Be Proud, Erin Bates.

151
Posts
536
Joined
9/15/2009
Location
Olive Branch, MS, USA
2/28/2010 10:48am Edited Date/Time 2/28/2010 10:51am
151
Posts
536
Joined
9/15/2009
Location
Olive Branch, MS, USA
2/28/2010 10:51am
151 wrote:
Obviously you are not going to change your mind, until someone sticks a mic in your face on the line and questions about that time your...
Obviously you are not going to change your mind, until someone sticks a mic in your face on the line and questions about that time your wife cheated on you???

And I would say, yes, to a champion winning is THAT important. And I am sure if you are married she is a wonderful woman, I was just making a point.
chuck317 wrote:
your a freaking idiot. in car racing after the driver has flipped ten times after slamming the wall the reporter is waiting on them to come...
your a freaking idiot. in car racing after the driver has flipped ten times after slamming the wall the reporter is waiting on them to come out of infield care center. you probally jerk off to erin and still cant get off. thats why you are so pissed.
Yeah well car racing has become an abomination of what it once was. I can't remember for certain but I think NASCAR has more female fans than male. The actual racing is no where near as good as it was in the 70's and 80's for NASCAR, and F1 is like playing simon says.

NASCAR has become a stupid excuse for racing. It is more of a soap opera.

The fact that you compare off road motorcycle racing to auto racing takes away most if not all credibility from your statements.

The fact that you cannot post without resorting to elemetary school tactics doesn't help your cause.

Do you even ride? Or are you just a spectator (ugh)?
jmar
Posts
14154
Joined
2/11/2007
Location
Oklahoma City, OK, USA
2/28/2010 10:54am
jmar wrote:
The person that pointed out the plugged muffler was Tim McAdams who is an AMA official, not a TV broadcast guy.
aminkman wrote:
Isn't he supposed to be a disinterested observer of the rules? Why would he help a racer with a mechanical issue?
He didn't touch the bike. He just informed RVs mechanic on what the problem was. He would have do the same for anyone.

No rules broken here.
chuck317
Posts
792
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Cleveland, TN, USA
2/28/2010 10:58am
151 wrote:
Obviously you are not going to change your mind, until someone sticks a mic in your face on the line and questions about that time your...
Obviously you are not going to change your mind, until someone sticks a mic in your face on the line and questions about that time your wife cheated on you???

And I would say, yes, to a champion winning is THAT important. And I am sure if you are married she is a wonderful woman, I was just making a point.
chuck317 wrote:
your a freaking idiot. in car racing after the driver has flipped ten times after slamming the wall the reporter is waiting on them to come...
your a freaking idiot. in car racing after the driver has flipped ten times after slamming the wall the reporter is waiting on them to come out of infield care center. you probally jerk off to erin and still cant get off. thats why you are so pissed.
151 wrote:
Yeah well car racing has become an abomination of what it once was. I can't remember for certain but I think NASCAR has more female fans...
Yeah well car racing has become an abomination of what it once was. I can't remember for certain but I think NASCAR has more female fans than male. The actual racing is no where near as good as it was in the 70's and 80's for NASCAR, and F1 is like playing simon says.

NASCAR has become a stupid excuse for racing. It is more of a soap opera.

The fact that you compare off road motorcycle racing to auto racing takes away most if not all credibility from your statements.

The fact that you cannot post without resorting to elemetary school tactics doesn't help your cause.

Do you even ride? Or are you just a spectator (ugh)?
i raced until i was 43, gave it up when i started worried about getting hurt. time to quit.. do not go watch now either. makes me miss it to much. i went to nascar in 70 and 80s, was much better then. yeah my comments were elementry, but hey, way it goes. right about f1 to.

The Shop

Foo723
Posts
197
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Pensacola, FL, USA
2/28/2010 11:08am
Erin reminds me a bit of Jamie Little, and that is a complement to both. Erin knows the sport.

one has to keep in mind, she has a producer hollering orders in her ears, probably all the time. last year in new orleans, i was sitting near the starting line and was able to watch her quite a bit. she works her little hiney off, working up camera angles, practicing the next blurb and so on, it looks like chaos.

it is only pure luck she happens to be there when villopoto goes into the mechanics area while vying fora points lead, or a james stewart crashes with reed in round 1 at A1 last year, jeez, let her get in there ... its all part of the sport growing.

i have no problems with the starting line interviews, a good racer would properly prepare his mind for a race in the solitude of his multi million dollar big rig, anyway. i would think that getting some face time for you and your sponsors on live tv would be a big deal. its when no one wants to talk to you on the starting line, you may have a problem

the only small flaw that Erin may have is she hasnt approved my facebook friend request ... i'm going to blame that on brian vickers.
plowboy
Posts
14320
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
2/28/2010 11:19am
I don't know Erin Bates personally. I do notice Erin Bates (a lot). Does she stumble and fumble sometimes...yes. Does she get (or at least try) to get the access I don't have...yes. All I know is that at the races she is all over the pits with her microphone and without it. She comes across as a fan of the sport and that's my measuring stick. I sat next to her at a Chili's after a race one time and she seemed pretty "real" to me.
Grendel
Posts
2559
Joined
5/17/2008
Location
USA
2/28/2010 11:41am
This is an important topic especially with some of the stuff that's happened this year.

When the riders shun the reporters so they can set up a camera in their house and create their own little press conference with their own set of questions, something has to be done in order to regain control. The DMXS guys have been touching on this lately and RC mentioned the importance and benefits of the journalist-rider rapport.

I can't think of any of the current batch of SX/MX interviewers/announcers/journalists that are outright disrespectful. But cronyism plagues this sport because it involves big money coupled with a relatively smaller atmosphere. For now, respectful persistence is the only solution until it gathers a bigger following and clears all the eggshells out of the pressroom.
swizcore
Posts
4234
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
2/28/2010 12:37pm
Grendel wrote:
This is an important topic especially with some of the stuff that's happened this year. When the riders shun the reporters so they can set up...
This is an important topic especially with some of the stuff that's happened this year.

When the riders shun the reporters so they can set up a camera in their house and create their own little press conference with their own set of questions, something has to be done in order to regain control. The DMXS guys have been touching on this lately and RC mentioned the importance and benefits of the journalist-rider rapport.

I can't think of any of the current batch of SX/MX interviewers/announcers/journalists that are outright disrespectful. But cronyism plagues this sport because it involves big money coupled with a relatively smaller atmosphere. For now, respectful persistence is the only solution until it gathers a bigger following and clears all the eggshells out of the pressroom.
Was that a poem? It was certainly poetic.

Oh and awesome use of "cronyism".
Grendel
Posts
2559
Joined
5/17/2008
Location
USA
2/28/2010 4:16pm
Blush
zippy895
Posts
5495
Joined
7/15/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
2/28/2010 4:20pm
she's doing fine.she is knowledgeable of the sport, she knows the riders NAMES and I'm sure this is what her bosses are asking her to do.she's on it.not sitting back,collecting a paycheck.
JJ #591
Posts
21
Joined
1/18/2010
Location
Bend, OR, USA
2/28/2010 4:58pm
I love this discussion.

To Rupert X,

Do you think Erin Bates is doing a good job when she says to Brett Metcalf, while on the podium, and after he has garnered a well earned third place,"What is it about this place that always gets the best of you?"

The guys just worked his ass off and got third place after taking a nasty fall, and you want to spoil the rider/sponsor celebration by doing that?

I have witnessed her do this on too many occations to count, so now I am saving them all for future reference.

Additionally, when interviewing Davi Millsaps she asked him if his third place was "bittersweet". I realize that she maybe is emplying that he could have won the race if he had a better start, but lets celebrate the rider and his sponsors and when they make the podim, not add negativity to the proceeding.

Just my opinion.
2/28/2010 5:09pm
Wasn't it RC that suggested they interview the riders on the line? I think it's cool when the hot chick over in euro land does it.
SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
2/28/2010 5:10pm
Clutchy wrote:
Nascar talks to its drivers on the starting line, during the race, while their taking a piss, playing with their dog................ You get the picture.

jmar wrote:
They don't allow anyone to walk up to the car when and start shoving mics in people's faces. It's a staged event and permission is given...
They don't allow anyone to walk up to the car when and start shoving mics in people's faces. It's a staged event and permission is given before it is allowed.
In today's NASCAR race they were interviewing Montoya while he was waiting for his car to be repaired and asking him what he thought of his teammate causing the wreck--and got quite an earful of an answer from Montoya about his teammate. There was no staging. It was in the middle of the race. It's something that happens all the time.
zippy895
Posts
5495
Joined
7/15/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
2/28/2010 5:16pm
JJ #591 wrote:
I love this discussion. To Rupert X, Do you think Erin Bates is doing a good job when she says to Brett Metcalf, while on the...
I love this discussion.

To Rupert X,

Do you think Erin Bates is doing a good job when she says to Brett Metcalf, while on the podium, and after he has garnered a well earned third place,"What is it about this place that always gets the best of you?"

The guys just worked his ass off and got third place after taking a nasty fall, and you want to spoil the rider/sponsor celebration by doing that?

I have witnessed her do this on too many occations to count, so now I am saving them all for future reference.

Additionally, when interviewing Davi Millsaps she asked him if his third place was "bittersweet". I realize that she maybe is emplying that he could have won the race if he had a better start, but lets celebrate the rider and his sponsors and when they make the podim, not add negativity to the proceeding.

Just my opinion.
i feel that it is cool she starts w/ a bad/negative and it ends w/ a positive ....great ride ending.
not the same old ..great ride how do you feel!
the riders always speak the positive side before the mic is gone,and she knows this.
bh626
Posts
34
Joined
3/9/2009
Location
CA
3/1/2010 8:51am
Her podium skills suck, along with most riders. Can you fix that Rup?

EB: "You crashed really hard in the whoops and lost the race. It'll probably cost you the title. How does that make you feel? What does it do to your confidence level?"

JoeRacer: Ya, I just wanna thank Monster, my mechanic, my mother, my dog, blah blah blah."
jmar
Posts
14154
Joined
2/11/2007
Location
Oklahoma City, OK, USA
3/1/2010 9:10am
Clutchy wrote:
Nascar talks to its drivers on the starting line, during the race, while their taking a piss, playing with their dog................ You get the picture.

jmar wrote:
They don't allow anyone to walk up to the car when and start shoving mics in people's faces. It's a staged event and permission is given...
They don't allow anyone to walk up to the car when and start shoving mics in people's faces. It's a staged event and permission is given before it is allowed.
SteveS wrote:
In today's NASCAR race they were interviewing Montoya while he was waiting for his car to be repaired and asking him what he thought of his...
In today's NASCAR race they were interviewing Montoya while he was waiting for his car to be repaired and asking him what he thought of his teammate causing the wreck--and got quite an earful of an answer from Montoya about his teammate. There was no staging. It was in the middle of the race. It's something that happens all the time.
That's bullshit and you know it. If his car was in the garage the team allowed the reporter to come in or he agreed to come out.

Reporters are not allowed to enter a garage with out permission. Only NASCAR officials came come and go as they please.
Trip
Posts
2255
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
USA
3/1/2010 9:45am
jmar wrote:
They don't allow anyone to walk up to the car when and start shoving mics in people's faces. It's a staged event and permission is given...
They don't allow anyone to walk up to the car when and start shoving mics in people's faces. It's a staged event and permission is given before it is allowed.
SteveS wrote:
In today's NASCAR race they were interviewing Montoya while he was waiting for his car to be repaired and asking him what he thought of his...
In today's NASCAR race they were interviewing Montoya while he was waiting for his car to be repaired and asking him what he thought of his teammate causing the wreck--and got quite an earful of an answer from Montoya about his teammate. There was no staging. It was in the middle of the race. It's something that happens all the time.
jmar wrote:
That's bullshit and you know it. If his car was in the garage the team allowed the reporter to come in or he agreed to come...
That's bullshit and you know it. If his car was in the garage the team allowed the reporter to come in or he agreed to come out.

Reporters are not allowed to enter a garage with out permission. Only NASCAR officials came come and go as they please.
Again, facts getting in the way of someones point... lol
Steve47
Posts
274
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Winter Springs, FL, USA
3/1/2010 9:51am
My opinion is that she's not qualified to do that job!!! It's not what she does (going around and asking questions) that's the problem, it's her speech. She's really not good at talking and asking questions.

She might be nice, work hard, look good but the fact is that her podium interviews are terrible.

I remember watching Krysta Voda during her first SX race thinking she'll have a hard time and problably didn't know squat about SX. Well, the thing is she was really good, sounded professional and was very informative. Interviews were good and you couldn't tell she didn't know much about SX. Jamie Little also had good interview skills.

I really believe Erin is not the right person for the job and it shows... It lacks serious professionalism.
TeamGreen
Posts
37011
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
3/1/2010 9:55am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 9:06pm
Dee, Dee, Dee...

When the Producer is screaming in you ear to "Go ask Ryan what's UP!?!?!"

You DO IT if you want to KEEP YOUR JOB!

Erin is a classy woman that knows this sport & it's atheletes.

It's doesn't hurt that she's damn sexxy, too!

I'm jus' sayin'...
Uncleof2
Posts
1276
Joined
5/10/2008
Location
Silverdale, WA, USA
3/1/2010 9:59am
aminkman wrote:
Isn't he supposed to be a disinterested observer of the rules? Why would he help a racer with a mechanical issue?
"disinterested observer of the rules" Yep sounds like a AMA official.Laughing
aminkman
Posts
514
Joined
1/3/2007
Location
Carmel Valley, CA, USA
3/1/2010 10:03am
I think we should leave the delicate flowers we call moto racers alone. Asking a question could really tailspin them. There is a fine line between winning and being a basket case. Look at Metcalf's position, he probably would have won if she didn't talk to him before the race. And Stroup surely would not have tossed it.
lucero10x
Posts
1624
Joined
9/25/2009
Location
Las Vegas, NV, USA
3/1/2010 10:06am
aminkman wrote:
I think we should leave the delicate flowers we call moto racers alone. Asking a question could really tailspin them. There is a fine line between...
I think we should leave the delicate flowers we call moto racers alone. Asking a question could really tailspin them. There is a fine line between winning and being a basket case. Look at Metcalf's position, he probably would have won if she didn't talk to him before the race. And Stroup surely would not have tossed it.
quit getting caught up in the reality of the situation!
Rooster
Posts
4432
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edmonton, CA
3/1/2010 10:09am
jmar wrote:
The person that pointed out the plugged muffler was Tim McAdams who is an AMA official, not a TV broadcast guy.
Regardless he was obviously informed about the plugged muffler as he was trying to point it out to the mechanic and Ryan from a position where he couldn't even see it.

Somebody was informing him through his headset and he relayed that information to the team.

Does that constitute outside assistance?
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
3/1/2010 10:14am Edited Date/Time 3/1/2010 10:16am
Okay, here are a few things...

Thursday is press day. With a limited selection of riders/teams. Mostly it's a chance for local media outlets to get the word out about the race, and help drum up ticket sales in the immediate area. The beat guys (and girls) who cover the sport week to week generally aren't there, unless it's in So. Cal., or close to their particular home. To make it to that one, it would require either a Wednesday flight (or red-eye), and two more nights in a hotel. Is that time and expense worth it? Not to me it isn't.

Clutchy's right. They frequently have rider interviews with drivers who are strapped in on the grid at four-wheeled motorsports events. They also do in-race interviews during caution flags via radio. (And boy are the pit reporters glad that they don't have to run alongside the cars.)

I don't fault them for asking questions on the line before a race, just because it hasn't been done before. For example, I walked by Josh Hill when he was sitting on the line for his heat race, and quickly asked if he was okay. He shook his head...and then went out and led the race before slipping back into the field.

Also, weren't they doing interviews during the Aussie SX series? I only got to watch a couple of the videos.

Anyway, the Speed/CBS crew are trying to change up how things are done...and hopefully that makes for better coverage in the future.

Now, for some of you guys who are bitching about Erin's performance, try setting up a camera, grab a toilet paper roll for a microphone, and bust out something smooth and insightful in one take. Make it 15-20 seconds long. Then post if up on YouTube for a worldwide audience to see. I'd be curious to see how you do.

Oh, and yes, Toolie's the one tasked with keeping the teams and riders in line from a technical side this year for the AMA. He replaced Dave Dye, who is now working at Hinson (and headed to Lake Whitney).
Trip
Posts
2255
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
USA
3/1/2010 10:15am
jmar wrote:
The person that pointed out the plugged muffler was Tim McAdams who is an AMA official, not a TV broadcast guy.
Rooster wrote:
Regardless he was obviously informed about the plugged muffler as he was trying to point it out to the mechanic and Ryan from a position where...
Regardless he was obviously informed about the plugged muffler as he was trying to point it out to the mechanic and Ryan from a position where he couldn't even see it.

Somebody was informing him through his headset and he relayed that information to the team.

Does that constitute outside assistance?
Yeah, probabley, but you will never see a bad thing written about Ryan. So unless it happens to someone other than who the mx media has a hard on for, it will not be a big deal.
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX, USA
3/1/2010 10:23am
Cant the rider on the gate say go away?
Christ, you bitches are making a bigger deal out of it then the riders.
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX, USA
3/1/2010 10:25am
jmar wrote:
The person that pointed out the plugged muffler was Tim McAdams who is an AMA official, not a TV broadcast guy.
Rooster wrote:
Regardless he was obviously informed about the plugged muffler as he was trying to point it out to the mechanic and Ryan from a position where...
Regardless he was obviously informed about the plugged muffler as he was trying to point it out to the mechanic and Ryan from a position where he couldn't even see it.

Somebody was informing him through his headset and he relayed that information to the team.

Does that constitute outside assistance?
He was standing right behind the bike, how could that possibly be " a position where he couldnt even see it"
Trip
Posts
2255
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
USA
3/1/2010 10:25am
Now, for some of you guys who are bitching about Erin's performance, try setting up a camera, grab a toilet paper roll for a microphone, and bust out something smooth and insightful in one take. Make it 15-20 seconds long. Then post if up on YouTube for a worldwide audience to see. I'd be curious to see how you do.


Thats the biggest cop out ever!!!! This reminds me of the 338 supporters who say you cant talk trash on him cause you cant ride as fast as he does. ( I'm all for J-Law, but I wont go there with it) WTF is that???
I'm not a professional on camera reporter like she is. This is her job, not mine. Her stumbling around words and trying to put sentances together on live TV is a joke.

So unless someone can do better at ones job, we are not allowed to give an opinion on anyones job??? Wowm kinda brings the message board to a grinding halt. That cant be good for business..

TeamGreen
Posts
37011
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
3/1/2010 10:29am
Trip get's the "Dee, Dee, Dee" of the Day.
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
3/1/2010 10:30am
I have an opinion. I think the majority of your posts lately suck. But that's just me.

Oh, and I reserve the right to retract the "lately" part. Smile

Post a reply to: Be Proud, Erin Bates.

The Latest