Is the Leatt fad now over ?

OW38B
Posts
3619
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Coto de Caza, CA, USA
1/18/2016 8:57pm
JQ wrote:
Arguing against a neck brace is in my opinion as stupid as arguing against a seat belt. Most of the time a seat belt will limit...
Arguing against a neck brace is in my opinion as stupid as arguing against a seat belt. Most of the time a seat belt will limit your injuries or save your life. Sometimes it may actually injure or kill you. Other times not wearing one will save you as you get thrown out of the car. But at the end of the day, overall it is safest to wear one. Same goes for neck braces.....I think people can't see the forest for the trees.
Then that begs the question.........why are so many Pros that used to wear them, no longer wearing them?

Maybe they know something, maybe they do not?
usafwx
Posts
1495
Joined
7/19/2012
Location
Trussville, AL, USA
1/18/2016 9:00pm Edited Date/Time 1/18/2016 9:01pm
All I know is both my Atlas neck brace and 6D helmet prevented a concussion and any neck or spinal cord injuries in my serious air evacuation crash this past season, as for my spleen, ribs and kidneys, not so much. Because of that I will forever wear both of these products.
1/18/2016 9:18pm
OW38B - Same reason many of them don't wear chest protectors. Just because they make a choice doesn't mean it's a good choice for an average consumer, or an educated choice. It's all mental for them. It's all in what you believe. If you believe a softer pair of grips will make your lap times better (or someone tells you they will) then they will because you believe it and instinctively will go faster. If you have a shade of doubt about something your lap times will show it at that high of a level. It doesn't matter if its a grip, or zip tie in the wrong place... these guys are searching for any "advantage" and it's easy for them to take a brace off and say they "feel" better. I like going skinny dipping too but there is a time and a place, and for an average consumer, I am not sure the risks associated with riding is the right time to throw caution to the wind with protective gear. Pros at that level get paid huge sums of money to do that, consumers need to work on Monday and feed their family.

Meanwhile guys like Anderson, Canard, RV when he was active, Herlings, Dungey a few years back, and many others are winning races and championships with braces on, unaffected. Can't blame the others for searching, but it's usually not the equipment holding them back.
worcsracer808
Posts
640
Joined
1/13/2009
Location
Boulder City, NV, USA
1/18/2016 9:33pm
My real concern is if the brace prevents your neck from hyper extension in the event it needs to be hyperextended. I feel like the leatt...
My real concern is if the brace prevents your neck from hyper extension in the event it needs to be hyperextended. I feel like the leatt mimics a perpendicular dive into an empty pool at every over the handlebar head first impact. Causing compression T 3-4-5 injuries.

I know guys that have gone over the bars and now are paralyzed. But if you were to witness the crash it didn't look that bad. Just looked like he couldn't roll out of it. I know this may sound stupid but there's a reason our neck hyperextends. To transfer the impact loads perhaps ? I know guys who now have collarbone and shoulder injuries.

I guess when I can see statistical data that shows the device won't cause injury and is proven to prevent in certain situations then I'd wear one.
you have a very good point here, I personally know a pro racer who crashed and was paralyzed, and I can't say for sure that the leatt was the cause, or that it wouldn't have happened or been injured bad regardless, but it was coincidental that his spinal cord damage was pretty exactly where the leatt brace sits, i believe it was the T-3 if i remember correctly.

That being said I don't personally wear one because I don't think it would benefit me and I do think it could cause more damage than good, however of the braces on the market the Atlas does seem to be the best designed and would be my choice if I were to start.

The Shop

bvm111
Posts
10193
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV, USA
1/18/2016 9:58pm
You guys convinced me I'm never wearing one again..... Evil Evil Whistling Whistling
1/18/2016 10:37pm Edited Date/Time 1/19/2016 1:12am
Marvin still believes in them even though his brother was paralysed wearing one.
aeffertz
Posts
12837
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
1/19/2016 1:38am
hillbilly wrote:
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique...
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique experience of breaking my neck,being totally paralyzed ,getting my movement back and racing for several more years.

The looks of the brace seems to hinge the neck in a unnatural way,and the pics I see of the pros,the brace is so far from the base of the helmet that youd have to stob your neck down 3 inches into your chest before the brace comes into play.

If its your time it is your time,want to be safer,work out,be in shape and limber from stretching.
One of the dumbest posts I've ever read. Holy shit.
Fearo
Posts
1383
Joined
12/17/2009
Location
BE
1/19/2016 1:55am
hillbilly wrote:
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique...
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique experience of breaking my neck,being totally paralyzed ,getting my movement back and racing for several more years.

The looks of the brace seems to hinge the neck in a unnatural way,and the pics I see of the pros,the brace is so far from the base of the helmet that youd have to stob your neck down 3 inches into your chest before the brace comes into play.

If its your time it is your time,want to be safer,work out,be in shape and limber from stretching.
Strong username to post content ratio.
chocolatethunder782
Posts
443
Joined
8/10/2015
Location
Saint Charles, MO, USA
1/19/2016 5:39am
My real concern is if the brace prevents your neck from hyper extension in the event it needs to be hyperextended. I feel like the leatt...
My real concern is if the brace prevents your neck from hyper extension in the event it needs to be hyperextended. I feel like the leatt mimics a perpendicular dive into an empty pool at every over the handlebar head first impact. Causing compression T 3-4-5 injuries.

I know guys that have gone over the bars and now are paralyzed. But if you were to witness the crash it didn't look that bad. Just looked like he couldn't roll out of it. I know this may sound stupid but there's a reason our neck hyperextends. To transfer the impact loads perhaps ? I know guys who now have collarbone and shoulder injuries.

I guess when I can see statistical data that shows the device won't cause injury and is proven to prevent in certain situations then I'd wear one.
By definition hyperextending would mean that it would be extending too far. I hyper extended my back and broke my t5 and t6. For the record this was a long time before any neck braces were around. I got lucky and didnt have any paralysis. I got knocked out and my theory is that I was out as soon as my head hit and I didn't have any muscle tone to prevent my feet from coming around and hitting me in the back of the head

Your head is going to bend in different angles depending on the crash. The neck braces will just prevent them from extending too far and will transfer the load from your neck to your collar bone instead depending on the angle of the crash.

It is the same concept as a knee brace or a wrist brace. It prevents hyper extension.
hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
1/19/2016 9:11am
hillbilly wrote:
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique...
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique experience of breaking my neck,being totally paralyzed ,getting my movement back and racing for several more years.

The looks of the brace seems to hinge the neck in a unnatural way,and the pics I see of the pros,the brace is so far from the base of the helmet that youd have to stob your neck down 3 inches into your chest before the brace comes into play.

If its your time it is your time,want to be safer,work out,be in shape and limber from stretching.
aeffertz wrote:
One of the dumbest posts I've ever read. Holy shit.
I've got dumber ones,look around.
hvaughn88
Posts
8361
Joined
6/19/2013
Location
Conway, AR, USA
1/19/2016 9:14am
JQ wrote:
Arguing against a neck brace is in my opinion as stupid as arguing against a seat belt. Most of the time a seat belt will limit...
Arguing against a neck brace is in my opinion as stupid as arguing against a seat belt. Most of the time a seat belt will limit your injuries or save your life. Sometimes it may actually injure or kill you. Other times not wearing one will save you as you get thrown out of the car. But at the end of the day, overall it is safest to wear one. Same goes for neck braces.....I think people can't see the forest for the trees.
OW38B wrote:
Then that begs the question.........why are so many Pros that used to wear them, no longer wearing them?

Maybe they know something, maybe they do not?
They asked brayton about that on Pulp one episode and he said he was slower when he was wearing it. He said at that level where tenths of seconds are so important, that taking it off was worth the risk. I'm paraphrasing from memory, so don't kill me.
hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
1/19/2016 9:28am
DannyST107 wrote:
Leatt from last 2 year. [img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2016/01/18/120391/s1200_FB_IMG_1453157916032.jpg[/img] New atlas for this season [img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2016/01/18/120392/s1200_20160108_174728.jpg[/img] Lightweight, 600 gram Look good Alot of clearance Nothing on spine Just shoulders Cheap...
Leatt from last 2 year.


New atlas for this season


Lightweight, 600 gram
Look good
Alot of clearance
Nothing on spine Just shoulders
Cheap compared to leatt
Sits fine on leatt protector

Also want to add that the leatt suffered quite some impacts lately, small and big. Always left me with a sore neck or as a result of a small tipover, a whiplash currently.

Always had pain on the same spot on my neck, where the backside of my brace meets my neck.

Hence the choice for atlas this year
cslacker wrote:
Can you even contact the new brace looking up as high as possible? That back looks extremely low on the new atlas.
That brace looks so far from the helmet I dont see how it is going to help transfer force to the shoulders.

And if you hit in a way it tucks the head into the chest it seems to me the force would be centered on one area of the neck instead of thru out like without a brace.
1/19/2016 9:32am
hvaughn88 wrote:
They asked brayton about that on Pulp one episode and he said he was slower when he was wearing it. He said at that level where...
They asked brayton about that on Pulp one episode and he said he was slower when he was wearing it. He said at that level where tenths of seconds are so important, that taking it off was worth the risk. I'm paraphrasing from memory, so don't kill me.
Yet his results remain the same.

As I mentioned these guys are searching for a mental gain that is all in their head. No one who has taken it off has immediately gone from 5th every weekend to winning all the time simply because they took it off.

Dungey won with one on, then lost for consecutive years in a row after that to RV, who was wearing one. Now he's winning again years later - not because of the brace, because RV retired and he has stepped his game up.

AC dominated his whole amateur career with one on, turned pro took it off, and has had the roughest few years of his career. Nothing to do with a brace, is just having a hard time.

Reed won and rode around with a number 1 plate for a year while wearing a brace.

(this list goes on)

At the end of the day they have to do what is comfortable for them, but the point is the best rider will rise to the top and win regardless, and whether it's with or without a brace it isn't making any difference in their performance, only putting them at risk.

Make the best decision for you, and your situation.

hvaughn88
Posts
8361
Joined
6/19/2013
Location
Conway, AR, USA
1/19/2016 9:36am
hvaughn88 wrote:
They asked brayton about that on Pulp one episode and he said he was slower when he was wearing it. He said at that level where...
They asked brayton about that on Pulp one episode and he said he was slower when he was wearing it. He said at that level where tenths of seconds are so important, that taking it off was worth the risk. I'm paraphrasing from memory, so don't kill me.
AtlasBrace wrote:
Yet his results remain the same. As I mentioned these guys are searching for a mental gain that is all in their head. No one who...
Yet his results remain the same.

As I mentioned these guys are searching for a mental gain that is all in their head. No one who has taken it off has immediately gone from 5th every weekend to winning all the time simply because they took it off.

Dungey won with one on, then lost for consecutive years in a row after that to RV, who was wearing one. Now he's winning again years later - not because of the brace, because RV retired and he has stepped his game up.

AC dominated his whole amateur career with one on, turned pro took it off, and has had the roughest few years of his career. Nothing to do with a brace, is just having a hard time.

Reed won and rode around with a number 1 plate for a year while wearing a brace.

(this list goes on)

At the end of the day they have to do what is comfortable for them, but the point is the best rider will rise to the top and win regardless, and whether it's with or without a brace it isn't making any difference in their performance, only putting them at risk.

Make the best decision for you, and your situation.

Yup, all good points. For the record, I wasn't saying it was a good reason, just pointing out what he said.
1/19/2016 9:40am
hillbilly wrote:
That brace looks so far from the helmet I dont see how it is going to help transfer force to the shoulders. And if you hit...
That brace looks so far from the helmet I dont see how it is going to help transfer force to the shoulders.

And if you hit in a way it tucks the head into the chest it seems to me the force would be centered on one area of the neck instead of thru out like without a brace.
If he was in a riding position it would be near touching, or touching.

We also include extra pads in the box to adjust the height of the brace, if the user wishes too. Since it would be touching in riding position (look at a photo of Wilson from the weekend in riding position, you will see what I mean), it is difficult to raise it up as it would further limit the field of vision for the rider - Which is a common issue for most average people, hence most braces getting a little lower.

Also your head doesn't just rotate in a crash, it gets compressed and rotated. Yes a higher brace would be more beneficial, but also wearing some brace is always better than no brace to help limit the compression and absorb the forces.

Side note - in testing we had helmets crush over the test dummy's shoulders. With a brace on this doesn't happen because the brace absorbs the energy and the foam shoulders distribute the forces over a wider area of the body. The sharp lower rim of helmets often times isn't doing your body any favours during a crash.
1/19/2016 9:41am
hvaughn88 wrote:
Yup, all good points. For the record, I wasn't saying it was a good reason, just pointing out what he said.
For sure, just adding to the conversation Smile
rjs
Posts
161
Joined
10/13/2009
Location
USA
1/19/2016 9:47am Edited Date/Time 1/19/2016 9:52am
deleted
1/19/2016 9:59am
I've had one of the original leatts for years but when i got my airoh a few months back I started running into issues. Picked up the new atlas and I love it! Got the defender chest protector too and it's a great combo. Lightweight and fair prices for both.
KennyT
Posts
4423
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Vista, CA, USA
1/19/2016 10:32am
It is so funny to read both sides of the beck brace issue. Neither side will ever win the discussion.

After riding for over 50 years now I have come to the conclusion that half of MC riders have the I don't give a fuck live or die no helmet needed ATV attitude and then the other half have the I value my life so I will have fun yet take any precaution I can to have fun another day and not end up 6' under or in a wheelchair attitude. I attribute my riding a bike for 50+ years to believing in safety first
peelout
Posts
18434
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT, USA
1/19/2016 10:35am
i've had mine basically bear trap me and had to have someone break the buckles apart to get the fucker off. regardless of what anyone here tells me or what pro wears one, i'll never wear one again.
1/19/2016 11:06am
From the look of his Instagram, it doesn't look like Herlings is wearing a neck brace now.
Grieby54
Posts
2826
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Castle Rock, CO, USA
1/19/2016 11:14am
hillbilly wrote:
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique...
I'd rather stick my head thru a wheelbarrow innertube and inflate the thing than wear one of those guillotine looking braces. And i have the unique experience of breaking my neck,being totally paralyzed ,getting my movement back and racing for several more years.

The looks of the brace seems to hinge the neck in a unnatural way,and the pics I see of the pros,the brace is so far from the base of the helmet that youd have to stob your neck down 3 inches into your chest before the brace comes into play.

If its your time it is your time,want to be safer,work out,be in shape and limber from stretching.
aeffertz wrote:
One of the dumbest posts I've ever read. Holy shit.
hillbilly wrote:
I've got dumber ones,look around.
He's not lying.
Cortami79
Posts
2036
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
NL
1/19/2016 11:21am
AtlasBrace wrote:
OW38B - Same reason many of them don't wear chest protectors. Just because they make a choice doesn't mean it's a good choice for an average...
OW38B - Same reason many of them don't wear chest protectors. Just because they make a choice doesn't mean it's a good choice for an average consumer, or an educated choice. It's all mental for them. It's all in what you believe. If you believe a softer pair of grips will make your lap times better (or someone tells you they will) then they will because you believe it and instinctively will go faster. If you have a shade of doubt about something your lap times will show it at that high of a level. It doesn't matter if its a grip, or zip tie in the wrong place... these guys are searching for any "advantage" and it's easy for them to take a brace off and say they "feel" better. I like going skinny dipping too but there is a time and a place, and for an average consumer, I am not sure the risks associated with riding is the right time to throw caution to the wind with protective gear. Pros at that level get paid huge sums of money to do that, consumers need to work on Monday and feed their family.

Meanwhile guys like Anderson, Canard, RV when he was active, Herlings, Dungey a few years back, and many others are winning races and championships with braces on, unaffected. Can't blame the others for searching, but it's usually not the equipment holding them back.
Herlings is not wearing any brace anymore (from what I see on his instagram)

Back on topic, what AtlasBrace (I don't know your name haha) is saying, it is all personal. I had them all, Leatt, Ortema, back to leatt, Atlas air and I still like riding without one the most. Most comfortable for me. I had a bad year this year with arm pump, stopped wearing my Atlas (thought that would help) and still had armpump after some laps, then I had a surgery on my arms and never raced with one since then. Maybe I will buy an Atlas or Ortema in the future.
newage
Posts
89
Joined
11/5/2010
Location
USA
1/19/2016 11:41am
DannyST107 wrote:
Leatt from last 2 year. [img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2016/01/18/120391/s1200_FB_IMG_1453157916032.jpg[/img] New atlas for this season [img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2016/01/18/120392/s1200_20160108_174728.jpg[/img] Lightweight, 600 gram Look good Alot of clearance Nothing on spine Just shoulders Cheap...
Leatt from last 2 year.


New atlas for this season


Lightweight, 600 gram
Look good
Alot of clearance
Nothing on spine Just shoulders
Cheap compared to leatt
Sits fine on leatt protector

Also want to add that the leatt suffered quite some impacts lately, small and big. Always left me with a sore neck or as a result of a small tipover, a whiplash currently.

Always had pain on the same spot on my neck, where the backside of my brace meets my neck.

Hence the choice for atlas this year
cslacker wrote:
Can you even contact the new brace looking up as high as possible? That back looks extremely low on the new atlas.
hillbilly wrote:
That brace looks so far from the helmet I dont see how it is going to help transfer force to the shoulders. And if you hit...
That brace looks so far from the helmet I dont see how it is going to help transfer force to the shoulders.

And if you hit in a way it tucks the head into the chest it seems to me the force would be centered on one area of the neck instead of thru out like without a brace.
I have a question. I thought that the section on the back of the helmet was supposed to be high to stop the head from going back. Looking at the new atlas brace it shows that the back is very low, why the big change? I have a leatt that is high in the back, is that wrong?

1/19/2016 12:27pm
newage wrote:
I have a question. I thought that the section on the back of the helmet was supposed to be high to stop the head from going...
I have a question. I thought that the section on the back of the helmet was supposed to be high to stop the head from going back. Looking at the new atlas brace it shows that the back is very low, why the big change? I have a leatt that is high in the back, is that wrong?

Great question!

The height and the curvature are 2 different things.

The height is lower because helmets have started getting bigger (lower), along with the addition of "fins" or what ever you would like to call them (think the back of the Shoei). The market is asking for lower braces, so we offer them along with height adjustment so that the user can tailor them to their needs.

The curvature of the leatt is in an effort to help prevent shearing (head going strait backwards). We found the big downfall of that is that it can act as a shovel into the ground during a crash, causing further manipulation of the head/neck/body so we opted to go away from that. We believe in keeping things in motion during a crash, but controlling those motions to manageable speeds, so we ended up with this profile. This is also why we do not pad the top of the brace, we want the helmet to continue sliding instead of planting firmly in one spot - Same reason you wouldn't pad the outside of a helmet. A stars also made their newer generation Bionic brace this way, similar to our shape, going away from the big scoop in the back that it used to have when they first came out.
hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
1/19/2016 1:15pm
If that is near normal clearance as you said in riding position it would almost be touching then what happens when you dont crash in the riding position?

I broke my neck going straight in ,falling over the front of the bike flying w style. I hung on,head down by the wheel,till the bike was going so slow it was wobbling. I hit like a javelin and broke it.

The helmet would need to be resting on the brace nearly in the standing position just like that picture for it to help it seems to me.

And, i get it,riders fear this injury more than any other and want something that gives a feeling of safety,. If it does that for you then wear it.

I wear kneebraces but know that it may break my femur to save my knee,its about the same kinda thing.
hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
1/19/2016 1:19pm
aeffertz wrote:
One of the dumbest posts I've ever read. Holy shit.
hillbilly wrote:
I've got dumber ones,look around.
Grieby54 wrote:
He's not lying.
Yeah,some of the stupidest stuff ever was when I was trying to communicate with you.
mx317
Posts
5423
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/19/2016 1:32pm Edited Date/Time 1/19/2016 1:38pm
hillbilly wrote:
If that is near normal clearance as you said in riding position it would almost be touching then what happens when you dont crash in the...
If that is near normal clearance as you said in riding position it would almost be touching then what happens when you dont crash in the riding position?

I broke my neck going straight in ,falling over the front of the bike flying w style. I hung on,head down by the wheel,till the bike was going so slow it was wobbling. I hit like a javelin and broke it.

The helmet would need to be resting on the brace nearly in the standing position just like that picture for it to help it seems to me.

And, i get it,riders fear this injury more than any other and want something that gives a feeling of safety,. If it does that for you then wear it.

I wear kneebraces but know that it may break my femur to save my knee,its about the same kinda thing.
Dave that describes a crash I had about 3 years ago perfect. Straight down the fork tube with legs over my head. I was wearing an A-Star brace (now Atlas) then and even though I was knocked out and nearly bit my tongue through and through, I walked away. My shoulders and chest were bruised from the brace and my helmet (Arai) was toast, but I say again, I walked away. Did the brace save me from being hurt worse? I can't say for sure, but I think it did.
1/19/2016 1:34pm
hillbilly wrote:
If that is near normal clearance as you said in riding position it would almost be touching then what happens when you dont crash in the...
If that is near normal clearance as you said in riding position it would almost be touching then what happens when you dont crash in the riding position?

I broke my neck going straight in ,falling over the front of the bike flying w style. I hung on,head down by the wheel,till the bike was going so slow it was wobbling. I hit like a javelin and broke it.

The helmet would need to be resting on the brace nearly in the standing position just like that picture for it to help it seems to me.

And, i get it,riders fear this injury more than any other and want something that gives a feeling of safety,. If it does that for you then wear it.

I wear kneebraces but know that it may break my femur to save my knee,its about the same kinda thing.
I would say that photo is above average, but yes and no to what you are asking.

There are just too many scenarios when crashing to go through them all, but if you can limit compression you are on the right track, so having a brace there in any capacity is better than not. The helmet doesn't need to be resting on it because your neck (all parts of your body) have a range at which they can stretch, compress, deform, bend, move, etc before an injury occurs. Your body does a pretty good job at protecting itself to a certain degree, but after that it needs some help - this is where safety equipment comes in.

Moral of the story: Limiting the compression is a good thing, and without a brace, there is no limit.
Underdog999
Posts
662
Joined
11/20/2011
Location
Kalaheo, HI, USA
1/19/2016 3:18pm
Facts: 1) Necks have been broken while wearing neck braces. In particular, Leatt neck braces. 2) They have never been scientifically tested, even though there's nothing...
Facts:
1) Necks have been broken while wearing neck braces. In particular, Leatt neck braces.
2) They have never been scientifically tested, even though there's nothing preventing the manufacturers from conducting tests on cadavers.
3) Plenty of people survived traumatic accidents prior to neck braces coming on the market.

Neck braces are a theory that have never been tested and people are still breaking their necks while wearing them. In other words, they are snake oil.
People have still died wearing seat belts, are those snake oil, too?

People have still died wearing helmets, are those snake oil, too?

Post a reply to: Is the Leatt fad now over ?

The Latest