpha mentality, we’ve all been there and done it, but with as fast as these guys go these days, even mistiming a rhythm can be career ending. I would personally rather see these guys sit out a race rather than a whole season...

GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
1/22/2018 10:00am
Premix wrote:
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole...
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole alpha mentality, we’ve all been there and done it, but with as fast as these guys go these days, even mistiming a rhythm can be career ending. I would personally rather see these guys sit out a race rather than a whole season...

I'll leave the answer to the medical professionals.

You got an answer in this thread that said he was cleared to race.
Tracktor
Posts
2343
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
The RTF/Amboy, WA, USA
1/22/2018 10:03am
motoxxx599 wrote:
In the PulpMX post racer interview he alluded to not having a clear head until the third main.
Yet he passed all medical testing. Hindsight will not be kind when looking back at moments like these. And the cavalier way in which this stuff...
Yet he passed all medical testing.

Hindsight will not be kind when looking back at moments like these. And the cavalier way in which this stuff is dismissed will disqualify people from saying “we didnt know any better”. Race officials only care about protecting their liability.
BobbyM wrote:
You are contradicting yerself.
No, the first sentence is ironic. It points out that the testing in MX/SX doesn't seem to line up with the rest of the medical community when it comes to concussions.

I'm not a doctor but have studied concussions more than most MX parents and we are the only people I know who take what is considered the proper time off to heal. Neither of my kids has ever lost consciousness but have had concussions (memory loss, nausea, dizziness, etc). I have read as much as I can find and spoken to multiple doctors and nothing I have learned matches what I see in the MX world.

Like I said I am not a doctor but I am curious as to why there is this difference in opinion on concussion protocol? Mainly due to the effect it has on younger riders who follow what they see pro's do and parents who push their kids to ride too soon.................

The Shop

jeffro503
Posts
27650
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR, USA
1/22/2018 10:21am
jeffro503 wrote:
That kid wants this championship. What else can you say? He was going to put in a good ride and gather as many points as he...
That kid wants this championship. What else can you say? He was going to put in a good ride and gather as many points as he could , and he didn't care how he felt. I'm sure that if he felt he was going to put other riders in danger , he would of called it.....but he didn't. He had a good race.
Premix wrote:
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole...
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole alpha mentality, we’ve all been there and done it, but with as fast as these guys go these days, even mistiming a rhythm can be career ending. I would personally rather see these guys sit out a race rather than a whole season...

Well , you're missing the point , as in he passed his tests. And if a rider does pass those tests , it ultimately boils down to the rider himself if he thinks he can race or not.

There is a huge grey area here , in which you can't just bench a rider because " you think " he may of gotten a concussion. Where does that line start and stop? Like I said.....if they can pass the test , it boils down to the rider himself. That's it.
LoudLove
Posts
3024
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
USA
1/22/2018 10:47am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2018 10:52am
The situation is not unique to SX. Tom Savage and Cam Newton were both allowed to return to the field after they clearly suffered a concussion (the Savage replay was especially harrowing). Hopefully SX has created better protocols than when Zach Bell was KO'd and later allowed to race the LCQ.
LoudLove
Posts
3024
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
USA
1/22/2018 10:57am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2018 10:59am
Removed from game to protect himself:


Allowed to race 225 lb motorcycle against 20 competitors in an arena 1 hour later:
wreckitrandy
Posts
4253
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC, USA
1/22/2018 10:59am
Yes.
Rosso391
Posts
3776
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
YO MAMA, MN, USA
1/22/2018 11:04am
It looked like he just got the wind knocked out of him. Like he was gasping for air.
Rosso391
Posts
3776
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
YO MAMA, MN, USA
1/22/2018 11:12am
LoudLove wrote:
Removed from game to protect himself: [embed] https://youtu.be/PbE5CzSoxQE [/embed] Allowed to race 225 lb motorcycle against 20 competitors in an arena 1 hour later: [embed] https://youtu.be/Y-jMz-hDgz0...
Removed from game to protect himself:


Allowed to race 225 lb motorcycle against 20 competitors in an arena 1 hour later:
Really? Comparing that pussy sport to ours? I'll bite. Maybe you should look at what is in a football helmet, I'll tell you, next to ZERO padding. Why? I'm not even sure. That's why they have so many concussions. Now look at a MOTO helmet...thousands more hours and tests must be performed before a manufacturer can even distribute or sell them.
sandtrack315
Posts
2877
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 11:46am
There is too much faith in "the protocol" and medical professionals. Neuroscientists learn more about head injuries every single day. The prognosis for minor impacts only gets worse, not better, as we (I am a neuroscientist) get better at quantifying the impact of them. Were Adam's motor skills impaired enough to make the race more dangerous to himself and others than if he had not crashed? Probably not. Had he hit his head later in the night, would the injury have been much worse than if he hadn't hit his head earlier in the night? Probably. There is a big difference between passing a test and your brain not having endured any injury. Unless they are taking samples of his brain's white matter and looking for shearing, the tests are just heuristics.
aFACEdismembered
Posts
2848
Joined
8/17/2009
Location
Oak Point, TX, USA
1/22/2018 11:50am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2018 11:53am
A person can claim they were not unconscious all they want but if they were not awake for the worst part how would you know for sure? Hang with me here. This doesn't apply to all scenarios. I'm thinking mainly of this one and Zach Bell.

I bring this up due to personal experience. The first time it happened to me I was unconscious for a couple of minutes at some dirt jumps and when I came to I had no idea I had been unconscious. I got up like I had just fallen, rolled, stopped and then I grabbed my bike and started riding back to the start hill. Halfway back I realized everyone was standing around me when I got up and I wondered how they all got there so fast from so far away. I was oblivious. I had to ask someone and they told me I had been down for a couple of minutes. My symptoms would have never showed it. With all the movement on a stadium floor I would have never been able to make that "time" correlation. Hell, I didn't even know I had a broken hand until I tried to open the door to my truck. Pinch
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 11:53am
Premix wrote:
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole...
There’s a difference between gutting it out and stupidity. What would have happened had he lost consciousness over one of the jumps? I get the whole alpha mentality, we’ve all been there and done it, but with as fast as these guys go these days, even mistiming a rhythm can be career ending. I would personally rather see these guys sit out a race rather than a whole season...

GuyB wrote:
I'll leave the answer to the medical professionals.

You got an answer in this thread that said he was cleared to race.
Yeah cause the SPORTS medical industry’s track record (especially in the department of concussions) has been so stellar. (SARCASM FONT)

This is really simple. Here is the age old litmus test... ask yourself not how it feels to be right on a topic. But ask how it’s gonna look to be WRONG.

Women being able to vote... even if you were against it, how’s it look in hindsight?

Civil rights? ... same question, same answer.

Now concussions. If we are all wrong, ok, so a kid got held out of a race or two in the name of safety. Now if y’all “alpha dogs” are all wrong? You were encouraging brain damage or at the very least, sweeping it under the rug.

CTE aint fake. It’s suffering by any definition. I dont have the answers. Because I love contact sports also. But I know the answer isnt burying one’s head in the sand and pretending ignorance later.
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 11:56am
LoudLove wrote:
Removed from game to protect himself: [embed] https://youtu.be/PbE5CzSoxQE [/embed] Allowed to race 225 lb motorcycle against 20 competitors in an arena 1 hour later: [embed] https://youtu.be/Y-jMz-hDgz0...
Removed from game to protect himself:


Allowed to race 225 lb motorcycle against 20 competitors in an arena 1 hour later:
Rosso391 wrote:
Really? Comparing that pussy sport to ours? I'll bite. Maybe you should look at what is in a football helmet, I'll tell you, next to ZERO...
Really? Comparing that pussy sport to ours? I'll bite. Maybe you should look at what is in a football helmet, I'll tell you, next to ZERO padding. Why? I'm not even sure. That's why they have so many concussions. Now look at a MOTO helmet...thousands more hours and tests must be performed before a manufacturer can even distribute or sell them.
Jesus Christ. Smh.
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 11:56am Edited Date/Time 1/22/2018 11:57am
There is too much faith in "the protocol" and medical professionals. Neuroscientists learn more about head injuries every single day. The prognosis for minor impacts only...
There is too much faith in "the protocol" and medical professionals. Neuroscientists learn more about head injuries every single day. The prognosis for minor impacts only gets worse, not better, as we (I am a neuroscientist) get better at quantifying the impact of them. Were Adam's motor skills impaired enough to make the race more dangerous to himself and others than if he had not crashed? Probably not. Had he hit his head later in the night, would the injury have been much worse than if he hadn't hit his head earlier in the night? Probably. There is a big difference between passing a test and your brain not having endured any injury. Unless they are taking samples of his brain's white matter and looking for shearing, the tests are just heuristics.
Thank you. Although, i doubt your words will have much impact. Feet have been dug in on this topic.

The irony of science is that humans treat it like a belief system at the first opportunity.
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
1/22/2018 11:59am
Yeah cause the SPORTS medical industry’s track record (especially in the department of concussions) has been so stellar. (SARCASM FONT) This is really simple. Here is...
Yeah cause the SPORTS medical industry’s track record (especially in the department of concussions) has been so stellar. (SARCASM FONT)

This is really simple. Here is the age old litmus test... ask yourself not how it feels to be right on a topic. But ask how it’s gonna look to be WRONG.

Women being able to vote... even if you were against it, how’s it look in hindsight?

Civil rights? ... same question, same answer.

Now concussions. If we are all wrong, ok, so a kid got held out of a race or two in the name of safety. Now if y’all “alpha dogs” are all wrong? You were encouraging brain damage or at the very least, sweeping it under the rug.

CTE aint fake. It’s suffering by any definition. I dont have the answers. Because I love contact sports also. But I know the answer isnt burying one’s head in the sand and pretending ignorance later.
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense medical evaluations here.
NorCal 50+
Posts
1455
Joined
5/31/2017
Location
Grass Valley, CA, USA
1/22/2018 12:00pm
Thank you for raising this issue. I think we clearly need to form a Vital MX committee and look into it.
Katoomey
Posts
1714
Joined
1/18/2013
Location
USA
1/22/2018 12:01pm
what happened to the bears around here?
MPJC
Posts
2082
Joined
5/18/2017
Location
CA
1/22/2018 12:02pm
While true that he nobody should stop him from racing if he passed the medical tests, it sounds like he passed them despite feeling "foggy" (I wonder if he disclosed that to the medical staff, and if he still would have passed had he told them). He's very lucky he didn't take another hit to the head as taking a second hit once one is already suffering from the effects of the first can take an otherwise minor trauma and make it much, much worse. Look at what happened to Sidney Crosby when he got his bell rung in 2011 and then took another hit again in the very next game. He was out for the rest of the season, and hardly played for the next few years. I wouldn't blame the medical staff or anyone else if all medical steps have been followed, as only the athlete himself knows how he feels.
sandtrack315
Posts
2877
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 12:04pm
GuyB wrote:
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense...
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense medical evaluations here.
That is very reasonable. But understand that they only know, at most, what neuroscience as a field knows, and neuroscience is a young field with much to learn about head trauma. Moreover, just because medical professionals can not detect brain damage does not mean it did not happen.
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 12:05pm
LoudLove wrote:
The situation is not unique to SX. Tom Savage and Cam Newton were both allowed to return to the field after they clearly suffered a concussion...
The situation is not unique to SX. Tom Savage and Cam Newton were both allowed to return to the field after they clearly suffered a concussion (the Savage replay was especially harrowing). Hopefully SX has created better protocols than when Zach Bell was KO'd and later allowed to race the LCQ.
The NFL took major heat for both occasions. It’s been a bad year for them in the PR department and they continually find new ways to step in otherwise avoidable shit.

The difference here is the MX media is still bery much complicit. Kinda like baseball media during the steroid era. Tho, even baseball media knew they were lying to the public. I really wouldn’t be surprised if the MX industry isnt trying to cover anything up. They might be legitimately ignorant on the topic of concussions.
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 12:12pm
Yeah cause the SPORTS medical industry’s track record (especially in the department of concussions) has been so stellar. (SARCASM FONT) This is really simple. Here is...
Yeah cause the SPORTS medical industry’s track record (especially in the department of concussions) has been so stellar. (SARCASM FONT)

This is really simple. Here is the age old litmus test... ask yourself not how it feels to be right on a topic. But ask how it’s gonna look to be WRONG.

Women being able to vote... even if you were against it, how’s it look in hindsight?

Civil rights? ... same question, same answer.

Now concussions. If we are all wrong, ok, so a kid got held out of a race or two in the name of safety. Now if y’all “alpha dogs” are all wrong? You were encouraging brain damage or at the very least, sweeping it under the rug.

CTE aint fake. It’s suffering by any definition. I dont have the answers. Because I love contact sports also. But I know the answer isnt burying one’s head in the sand and pretending ignorance later.
GuyB wrote:
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense...
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense medical evaluations here.
Forgive my laughter but i hope you too can see the comedy here.

In a thread in which the value of one’s brain is being discussed. The “reasonable” solution is to not use one’s own brain to form a sound judgement but go on autopilot and defer to “professionals” who are hired to protect Feld’s liability first, rider safety second.

It’s no wonder half the mob dont care about brain damage. Who needs critical thinking. Hahaha
akillerwombat
Posts
3211
Joined
10/16/2013
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
1/22/2018 12:14pm
Forgive my laughter but i hope you too can see the comedy here. In a thread in which the value of one’s brain is being discussed...
Forgive my laughter but i hope you too can see the comedy here.

In a thread in which the value of one’s brain is being discussed. The “reasonable” solution is to not use one’s own brain to form a sound judgement but go on autopilot and defer to “professionals” who are hired to protect Feld’s liability first, rider safety second.

It’s no wonder half the mob dont care about brain damage. Who needs critical thinking. Hahaha
By this logic; why have professionals in anything?
sandtrack315
Posts
2877
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 12:17pm
By this logic; why have professionals in anything?
Professionals know more than you, but they don't know everything, and they are not perfect.
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 12:18pm
Let me make something clear, I dont envy the team doctor’s position on this topic. That includes EddieC.

Ive seen him at work. Ive seen him try to pull a rider from the field due to dehydration (which we’ve learned as of late is very dangerous & life threatening).

Athletes lie. To themselves more than anyone. So lying to the doctor is like a easy art form them.

Fans dont really know what they want. NFL is proof of that.

And the promoters got to put on a show.

The medical industry is in a VERY difficult position on this topic.
akillerwombat
Posts
3211
Joined
10/16/2013
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
1/22/2018 12:21pm Edited Date/Time 1/22/2018 12:22pm
Professionals know more than you, but they don't know everything, and they are not perfect.
Of course they don't – they're human.

But to discredit the dedication, experience, and work of countless humans in a simple post is far from the perfect approach to remedying the situation. If Jabroni has so little faith in those who have chosen to protect the athletes in our sport then perhaps he should contact them and have a conversation with them; learn about what their understand of CTE is, etc.

At this point has there been any exchange of ideas or formal conversation or is it just, "those guys don't give a shit about our riders... just look at football"?
Tracktor
Posts
2343
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
The RTF/Amboy, WA, USA
1/22/2018 12:27pm
GuyB wrote:
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense...
I'll defer to medical pros pretty much 100% of the time, versus guys sitting at home and watching on their TV who then need to dispense medical evaluations here.
The question is which medical pros do you trust? I am the guy at home watching but have seen/heard enough evidence that I think it's reasonable to question how this issue is handled for the reasons I stated above. No race win is worth the risks of brain damage, imo. It's tough to argue that the restrictions from racing after a head injury are pretty lax when looking in from the outside.

I am looking for clarity since I have kids that race and getting information from doctors who are on the front line of the sport seems like a good source. Especially since there is the appearance of major differences between views on head injuries and how they should be handled...................
Ghost of Jabroni
Posts
4425
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/22/2018 12:28pm
Forgive my laughter but i hope you too can see the comedy here. In a thread in which the value of one’s brain is being discussed...
Forgive my laughter but i hope you too can see the comedy here.

In a thread in which the value of one’s brain is being discussed. The “reasonable” solution is to not use one’s own brain to form a sound judgement but go on autopilot and defer to “professionals” who are hired to protect Feld’s liability first, rider safety second.

It’s no wonder half the mob dont care about brain damage. Who needs critical thinking. Hahaha
By this logic; why have professionals in anything?
I dunno man.

Some people prefer stop lights to tell them when it’s safe to go. And they blindly trust them.

Others of us prefer roundabouts. In which I decide when it’s safe.

Different strokes.

The “professionals” in this field of brain trauma are all saying the same thing: the more they find out, the worse it is. There’s every indication that we should be cautious on this topic. The testing these “professionals” are using as a defense isn’t comprehensive and continues to be proven to only scratch the surface.

Drop the agenda (liability) angle and there isnt much to debate here for the “professionals”.
akillerwombat
Posts
3211
Joined
10/16/2013
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
1/22/2018 12:38pm
I dunno man. Some people prefer stop lights to tell them when it’s safe to go. And they blindly trust them. Others of us prefer roundabouts...
I dunno man.

Some people prefer stop lights to tell them when it’s safe to go. And they blindly trust them.

Others of us prefer roundabouts. In which I decide when it’s safe.

Different strokes.

The “professionals” in this field of brain trauma are all saying the same thing: the more they find out, the worse it is. There’s every indication that we should be cautious on this topic. The testing these “professionals” are using as a defense isn’t comprehensive and continues to be proven to only scratch the surface.

Drop the agenda (liability) angle and there isnt much to debate here for the “professionals”.
Then do something about it.

I mean no disrespect but all I'm reading is that the doctors have an agenda, the riders don't know themselves well enough, science doesn't know enough, doctors don't know that science that they do have well enough, some people light stop lights some like roundabouts, etc.
EddieC
Posts
362
Joined
2/26/2012
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
1/22/2018 1:22pm
Yet he passed all medical testing. Hindsight will not be kind when looking back at moments like these. And the cavalier way in which this stuff...
Yet he passed all medical testing.

Hindsight will not be kind when looking back at moments like these. And the cavalier way in which this stuff is dismissed will disqualify people from saying “we didnt know any better”. Race officials only care about protecting their liability.
And if he sat out even though he passed the tests, everyone would blow him out on here. There is no winning in this situation so...
And if he sat out even though he passed the tests, everyone would blow him out on here. There is no winning in this situation so at the end of the day, if he passes the tests and wants to race, then that's his decision.
The very nature of a concussion is that it’s not “his decision” anymore. Im not blaming AC at all. I dont expect a rider to voluntarily...
The very nature of a concussion is that it’s not “his decision” anymore.

Im not blaming AC at all. I dont expect a rider to voluntarily “sit out”. I expect the medical professionals to do their jobs and protect both the rider from himself & his competition. They ran tests, he passed. I believe EddieC when he says that. But the kid clearly wasnt right by evidence of the Matthes interview.

It’s pretty clear the testing is a joke and merely a liability cover.

The irony is that much like with PEDs (which I am not against) the very nature of SX/MX is very dangerous. Preaching safety is probably never gonna go over well.
I take it personal when you say the program is a joke. You are making assumptions about things you only saw on t.v. or heard on a podcast.

Is it possible that a rider could have sustained another injury that could have caused difficulty in walking off the track?
This is one of the first things taught to all healthcare professionals. The obvious injury is not always the only injury.


Is it possible that an athlete could experience something similar to what is referred to as "fog of war", the really great athletes have the ability to slow down time while competing under the greatest of pressure while others in similar situations will play on instincts and often times not remember plays or events that have happened during the game.
Take a sports psychology class.

Is it possible that an athlete can be cleared and later develop symptoms? Absolutely, that is why we tell every rider as well as anyone else allowed the information that symptoms could present themselves later and if so to contact the medical team.

If after the rider is cleared and continues to ride and there is question as to the riders ability to be safe on the track the medical team or AMA staff can black flag the rider.

You want to call the program I helped develop a joke, come up with a better one. Until then shut your pie hole, sit back and enjoy the racing.

Post a reply to: Should AC92 been allowed to race?

The Latest