Would no whoops bring better racing?

wopachop
Posts
56
Joined
6/17/2023
Location
Glamis, CA US

Cooper Webb on Pulp a couple weeks back talked about how they setup the suspension different for dozer whoops versus the loader. He said it helps a lot knowing in advance because they setup the bike for the whoop section and just deal with it everywhere else. 

Would there be better racing and more ability to pass in the turns if the bikes were not setup to handle whoops? I think they are insane and cant believe the skill it takes. Ive personally never hit a set of whoops, so consider that in terms of my perspective. At one point i remember Glen Helen had some whoops in the late 90s but i just went around them being a noob rider on a Thursday afternoon. 

I dont think TV gives the whoops justice. So in terms of fans watching racing on TV, why even have them? Maybe that is where SMX comes into play. I just like watching the dudes rip. In person up close i could see the whoops being insanely entertaining. But on TV not so much. I think a split lane might be better racing for TV than a whoop section. Have they ever built a long split lane rhythm section? Since the tracks are getting so beat up with the gnarly horsepower, maybe more split lanes would help. Or ditch the 20 wide start. Just today on the Thursday show i think Osborne talked about starting position. He said if you have 18th gate pick youre never making it up front. So why not stagger the guys and free up floor space? 

Im more a new fan of the sport. Didnt watch back in the day cause i dont really watch TV. Having Peacock changed everything and now i watch every race day live. Didnt realize at the time how cool it was watching Blair and Jim!!!

1
32
|
inflammable
Posts
2219
Joined
10/2/2009
Location
Abilene, TX US
3/28/2024 8:02pm

I'd like to see some old-school uneven, irregularly spaced whoops. 

59
ATKpilot99
Posts
10412
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI US
3/28/2024 8:10pm

I'd like to see some old-school uneven, irregularly spaced whoops. 

Yes beat me to it .

9
wopachop
Posts
56
Joined
6/17/2023
Location
Glamis, CA US
3/28/2024 8:21pm

I'd like to see some old-school uneven, irregularly spaced whoops. 

Interesting. Would they make them irregular on purpose or just part of the deal?

CPR
Posts
6568
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
3/28/2024 8:24pm

No whoops, no supercross, that’s stadium motocross.

18
1

The Shop

wopachop
Posts
56
Joined
6/17/2023
Location
Glamis, CA US
3/28/2024 8:33pm
CPR wrote:

No whoops, no supercross, that’s stadium motocross.

Could the racing be better? 

9
bvm111
Posts
10076
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV US
3/28/2024 8:40pm

it’s the dumbing down of SX 

20
chad_111
Posts
302
Joined
4/22/2016
Location
CA
3/28/2024 8:41pm

racing would be better with old school loader whoops. 161015141 10161222736753973 5662572729680122334 n

34
CPR
Posts
6568
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
3/28/2024 8:58pm
CPR wrote:

No whoops, no supercross, that’s stadium motocross.

wopachop wrote:

Could the racing be better? 

If the rest of the track is like current tracks; no. One less passing opportunity.

4
1
CPR
Posts
6568
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
3/28/2024 8:58pm
chad_111 wrote:
racing would be better with old school loader whoops.

racing would be better with old school loader whoops. 161015141 10161222736753973 5662572729680122334 n

No jumping through those suckers.

15
inflammable
Posts
2219
Joined
10/2/2009
Location
Abilene, TX US
3/28/2024 9:01pm
wopachop wrote:

Interesting. Would they make them irregular on purpose or just part of the deal?

On purpose, as part of the track design 🙂

4
Gator 4
Posts
340
Joined
12/31/2021
Location
Southern California, CA US
3/28/2024 9:07pm

I would like to see some variety with the whoops so they are not always killer whoops.  I remember Lusk saying on track walk one night, he could see that the whoops were a little bit tamed down and he knew he would have a better shot at winning, and he won that night.     

Zachintosh
Posts
348
Joined
12/11/2015
Location
Orange County, CA US
3/28/2024 9:09pm

Those high speed rollers at one of the Monster Cup races were pretty rad. Would like to see a section like that at a regular SX.

1
cbarber
Posts
238
Joined
6/6/2014
Location
Atwater, MN US
3/29/2024 4:53am

split start with loader whoops. everyone is happy. or isn't..

1
SonofThor32
Posts
839
Joined
5/30/2021
Location
Corryton, TN US
3/29/2024 7:09am

I would never be a fan of taking whoops out - ever.  However, I will say at Birmingham, what was supposed to be the whoops, was right in front of me.  They basically just made  a roller section in place of where the whoops were, and they had completely different rhythms based on entry from the inside of the corner, or the outside.  There was a lot of different lines, different rhythms, and honestly decent passing.  It was not whoops, but provided a lot more than I thought it would.

6
3/29/2024 7:14am

Whoops exist to be blitzed across the top. If you want jumpers, that's called a rhythm section of doubles.

17
c0ncEpT
Posts
1309
Joined
5/13/2015
Location
Harrison Twp., MI US
3/29/2024 7:17am

Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect.

When you have vanilla tracks the racing gets worse. Nothing to seperate, nowhere to pass, Ect.

10
ATKpilot99
Posts
10412
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI US
3/29/2024 7:21am
c0ncEpT wrote:
Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect. When you have vanilla tracks the racing...

Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect.

When you have vanilla tracks the racing gets worse. Nothing to seperate, nowhere to pass, Ect.

That long rhythm lane at Daytona did that better than anything else this season . 

1
1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
NY US
3/29/2024 7:37am

The closest thing we have had to whoops this year is Daytona. That should tell you everything you need to know.

In essence we have "No Whoop Racing" as it stands.

3
inflammable
Posts
2219
Joined
10/2/2009
Location
Abilene, TX US
3/29/2024 7:40am
c0ncEpT wrote:
Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect. When you have vanilla tracks the racing...

Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect.

When you have vanilla tracks the racing gets worse. Nothing to seperate, nowhere to pass, Ect.

Wouldn't it also lead to a lot of boring races and few different winners?

Personally I'd like to see more racing, and tracks that lend themselves to more riders with the opportunity to win. My take is that's what I'm paying to see when I go to a Supercross. I want to see racing, not follow the leader. 

2
ILoveMoto
Posts
3599
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
3/29/2024 7:46am

Imagine the circus without lions and elephants 🤔

3
7
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
NY US
3/29/2024 7:50am
ILoveMoto wrote:

Imagine the circus without lions and elephants 🤔

Clowns are cheaper.

1
TeamGreen
Posts
36524
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA US
3/29/2024 7:51am

So…we’ve got no Dragon’s Back…we’re down to 9 Whoops…and now we’re suggesting No Whoops? 

Hmmmmmmm. Just REMOVE the name “Supercross” and call it Super TT by the time you’ve made it into what’s being suggested. 

Damn, we’re getting soft and boring. 

24
2
ILoveMoto
Posts
3599
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
3/29/2024 7:55am
ILoveMoto wrote:

Imagine the circus without lions and elephants 🤔

MxAddic wrote:

Clowns are cheaper.

I need my lions and elephants 😳

8
Shiner590
Posts
144
Joined
4/10/2021
Location
Ithaca, NY US
3/29/2024 7:57am

 

No. They'll be back to 9+ whoops once Jett gets a couple years in the 450s

2
4
ILoveMoto
Posts
3599
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
3/29/2024 7:58am
TeamGreen wrote:
So…we’ve got no Dragon’s Back…we’re down to 9 Whoops…and now we’re suggesting No Whoops?  Hmmmmmmm. Just REMOVE the name “Supercross” and call it Super TT by...

So…we’ve got no Dragon’s Back…we’re down to 9 Whoops…and now we’re suggesting No Whoops? 

Hmmmmmmm. Just REMOVE the name “Supercross” and call it Super TT by the time you’ve made it into what’s being suggested. 

Damn, we’re getting soft and boring. 

KTM Juniors are back this week so what whoops are there will be the micro version 😌

6
Zycki11
Posts
7683
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
3/29/2024 8:04am
c0ncEpT wrote:
Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect. When you have vanilla tracks the racing...

Supercross needs obstacles that separate riders. Sections that are difficult to hit perfectly, difficult to go through fast, ect.

When you have vanilla tracks the racing gets worse. Nothing to seperate, nowhere to pass, Ect.

Wouldn't it also lead to a lot of boring races and few different winners? Personally I'd like to see more racing, and tracks that lend themselves...

Wouldn't it also lead to a lot of boring races and few different winners?

Personally I'd like to see more racing, and tracks that lend themselves to more riders with the opportunity to win. My take is that's what I'm paying to see when I go to a Supercross. I want to see racing, not follow the leader. 

My take is I want to see the best compete on technical tracks. Which is what supercross is supposed to be. We have technicality thanks to weather and laps this years. Give me whoops, good rhythms, 180’s, and great racing will happen. The tracks today are like a mom kissing her teenager goodbye in the morning as she drops him off at high school. 

1
TAUTOG
Posts
1561
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA US
3/29/2024 8:26am
I would never be a fan of taking whoops out - ever.  However, I will say at Birmingham, what was supposed to be the whoops, was...

I would never be a fan of taking whoops out - ever.  However, I will say at Birmingham, what was supposed to be the whoops, was right in front of me.  They basically just made  a roller section in place of where the whoops were, and they had completely different rhythms based on entry from the inside of the corner, or the outside.  There was a lot of different lines, different rhythms, and honestly decent passing.  It was not whoops, but provided a lot more than I thought it would.

I liked that section too. But agreed, the track also needed a whoop section. Every Supercross track needs whoops.

3
wopachop
Posts
56
Joined
6/17/2023
Location
Glamis, CA US
3/29/2024 8:32am

I'm surprised nobody agrees with me. Wonder what the racers would say. If they could be more aggressive in the turns I would think it would be more fun to watch. Especially with so many fans thinking the races have been a bit boring. Maybe I'm way off here but bike setup seems to matter more than skill for the majority of riders. 

Here's a funny question. Where would Jett finish on a Beta?

5
DF313
Posts
696
Joined
6/17/2016
Location
Ogden, UT US
3/29/2024 8:46am Edited Date/Time 3/29/2024 8:52am

speaking of whoops, what was the year at Daytona when they fixed the whoops after the heats and then it was a war zone on the first lap of the 250s?  I don't think it was this link I posted, but maybe it is and I am just remembering wrong?

ILoveMoto
Posts
3599
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
3/29/2024 8:55am
wopachop wrote:
I'm surprised nobody agrees with me. Wonder what the racers would say. If they could be more aggressive in the turns I would think it would...

I'm surprised nobody agrees with me. Wonder what the racers would say. If they could be more aggressive in the turns I would think it would be more fun to watch. Especially with so many fans thinking the races have been a bit boring. Maybe I'm way off here but bike setup seems to matter more than skill for the majority of riders. 

Here's a funny question. Where would Jett finish on a Beta?

"Where would Jett finish on a Beta?"

No beta than his Honda.

I'll be here all week try the veal.

4
8

Post a reply to: Would no whoops bring better racing?

The Latest