How to red sticker 2023 bike? Commiefornia

JK BRO
Posts
348
Joined
7/29/2021
Location
Oroville, CA US
Fantasy
9/3/2024 11:16am
If I were living in Cali-fornifica, I'd go speak to a lawyer.  The law written states the EPA has no jurisdiction over race model only vehicles...

If I were living in Cali-fornifica, I'd go speak to a lawyer.  The law written states the EPA has no jurisdiction over race model only vehicles.  I would think a good lawyer may be able to show that state laws don't trump US laws.  So the California laws I'd think also couldn't regulate race only vehicles. With the Chevron Deference ruling, plus the rulings that states tried to make sanctuary gun laws getting squashed, should help.  I'd think that especially for racing even on public land, you'd be able to win that battle.  I'd fight for no sticker at all on a race only vehicle, because no regulation should mean no registration. Jmho. 

When your riding on state owned property they can make whatever laws/regulations they want. Not sure anyone here has the money to fight the state of CA with a personal lawyer lol.

People who bought 22+ knew there was a risk with registration. This subject has been talked about and plastered on many forums.

Fact is 2021's are gold in CA due to the new law. 

Falcon
Posts
12171
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
9/3/2024 11:29am
Falcon wrote:
"Should." The people at the DMV don't know what to do. Their own vehicle inspection document (I saw it) indicates that this bike is "competition only" and...

"Should." 

The people at the DMV don't know what to do. Their own vehicle inspection document (I saw it) indicates that this bike is "competition only" and not eligible for any sticker. CARB, an unelected entity which technically has no legal standing, changes their rules all the time and DMV doesn't know what the rules are.

I have very little hope that I'll ever see a registration for the bike, but happily enough I have even little care. My son and I are going to ride responsibly all over the tracks and desert, and we will probably never have an issue. If I ever need to go to court, I'll show them the receipt printout for my $52 and their own CARB regulations. You can only go so far out of your way to help this stupid state along. 

RichieW13 wrote:

Why wouldn't CARB have legal standing?  It was created by the California legislature to create regulations for improving air quality.

I am thinking of the Chevron doctrine and the fact that nobody in CARB is an elected official. Saying they do not have legal standing is somewhat inacccurate, I suppose. 

It is my opinion that CARB should not have the regulatory authority to provide standards which become de-facto laws. 

4
sumdood
Posts
8583
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA US
Fantasy
9/3/2024 12:19pm

Falcon I’m with you, just go ride wherever you want, don’t be a douchebag doing douchebag  things and you “probably” wont even get noticed. 
I imagine those rules will get enforced about as much as the “No 2 stroke leaf blowers” rule. Which is absolutely zero.  I don’t know about other areas but out in Octotillo Wells there’s enough SxS idiots to keep the rangers more than busy 

1
RichieW13
Posts
2386
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA US
9/3/2024 12:43pm
Falcon wrote:
"Should." The people at the DMV don't know what to do. Their own vehicle inspection document (I saw it) indicates that this bike is "competition only" and...

"Should." 

The people at the DMV don't know what to do. Their own vehicle inspection document (I saw it) indicates that this bike is "competition only" and not eligible for any sticker. CARB, an unelected entity which technically has no legal standing, changes their rules all the time and DMV doesn't know what the rules are.

I have very little hope that I'll ever see a registration for the bike, but happily enough I have even little care. My son and I are going to ride responsibly all over the tracks and desert, and we will probably never have an issue. If I ever need to go to court, I'll show them the receipt printout for my $52 and their own CARB regulations. You can only go so far out of your way to help this stupid state along. 

RichieW13 wrote:

Why wouldn't CARB have legal standing?  It was created by the California legislature to create regulations for improving air quality.

Falcon wrote:
I am thinking of the Chevron doctrine and the fact that nobody in CARB is an elected official. Saying they do not have legal standing is...

I am thinking of the Chevron doctrine and the fact that nobody in CARB is an elected official. Saying they do not have legal standing is somewhat inacccurate, I suppose. 

It is my opinion that CARB should not have the regulatory authority to provide standards which become de-facto laws. 

I believe the Chevron deference only related to federal agencies.  States can still defer to state agencies for setting rules and regulations.

1

The Shop

mx317
Posts
5281
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
TN US
9/3/2024 1:08pm

Seems like people will be having some bootleg stickers made. You could probably do it on a good copy machine and put clear backing over it.

9/3/2024 2:01pm Edited Date/Time 9/3/2024 2:01pm
mx317 wrote:

Seems like people will be having some bootleg stickers made. You could probably do it on a good copy machine and put clear backing over it.

We'd get in way less trouble here going without the sticker. Chances are we'd get more punished than the actual criminals here if we made fake stickers.

3
Falcon
Posts
12171
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
9/3/2024 2:08pm
RichieW13 wrote:

Why wouldn't CARB have legal standing?  It was created by the California legislature to create regulations for improving air quality.

Falcon wrote:
I am thinking of the Chevron doctrine and the fact that nobody in CARB is an elected official. Saying they do not have legal standing is...

I am thinking of the Chevron doctrine and the fact that nobody in CARB is an elected official. Saying they do not have legal standing is somewhat inacccurate, I suppose. 

It is my opinion that CARB should not have the regulatory authority to provide standards which become de-facto laws. 

RichieW13 wrote:

I believe the Chevron deference only related to federal agencies.  States can still defer to state agencies for setting rules and regulations.

I stand corrected, then. 

Justthefacts
Posts
203
Joined
2/20/2022
Location
Bettendorf, IA US
9/3/2024 2:57pm Edited Date/Time 9/3/2024 3:10pm

CARB was handed authority by the US Congress, through the air quality act of 1967, and the clean air act of 1970.  Thus, they may not be able to say they were given authority for race only vehicles.  Like an argument of what authority were they able to hand over in the first place.  Since congress specifically excluded regulations for race only vehicles. 

 

"When a state can set its own rules isn’t always clear. Almost 60 years ago, Congress granted California the authority to set its own emission standards for vehicles. But a California mandate requiring major truck manufacturers to ramp up the sale of zero-emission vehicles might be an early test case, since experts are divided as to whether an interpretation of the Clean Air Act properly allows for such a law. 

California, above and beyond

There are areas of the regulatory universe where California law clearly can, and often does, go far above what the feds require."

1
Justthefacts
Posts
203
Joined
2/20/2022
Location
Bettendorf, IA US
9/3/2024 3:27pm

In the Air Quality Act of 1967, it basically states in section 303, they can not supercede the Federal Authority of what they were given to monitor. Thus, I'd still recommend speaking with a lawyer or someone within the AMA lawyers regarding this. 

Falcon
Posts
12171
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
9/4/2024 8:05pm

HAhahahahhaHAHAHAHAHAhahahaahh. Ha. Haha, ha, hah. 

I received all my registration materials back from the DMV with a handwritten note that reads: "Hem [sic] was voided dg [sic] returning originals back to you. Must contact C.A.R.B. 1 800 242-4450 or arb.ca.gov for certification before registration."

OF COURSE, the CARB website is 100% completely worthless. OF COURSE it is filled with tons of useless drivel about keeping California's air clean and healthy by eliminating those pesky weedwackers and diesel construction machines. OF COURSE there is a link to register to vote (with no ID required.) OF COURSE when I call the phone number, I get a recording which tells me nothing at all, except if I am a manufacturer looking to certify a zero-emissions vehicle to press 1, or to go to arb.ca.gov for all other subjects.

These effing guys don't know my YZ125 from an electric toothbrush, nor can they even instruct another state entity in their own requirements, yet they are trying to regulate everything in the state. 

Fuck 'em. If they don't want me to register my bike, so much the better. I'll save some $ and operate it anyway. Their loss.

5
JK BRO
Posts
348
Joined
7/29/2021
Location
Oroville, CA US
Fantasy
9/5/2024 11:38am
mx317 wrote:

Seems like people will be having some bootleg stickers made. You could probably do it on a good copy machine and put clear backing over it.

Nope, you're printer isn't that good. 

Here's what they look like. Good luck with the holographic state seals and fake numbers.

CA
1
hubbardmx50
Posts
2772
Joined
11/17/2016
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA US
9/5/2024 11:51am
Falcon wrote:
HAhahahahhaHAHAHAHAHAhahahaahh. Ha. Haha, ha, hah. I received all my registration materials back from the DMV with a handwritten note that reads: "Hem [sic] was voided dg [sic]...

HAhahahahhaHAHAHAHAHAhahahaahh. Ha. Haha, ha, hah. 

I received all my registration materials back from the DMV with a handwritten note that reads: "Hem [sic] was voided dg [sic] returning originals back to you. Must contact C.A.R.B. 1 800 242-4450 or arb.ca.gov for certification before registration."

OF COURSE, the CARB website is 100% completely worthless. OF COURSE it is filled with tons of useless drivel about keeping California's air clean and healthy by eliminating those pesky weedwackers and diesel construction machines. OF COURSE there is a link to register to vote (with no ID required.) OF COURSE when I call the phone number, I get a recording which tells me nothing at all, except if I am a manufacturer looking to certify a zero-emissions vehicle to press 1, or to go to arb.ca.gov for all other subjects.

These effing guys don't know my YZ125 from an electric toothbrush, nor can they even instruct another state entity in their own requirements, yet they are trying to regulate everything in the state. 

Fuck 'em. If they don't want me to register my bike, so much the better. I'll save some $ and operate it anyway. Their loss.

Absolute lunacy. This state has gone full retard. Let's pick up the moto industry and move it to Northern AZ. 

4
mx317
Posts
5281
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
TN US
9/5/2024 11:54am
JK BRO wrote:
Nope, you're printer isn't that good. Here's what they look like. Good luck with the holographic state seals and fake numbers.

Nope, you're printer isn't that good. 

Here's what they look like. Good luck with the holographic state seals and fake numbers.

CA

You are right! I've never seen the newer ones like that.

1
Falcon
Posts
12171
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
9/5/2024 1:25pm
Falcon wrote:
HAhahahahhaHAHAHAHAHAhahahaahh. Ha. Haha, ha, hah. I received all my registration materials back from the DMV with a handwritten note that reads: "Hem [sic] was voided dg [sic]...

HAhahahahhaHAHAHAHAHAhahahaahh. Ha. Haha, ha, hah. 

I received all my registration materials back from the DMV with a handwritten note that reads: "Hem [sic] was voided dg [sic] returning originals back to you. Must contact C.A.R.B. 1 800 242-4450 or arb.ca.gov for certification before registration."

OF COURSE, the CARB website is 100% completely worthless. OF COURSE it is filled with tons of useless drivel about keeping California's air clean and healthy by eliminating those pesky weedwackers and diesel construction machines. OF COURSE there is a link to register to vote (with no ID required.) OF COURSE when I call the phone number, I get a recording which tells me nothing at all, except if I am a manufacturer looking to certify a zero-emissions vehicle to press 1, or to go to arb.ca.gov for all other subjects.

These effing guys don't know my YZ125 from an electric toothbrush, nor can they even instruct another state entity in their own requirements, yet they are trying to regulate everything in the state. 

Fuck 'em. If they don't want me to register my bike, so much the better. I'll save some $ and operate it anyway. Their loss.

Absolute lunacy. This state has gone full retard. Let's pick up the moto industry and move it to Northern AZ. 

100%. 

Wife and I are going to retire in AZ. Just have to pick the city and wait until she retires in 20 years. West Sedona or Cottonwood get my vote. 

Falcon
Posts
12171
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
9/6/2024 8:31am

Well, I didn't actually expect to hear back from CARB, but they answered my email today. 

"There is no letter or certificate that CARB provides for closed course motorcycles." 

Yeah, I know. Let's forget the fact that motocross bikes from 2021 and older are now supposedly grandfathered in for green stickers. I really don't even care; just give me a title. I don't even want or need a sticker, red or green. 

1

Post a reply to: How to red sticker 2023 bike? Commiefornia

The Latest