mxa/ stewart news?

Fraser
Posts
780
Joined
9/12/2008
Location
Leics, GB
12/16/2014 9:39am
You must be dumb? Its not about enforcing the rules im all for the rule book and enforcing the rules.....its the discipline that needs to be...
You must be dumb?

Its not about enforcing the rules im all for the rule book and enforcing the rules.....its the discipline that needs to be written out. you cant run a company without them. Name me one sports league that has an * for their rulebook.

Go to the Nfl rule book

First offense for adderall is a 4 game suspension

Baseball, track, swiming, basketball, and all these sports have written penalties and very quick turn arounds on their disciplinary actions...but guess who doesnt? Fim

Its one thing if these actions come within a reasonable timeframe, but this is ridiculous...Im pretty sure that James could have saved a lot of time in life and money having the correct rules and disciplinary actions in place.

Fraser wrote:
He'd have saved himself a great deal of time and money if he'd followed the [b]rules[/b] that were already in place, and not taken a banned...
He'd have saved himself a great deal of time and money if he'd followed the rules that were already in place, and not taken a banned substance without a TUE in the first place. Blame the FIM and WADA as much as you like, there's only one person responsible for his failed drug test. (and its not me by the way)
So you don't think the AMA/FIM should've already had penalties written out in case something like this happened?
Maybe, certainly would have been better if we'd been told what was happening in June.

But I guess with any drug testing policy the goal posts are constantly moving, and at least they say they consider each case individually.
davistld01
Posts
9288
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Springfield, MO, USA
12/16/2014 9:40am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 9:40am
Fraser wrote:
He'd have saved himself a great deal of time and money if he'd followed the [b]rules[/b] that were already in place, and not taken a banned...
He'd have saved himself a great deal of time and money if he'd followed the rules that were already in place, and not taken a banned substance without a TUE in the first place. Blame the FIM and WADA as much as you like, there's only one person responsible for his failed drug test. (and its not me by the way)
davistld01 wrote:
Why keep hammering the point, Fraser?
Fraser wrote:
Dunno, just frustrates me the number of people that want to blame everyone else in sight for one team's mistake. I'm getting tired of arguing now...
Dunno, just frustrates me the number of people that want to blame everyone else in sight for one team's mistake. I'm getting tired of arguing now though. Lets hope that FIM press release comes quick so we can get back to arguing about the MXDN.
For whatever reason it happened, James did break the rules. But I'm hoping for at least some leniency so we can watch the man ride this year instead of fading off of the grid with a jacked up legacy.
Olson
Posts
4605
Joined
4/14/2012
Location
SE
12/16/2014 9:40am
Flip109 wrote:
Man that racerx post sure makes it sound like he won't be racing this year. What a shame!
When the article even mentions Lucas Oil Pro Motocross it certainly looks bad regarding Monster Energy Supercross.
Fraser
Posts
780
Joined
9/12/2008
Location
Leics, GB
12/16/2014 9:53am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 10:01am
Aye~ I feel like im talking to my 5 year old... Didnt you just tell me you have the penalty structure? So please inform me. Is...
Aye~

I feel like im talking to my 5 year old...

Didnt you just tell me you have the penalty structure? So please inform me. Is James racing or not? Whip out that magic rule book of yours, where everything is clearly written out.

Man you're aggressive. I'm assuming that reply was aimed at me? You're 5 year old not understand what you're on about either?

No, I didn't tell you I had the penalty structure, how could I? All any of us can do is look at the rules that exist, and try and stick to them.

AMA rules-
4.5 Substance Abuse Policy
a. 450SX and 250SX class.
1. The 450SX and 250SX class riders will follow the terms and
conditions of the FIM Anti Doping Code.
b. AMA Officials and Crew credential holders.
1. AMA Officials and crew credential holders will follow the
terms and conditions of the AMA Substance Abuse Policy.
c. Random tests for drugs and alcohol may be conducted at the
discretion of AMA the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners.
d. Compliance with the FIM Anti-Doping Code or AMA's
Substance Abuse Policy is an essential precondition to the
issuance of a Professional Competition license or event
credential.
e. Any violation of the policy or refusal to submit to testing as
requested by AMA, the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners may result in the immediate suspension of the
competitor’s license and loss of all rights to compete in AMA
Professional, AMA Amateur sanctioned events, or FIM
sanctioned events.
f. Both the AMA Substance Abuse Policy and the FIM Anti
Doping Code are available upon request from the AMA office.

FIM rule book for a first offence




And if you can't prove the above conditions its a 2 yr ban for a first offence.

The Shop

12/16/2014 9:59am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 10:02am
Fraser wrote:
He'd have saved himself a great deal of time and money if he'd followed the [b]rules[/b] that were already in place, and not taken a banned...
He'd have saved himself a great deal of time and money if he'd followed the rules that were already in place, and not taken a banned substance without a TUE in the first place. Blame the FIM and WADA as much as you like, there's only one person responsible for his failed drug test. (and its not me by the way)
So you don't think the AMA/FIM should've already had penalties written out in case something like this happened?
Fraser wrote:
Maybe, certainly would have been better if we'd been told what was happening in June. But I guess with any drug testing policy the goal posts...
Maybe, certainly would have been better if we'd been told what was happening in June.

But I guess with any drug testing policy the goal posts are constantly moving, and at least they say they consider each case individually.
That's only because the AMA/FIM refused to write rules for what happens if rider x fails a drug test.
If only an organization existed that had done that before.... Wait, the NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, MLS, Cricket.

If the AMA/FIM simply had it in writing that the first failed drug test is x amount of races, it's fair for everyone and we don't have these things linger over the sports head forever. You need something more concrete then, "We might ban you for two years, who knows."

If this is not a good sign that the AMA/FIM has failed this sport, I don't know what is.

They didn't even understand they should put a camera on the finish line in case a race was really close for fucks sake...
12/16/2014 10:06am
Fraser wrote:
Man you're aggressive. I'm assuming that reply was aimed at me? You're 5 year old not understand what you're on about either? No, I didn't tell...
Man you're aggressive. I'm assuming that reply was aimed at me? You're 5 year old not understand what you're on about either?

No, I didn't tell you I had the penalty structure, how could I? All any of us can do is look at the rules that exist, and try and stick to them.

AMA rules-
4.5 Substance Abuse Policy
a. 450SX and 250SX class.
1. The 450SX and 250SX class riders will follow the terms and
conditions of the FIM Anti Doping Code.
b. AMA Officials and Crew credential holders.
1. AMA Officials and crew credential holders will follow the
terms and conditions of the AMA Substance Abuse Policy.
c. Random tests for drugs and alcohol may be conducted at the
discretion of AMA the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners.
d. Compliance with the FIM Anti-Doping Code or AMA's
Substance Abuse Policy is an essential precondition to the
issuance of a Professional Competition license or event
credential.
e. Any violation of the policy or refusal to submit to testing as
requested by AMA, the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners may result in the immediate suspension of the
competitor’s license and loss of all rights to compete in AMA
Professional, AMA Amateur sanctioned events, or FIM
sanctioned events.
f. Both the AMA Substance Abuse Policy and the FIM Anti
Doping Code are available upon request from the AMA office.

FIM rule book for a first offence




And if you can't prove the above conditions its a 2 yr ban for a first offence.
That last bit is what everyone has a problem with.
It says, "depending on the person, we might just slap you on the wrist, or we might banish you for two years."

Make it fair and say regardless, a first offense is X amount of time.
hasko158
Posts
874
Joined
8/14/2010
Location
Charlotte, NC, USA
12/16/2014 10:33am
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if they approved that same TUE for the motocross series.
12/16/2014 10:33am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 10:34am
Aye~ I feel like im talking to my 5 year old... Didnt you just tell me you have the penalty structure? So please inform me. Is...
Aye~

I feel like im talking to my 5 year old...

Didnt you just tell me you have the penalty structure? So please inform me. Is James racing or not? Whip out that magic rule book of yours, where everything is clearly written out.

Fraser wrote:
Man you're aggressive. I'm assuming that reply was aimed at me? You're 5 year old not understand what you're on about either? No, I didn't tell...
Man you're aggressive. I'm assuming that reply was aimed at me? You're 5 year old not understand what you're on about either?

No, I didn't tell you I had the penalty structure, how could I? All any of us can do is look at the rules that exist, and try and stick to them.

AMA rules-
4.5 Substance Abuse Policy
a. 450SX and 250SX class.
1. The 450SX and 250SX class riders will follow the terms and
conditions of the FIM Anti Doping Code.
b. AMA Officials and Crew credential holders.
1. AMA Officials and crew credential holders will follow the
terms and conditions of the AMA Substance Abuse Policy.
c. Random tests for drugs and alcohol may be conducted at the
discretion of AMA the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners.
d. Compliance with the FIM Anti-Doping Code or AMA's
Substance Abuse Policy is an essential precondition to the
issuance of a Professional Competition license or event
credential.
e. Any violation of the policy or refusal to submit to testing as
requested by AMA, the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners may result in the immediate suspension of the
competitor’s license and loss of all rights to compete in AMA
Professional, AMA Amateur sanctioned events, or FIM
sanctioned events.
f. Both the AMA Substance Abuse Policy and the FIM Anti
Doping Code are available upon request from the AMA office.

FIM rule book for a first offence




And if you can't prove the above conditions its a 2 yr ban for a first offence.
Aggressive how?

You clearly indicated that if I took the time to read the rule book, all that I need to know would be there for me to read. Well I read it and still no answers? So why not just admit that you are wrong in this instance...and ask yourself what would be good for our sport, a sport with rules, but dont apply to all riders in certain conditions based on fan base or royalties or pure discretion. Or a sport that has rules that have parameters and procedures that need to be followed per disciplinary actions, no matter the sanctioning bodies, persons or investigative actions that all persons racing will fall under the same penalty no matter the circumstances. An appeals process can insure that said rider will have his time to speak, however till that time of appeals (which also should have a time frame associated with it) a disciplinary action has been enforced.
12/16/2014 10:42am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 10:48am
hasko158 wrote:
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if...
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if they approved that same TUE for the motocross series.
In the nhl its 20 games no pay

Nfl 4 games no pay

Mlb 25 games no pay

Nba 5 games no pay

Track and field is 6 months of sanctioned racing

See a trend here...not sports league is over a complete season and all are clear as day on the infraction and disciplinary action.

Keep in mind those are for basic ped, growth hormones afe much harsher in discipline...mandatory 2 year ban from track and field

All major sports leagues also have harsher penalties plus fines for growth hormones and steroid use. Plus WADA is pushing for double penalty time for growth hormone/steroid usage which shows how much more the drug is looked at.

12/16/2014 10:43am
hasko158 wrote:
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if...
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if they approved that same TUE for the motocross series.
The NFL understands that sports are really only athletic entertainment and not some gift bestowed on us from the gods.
12/16/2014 10:49am
Terrible. There has to be a punishment, but anything over four races is BS.
12/16/2014 11:07am
I dont if anyone has instagram, but mxa instagram has a pic of #7 and it says under it, whose ready for sx? I ll tell ya what, if js7 is suspended mxa is a COMPLETLY fcked up company! Thats about as shady as u can get!
peelout
Posts
18384
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT, USA
12/16/2014 11:07am
That last bit is what everyone has a problem with. It says, "depending on the person, we might just slap you on the wrist, or we...
That last bit is what everyone has a problem with.
It says, "depending on the person, we might just slap you on the wrist, or we might banish you for two years."

Make it fair and say regardless, a first offense is X amount of time.
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different.

you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set punishment. you guys kept bringing up cold medicine and other shit, would it be fair if something traced from cold medicine was the same penalty as finding an obvious PED in someone's system?

you guys can go on and on about how long it's taken, but i look at it as it is a very complex issue with Stewart and his prescription and the lack of a TUE, all avenues need to be exhausted before handing down a fine. obviously they're looking into WHY Stewart never had a TUE, how long his prescription has been in effect, and other things.

carry on.
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
12/16/2014 11:11am
peelout wrote:
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different. you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set...
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different.

you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set punishment. you guys kept bringing up cold medicine and other shit, would it be fair if something traced from cold medicine was the same penalty as finding an obvious PED in someone's system?

you guys can go on and on about how long it's taken, but i look at it as it is a very complex issue with Stewart and his prescription and the lack of a TUE, all avenues need to be exhausted before handing down a fine. obviously they're looking into WHY Stewart never had a TUE, how long his prescription has been in effect, and other things.

carry on.
Yep, peelout brings it.
mx_563
Posts
2198
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/16/2014 11:14am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 11:17am
Matthes said he reached out to WADA and they said it was in the FIM's hands...Next thing I know I've got my tin foil conspiracy theory hat on, and I'm rubbing my chin....

what if the processing time and subsequent punishment (which RaceX is reporting MAY affect James' ourdoor national eligibility) are all part of a grand scheme by the FIM and Luongo (and mxgeoff, what the heck, I'll throw him in there too) to back James into a corner wherein his only option is to race GPs in 2015?

Uuaaaaaaaaahahahahaha.........!!!!!!




(obviously I'm joking and yes, Peelout always brings it!)
hasko158
Posts
874
Joined
8/14/2010
Location
Charlotte, NC, USA
12/16/2014 11:20am
hasko158 wrote:
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if...
NFL players get 4 games for this same offense. I know it's not WADA but this penalty is steep for a 1st time offense, especially if they approved that same TUE for the motocross series.
The NFL understands that sports are really only athletic entertainment and not some gift bestowed on us from the gods.


Exactly!
hasko158
Posts
874
Joined
8/14/2010
Location
Charlotte, NC, USA
12/16/2014 11:23am
How could they suspend him for the motocross series where his TUE was approved? This sport is so jacked it's not even funny.
12/16/2014 11:29am Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 11:32am
That last bit is what everyone has a problem with. It says, "depending on the person, we might just slap you on the wrist, or we...
That last bit is what everyone has a problem with.
It says, "depending on the person, we might just slap you on the wrist, or we might banish you for two years."

Make it fair and say regardless, a first offense is X amount of time.
peelout wrote:
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different. you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set...
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different.

you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set punishment. you guys kept bringing up cold medicine and other shit, would it be fair if something traced from cold medicine was the same penalty as finding an obvious PED in someone's system?

you guys can go on and on about how long it's taken, but i look at it as it is a very complex issue with Stewart and his prescription and the lack of a TUE, all avenues need to be exhausted before handing down a fine. obviously they're looking into WHY Stewart never had a TUE, how long his prescription has been in effect, and other things.

carry on.
Same could be said that adderall and steroids are being classified as the same currently...

At the end of the day this is what testing brings to our sport, so yes if you want testing then certain cold medicines should also be classified as a ped as its on the Wada list.

This is what appeals process is for, then they can make a decision on what the final ruling should be after everythiing is brought into the equation. With a set timeline in place a proper process and written procedures that takes precedence above all else.
theToothPerry
Posts
538
Joined
11/23/2010
Location
Santa Clarita, CA, USA
12/16/2014 11:34am
Theyre about to make an example out of him. Lets let someone in Europe decide what happens with series in America. Good idea AMA.
kongols
Posts
24222
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/16/2014 11:38am
Who want`s to bet me 20 bucks he`ll be on a line at A1? If they are waiting for Stewart to brake the news it`s all good.
12/16/2014 11:57am
kongols wrote:
Who want`s to bet me 20 bucks he`ll be on a line at A1? If they are waiting for Stewart to brake the news it`s all...
Who want`s to bet me 20 bucks he`ll be on a line at A1? If they are waiting for Stewart to brake the news it`s all good.
I agree with you 100%

rippaaa
Posts
366
Joined
11/22/2014
Location
CA
12/16/2014 12:01pm Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 12:01pm
MotoXaddicts posted about it saying a 4 race ban. Hold it loosely..
12/16/2014 12:04pm
AMA rules-
4.5 Substance Abuse Policy
a. 450SX and 250SX class.
1. The 450SX and 250SX class riders will follow the terms and
conditions of the FIM Anti Doping Code.
b. AMA Officials and Crew credential holders.
1. AMA Officials and crew credential holders will follow the
terms and conditions of the AMA Substance Abuse Policy.
c. Random tests for drugs and alcohol may be conducted at the
discretion of AMA the FIM or their respective drug-testing
partners.

Wow, sure hope they don't test the crew members.. I would predict mass job openings.
12/16/2014 12:12pm
peelout wrote:
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different. you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set...
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different.

you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set punishment. you guys kept bringing up cold medicine and other shit, would it be fair if something traced from cold medicine was the same penalty as finding an obvious PED in someone's system?

you guys can go on and on about how long it's taken, but i look at it as it is a very complex issue with Stewart and his prescription and the lack of a TUE, all avenues need to be exhausted before handing down a fine. obviously they're looking into WHY Stewart never had a TUE, how long his prescription has been in effect, and other things.

carry on.
A "pro" sport shouldn't be using WADA.
They really should have their own drug testing policies, rules, etc and that would rlimunste tge cold medication problem. I don't know of many others that even test for that.
But.
This seribg how it's run by the circus and ran like a circus, maybe it's time we stop calling it professional.
Sandberm
Posts
5845
Joined
3/27/2009
Location
Pasco, WA, USA
12/16/2014 12:13pm
Why would the Lucas Oil MX Nationals honor the penalty against Stewart NOW....when they did not go along with the banning of Stewart racing that the FIM placed on James in June?

GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
12/16/2014 12:14pm
A "pro" sport shouldn't be using WADA. They really should have their own drug testing policies, rules, etc and that would rlimunste tge cold medication problem...
A "pro" sport shouldn't be using WADA.
They really should have their own drug testing policies, rules, etc and that would rlimunste tge cold medication problem. I don't know of many others that even test for that.
But.
This seribg how it's run by the circus and ran like a circus, maybe it's time we stop calling it professional.
Okay, time for a little break to come up with some better material.
Zracer
Posts
1479
Joined
2/17/2013
Location
Saint Clair, MI, USA
12/16/2014 12:15pm
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2014/12/16/74031/s1200_Screenshot_2014_12_16_12_02_54.jpg[/img] Who wouldnt want to see more of this





Who wouldnt want to see more of this
As it says form the real JS7 . "Sometimes lowering the bar isnt a bad thing. " Well that about says is all.
kongols
Posts
24222
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
12/16/2014 12:16pm
Whatever the outcome, Crash will demand explanation.Woohoo Whistling Wink
12/16/2014 12:16pm
peelout wrote:
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different. you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set...
the point is that every case SHOULD be and IS different.

you should be happy that every case is different and that there isn't a set punishment. you guys kept bringing up cold medicine and other shit, would it be fair if something traced from cold medicine was the same penalty as finding an obvious PED in someone's system?

you guys can go on and on about how long it's taken, but i look at it as it is a very complex issue with Stewart and his prescription and the lack of a TUE, all avenues need to be exhausted before handing down a fine. obviously they're looking into WHY Stewart never had a TUE, how long his prescription has been in effect, and other things.

carry on.
I Think if he got the prescription after he got caught then he will miss the complete season. In my opinion that is the key to his punishment.

Post a reply to: mxa/ stewart news?

The Latest