James Stewart and San Manuel deserve........

1/17/2011 1:14pm
P wrote:
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any real research...
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the
whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any
real research other than overhearing comments from another team. Their
comments not only tainted the win for James Stewart, but painted him and
his team as well, cheaters. Personally, I feel that they have done great harm to
the reputation of the team and the rider no matter how much
"advertisement" GET got.

If they have the least bit of class they will issue an apology. That's
just MHO.


P

It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize it was a gotcha question . He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won


http://moto-racing.speedtv.com/article/video-ama-sx-phoenix-recap
gsxrcr28
Posts
7419
Joined
3/5/2009
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
1/17/2011 1:30pm
P wrote:
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any real research...
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the
whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any
real research other than overhearing comments from another team. Their
comments not only tainted the win for James Stewart, but painted him and
his team as well, cheaters. Personally, I feel that they have done great harm to
the reputation of the team and the rider no matter how much
"advertisement" GET got.

If they have the least bit of class they will issue an apology. That's
just MHO.


P

It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize...
It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize it was a gotcha question . He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won


http://moto-racing.speedtv.com/article/video-ama-sx-phoenix-recap
He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won

So now you are insinuating he actually had Traction Control.

I don't usually do this but, Damn dude you're dumb.
BLAHBLAH
Posts
1118
Joined
4/9/2010
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
1/17/2011 1:32pm
P wrote:
Riders answer questions about winning races or not winning races. If they REALLY wanted to know what the deal was with his bike they could have...
Riders answer questions about winning races or not winning races.

If they REALLY wanted to know what the deal was with his bike they could have interviewed his mechanic or talked to Larry Brooks. Hell they could have just asked the guys in AMA tech inspection.

It's sad that so many of you approve of the way the whole thing went down. You are basically saying that it doesn't matter if your broadcasters don't get it right. Sad.


P
It's sad how worked up you are getting over this.. 99% of people believe JS won fair and square on Saturday, the other 1% are trying (succesfully I might add) to get your goat.

You are making it out to be like there was some sort of witch hunt saturday night, they talked about something on his bike before the main and then Erin asked him a stupid question. That was it, no more no less.

LET IT GO!
1/17/2011 1:55pm
P wrote:
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any real research...
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the
whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any
real research other than overhearing comments from another team. Their
comments not only tainted the win for James Stewart, but painted him and
his team as well, cheaters. Personally, I feel that they have done great harm to
the reputation of the team and the rider no matter how much
"advertisement" GET got.

If they have the least bit of class they will issue an apology. That's
just MHO.


P

It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize...
It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize it was a gotcha question . He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won


http://moto-racing.speedtv.com/article/video-ama-sx-phoenix-recap
gsxrcr28 wrote:
[b]He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked...
He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won

So now you are insinuating he actually had Traction Control.

I don't usually do this but, Damn dude you're dumb.
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell it out clearly

The Shop

uk125250
Posts
3947
Joined
10/4/2009
Location
Gnome, AQ
1/17/2011 1:58pm
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell...
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell it out clearly
Sarcasm.
mcopsey
Posts
452
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/17/2011 1:59pm
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell...
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell it out clearly
The data acquisition is LEGAL in practice but not in the racing. Are you really thinking they would just remove it for the heat race and reinstall for the main?
tyler durden
Posts
376
Joined
10/2/2010
Location
Dallas, TX, USA
1/17/2011 2:02pm
I believe data acquisition alone IS legal in the race. As long as there is no real-time transmittance of data. could be wrong tho.
gsxrcr28
Posts
7419
Joined
3/5/2009
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
1/17/2011 2:03pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2011 2:04pm
gsxrcr28
Posts
7419
Joined
3/5/2009
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
1/17/2011 2:04pm
It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize...
It was a straight up question and he was clearly unprepared for it .I don't think Erin even knows traction control is illegal ,and didn't realize it was a gotcha question . He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won


http://moto-racing.speedtv.com/article/video-ama-sx-phoenix-recap
gsxrcr28 wrote:
[b]He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked...
He did say " it obviously didn't help any"( I beg to differ)holeshoot was the first clue-James not known for his holeshots ,she should of asked how asked how did it not help -you won

So now you are insinuating he actually had Traction Control.

I don't usually do this but, Damn dude you're dumb.
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell...
pleace explain his remark "it obviously didn't help any" how can you say it didn't help any if it does't exist -remember I'm dumb so spell it out clearly
IT WAS A JOKE. But hey if you want to think they have it more power to ya.
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
1/17/2011 2:06pm
P wrote:
Riders answer questions about winning races or not winning races. If they REALLY wanted to know what the deal was with his bike they could have...
Riders answer questions about winning races or not winning races.

If they REALLY wanted to know what the deal was with his bike they could have interviewed his mechanic or talked to Larry Brooks. Hell they could have just asked the guys in AMA tech inspection.

It's sad that so many of you approve of the way the whole thing went down. You are basically saying that it doesn't matter if your broadcasters don't get it right. Sad.


P
BLAHBLAH wrote:
It's sad how worked up you are getting over this.. 99% of people believe JS won fair and square on Saturday, the other 1% are trying...
It's sad how worked up you are getting over this.. 99% of people believe JS won fair and square on Saturday, the other 1% are trying (succesfully I might add) to get your goat.

You are making it out to be like there was some sort of witch hunt saturday night, they talked about something on his bike before the main and then Erin asked him a stupid question. That was it, no more no less.

LET IT GO!
It stated before his Heat race, carried over to Erin's question, was mentioned in Emig's closing remarks and was talked about on pretty much every credible site on the web (usually including the word "cheater". All of that because the "professionals" didn't do a little research.


P
MunchMunch
Posts
18
Joined
1/16/2011
Location
Cairns, Australia, AU
1/17/2011 2:11pm
Who gives a shit, he's always going to smoke the field regardless of whats on the motorcycle. Damn P diddy stop whining he won the damn race!! Did James ever apologise for kicking over bikes or taking people out, doubt it!! JS#7 2011 SX CHAMP!!
1/17/2011 2:15pm
who in there right mind would cast a cloud of supicion on themselves.
if you want to believe that then more power to ya
mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
1/17/2011 2:20pm
They all cheat at that level LOL!
gsxrcr28
Posts
7419
Joined
3/5/2009
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
1/17/2011 2:21pm
Hey P,

I agree, its a dumb question to ask any rider while they are on the podium. That being said, its no big deal... It just adds more interest for the fans that don't know much about it. The casual fans will know there was no protest if they follow the series close enough.

JBlain619
Posts
1855
Joined
6/10/2010
Location
Severna Park, MD, USA
1/17/2011 2:27pm
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was on the witness stand in court, he looked guilty because he didn't give a straight answer. If there isn't any improprieties going on with whatever the fuck it is on his bike, answer the question and answer it straight. Very simple actually. It's the broadcasters and media's job to stir controversy, come on now. There wasn't a protest and we are still talking about it. Good job on their parts!
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
1/17/2011 2:35pm
JBlain619 wrote:
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was...
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was on the witness stand in court, he looked guilty because he didn't give a straight answer. If there isn't any improprieties going on with whatever the fuck it is on his bike, answer the question and answer it straight. Very simple actually. It's the broadcasters and media's job to stir controversy, come on now. There wasn't a protest and we are still talking about it. Good job on their parts!
It's amazing how some of you try to justify stuff that is wrong. Sad.

A professional broadcasting team would have no problem issuing an apology.


P
1/17/2011 2:42pm
P wrote:
Apparently, you feel that it is ok to falsely accuse someone of something. Now that is sad.


P
welcome to America youngster.
jeffro503
Posts
27647
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR, USA
1/17/2011 2:44pm
P.....you have to remember that most of the media people ( including Erin ) don't know squat about how these bikes even work. And we have seen it plenty of times over the past few years ( never remember seeing Jamie do this though ).

The point is......it's the media who threw that question at James....not Just Erin. And if you were looking for an apology , the media people should be the ones to give it. BUT.....you'll be hard pressed to get anything like that out of them. They are there to do their stupid reporting and make it interesting for the monster truck crowd / fans. Who knows.....maybe next week either Ralph or Erin will throw out an apology of some sort......stranger things have happened.
Hold It On
Posts
159
Joined
1/4/2010
Location
Mackay, AU
1/17/2011 2:44pm
Hasn't this pony been beaten enough?

Crikey, let it go, both sides of the fence.
tyler durden
Posts
376
Joined
10/2/2010
Location
Dallas, TX, USA
1/17/2011 2:45pm
JBlain619 wrote:
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was...
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was on the witness stand in court, he looked guilty because he didn't give a straight answer. If there isn't any improprieties going on with whatever the fuck it is on his bike, answer the question and answer it straight. Very simple actually. It's the broadcasters and media's job to stir controversy, come on now. There wasn't a protest and we are still talking about it. Good job on their parts!
P wrote:
It's amazing how some of you try to justify stuff that is wrong. Sad.

A professional broadcasting team would have no problem issuing an apology.


P
And a more professional rider would have ________

We will let you fill in the blank there.

Theres no such thing as journalism anymore (Matthes excluded LOL); especially not on Live Sportscasting.

Notwithstanding that, tt was a technical question that Erin botched; one word would have made the question much less threatening. I think we have been too quick to assign intent to the producer when it may not have been there. James, on the other hand did a great job of validating what it was she supposedly was insinuating.

Furthermore, there's nothing wrong with speculating about the technical purpose of new equipment; that's part of what makes Motocross such a great sport. JS7 is supposed to be at the top. People at the top will always be eyeballed more. Hell, look at the shitstorm Armstrong has been wading through.

IceMan446
Posts
4676
Joined
1/10/2010
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
1/17/2011 2:52pm
I think JS negated any obligatory apology with his equally unpolished response
James' job is to race the motorcycle that is provided to him by his team. Not answer a question on a made up story he had no idea about. LB is the man to answer those questions. James did his job by winning the race and he didn't have to have a polished response to a shit question that had nothing to do with his win.

This whole traction control story is a fucking joke. They see Chad and James are buddies now so that takes away the drama there. Then they see that James is cool with Dungey after the Nike show and all they have left is the TC story and a so called rivalry with RV that hasn't even started yet.
JBlain619
Posts
1855
Joined
6/10/2010
Location
Severna Park, MD, USA
1/17/2011 2:58pm
JBlain619 wrote:
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was...
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was on the witness stand in court, he looked guilty because he didn't give a straight answer. If there isn't any improprieties going on with whatever the fuck it is on his bike, answer the question and answer it straight. Very simple actually. It's the broadcasters and media's job to stir controversy, come on now. There wasn't a protest and we are still talking about it. Good job on their parts!
P wrote:
It's amazing how some of you try to justify stuff that is wrong. Sad.

A professional broadcasting team would have no problem issuing an apology.


P
I didn't try to justify shit. Im telling you EXACTLY how it was. She asked a question, he balked, simple as that.
JBlain619
Posts
1855
Joined
6/10/2010
Location
Severna Park, MD, USA
1/17/2011 3:09pm
I think JS negated any obligatory apology with his equally unpolished response
IceMan446 wrote:
James' job is to race the motorcycle that is provided to him by his team. Not answer a question on a made up story he had...
James' job is to race the motorcycle that is provided to him by his team. Not answer a question on a made up story he had no idea about. LB is the man to answer those questions. James did his job by winning the race and he didn't have to have a polished response to a shit question that had nothing to do with his win.

This whole traction control story is a fucking joke. They see Chad and James are buddies now so that takes away the drama there. Then they see that James is cool with Dungey after the Nike show and all they have left is the TC story and a so called rivalry with RV that hasn't even started yet.
Seriously!?! If you truly believe that James doesn't know whats on his bike, or whats done to his bike and he just shows up and rides what the team brings him, you have obviously no fucking clue about this sport. That might have just been the dumbest post I have ever seen on here. That's a Nascar cop-out! Sorry Clint!
1/17/2011 3:13pm
the look on his face was priceless, he looked like obama with out his telepromter
FlaNard
Posts
3620
Joined
10/13/2009
Location
Layton, UT, USA
1/17/2011 3:13pm
P wrote:
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any real research...
a public apology on the next race broadcast from whoever approved the
whole "traction control" story. It appears that they failed to do any
real research other than overhearing comments from another team. Their
comments not only tainted the win for James Stewart, but painted him and
his team as well, cheaters. Personally, I feel that they have done great harm to
the reputation of the team and the rider no matter how much
"advertisement" GET got.

If they have the least bit of class they will issue an apology. That's
just MHO.


P

Someone get P a tissue.
tyler durden
Posts
376
Joined
10/2/2010
Location
Dallas, TX, USA
1/17/2011 3:18pm
the look on his face was priceless, he looked like obama with out his telepromter
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
1/17/2011 4:12pm
jeffro503 wrote:
P.....you have to remember that most of the media people ( including Erin ) don't know squat about how these bikes even work. And we have...
P.....you have to remember that most of the media people ( including Erin ) don't know squat about how these bikes even work. And we have seen it plenty of times over the past few years ( never remember seeing Jamie do this though ).

The point is......it's the media who threw that question at James....not Just Erin. And if you were looking for an apology , the media people should be the ones to give it. BUT.....you'll be hard pressed to get anything like that out of them. They are there to do their stupid reporting and make it interesting for the monster truck crowd / fans. Who knows.....maybe next week either Ralph or Erin will throw out an apology of some sort......stranger things have happened.
It wasn't just Erin. Emig, Ralph and whoever was behind the scenes producing the show they all played it up.

Like I said before, if they have ANY class they will issue an apology.


P
Pdub
Posts
1477
Joined
8/2/2006
Location
Wheaton, MD, USA
1/17/2011 4:17pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2011 4:17pm
P, you know I love you, but...



Your first mistake: expecting class and/or journalism from the people who broadcast supercross.



Your second mistake: expecting a reasonable discussion about that here



Your third mistake: taking the bait... but if you're having fun with it, have at it! Wink
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
1/17/2011 4:17pm
JBlain619 wrote:
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was...
Dude let it go! James' kinda looked dumb by not knowing how to answer and dancing around the question. It was just like if he was on the witness stand in court, he looked guilty because he didn't give a straight answer. If there isn't any improprieties going on with whatever the fuck it is on his bike, answer the question and answer it straight. Very simple actually. It's the broadcasters and media's job to stir controversy, come on now. There wasn't a protest and we are still talking about it. Good job on their parts!
P wrote:
It's amazing how some of you try to justify stuff that is wrong. Sad.

A professional broadcasting team would have no problem issuing an apology.


P
JBlain619 wrote:
I didn't try to justify shit. Im telling you EXACTLY how it was. She asked a question, he balked, simple as that.
"It's the broadcasters and media's job to stir controversy, come on now."


That statement is why the media has become what it is today. It's all about "creating" a story instead of reporting the facts and reporting on the actual story.

I said it before and I'll say it again, if they have any class they will issue an apology. If not, how can you really believe anything that they "report" on again?


P
P
Posts
6054
Joined
11/21/2006
Location
Greensboro, NC, USA
1/17/2011 4:25pm
Pdub wrote:
P, you know I love you, but... Your first mistake: expecting class and/or journalism from the people who broadcast supercross. Your second mistake: expecting a reasonable...
P, you know I love you, but...



Your first mistake: expecting class and/or journalism from the people who broadcast supercross.



Your second mistake: expecting a reasonable discussion about that here



Your third mistake: taking the bait... but if you're having fun with it, have at it! Wink
Yeah, I know.

I was actually hoping that at least someone on the broadcast team or associated with it would read the post and decide to take some pride in their craft and recognize their mistake. If they don't mention it again they simply say to the people "the stuff that we tell you doesn't mean shit." If they issue and apology they at least give you the idea that they have some journalistic integrity and want to bring you a quality product. An apology doesn't downgrade them it actually gives the more credibility IMHO.


P

Post a reply to: James Stewart and San Manuel deserve........

The Latest