Could wearing a chest heart rate monitor be dangerous in a crash?

Falcon
Posts
12718
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
11/17/2026 8:22am

I don't need no stinkin' heart rate monitor. I already know my HR is too high, because I'm not fit enough! 

 

To answer the OP's question: yes, wearing a monitor could be dangerous. The same way wearing a GoPro on your helmet (or chest, for that matter,) could be. 

3
3strokemx
Posts
3421
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 8:31am Edited Date/Time 11/17/2026 8:31am
mx317 wrote:
I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I...

I have used one on my bicycle before to keep my effort at the correct level. I use it more often on my Peloton where I can monitor it better while riding and not dodging cars or potholes. I could see it being good in moto if you had a trainer to sort it all out after your race or ride. Most of us are pegging the old meter anyway while racing and wouldn't think to check a HR rate on a watch even strapped to the handlebars.

3strokemx wrote:

Do you have to stand while you're pegging or can you peg yourself while seated?

mx317 wrote:
On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot...

On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot of RPMs vs pushing a big gear. 

I'm going to have to google pegging.

1
2
mx317
Posts
5428
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/17/2026 8:35am
3strokemx wrote:

Do you have to stand while you're pegging or can you peg yourself while seated?

mx317 wrote:
On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot...

On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot of RPMs vs pushing a big gear. 

3strokemx wrote:

I'm going to have to google pegging.

Max heart rate is what I call pegging, it used to be 220 minus your age. A lot of things or people's beliefs have changed though.

cslacker
Posts
401
Joined
6/6/2014
Location
Glendale, AZ, USA
11/17/2026 8:39am
mx317 wrote:
On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot...

On my motocross bike it is mostly while standing, but either on the bicycles. I find my heartrate going up more when I'm spinning a lot of RPMs vs pushing a big gear. 

3strokemx wrote:

I'm going to have to google pegging.

mx317 wrote:

Max heart rate is what I call pegging, it used to be 220 minus your age. A lot of things or people's beliefs have changed though.

You should checkout a site called Reddit.  There is a subreddit all about pegging that might help keep you up to date on those changing beliefs.

4

The Shop

3strokemx
Posts
3421
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
11/17/2026 8:43am
3strokemx wrote:

I'm going to have to google pegging.

mx317 wrote:

Max heart rate is what I call pegging, it used to be 220 minus your age. A lot of things or people's beliefs have changed though.

cslacker wrote:

You should checkout a site called Reddit.  There is a subreddit all about pegging that might help keep you up to date on those changing beliefs.

DO NOT Google pegging!

It spiked my heart rate so much just looking at that subreddit that my garmin sent a medical alert to my emergency contact (ex wife).

3
2
Rowdy Sparks
Posts
110
Joined
5/13/2022
Location
Delmont, PA, USA
9 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a...

I understand it tracks your pulse rate. The question was how that informs your fitness.

You could get a lot of spikes by wearing it during a hauted house, does that mean you are out of shape though?

 

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

3strokemx wrote:
I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a...

I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. 

I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a user their fitness level, as claimed. 

Seems like the people wearing them just enjoy the smugness of recording their pulse.   

Perceiving your own ill-informed opinion as other people's smugness is some wildly backwards hypocritical shit even by Vital standards. Like who is smug, the guy minding his own business riding his dirt bike with a heart rate monitor on or the guy parked across from him who sees he has a heart rate monitor on and judges him without knowing anything else about him?  

3strokemx
Posts
3421
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
7 hours ago Edited Date/Time 7 hours ago
You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro...

You're being intentionally obtuse. Heart rate is used in all types of fitness and cardio training and it works out to averages and zones in motocross/enduro just like any other sport. 

3strokemx wrote:
I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a...

I know HR is used widely. I did several years training primarily by HR. 

I don't know how wearing it during a MX race would tell a user their fitness level, as claimed. 

Seems like the people wearing them just enjoy the smugness of recording their pulse.   

Perceiving your own ill-informed opinion as other people's smugness is some wildly backwards hypocritical shit even by Vital standards. Like who is smug, the guy minding...

Perceiving your own ill-informed opinion as other people's smugness is some wildly backwards hypocritical shit even by Vital standards. Like who is smug, the guy minding his own business riding his dirt bike with a heart rate monitor on or the guy parked across from him who sees he has a heart rate monitor on and judges him without knowing anything else about him?  

Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge you. 

Not because I think I'm better than you, it's because I'm disappointed marketing hype has overshadowed observational facts.

I also began by asking the HR montior users here how they discern fitness or effort while controlling for adrenaline based HR spikes and other environmental conditions, but noone had a reasonable answer.  So if people feel attacked, please let me know how I'm wrong, I'm geniuinely curious how you think it helps.

2
4 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge...

Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge you. 

Not because I think I'm better than you, it's because I'm disappointed marketing hype has overshadowed observational facts.

I also began by asking the HR montior users here how they discern fitness or effort while controlling for adrenaline based HR spikes and other environmental conditions, but noone had a reasonable answer.  So if people feel attacked, please let me know how I'm wrong, I'm geniuinely curious how you think it helps.

I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM during moto to primarily help monitor my load/TSS and adjust my cycling and running weekly training loads to account for it. 

As for decerning fitness or effort, I do think HR can be used in conjunction with lap times or splits to get useful data. At a moto track, doing 1 lap sprints (Z5 effort), 1 lap “recovery” (Z2/low Z3 effort with a focus on form, smoothness and absolutely no dabbing) HR is useful for getting heart rate recovery time, and for informing the effort level. Ideally your sprint laps stay consistent time wise or slightly improve, but RPE gets slightly easier. Your recovery laps should improve time wise through the session via improving efficiency but effort should stay the same. HR helps verify this. If your HR is not coming down sufficiently by the end of the “recovery” lap you’re pushing too hard or have done enough reps for the session.

Similar thing for putting together consistent 20min practice motos. Looking for consistent lap times at threshold (Z4) HR on the average.


For hare scrambles, post-race I’m looking to see a high HR for the first ~10-20 mins consistent with the start and jockeying for position, ideally without spending too much time in the red. After that I’m looking to see HR vs lap times through the race, hopefully consistent for both. In full summer heat I can expect HR creep, but otherwise I expect it to be pretty steady and dip slightly as I find improved lines so I can maintain speed with reduced effort. Looking for spots where I had HR spikes (crash, battling, gnarly section) and if I recovered well and it’s impact on the race down the line (did I over exert and blow up before the end?). Analyzing HR data across those helped me improve general race strategy, such as not scrambling as quickly as possible to get going after a crash as the resulting HR spike of heaving the bike up costs more race time via additional time at a slower pace recovering, than taking 2 extra seconds to pick up the bike more efficiently with an elevated but not maxed HR. Same thing for seeing how I was pacing start battles and determining the max effort without over extending. 

These are all instances where using heart rate is useful and actionable in training outside of monitoring load/TSS. Is it required? No. Could it be done by RPE instead? Certainly for the drills.

3
3strokemx
Posts
3421
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
3 hours ago Edited Date/Time 2 hours ago
3strokemx wrote:
Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge...

Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge you. 

Not because I think I'm better than you, it's because I'm disappointed marketing hype has overshadowed observational facts.

I also began by asking the HR montior users here how they discern fitness or effort while controlling for adrenaline based HR spikes and other environmental conditions, but noone had a reasonable answer.  So if people feel attacked, please let me know how I'm wrong, I'm geniuinely curious how you think it helps.

I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM...

I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM during moto to primarily help monitor my load/TSS and adjust my cycling and running weekly training loads to account for it. 

As for decerning fitness or effort, I do think HR can be used in conjunction with lap times or splits to get useful data. At a moto track, doing 1 lap sprints (Z5 effort), 1 lap “recovery” (Z2/low Z3 effort with a focus on form, smoothness and absolutely no dabbing) HR is useful for getting heart rate recovery time, and for informing the effort level. Ideally your sprint laps stay consistent time wise or slightly improve, but RPE gets slightly easier. Your recovery laps should improve time wise through the session via improving efficiency but effort should stay the same. HR helps verify this. If your HR is not coming down sufficiently by the end of the “recovery” lap you’re pushing too hard or have done enough reps for the session.

Similar thing for putting together consistent 20min practice motos. Looking for consistent lap times at threshold (Z4) HR on the average.


For hare scrambles, post-race I’m looking to see a high HR for the first ~10-20 mins consistent with the start and jockeying for position, ideally without spending too much time in the red. After that I’m looking to see HR vs lap times through the race, hopefully consistent for both. In full summer heat I can expect HR creep, but otherwise I expect it to be pretty steady and dip slightly as I find improved lines so I can maintain speed with reduced effort. Looking for spots where I had HR spikes (crash, battling, gnarly section) and if I recovered well and it’s impact on the race down the line (did I over exert and blow up before the end?). Analyzing HR data across those helped me improve general race strategy, such as not scrambling as quickly as possible to get going after a crash as the resulting HR spike of heaving the bike up costs more race time via additional time at a slower pace recovering, than taking 2 extra seconds to pick up the bike more efficiently with an elevated but not maxed HR. Same thing for seeing how I was pacing start battles and determining the max effort without over extending. 

These are all instances where using heart rate is useful and actionable in training outside of monitoring load/TSS. Is it required? No. Could it be done by RPE instead? Certainly for the drills.

  1. How are you calculating TSS without a normalized force output? 
  2. Recovery time to Baseline HR and RPE vs HR could be helpful, but you're still assuming HR is primarily related to Metabolic exertion and not controlling for adrenaline/stress induced HR.
  3. You have an emphasis on consistency but MX/HS is inherently inconsistent due to the changing postures required every few seconds (pushing and sitting going into a corner, standing and pulling exiting a corner, rest in the air, etc.)  Here's a simplified example to highlight why that's an issue: Resting for 2 seconds, then max effort for 2 seconds,  your 4 second average is in the middle..........even though your effort was never in the middle.


    For the record, I agree with you that panic/stress is a major detriment on performance and I'm glad you were able to identify and improve in that area. 

    Correct me if I'm wrong here, you think the HRM is valuable when used with Perceived Effort and Lap Times to triangulate areas where stress occurs.  
    My argument is that HRM data doesn't inform fitness changes in this application.  Using it as a stress monitor could be helpful, although Perceived Effort and Lap Times (without HR) would work just as well.
1
Mototech853
Posts
194
Joined
1/20/2024
Location
Itasca, IL, USA
2 hours ago

I wear an Alpinestars A1 chest protector and a Garmin HRM-200. I race hare scrambles. I’ve had a few crashes where my chest has hit the bars/bar pad and I didn’t notice any soreness or marks from the hrm. I think if you take a hard enough hit you’re going to get hurt regardless if the hrm is there or not. I think this actually answers your question. 

1
Cabin09
Posts
32
Joined
1/29/2023
Location
Rotorua, NZ
16 minutes ago
3strokemx wrote:
Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge...

Being judgemental and smug are different things. But yeah, if you show up with a tool and misunderstanding of how it works, I'm going to judge you. 

Not because I think I'm better than you, it's because I'm disappointed marketing hype has overshadowed observational facts.

I also began by asking the HR montior users here how they discern fitness or effort while controlling for adrenaline based HR spikes and other environmental conditions, but noone had a reasonable answer.  So if people feel attacked, please let me know how I'm wrong, I'm geniuinely curious how you think it helps.

I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM...

I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM during moto to primarily help monitor my load/TSS and adjust my cycling and running weekly training loads to account for it. 

As for decerning fitness or effort, I do think HR can be used in conjunction with lap times or splits to get useful data. At a moto track, doing 1 lap sprints (Z5 effort), 1 lap “recovery” (Z2/low Z3 effort with a focus on form, smoothness and absolutely no dabbing) HR is useful for getting heart rate recovery time, and for informing the effort level. Ideally your sprint laps stay consistent time wise or slightly improve, but RPE gets slightly easier. Your recovery laps should improve time wise through the session via improving efficiency but effort should stay the same. HR helps verify this. If your HR is not coming down sufficiently by the end of the “recovery” lap you’re pushing too hard or have done enough reps for the session.

Similar thing for putting together consistent 20min practice motos. Looking for consistent lap times at threshold (Z4) HR on the average.


For hare scrambles, post-race I’m looking to see a high HR for the first ~10-20 mins consistent with the start and jockeying for position, ideally without spending too much time in the red. After that I’m looking to see HR vs lap times through the race, hopefully consistent for both. In full summer heat I can expect HR creep, but otherwise I expect it to be pretty steady and dip slightly as I find improved lines so I can maintain speed with reduced effort. Looking for spots where I had HR spikes (crash, battling, gnarly section) and if I recovered well and it’s impact on the race down the line (did I over exert and blow up before the end?). Analyzing HR data across those helped me improve general race strategy, such as not scrambling as quickly as possible to get going after a crash as the resulting HR spike of heaving the bike up costs more race time via additional time at a slower pace recovering, than taking 2 extra seconds to pick up the bike more efficiently with an elevated but not maxed HR. Same thing for seeing how I was pacing start battles and determining the max effort without over extending. 

These are all instances where using heart rate is useful and actionable in training outside of monitoring load/TSS. Is it required? No. Could it be done by RPE instead? Certainly for the drills.

3strokemx wrote:
How are you calculating TSS without a normalized force output? Recovery time to Baseline HR and RPE vs HR could be helpful, but you're still assuming HR...
  1. How are you calculating TSS without a normalized force output? 
  2. Recovery time to Baseline HR and RPE vs HR could be helpful, but you're still assuming HR is primarily related to Metabolic exertion and not controlling for adrenaline/stress induced HR.
  3. You have an emphasis on consistency but MX/HS is inherently inconsistent due to the changing postures required every few seconds (pushing and sitting going into a corner, standing and pulling exiting a corner, rest in the air, etc.)  Here's a simplified example to highlight why that's an issue: Resting for 2 seconds, then max effort for 2 seconds,  your 4 second average is in the middle..........even though your effort was never in the middle.


    For the record, I agree with you that panic/stress is a major detriment on performance and I'm glad you were able to identify and improve in that area. 

    Correct me if I'm wrong here, you think the HRM is valuable when used with Perceived Effort and Lap Times to triangulate areas where stress occurs.  
    My argument is that HRM data doesn't inform fitness changes in this application.  Using it as a stress monitor could be helpful, although Perceived Effort and Lap Times (without HR) would work just as well.

I'm going to assume that in his case, the TSS is coming from Training Peaks (or similar app planning/monitoring training)?

Will it be 100% accurate without force output? No.

 But if he is also using cycling/running and other things in training, then using a Heart Rate generated TSS gives a reasonable approximation of total training load on body for monitoring this. And again, its individual patterns that become most useful, rather than reading too much into any one session or data set

3strokemx
Posts
3421
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
10 minutes ago Edited Date/Time 4 minutes ago
I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM...

I agree with many of your points; the data needs to be actionable in some way in order to be useful. Like you, I used HRM during moto to primarily help monitor my load/TSS and adjust my cycling and running weekly training loads to account for it. 

As for decerning fitness or effort, I do think HR can be used in conjunction with lap times or splits to get useful data. At a moto track, doing 1 lap sprints (Z5 effort), 1 lap “recovery” (Z2/low Z3 effort with a focus on form, smoothness and absolutely no dabbing) HR is useful for getting heart rate recovery time, and for informing the effort level. Ideally your sprint laps stay consistent time wise or slightly improve, but RPE gets slightly easier. Your recovery laps should improve time wise through the session via improving efficiency but effort should stay the same. HR helps verify this. If your HR is not coming down sufficiently by the end of the “recovery” lap you’re pushing too hard or have done enough reps for the session.

Similar thing for putting together consistent 20min practice motos. Looking for consistent lap times at threshold (Z4) HR on the average.


For hare scrambles, post-race I’m looking to see a high HR for the first ~10-20 mins consistent with the start and jockeying for position, ideally without spending too much time in the red. After that I’m looking to see HR vs lap times through the race, hopefully consistent for both. In full summer heat I can expect HR creep, but otherwise I expect it to be pretty steady and dip slightly as I find improved lines so I can maintain speed with reduced effort. Looking for spots where I had HR spikes (crash, battling, gnarly section) and if I recovered well and it’s impact on the race down the line (did I over exert and blow up before the end?). Analyzing HR data across those helped me improve general race strategy, such as not scrambling as quickly as possible to get going after a crash as the resulting HR spike of heaving the bike up costs more race time via additional time at a slower pace recovering, than taking 2 extra seconds to pick up the bike more efficiently with an elevated but not maxed HR. Same thing for seeing how I was pacing start battles and determining the max effort without over extending. 

These are all instances where using heart rate is useful and actionable in training outside of monitoring load/TSS. Is it required? No. Could it be done by RPE instead? Certainly for the drills.

3strokemx wrote:
How are you calculating TSS without a normalized force output? Recovery time to Baseline HR and RPE vs HR could be helpful, but you're still assuming HR...
  1. How are you calculating TSS without a normalized force output? 
  2. Recovery time to Baseline HR and RPE vs HR could be helpful, but you're still assuming HR is primarily related to Metabolic exertion and not controlling for adrenaline/stress induced HR.
  3. You have an emphasis on consistency but MX/HS is inherently inconsistent due to the changing postures required every few seconds (pushing and sitting going into a corner, standing and pulling exiting a corner, rest in the air, etc.)  Here's a simplified example to highlight why that's an issue: Resting for 2 seconds, then max effort for 2 seconds,  your 4 second average is in the middle..........even though your effort was never in the middle.


    For the record, I agree with you that panic/stress is a major detriment on performance and I'm glad you were able to identify and improve in that area. 

    Correct me if I'm wrong here, you think the HRM is valuable when used with Perceived Effort and Lap Times to triangulate areas where stress occurs.  
    My argument is that HRM data doesn't inform fitness changes in this application.  Using it as a stress monitor could be helpful, although Perceived Effort and Lap Times (without HR) would work just as well.
Cabin09 wrote:
I'm going to assume that in his case, the TSS is coming from Training Peaks (or similar app planning/monitoring training)?Will it be 100% accurate without force...

I'm going to assume that in his case, the TSS is coming from Training Peaks (or similar app planning/monitoring training)?

Will it be 100% accurate without force output? No.

 But if he is also using cycling/running and other things in training, then using a Heart Rate generated TSS gives a reasonable approximation of total training load on body for monitoring this. And again, its individual patterns that become most useful, rather than reading too much into any one session or data set

Yeah that's likely the case but it also is the point I've been trying to drive home, HR will vary on the motocross bike because of stress/adrenaline, so using it to evaluate metabolic work is a red herring. 

The haunted house example I gave earlier would give an estimated TSS way above your actual physical output.

Looking at trends, after your 6th lap through the haunted house, your stress/adrenaline (and HR) would be lower because you know what is happening. We can't point to the lower HR /estimatedTSS and honestly say it is due to improved fitness.

Post a reply to: Could wearing a chest heart rate monitor be dangerous in a crash?

The Latest