Motostuff caliper or Ride engineering Caliper?

afk66
Posts
218
Joined
7/28/2018
Location
Mechanicsville, MD, USA
Price point is a lot lower with the ride engineering brake caliper but how does it compare to the motostuff? Anyone have experience with both? Was curious how they compared.
|
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
1/24/2021 11:47am Edited Date/Time 1/24/2021 3:47pm
I had the same question, so I am in the process of building up a bunch of front brake systems to experiment with for my CRFs and YZFs (I build complete systems to quickly swap out vs. swap parts out and fill/re-bleed).

I have a Motostuff V2 and a bunch of Ride Engineering V2 calipers (thanks Langhammx + Sandy!). I also have a variety of master cylinders (Brembos, 2007+ Hondas), CoreMoto stainless steel brake lines, a variety of 270mm and 280mm Motostuff rotors, and ARC Powerlevers with multiple leverage ratios to fine tune engagement and modulation.

If you're in no hurry, ping me in a few months and I may have some answers.

No doubt there will be some awesome configurations here and I'll be splitting hairs on what's best, but I've always wondered as well, so I am going to put this question to bed for myself once and for all. I'll likely sell whatever I don't keep (likely 4-5 complete front brake systems).

Also note that ARC is coming out with and very unique, *likely* game-changing master cylinder soon. It will be in the $500 price range and available in a few months. If I wasn't so far into this experiment, that is where I'd likely start. Here's a snippet of what is to come:
https://m.vitalmx.com/videos/features/First-Look-ARC-Master-Cylinders-D…

Given this ^^^, your question is quite timely. 🙃
4
afk66
Posts
218
Joined
7/28/2018
Location
Mechanicsville, MD, USA
1/24/2021 12:32pm
Awesome, this is exactly the type of response I was looking forward to reading! I’ve never found anything In depth other than the standard pitch’s “light weight, reduced flex, more progressive, etc”
1
yz133rider
Posts
5029
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA, USA
1/24/2021 2:55pm
I don’t have any input on the Moto stuff, but I bought a ride engineering unit, and it was a MASSIVE improvement over the stock rmz caliper.

It was one of the few aftermarket upgrades that was worth the asking price and was immediately noticeable and better.

That rmz450 went from feeling like the brakes weren’t nearly enough to get her stopped, to being on par with brembos. It had a light lever pull great modulation and tons of power.
3
afk66
Posts
218
Joined
7/28/2018
Location
Mechanicsville, MD, USA
1/26/2021 6:53am
Thanks for the information - I really haven't found any reviews on the motostuff caliper so i'm interested to hear Rider 5280's feedback!

yZ133rider - I'm currently running 270mm rotors and that's been an improvement, especially with fade. I'm wondering how much more can be gained with either caliper.

The Shop

yz133rider
Posts
5029
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA, USA
1/26/2021 7:55am Edited Date/Time 1/26/2021 7:56am
afk66 wrote:
Thanks for the information - I really haven't found any reviews on the motostuff caliper so i'm interested to hear Rider 5280's feedback! yZ133rider - I'm...
Thanks for the information - I really haven't found any reviews on the motostuff caliper so i'm interested to hear Rider 5280's feedback!

yZ133rider - I'm currently running 270mm rotors and that's been an improvement, especially with fade. I'm wondering how much more can be gained with either caliper.
I’ve ran oversized rotors in the past and the improvement has been a 2/10. Can feel it but, eh not really worth the cost to me. I’ve done stainless lines in the past as well, and similar results for me.

The caliper even though it’s more expensive it’s much more noticeable to me. It was a 10/10 improvement for me, on that rmz. The caliper and braking cm46 pads was all I needed on the rmz. I didn’t do oversized rotor or stainless line and it was NIGHT AND DAY better, seriously.

1
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
1/26/2021 8:25am Edited Date/Time 1/26/2021 8:32am
No question stainless steel lines are good/must haves. I personally felt this was a 7/10 for me. A long-term, nice feature of stainless steel brake lines is that they stay firm whereas the stock lines tend to soften/get mushier with time. It's progressive, too, so you don't notice it until you're like "wait … was it always that spongy?" Nope.

Another thing you might consider this the ARC Powerlever:
https://arclevers.com/index.php?route=information/insert_levers

This product is VERY unique and seems to have taken my late model YZ450F with a stock front brake up to the next level. I've purchased mine on eBay for ~ $105 new, shipped (MSRP = $135).
afk66
Posts
218
Joined
7/28/2018
Location
Mechanicsville, MD, USA
1/26/2021 9:04am
Rider 5280 wrote:
No question stainless steel lines are good/must haves. I personally felt this was a 7/10 for me. A long-term, nice feature of stainless steel brake lines...
No question stainless steel lines are good/must haves. I personally felt this was a 7/10 for me. A long-term, nice feature of stainless steel brake lines is that they stay firm whereas the stock lines tend to soften/get mushier with time. It's progressive, too, so you don't notice it until you're like "wait … was it always that spongy?" Nope.

Another thing you might consider this the ARC Powerlever:
https://arclevers.com/index.php?route=information/insert_levers

This product is VERY unique and seems to have taken my late model YZ450F with a stock front brake up to the next level. I've purchased mine on eBay for ~ $105 new, shipped (MSRP = $135).
I've seen those levers and also wondered how well they work, so it's nice to hear they do.

I'm on a 20 crf250r, and 21 crf450r both the same brake setup as my baseline. As of now I only have the 270 rotors, still looking for more performance / prolonged performance / consistency.
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
1/26/2021 11:48am Edited Date/Time 1/26/2021 1:13pm
Honestly, starting with a Galfer SS line (~ $55) or CoreMoto (~ $75) = your best first step IMO. There's a lot of performance to be had there in my experience. And since you'll likely go there in the quest for better braking, knocking out the least expensive mod first = good logic.

Since you've got 20 & 21 CRFs, I would contact Motostuff about your OEM brake calipers. I could be wrong, but I *think* the 2019+ Honda CRF front brake calipers have different sized pistons (for better modulation) and *may* be cast versions of the HRC caliper Roczen uses that Motostuff copied with its V2 caliper product. If this is the case, you won't achieve a whole lot more benefit caliper-wise. Stainless steel lines, yes. 280mm rotor, yes. Specialty levers, yes. But you may be better situated than first thought as far as "awesome-ing up" your brake system.

FWIW - I have both 270mm and 280mm Motostuff rotors on my CRFs and I love them both, but prefer the 280mm unit for its feel. I can slow down better with more control and less effort.

Lastly, you might also try Maxima's High-temp Racing Brake Fluid. You may be due for a flush any way and some higher temp capability may help (you may be such a rider!). It's cheap and will rule out worn fluid + you'll bleed the system fully. Here's a peek:
https://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/parts/maxima-hi-temp-racing-brake-fl…

One of the reviewers even said "...if you are having a fading problem, try this ^^^ before you throw more money like parts at the bike."
1
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
12/20/2021 6:56pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2022 4:06pm
Rode the Ride Engineering V2 caliper yesterday ... jury is out, mine is VERY touchy. I *belive* it's very well bled, but will try some more.

It stops very well, but I was expecting a far more progressive feel.

More to come, but so far I'm feeling like it's wash relative to the stock Honda caliper.

Steup:
(1) 2017 Honda OEM master cylinder
(2) Core Moto stainless steel line
(3) 280mm Motostuff rotor and relocation bracket (have this same setup with a stock caliper to test side-by-side, so I know exactly what this feels like - and I like it)
(4) ARC Memlon lever (not Powerlever yet)
(5) Honda OEM brake pads
(6) Honda Pro Honda DOT 4 brake fluid

The only difference between my 2 setups is the Ride Engineering V2 caliper.

P.S. I hope to try out the Motostuff V2 caliper over Christmas break as well, weather permitting. I will also bring the stock system to compare again. A 3fer!


Bruce372
Posts
6329
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/21/2021 3:21am
Just out of interest, if an aftermarket company came out with a bracket so you could run a brembo caliper on a Japanese bike, would you buy it and go this route?
5
hylo
Posts
180
Joined
2/24/2015
Location
NO
12/21/2021 5:03am Edited Date/Time 12/21/2021 5:06am
Bruce372 wrote:
Just out of interest, if an aftermarket company came out with a bracket so you could run a brembo caliper on a Japanese bike, would you...
Just out of interest, if an aftermarket company came out with a bracket so you could run a brembo caliper on a Japanese bike, would you buy it and go this route?
I would, but I am biased.

But then again, I would love to try the set of calipers from moto master.

I had a TM with Brembo calipers and Nissin master cyliders and that setup was very good and would not mind at all to have that setup on a japanese bike.

Edit: has anyone tried the ride engineering caliper with stock rotors?
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
12/21/2021 12:59pm Edited Date/Time 12/21/2021 12:59pm
Skerby
Posts
1282
Joined
4/9/2013
Location
Mayes County, OK, USA
6/21/2022 9:18am
Little off topic, but does anyone know of a good way to tame the front brake on new yamahas? The lever isnt especially firm on my 21, but it bites stupid hard initially. I can get used to it, but if I go back and forth between my 06 yz125 and 21 yz250f the initial bite throws me off a ton. Much prefer the brake on my 125, it's stock 06 (beefier caliper than later models), and has a 270mm galfer rotor.
FGR01
Posts
6107
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
Fantasy
6/21/2022 11:28am
Skerby wrote:
Little off topic, but does anyone know of a good way to tame the front brake on new yamahas? The lever isnt especially firm on my...
Little off topic, but does anyone know of a good way to tame the front brake on new yamahas? The lever isnt especially firm on my 21, but it bites stupid hard initially. I can get used to it, but if I go back and forth between my 06 yz125 and 21 yz250f the initial bite throws me off a ton. Much prefer the brake on my 125, it's stock 06 (beefier caliper than later models), and has a 270mm galfer rotor.
I had the same setup on my 06 YZ125.. and the pads I was using were the Galfer Kevlar ones (black) that came with the rotor. They had a soft initial bite and took some time to get heat in them to get full power.

Point I'm getting at is maybe the difference you are feeling is partly/mostly due to pad difference or maybe you could soften up the bite on the newer bike with less aggressive pads.
1
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
6/25/2022 11:30pm Edited Date/Time 6/26/2022 10:20am
Skerby wrote:
Little off topic, but does anyone know of a good way to tame the front brake on new yamahas? The lever isnt especially firm on my...
Little off topic, but does anyone know of a good way to tame the front brake on new yamahas? The lever isnt especially firm on my 21, but it bites stupid hard initially. I can get used to it, but if I go back and forth between my 06 yz125 and 21 yz250f the initial bite throws me off a ton. Much prefer the brake on my 125, it's stock 06 (beefier caliper than later models), and has a 270mm galfer rotor.
FGR01 wrote:
I had the same setup on my 06 YZ125.. and the pads I was using were the Galfer Kevlar ones (black) that came with the rotor...
I had the same setup on my 06 YZ125.. and the pads I was using were the Galfer Kevlar ones (black) that came with the rotor. They had a soft initial bite and took some time to get heat in them to get full power.

Point I'm getting at is maybe the difference you are feeling is partly/mostly due to pad difference or maybe you could soften up the bite on the newer bike with less aggressive pads.
Agree with FGR01.

Another trick I've heard people talk about to lessen and smooth the initial bite is to chamfer the leading edge of the brake pads slightly. Never tried it myself, but maybe worth a try.
Rider 5280
Posts
2394
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO, USA
10/2/2022 8:31pm Edited Date/Time 10/3/2022 8:11am
Rider 5280 wrote:
Rode the Ride Engineering V2 caliper yesterday ... jury is out, mine is VERY touchy. I *belive* it's very well bled, but will try some more...
Rode the Ride Engineering V2 caliper yesterday ... jury is out, mine is VERY touchy. I *belive* it's very well bled, but will try some more.

It stops very well, but I was expecting a far more progressive feel.

More to come, but so far I'm feeling like it's wash relative to the stock Honda caliper.

Steup:
(1) 2017 Honda OEM master cylinder
(2) Core Moto stainless steel line
(3) 280mm Motostuff rotor and relocation bracket (have this same setup with a stock caliper to test side-by-side, so I know exactly what this feels like - and I like it)
(4) ARC Memlon lever (not Powerlever yet)
(5) Honda OEM brake pads
(6) Honda Pro Honda DOT 4 brake fluid

The only difference between my 2 setups is the Ride Engineering V2 caliper.

P.S. I hope to try out the Motostuff V2 caliper over Christmas break as well, weather permitting. I will also bring the stock system to compare again. A 3fer!


Some more testing updates (more to come ... sorry been soooooo slow guys):

(1) The Ride Engineering V2 caliper on a late-model YZ250F, using a 280mm Motostuff rotor with stock Honda pads, a CoreMoto stainless steel brake line, 2012 CRF450R Nissin master cylinder and ARC Memlon standard lever (not the PowerLever) is A LOT of brake. A LOT. At current time I am leaning toward the OEM setup for woods riding running a standard ARC Memlon lever (non PowerLever). It was a bit more "mountain bike-ish" as an OEM setup, which I really liked for this bike.

(2) The Ride Engineering V2 caliper on a 2008 CRF450R, using a 280mm Motostuff rotor with stock Honda pads, a CoreMoto stainless steel brake line, 2017 CRF450R Nissin master cylinder and ARC Memlon PowerLever (with multiple leverage ratios) is a very powerful, progressive brake. Did I say powerful?! On a 450F, I really like this setup now, especially when I set up my lever such that I can rest my index finger at the lever's elbow. It's quite nice, not too grabby, and just REALLY REALLY good stopping power. This setup on the 450F = cat's meow.

--------------------

My next experiment/comparison, all on a 2020 YZ450F, will be:

(1) MotoStuff V2 caliper with CoreMoto stainless line and Honda master cylinder

(2) Late-model KTM Brembo caliper with CoreMoto stainless line and Brembo master cylinder (Luxon MX is fabricating Yamaha YZF adapter brackets for this application now)

(3) Ride Engineering V2 caliper as described above (transferred to the YZ450 to see how it is on a much heavier bike)

(4) OEM Yamaha front-brake system

I will try a mix of 270mm and 280mm rotors as well as ARC Memlon levers in standard and PowerLever versions. Note that the reason I like the Memlon material is that it adds to the "progressive" feel of the brake actuation, in my opinion, as well as takes abuse amazing well.
2
rmhrc
Posts
2
Joined
7/20/2017
Location
AU
1/18/2024 8:29pm

Is ANYONE making a caliper adaptor to fit Brembo KTM calipers to showa CRF USD forks?

Post a reply to: Motostuff caliper or Ride engineering Caliper?

The Latest