Upgrade to enjoy this feature!
Vital MX fantasy is free to play, but Premium users receive great benefits. Premium benefits include:
- View and download rider stats
- Pick trends
- Create a private league
- And more!
Only $10 for all 2026 SX, MX, and SMX series.
Ok, I understand.
To me, however, technical means more big crashes, more injuries, more riders missing races (a diminishes field), more lappers (and sooner in the races), less interest from privateers, etc. Plus, with modern bikes and traction control, a lot of the technical part has been lost anyway. As Supercross has matured, the obstacles have become more standardized, leading to a lack of creativity in track designs.
Personally, if I pay the money to go see a Supercross, I want to be on the edge of my seat watching several riders battle for the win. Not sure there is a good formula to have technical tracks and tracks that lead to close racing though.
Look no further than the past with RC, James, and Chad. Were they above everyone else on the regular? Yes..Did the slower more technical tracks provide great racing? Yes. injuries? Yes. The sport will have injuries regardless, and the injuries today are more catastrophic due to the watered down high speed tracks. I also refuse to watch the best riders compete on tracks that are simply not good enough because some are better than others
The bikes…… on one hand we have superior machines with tons of technology to make the sport easier. But I am a believer that the 250f is the proper supercross size and the 450 is too large and doesn’t allow the riders to be as aggressive as in the past. Take away the grates, launch control, and the starting devices. Easy changes to make racing better
what would you replace the whoops with to make the racing more exciting? Cant be more jumps because everyone already does the same thing.
I would love for the sport to move to 250 indoors / 450 outdoors
The Shop
DeCal Works Huge Plastic Inventory of UFO and Polisport kits.
If you write a nice letter to Mr. Feld I am sure he will do his best...
I agree on your take of technical tracks tending to make for less exciting battles. But I was thinking , Darkfish tells everybody the fastest way around the track as soon as anybody is able to do a section . If they made a section that each of the top guys had , that they were better in. It might be a way to make for better racing and more technical tracks? Since it would give each guy a section they could make up time on the others.
But You would still run into lappers sooner, and have the better chances of injuries.
I too would rather watch a battle between a few guys , than watch Jett or somebody else runaway and ride on a track that 18 or more of the racers are just trying to make it around.
Southwick is one of the most basic tracks as far as jumps. there has only been a couple jumps on the track over the years that not every rider was able to do in just about every class. And still , when the National came around I found myself in awe. Watching the guys rail a corner and hit a section I rode on all the time. And seeing how fast and consistent they were. I think You could argue that easier tracks are more identifiable. Like how everybody who watches a Nascar road course race feels like they could drive the course. Or watching pro golf VS playing Yourself. Or other Pro sports having the same basic settings for am and Pro versions.
People have made the case for years that some of the most popular sports as far as viewing numbers, are sports that are relightable . You could see Yourself doing whatever activity , and see how much better the Pro is able to do it.
I'm not sure that setup is going to be the same for every rider. Webb has been known to not be great in whoops. So that could be why his setup is so heavily biased towards whoops. Guys like Jett or Kenny that are better in whoops may not be focused on the whoops as much as Webb when they set their bikes up for a track. I give credit to the OP for making the post and making a good case for trying a track without whoops. But I think that just like other sections of the tracks, its going to favor some riders more by changing them.
Imagine the extreme disappointment Webb would have if he gets to a track and there are no whoops. I mean after all, that is not actually his strength......
Feld still has 'em... Ringling Brothers Barnum and Bailey circus. 🐘 🦁 🍿
The thing to me is what is better racing? Closer isn't always better. Look at cycling or moto3 racing, they are all stuck together in groups so most of the race is a parade anyway.
Taking out whoops would almost certainly mean closer lap times but that also means theres less opportunity to make up time on a leader or make your way through the pack.
Maybe my perception is skewed as a hard enduro guy but I want to see pros hit the gnarliest obstacles lap after lap, so that I can sit at home and get inspired to improve. I dont want to just see another straight or triple that takes a crack of throttle on a modern 450. I do want to see guys grease tricky rhythms or step on step offs or blast through 14 whoops
That would make room for 125s in what is now the 250 class!
2 strokes indoors, whatever they want outdoors!
If the whoop sections are removed, the biggest change will be to the signage out front. It will now say Supermoto.
Another thing to consider, and it's been shown in this topic, is there are differing ideas about what is better racing.
As far has seeing riders hit the gnarliest obstacles lap after lap, doesn't that only translate to the hard core fans who have a developed understanding of the skill involved?
I will say that to me Supercross is the icing, and motocross is the cake.
So what can Supercross do to create the type of racing that sells out every stadium?
One of the least popular ideas, but probably one of the best for great racing, is inverted starts. Not inverted gate picks, but starts that give a disadvantage to the faster riders. And no, I wouldn't consider passing points - same points distribution as has been. Not sure how to work it so the fastest riders can't game the system though.
I do think this is a good topic 🙂
Bring back loader whoops and long sections of them. There is a way to make it challenging and be safe. The tracks have sucked ass this year for the most part.
Just make the whole track a whoop section please. 1/2 big loader whoops and half dozer.
Whoops are a defining feature of Supercross. Some outdoors (maybe Washougal) have similar, but removing them would likely bring the lap times even closer together. Really need the irregular whoops cited above to separate the men from the boys, and the boys from their bikes!
Pit Row
Super simple. Loader whoops and more than 9, long rhythms with 180s at the end of them and varying jump obstacles instead of the 3footer and 5 footer standards. Whoever is in charge of tracks and decision making clearly did not race.
Its funny, I see it differently, if the tracks were easier, surely there would be chance of MORE different winners.
Less skill needed to navigate the obstacles means that more people have that level of skill.
As an example, at Daytona, ONLY Jett was doing that rhythm each lap- so if we take that obstacle out, then Jett doesn't have that opportunity to make gains over the rest of them.
Im not saying I want easier tracks btw..
Yah and having less places that are easier for a hand full of riders to make up time, will force them to find other ways of making up time.
Years ago I was out riding with a group of guys . Mostly B class guys , a Pro and a top 100 Pro. We were on a simple whooped out sand oval. Most of us had a lap time of around a minute. The top 100 guy was able to put down a lap 15 seconds faster than the slowest of us. And 6 05 8 seconds faster than the second fastest. The top 100 Guy was a Factory Husky rider back when JT was on the team. We were all blown away that somebody was able to go so much faster on such a basic simple track that the rest of us were all so close on. It was 2 straights and 2 180 corners with average 2-4 foot deep sand whoops. And the fastest guy was on a 125 . Most of us were on 250 2 strokes. And we rode that silly oval at least 1 time every week , and had been for about a year. And he did it his first time ever riding there.
Everybody knows a top guy is going to be able to hit the toughest stuff, and I do enjoy watching that too. But as far as exciting races go. The ones that Tomac and Sexton had where they were 1 second apart at the finish and the 3 way battle between J-Law, Dungey and Grant at Budd's Creek were exciting to watch.
I can find enjoyment in either type of racing honestly. But I get more excited when there are close battles with lots of passing.
And while we are are at it:
Bring back the old number system where it was based on season ending points. I want to know at a glance which rider is more consistent/faster. Gives ya something to learn each season!
Fold up your chairs and get off my lawn...
Yes SX has changed in the last decade. Tracks are smoother and have more flow. Yes there are more jumps. Yes Davey and Co. killed the 2T. Yes track conditions caused by weather can make an easy track hard. Yes, removing or dumbing down/limiting the whoop section and eliminating the Dragon's Back is the woke way to design a track.
In the end all the riders race the same track. Some fields are deeper than others. Sometimes there is a generational rider that waxes everybody for years ie MC. Regardless, we will watch, on the edge of our seat, and complain about this or that. It is a never ending cycle...
You are not off my lawn yet?
Bro, are you kidding me? Everything they do is to make it more like NASCAR. where do you think the triple crap format comes from?
I think that hardcore fans may be the last person they should ask about making changes . Chances are 99% of us will all watch no matter what they do. To an extent anyway. Pulling in new, loyal viewers while not pissing off the hardcore guys is more likely their goal. You will never make everybody happy. Sometimes You have to shoot for making the most happy and pissing off the least.
I think theOP made a solid argument for removing whoops. I think it may be based too much on a single riders point of view though. I like that the whoops allow riders to make up time on others and I would not support getting rid of them at every track for every round. Maybe trying smaller whoops or sand whoops at a round here and there and seeing how it works out. But I think they should keep whoops. If 9 whoops and no dragons backs keep more guys healthy, I'm all for it!
You may actually be on to something for once. With a lack of separation by track obstacles the riders may indeed be taking more risk to create it.
I like the new numbering system. I'd prefer that whatever number a rider gets their first year, they get to keep for the rest of their career if they so desire. It's more easily recognizable year after year, and they can build a brand around it that helps them continue to fund their racing throughout their career. My number 446 comes from racing BMX in the 70's, and I still run it today, 48 years later. It's my number! And ironically, when I beat the world record for the fastest mile for a man over 60 (running), I'll have to run it in 4:46 or better
.
No, it wouldn't. Whoops are a part of supercross, and arenacross. We want to make the tracks easier than they were in the 90's ? Why?
They are an element that separates the riders, as they should be. I don't agree with the 9 whoop rule , let alone none. I wonder how MC would have reacted to 9 whoop sections and no dragon's backs.
Whoops are the clowns of moto. They only make racing worse. Everyone says they separate the riders, but that's the last thing I want as a racer or a spectator. If I am racing I want to be banging bars. If I am watching I want to see bar to bar racing.
Tracks are easier now in 2024, than they have been at any time in the modern era, which we could say from 2000, on. Watch some old races if you don't believe it.
Plenty of times only MC jumped something, or only James, or maybe James and chad ( stl 2009). The cream of the crop shouldn't be punished because the other guys can't jump something. Be like dungey and make it up in the turns then.
I know that not one single person is going to approve of my comment but I don't care for the whoops at all..... they're so out of place with the rest of the sync of the track and in person watching the race they remind me of an endurocross obstacle. I don't know why everyone is so in love with the whoops....I've been watching sx religiously since the late 80's and I've never had a problem hitting whoops...maybe no sx level but it's long been said riders set their bike up just for the whoops and I agree with the op on this ....it would be interesting to see what riders could do with a bike setup for the whole track amd not just one obstacle. I mean...just try it out as an experiment and see how it goes.
I don't care how many people disagree with me that's just my stance on it and I'm ok with my opinion not being popular ...they could fit in another rhythm section. There are plenty of other obstacles that can separate riders too. I get the purist standpoint but the focus solely on the whoops and the outrage when they're not gnarly or too gnarly during a race seems kind of ridiculous at times. I know it's blasphemy to say what I said so flame of if you must
Post a reply to: Would no whoops bring better racing?