Shimoda”s Honda

sandman768
Posts
7953
Joined
3/21/2014
Location
Saratoga Springs, NY US

Any idea what broke on the Factory HRC Honda? I could not tell if it would not start or something like clutch or transmission issue? Flame on…

2
|
valveless
Posts
224
Joined
7/26/2013
Location
Island Grove, FL US
1/14/2024 5:35am Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 5:53am

The way he was acting it seemed like it must have been running. Must have been clutch or transmission related. 

1
1/14/2024 5:38am

It didn't make it very far in the main. Curious also.

 

7
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
NY US
1/14/2024 5:40am

"electrical issues..."

16
2
Markee
Posts
3658
Joined
4/15/2013
Location
Suffolk, VA US
1/14/2024 5:45am

The feeling they got when they saw a clutch plate laying on a shop towel. Brutal 

12

The Shop

1/14/2024 5:48am
valveless wrote:

The way he was acting it seemed like it must have been running. Must have been clutch or transmission related. 

In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon.

For mud races they all need to revert back to a good ol clutch cable. That way you at least have a little control over your destiny.

1
5
1/14/2024 5:51am

Shimoda was also one of my fantasy riders...Blink

4
7
Money
Posts
1847
Joined
1/18/2011
Location
Fresno, CA US
1/14/2024 6:00am

I would think after the heat they would have changed engines. No since in taking chances for a title guy. Put a fresh engine in and send it for the main. Not a good look that it only made a few corners. His championship is over now 

2
3
Spudinki45
Posts
641
Joined
2/16/2019
Location
Dallas, TX US
1/14/2024 6:11am

Imo he should’ve stayed on the Kawi. Mitch’s bikes have more power and are more reliable.

13
18
SX_336
Posts
367
Joined
12/29/2021
Location
Archdale, NC US
1/14/2024 6:26am
valveless wrote:

The way he was acting it seemed like it must have been running. Must have been clutch or transmission related. 

Boomslang wrote:
In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon. For mud races they all need to...

In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon.

For mud races they all need to revert back to a good ol clutch cable. That way you at least have a little control over your destiny.

The 250R IS a clutch cable. Only the 450R has a hydraulic. 

3
slowgti
Posts
1005
Joined
1/14/2016
Location
Monroe, GA US
1/14/2024 6:32am

The way he went down, I wonder if it hit the shifter hard enough to break the shift drum or pop a shift fork off internally?

7
1
ML512
Posts
16877
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA US
Fantasy
1/14/2024 6:43am
valveless wrote:

The way he was acting it seemed like it must have been running. Must have been clutch or transmission related. 

Boomslang wrote:
In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon. For mud races they all need to...

In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon.

For mud races they all need to revert back to a good ol clutch cable. That way you at least have a little control over your destiny.

SX_336 wrote:

The 250R IS a clutch cable. Only the 450R has a hydraulic. 

Jo’s bike has a hydro

8
1
Zycki11
Posts
7698
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
1/14/2024 6:44am
Boomslang wrote:
In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon. For mud races they all need to...

In those condition it can only be the damn clutch. I found it shocking that it happened so soon.

For mud races they all need to revert back to a good ol clutch cable. That way you at least have a little control over your destiny.

SX_336 wrote:

The 250R IS a clutch cable. Only the 450R has a hydraulic. 

ML512 wrote:

Jo’s bike has a hydro

So can we call that Myth “debunked”? 😂 

2
Zycki11
Posts
7698
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
1/14/2024 6:47am Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 6:49am
Spudinki45 wrote:

Imo he should’ve stayed on the Kawi. Mitch’s bikes have more power and are more reliable.

I initially thought the same thing, then realized he probably signed before the engine found its upgrades.  Honda has been on a run with the Lawrence brothers along with the updated bike. It may be down on power but I suspect it may not be much but maybe more so how it is delivered.  

2
Jack_4196
Posts
256
Joined
7/22/2015
Location
Franklin, MA US
1/14/2024 6:47am
MxAddic wrote:

"electrical issues..."

Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection issue lol

3
1
Zycki11
Posts
7698
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
1/14/2024 6:50am
MxAddic wrote:

"electrical issues..."

Jack_4196 wrote:
Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection...

Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection issue lol

That is because Phil is a pro and knows how to circumvent these situations with class. Phil is pure moto, was really hoping the racing gods were going to bless him with a podium. But alas, Phil got Phild 

8
valveless
Posts
224
Joined
7/26/2013
Location
Island Grove, FL US
1/14/2024 6:51am
MxAddic wrote:

"electrical issues..."

Jack_4196 wrote:
Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection...

Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection issue lol

The injector is activated by an electrical pulse. I don’t know if Nicoletti ever said it was mechanical injector failure or electrical.

13
yak651
Posts
8590
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
1/14/2024 6:53am Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 6:54am

Thought only the Club & Beta bikes failed, who would’ve thought a mighty HRC bike could have issues 🤷‍♂️

3
2
1/14/2024 7:34am
Spudinki45 wrote:

Imo he should’ve stayed on the Kawi. Mitch’s bikes have more power and are more reliable.

Vohlands bike went out not long into the main from what looked like a similar issure. It happens to the best of bikes on nights like that. 

14
Richy
Posts
3086
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK GB
1/14/2024 7:40am
Jack_4196 wrote:
Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection...

Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection issue lol

People often throw the ECU, injector (as said, it's a 12v supply and a few milliseconds ground pulse from the ECU to trigger it) and related sensors into the "Fuel Injection" or "EFI" box.

was good to see him have a good ride though, was hoping for a podium but Marchbanks was going well and deserved it. Phil is always funny on the mic, such a legend.

4
Spudinki45
Posts
641
Joined
2/16/2019
Location
Dallas, TX US
1/14/2024 7:49am
Vohlands bike went out not long into the main from what looked like a similar issure. It happens to the best of bikes on nights like...

Vohlands bike went out not long into the main from what looked like a similar issure. It happens to the best of bikes on nights like that. 

I think Vohlands died because he was abusing the clutch. Shimoda is known to not be that hard on it

1
2
1/14/2024 8:09am

Wasn't there some stupid little thing at the motodesnations a few years back that the mud caused a dnf. The amount of mud last night was insane and not normal, even kr94 said so. 

1
Mit12
Posts
2176
Joined
6/23/2014
Location
Lake Havasu City, AZ US
1/14/2024 8:29am

Pro Circuit to Honda not working out well for him.

1
11
1/14/2024 8:42am
MxAddic wrote:

"electrical issues..."

Jack_4196 wrote:
Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection...

Did you guys notice the broadcast kept saying Phil had electrical issues at A1, when in interviews he was open about it being a fuel injection issue lol

"Electronic" Fuel injection.... 'EFI'...

5
donman
Posts
711
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Golden, CO US
1/14/2024 10:21am
Spudinki45 wrote:

Imo he should’ve stayed on the Kawi. Mitch’s bikes have more power and are more reliable.

11
twotwosix
Posts
2221
Joined
9/29/2016
Location
TN US
1/14/2024 10:35am Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 10:36am

Bike only lasted 1/2 a lap into the main... say goodbye to that 250 regional title this year. Hate it for Jo.

3
Pop Shmoke
Posts
1772
Joined
6/17/2020
Location
Boston, MA US
1/14/2024 10:38am

Pretty wild to see the bike shit the bed 4 corners into the first lap. That absolutely ruined any shot he had at a championship, hes outside the top 10 in points already. Id definitely like to know what could possibly break that fast on the bike. Did they send him out there with an old clutch? 

1
1
1/14/2024 10:41am
Pop Shmoke wrote:
Pretty wild to see the bike shit the bed 4 corners into the first lap. That absolutely ruined any shot he had at a championship, hes...

Pretty wild to see the bike shit the bed 4 corners into the first lap. That absolutely ruined any shot he had at a championship, hes outside the top 10 in points already. Id definitely like to know what could possibly break that fast on the bike. Did they send him out there with an old clutch? 

Almost no way it could have been a clutch that early unless it was installed incorrectly to begin with.  I suppose that is possible.

1
sandman768
Posts
7953
Joined
3/21/2014
Location
Saratoga Springs, NY US
1/14/2024 10:43am

I would think a recluse auto clutch for the mud would have been a better choice? Seems to work good for all the GNCC guys, who race in the mud for 3hrs straight… or is it a question of too much torque & HP out of the modified 250”s, the clutches cannot handle? Just spitballing here… we don’t even know if it was the clutch that failed…. Here is  another analogy… in this 4t world, we’re told to not use the clutch as much…yet when you go to a National or an SX like last nite, all you smell is burned up clutch’s…. All I know is, when I”m riding by myself I can stay off the clutch pretty good, but soon as I get into a race battle, I”m on the clutch just like my 2 strokes😂… 

3
1
1/14/2024 10:54am

Its only one race. And who knows who else will have a bad night.  There could be another mud race or who knows. But It will be harder for him to get the title now for sure. Just about every brand had some sort of issue in that crazy mud.

A friend of mine that was/is a local pro used to be able to smoke a clutch in a Honda  after doing a start and the first turn. If He used aftermarket plates they were just enough thinner  that they slipped and got destroyed VERY fast. I doubt that HRC would have had an issue like that. But they could have had a plate break. A defective friction  plate falling apart would do that pretty quickly. That same rider I know had a brand new 100% stock RM 125 that had a couple fiber's  fall apart in the first 20 minutes of riding the bike. And that was in much better conditions. He had just gotten the bike after his previous RM125 was slipping out of gear very often. When the new RM broke so quickly he was about to go trade it in and get a Honda. But kept it after seeing it was just a plate. 

Might just have been some bad luck , sometimes You get a bad part.  Its another reason the perfect seasons are so impressive when a rider has one. Whatever it was ,  it looked to be clutch/trans related in some way. Doubt they will get too specific with what they say officially. But maybe Pulp or somebody will get some sort of leaked info.  

2
4
wvumounty
Posts
357
Joined
10/2/2018
Location
Butler, PA US
1/14/2024 11:20am

In situations when the clutch is abused a lot would oil make a difference? Conventional versus synthetic? I know some oils can cause clutch issues/slippage but do current racers ever use just conventional oil?

1

Post a reply to: Shimoda”s Honda

The Latest