who is the favourite in 250 nationals?

Huckster
Posts
2585
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Woodstock, NY, USA
5/9/2012 2:43pm
Huckster wrote:
actually your last statement is not true.....Ratray moved up and as you know finished 2nd o/a and won multiple races last year.....but whose keeping track of...
actually your last statement is not true.....Ratray moved up and as you know finished 2nd o/a and won multiple races last year.....but whose keeping track of the facts.....
NoGo wrote:
So rattray has left .What is your point ? They didn't beat him either. And with the addition of roczen and bogle doesn't help. Hell they...
So rattray has left .What is your point ? They didn't beat him either. And with the addition of roczen and bogle doesn't help. Hell they still have to finish ahead of Cunningham he was 4th or 5th in championship.
my point is your last statement is not true.....And as one who clearly likes to point out "facts" you should be able to appreciate that......
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/9/2012 2:47pm
Huckster wrote:
my point is your last statement is not true.....And as one who clearly likes to point out "facts" you should be able to appreciate that......
That's really all you've got? Because I failed to remember a rider that has only left the class in the past 3 days.
5/9/2012 2:48pm
Huckster wrote:
Marvin Musquin, Red Bull KTM, 6th in Lites West main, 5th in East/West Shootout Racer X: So this is your first Las Vegas East/West Shootout. How...
Marvin Musquin, Red Bull KTM, 6th in Lites West main, 5th in East/West Shootout



Racer X: So this is your first Las Vegas East/West Shootout. How did it treat you?
Marvin Musquin: It was a really tough race. The track was really rough, and it got really dry and hard packed. That was kind of difficult. I rode well during the Shootout with Roczen—he was riding really good. We finished out of the podium, but it was still a really good race, especially after some bad news this morning. I had an X-ray at the Asterisk truck and there is a little crack on my hand—the one that I broke last year at Freestone. I don’t know what I’m going to do for the outdoors. I want to ride, but I also need to get better.


Was that from last weekend?
Yeah, I crashed during the heat race with [Martin] Davalos. I had a small crash, actually, but it hurt my hand. I raced the main event right after. It hurt a little bit, but during the week I couldn’t ride outdoors. I tried to ride and it wasn’t possible. I had an X-ray and it didn’t show anything, so I was kind of surprised this morning when they said it was cracked. That sucks, you know, but I’ll get ready for outdoors.
The worst news of the day for us, french MX fans...

Angry
Huckster
Posts
2585
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Woodstock, NY, USA
5/9/2012 2:52pm
Huckster wrote:
my point is your last statement is not true.....And as one who clearly likes to point out "facts" you should be able to appreciate that......
NoGo wrote:
That's really all you've got? Because I failed to remember a rider that has only left the class in the past 3 days.
no actually you ignored my previous post......Care to respond to that? Your logic has many holes......

The Shop

NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/9/2012 2:55pm
Huckster wrote:
no actually you ignored my previous post......Care to respond to that? Your logic has many holes......
I responded. Go back a page.
Huckster
Posts
2585
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Woodstock, NY, USA
5/9/2012 3:08pm
NoGo wrote:
Don't count it as a full season? No I don't because he didn't line up every Moto. Barcias rookie season dungey won the title and barcia...
Don't count it as a full season? No I don't because he didn't line up every Moto.

Barcias rookie season dungey won the title and barcia won an overall. The next season dungey was gone and he still didn't win an overall. Last year dungey pourcel and canard were gone and he didn't win a 250 overall. The only guys who won an overall in 09 -10 that don't have a national title are barcia, tomac, and weimer. Wilson won overalls in 2010 and the following year won the title.

Although he is injured , Wilson is still in the class and his shoulder doesnt seem to hold him to far back. So they still have to deal with last years champ as well as the guy he was battling with on top of another gp champ being added to the class. And you think theyre favorites ?when neither had anything for pc the whole summer. Great sx season but I don't see any indication of things going the same come hangtown. Daytona was the only partial sign we saw of what is to come for outdoors and baggett ran down barcia twice in a shortened main event.
my bad I did not see this.....

Last year he was hurt going into the season and he showed he had the speed but he couldn't put it together for two moto's for whatever reason on the 250F. No denying that. However, based off the speed that he did show, his results on the 450 at years end and his complete dominance of Roczen, Baggett, Bogle and the rest in SX this year, it is not a stretch to consider him amongst the favorites for this years outdoor title. Most would say that he has increased his speed and has become way more consistent. If you do not see that and do not feel that he is a "contender" than your are entitled to your opinion but most would question your judgement.

Baggett didnt line up for the full season because he ate shit and hurt himself....no ones fault other than his. It's his third season this year no matter how you try to twist that....Heck Justin battled through mono and a broken wrist last year. Would you think differently of him if he had chose not to ride outdoors in '11 until he was fully healthy?
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/9/2012 3:15pm
Huckster wrote:
my bad I did not see this..... Last year he was hurt going into the season and he showed he had the speed but he couldn't...
my bad I did not see this.....

Last year he was hurt going into the season and he showed he had the speed but he couldn't put it together for two moto's for whatever reason on the 250F. No denying that. However, based off the speed that he did show, his results on the 450 at years end and his complete dominance of Roczen, Baggett, Bogle and the rest in SX this year, it is not a stretch to consider him amongst the favorites for this years outdoor title. Most would say that he has increased his speed and has become way more consistent. If you do not see that and do not feel that he is a "contender" than your are entitled to your opinion but most would question your judgement.

Baggett didnt line up for the full season because he ate shit and hurt himself....no ones fault other than his. It's his third season this year no matter how you try to twist that....Heck Justin battled through mono and a broken wrist last year. Would you think differently of him if he had chose not to ride outdoors in '11 until he was fully healthy?
Yes I would count barcias results differently had he sat out 2011, because if he had it wouldn't have been a full year wether the crash was his fault or not. Barcia was hurt going into the season but he won a regional title hurt and did well when put on a 450. He would be a contender of he showed speed outdoors on a small bike. Which he has not done in 2 years. His abbreviated 450 stint and this years sx arent an indicator of what will go down outdoors. I wouldn't exactly say he became more consistent in sx either I would say the rider closest to his speed last year( Wilson) switched coast. No other rider last year including baggett was on their level.
Huckster
Posts
2585
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Woodstock, NY, USA
5/9/2012 3:31pm
I guess your forget that he did have a few moto podiums on the 250f last year so speed is not the question. Riding SX with a broken wrist and then heading to the great outdoors are two completely different animals with respect to the punishment your wrist takes and how long you're on the bike. Are you going to argue that?

We will find out soon enough if you are right. I actually think he would have a better chance of winning the title on a 450 but I still think he has to be considered a "contender" in the 250F class......

Wilson's hurt, Roczen appears to have some arm pump issues, Musquin has a broken wrist, Durham is out so who is left besides Baggett? If Baggett's lack of SX speed and desire are any indication of his season to come, its going to be interesting....
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/9/2012 3:42pm
I'm not arguing that mx isnt harder on the body. But he did fine when put on the 450 do saying his wrist injury held him back isn't all that accurate.

Like you said we've just go to wait til hangtown. Roczen and musquin are question marks. Bogle showed speed. Wilson's hurt but not held back.wil Hahn is healthy. Baggetts shitty sx season which didn't turn around til the last few rounds.
Sherwood
Posts
3682
Joined
5/12/2010
Location
USA
5/9/2012 4:34pm
Sherwood wrote:
It's not that you point them out it's that you go out of your way to do so. Every other post is about how the Geico...
It's not that you point them out it's that you go out of your way to do so.

Every other post is about how the Geico squad sucks outdoors. It makes you sound like your bitter they won the E and W title.
NoGo wrote:
How am I going out of my way when this whole thread is about 250 outdoor favorites and why they are or are not a favorite...
How am I going out of my way when this whole thread is about 250 outdoor favorites and why they are or are not a favorite.

Youve stretched my words completely. I've never said the geico squad sucks outdoors. I said they haven't performed and that is a reality. Just like how PC hasn't performed indoors this year. Obviously geico doesn't suck outdoors they won the title in '10.

I'm in no way bitter about their regional title sweep nor am I bitter about barcias title last year. He and tomac are both animals indoors. They had the 2012 titles on a stranglehold right from the beginning.

As was proven last year their sx results don't translate to mx. I don't see that changing when none of the competition has left there's only more that have came in( roczen,bogle)
When you say things like, "but when outdoors come around barcia is everyones bitch" you're going out of your way to talk bad about a rider. Any thread that's brought up with Barcia, even if it's SX related you go out of your way to say, "Well he won't do that outdoors."

It would be different if I was the only person that thought you where bitter about Barcia, but about 4 or 5 others have said the same thing.
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/9/2012 4:57pm
Sherwood wrote:
When you say things like, "but when outdoors come around barcia is everyones bitch" you're going out of your way to talk bad about a rider...
When you say things like, "but when outdoors come around barcia is everyones bitch" you're going out of your way to talk bad about a rider. Any thread that's brought up with Barcia, even if it's SX related you go out of your way to say, "Well he won't do that outdoors."

It would be different if I was the only person that thought you where bitter about Barcia, but about 4 or 5 others have said the same thing.
If you actually looked at the post I was responding too you'd know why I said when outdoors comes he's everyone's bitch. It I was bitter I'd say he sucks altogether. And his back to back regional titles were a gift or something to that effect.that Is not the case , he earned both his titles 100% and dominated this season as a whole. His indoor domination and skill have yet I translate in an outdoor season. And I have always begun by saying that. Then people want to say " well they were barcias bitch indoors" so I responded back. I did not come out of nowhere with that remark. Clearly you read my posts so u think you would have seen what I responded back to instead of just bringing up one specific thing I said.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13255
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
5/10/2012 9:41am
Putting who's the favorite aside for a moment: Bogle, Wharton . . . contenders or spoilers, or neither? Others?
TeamGreen
Posts
37095
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
5/10/2012 9:43am
12
mccread
Posts
5934
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
5/10/2012 10:50am
Putting who's the favorite aside for a moment: Bogle, Wharton . . . contenders or spoilers, or neither? Others?
Spoilers, as would Durham and a few others ... can't see those guys being title contenders though.
Paul333
Posts
2195
Joined
2/15/2012
Location
Virginia Beach, VA, USA
5/10/2012 1:27pm
Tough one to call.

Pro Circuit is stacked but have a few riders injured. Geico Honda is stacked. Rockstar Suzuki and Yamaha might have a rider jump out.

Everyone always forgets that being fast indoors does not always mean you will be a top rider outdoors.
M-M
Posts
2138
Joined
11/20/2008
Location
GB
5/10/2012 2:02pm Edited Date/Time 5/10/2012 2:05pm
Barcia has to be favourite for the outdoors. No wrist problems/mono/etc for him this time. I would have said Wilson if he wasn't injured(?) Also Baggett if he's finds those flashes of unbelievable speed he had last year.




I will be backing the KTM boys though.
Ripper02
Posts
130
Joined
4/27/2012
Location
Santa Monica, CA, USA
5/10/2012 3:05pm
I think Baggett has been thinking about outdoors all SX season, he'll come out swinging just like he did last year, he believes he can win outside
5/10/2012 4:34pm
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person is labeled a hater. Think about this for a sec ... what has Barcia done outdoors on a 250? One cannot take his supercross success and extrapolate that to the outdoors. NoGo is using facts ... I don't think Barcia can be considered a favorite for the title until he proves he can consistently run up front on a 250.

I think Barcia did well on a 450 because there were no expectations. I really think that because he was considered a favorite for the 250 and then failed to meet expectations he put a lot of pressure on himself. If Barcia starts strong I think he will be strong the entire outdoor season. If not, he'll be moved up to the 450.

Barcia reminds me so much of Bradshaw.

My predictions in this order:

1. Deano (if healthy)
2. Roczen
3. Baggett
4. Marvin
5. Tomac
Sherwood
Posts
3682
Joined
5/12/2010
Location
USA
5/10/2012 4:39pm
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person...
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person is labeled a hater. Think about this for a sec ... what has Barcia done outdoors on a 250? One cannot take his supercross success and extrapolate that to the outdoors. NoGo is using facts ... I don't think Barcia can be considered a favorite for the title until he proves he can consistently run up front on a 250.

I think Barcia did well on a 450 because there were no expectations. I really think that because he was considered a favorite for the 250 and then failed to meet expectations he put a lot of pressure on himself. If Barcia starts strong I think he will be strong the entire outdoor season. If not, he'll be moved up to the 450.

Barcia reminds me so much of Bradshaw.

My predictions in this order:

1. Deano (if healthy)
2. Roczen
3. Baggett
4. Marvin
5. Tomac
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX.

When you hear him spew the same crap again and again in any thread that brings up the name Barcia it paints a picture.
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/10/2012 4:43pm
Sherwood wrote:
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX. When you hear...
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX.

When you hear him spew the same crap again and again in any thread that brings up the name Barcia it paints a picture.
I spew facts not slander. Its not like what I'm saying is inaccurate.
5/10/2012 4:51pm
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person...
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person is labeled a hater. Think about this for a sec ... what has Barcia done outdoors on a 250? One cannot take his supercross success and extrapolate that to the outdoors. NoGo is using facts ... I don't think Barcia can be considered a favorite for the title until he proves he can consistently run up front on a 250.

I think Barcia did well on a 450 because there were no expectations. I really think that because he was considered a favorite for the 250 and then failed to meet expectations he put a lot of pressure on himself. If Barcia starts strong I think he will be strong the entire outdoor season. If not, he'll be moved up to the 450.

Barcia reminds me so much of Bradshaw.

My predictions in this order:

1. Deano (if healthy)
2. Roczen
3. Baggett
4. Marvin
5. Tomac
Sherwood wrote:
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX. When you hear...
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX.

When you hear him spew the same crap again and again in any thread that brings up the name Barcia it paints a picture.
I understand what you mean. I wasn't speaking to you specifically but generally because there are many posters in this thread that believe Barcia is gonna kill it this summer. He may very well do just that. However, I am reserving judgment until I see him in the first couple of rounds.

Last year was really disappointing. I expected him to be up front and he did nothing. He was so far out of the championship chase that he was moved up as a replacement rider for Canard (I believe).

Tomac is the great unknown to me. He is good outdoors and certainly has the fitness ... I just wonder if he has the speed to keep up with the really good guys.
Sherwood
Posts
3682
Joined
5/12/2010
Location
USA
5/10/2012 4:51pm
Sherwood wrote:
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX. When you hear...
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX.

When you hear him spew the same crap again and again in any thread that brings up the name Barcia it paints a picture.
NoGo wrote:
I spew facts not slander. Its not like what I'm saying is inaccurate.
But you don't need to do it in every thread Barcia's in.
Only reporting certain facts and not others also paint a picture.
Sherwood
Posts
3682
Joined
5/12/2010
Location
USA
5/10/2012 4:55pm Edited Date/Time 5/10/2012 4:57pm
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person...
What is interesting to read is that when someone points out that Barcia has really not met expectations outdoors on a 250 ... then that person is labeled a hater. Think about this for a sec ... what has Barcia done outdoors on a 250? One cannot take his supercross success and extrapolate that to the outdoors. NoGo is using facts ... I don't think Barcia can be considered a favorite for the title until he proves he can consistently run up front on a 250.

I think Barcia did well on a 450 because there were no expectations. I really think that because he was considered a favorite for the 250 and then failed to meet expectations he put a lot of pressure on himself. If Barcia starts strong I think he will be strong the entire outdoor season. If not, he'll be moved up to the 450.

Barcia reminds me so much of Bradshaw.

My predictions in this order:

1. Deano (if healthy)
2. Roczen
3. Baggett
4. Marvin
5. Tomac
Sherwood wrote:
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX. When you hear...
Again, it's not that he pointed it out once but the fact he even points it out in threads only relating to SX.

When you hear him spew the same crap again and again in any thread that brings up the name Barcia it paints a picture.
I understand what you mean. I wasn't speaking to you specifically but generally because there are many posters in this thread that believe Barcia is gonna...
I understand what you mean. I wasn't speaking to you specifically but generally because there are many posters in this thread that believe Barcia is gonna kill it this summer. He may very well do just that. However, I am reserving judgment until I see him in the first couple of rounds.

Last year was really disappointing. I expected him to be up front and he did nothing. He was so far out of the championship chase that he was moved up as a replacement rider for Canard (I believe).

Tomac is the great unknown to me. He is good outdoors and certainly has the fitness ... I just wonder if he has the speed to keep up with the really good guys.
Coming off his broken wrist from SX, getting mono and getting IMO what many in this sport would call a championship hangover I feel contributed to his poor 250f results last year. With him healthy and Stanton saying they will be placing special interest in him getting it done outdoors makes me think he'll do better. As Roger DeCoster told Mike Alessi last year, " SX just isn't that much different from MX."
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/10/2012 4:58pm
Sherwood wrote:
But you don't need to do it in every thread Barcia's in.
Only reporting certain facts and not others also paint a picture.
It really isn't every barcia thread. Just the ones that say that his great sx means hes going to slaughter everyone outdoors.

The facts I've put out are of his and others 250 outdoors results which is what this whole thread is about.
dboivin
Posts
3170
Joined
5/19/2010
Location
Saginaw, MI, USA
5/10/2012 5:03pm
i think kenny is gonna be a beast outdoors. I don't think hes got the supercross down yet but pretty good. outdoors he knows...if he don't battle for championship, i will be disappointed. all the euro guys on here toted him as the best.....here's his chance.
pilotdude
Posts
3844
Joined
1/12/2009
Location
Vancouver, WA, USA
5/10/2012 5:15pm
Sherwood wrote:
But you don't need to do it in every thread Barcia's in.
Only reporting certain facts and not others also paint a picture.
NoGo wrote:
It really isn't every barcia thread. Just the ones that say that his great sx means hes going to slaughter everyone outdoors. The facts I've put...
It really isn't every barcia thread. Just the ones that say that his great sx means hes going to slaughter everyone outdoors.

The facts I've put out are of his and others 250 outdoors results which is what this whole thread is about.
Ummm, no. The "facts" you put out there are that he's had 2 meltdowns which have NOTHING with him as a rider and everything to do with him being young and filled with an overwhelming desire to win.

If DeCoster says supercross isn't that different from motocross, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt.
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/10/2012 5:19pm Edited Date/Time 5/10/2012 5:19pm
pilotdude wrote:
Ummm, no. The "facts" you put out there are that he's had 2 meltdowns which have NOTHING with him as a rider and everything to do...
Ummm, no. The "facts" you put out there are that he's had 2 meltdowns which have NOTHING with him as a rider and everything to do with him being young and filled with an overwhelming desire to win.

If DeCoster says supercross isn't that different from motocross, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt.
his meltdowns were only brought up because someone was saying how mature he has been this season compared to others.
Sherwood
Posts
3682
Joined
5/12/2010
Location
USA
5/10/2012 5:23pm Edited Date/Time 5/10/2012 5:25pm
pilotdude wrote:
Ummm, no. The "facts" you put out there are that he's had 2 meltdowns which have NOTHING with him as a rider and everything to do...
Ummm, no. The "facts" you put out there are that he's had 2 meltdowns which have NOTHING with him as a rider and everything to do with him being young and filled with an overwhelming desire to win.

If DeCoster says supercross isn't that different from motocross, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt.
NoGo wrote:
his meltdowns were only brought up because someone was saying how mature he has been this season compared to others.
I went through all 18 pages of posts you wrote and under the thread No Sx Titles For PC you brought it up that Barcia wouldn't beat them outdoors. 

In the thread Deano Kind of a Baby you wrote, " I like how you call him a cry baby, but when barcia (who cried about a 2nd place and extending his points lead) it's completely okay. Haha what a joke!"

 Again going out of your way

In a thread Barcia Fined 5k you went out of your way to bring up how he won't do anything outdoors.  In that same thread you said, "I'd definetly buy a tshirt with a pic of him crying on it."

In a thread titled lets face it Barcia is the new guy you said ,"He's dominating a regional series.not that spectacular"

And on and on and on. It's 18 pages of you shitting on Barcia... And I didn't even copy all of what you said in those 18 pages about Barcia. It's insane, you say atleast one bad thing about Barcia per page.
NoGo
Posts
708
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
A, CA, USA
5/10/2012 5:29pm
Sherwood wrote:
I went through all 18 pages of posts you wrote and under the thread No Sx Titles For PC you brought it up that Barcia wouldn't...
I went through all 18 pages of posts you wrote and under the thread No Sx Titles For PC you brought it up that Barcia wouldn't beat them outdoors. 

In the thread Deano Kind of a Baby you wrote, " I like how you call him a cry baby, but when barcia (who cried about a 2nd place and extending his points lead) it's completely okay. Haha what a joke!"

 Again going out of your way

In a thread Barcia Fined 5k you went out of your way to bring up how he won't do anything outdoors.  In that same thread you said, "I'd definetly buy a tshirt with a pic of him crying on it."

In a thread titled lets face it Barcia is the new guy you said ,"He's dominating a regional series.not that spectacular"

And on and on and on. It's 18 pages of you shitting on Barcia... And I didn't even copy all of what you said in those 18 pages about Barcia. It's insane, you say atleast one bad thing about Barcia per page.
1.Your obviously a stalker.
2. I'm sure if i went through all your posts it'd be filled with you getting all bummed out cause someone doesn't like barcia or someone pointed out that he's not good outdoors.
3. Those forum post only show what I wrote. Not what I was replying too.So you saying I go out of my way is again false.

Post a reply to: who is the favourite in 250 nationals?

The Latest