The Elusive third title..

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

22
|
MKMX
Posts
493
Joined
3/3/2021
Location
Timbuktu, WA AU
5/8/2023 2:13am

You can add Webb to that list as well, his 2023 season took the same turn Eli’s did.

19
2
5/8/2023 4:35am
Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had...

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

Imagine telling someone after the 2009 season that neither Chad nor Stew would ever win another title.

21
RCMartin406
Posts
619
Joined
4/9/2023
Location
Dallas, GA US
5/8/2023 6:08am Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 7:44am
Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had...

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

Imagine telling someone after the 2009 season that neither Chad nor Stew would ever win another title.

From 2008 MX and 2009 SX Stew had 23 wins out 29 races. I said, well, he’s going to break every record and dominate for the next 5-6 years. Little did I know, injuries, bad bikes(Yamaha), and just bad decision making would be what dominated for the rest of his career. Just so disappointing with the way his career went after 2009.

8
Falcon
Posts
12253
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
5/8/2023 2:36pm
Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had...

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

Imagine telling someone after the 2009 season that neither Chad nor Stew would ever win another title.

From 2008 MX and 2009 SX Stew had 23 wins out 29 races. I said, well, he’s going to break every record and dominate for the...

From 2008 MX and 2009 SX Stew had 23 wins out 29 races. I said, well, he’s going to break every record and dominate for the next 5-6 years. Little did I know, injuries, bad bikes(Yamaha), and just bad decision making would be what dominated for the rest of his career. Just so disappointing with the way his career went after 2009.

This. There was so much hope when he moved to Suzuki and won the first 4 motos of the year, too... and then when he healed up... and then... and then....

8

The Shop

kpiper
Posts
2360
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
AZ US
5/8/2023 2:44pm Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 3:40pm

I doubt the 3rd title will be that big of a deal to Eli a couple of months from now. He got the 51 wins. Despite how he downplayed it, that was a BIG deal (ask J7) and I bet he is happy with what he has done in his career.

7 wins and having the title wrapped up (except for a freak incident) at 30 years old was amazing.

8
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
5/8/2023 3:13pm Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 3:25pm
MKMX wrote:

You can add Webb to that list as well, his 2023 season took the same turn Eli’s did.

Yup.

Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as how Chase will take this title....     

 

I was rooting for Webb to win the title this year.   First thing I said when Eli had that crash a few weeks back (to which he bounced right back from)..."I don't want to see Webb win a title like that". 

 

17
5/8/2023 3:20pm Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 3:21pm
Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had...

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

What if in 2003, someone told you Husky would have 4x the premiere titles of Honda over the next twenty years?

15
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65697
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
5/8/2023 3:26pm
MKMX wrote:

You can add Webb to that list as well, his 2023 season took the same turn Eli’s did.

Magoofan wrote:
Yup. Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as...

Yup.

Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as how Chase will take this title....     

 

I was rooting for Webb to win the title this year.   First thing I said when Eli had that crash a few weeks back (to which he bounced right back from)..."I don't want to see Webb win a title like that". 

 

And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend. 

No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the record books. 

9
1
Park Boys
Posts
3816
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
5/8/2023 3:41pm
Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had...

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

Before Gainesville 89, had you said RJ would never win a title again people would have you committed and put in a insane asylum. 
 

There are a few cases similar to what you are saying. 

2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
5/8/2023 3:42pm Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 3:43pm
MKMX wrote:

You can add Webb to that list as well, his 2023 season took the same turn Eli’s did.

Magoofan wrote:
Yup. Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as...

Yup.

Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as how Chase will take this title....     

 

I was rooting for Webb to win the title this year.   First thing I said when Eli had that crash a few weeks back (to which he bounced right back from)..."I don't want to see Webb win a title like that". 

 

-MAVERICK- wrote:
And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend.  No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the...

And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend. 

No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the record books. 

Agreed.  I was only saying that I wanted Webb to title...but not against an injured Tomac.

It's even worse in Chase's case...he was third place a week ago.     Inheriting a title from 18 points back due to injury sucks.

 

2
5
kpiper
Posts
2360
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
AZ US
5/8/2023 3:45pm Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 3:46pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:
And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend.  No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the...

And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend. 

No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the record books. 

That is very true but Chase will always know it and you can tell he does with the way he responded to all this. Fans will forget what happened to ET and CW but Chase won't. Having said that, Chase was the fastest guy this year so he can hold on to that. Winning this way is not fulfilling though.

Seeing his reaction to what happened to Eli really shows what Chase is made up of. Seems like a great person. Classy guy.

11
GrapeApe
Posts
8783
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX US
5/8/2023 3:49pm
Magoofan wrote:
Yup. Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as...

Yup.

Had Webb not been hit by AC, he'd be looking at title 3 this week.       Which I would  have hated as much as how Chase will take this title....     

 

I was rooting for Webb to win the title this year.   First thing I said when Eli had that crash a few weeks back (to which he bounced right back from)..."I don't want to see Webb win a title like that". 

 

-MAVERICK- wrote:
And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend.  No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the...

And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend. 

No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the record books. 

Magoofan wrote:
Agreed.  I was only saying that I wanted Webb to title...but not against an injured Tomac. It's even worse in Chase's case...he was third place a...

Agreed.  I was only saying that I wanted Webb to title...but not against an injured Tomac.

It's even worse in Chase's case...he was third place a week ago.     Inheriting a title from 18 points back due to injury sucks.

 

When you fall over in a bowl corner on the first lap with the entire pack bearing down odds of injury are pretty high. Sucks that Webb crashed out, like so many others.

I agree Eli's situation was different and unique and obviously Chase feels a little weird about it, too.

burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA US
5/8/2023 3:56pm
GrapeApe wrote:
When you fall over in a bowl corner on the first lap with the entire pack bearing down odds of injury are pretty high. Sucks that...

When you fall over in a bowl corner on the first lap with the entire pack bearing down odds of injury are pretty high. Sucks that Webb crashed out, like so many others.

I agree Eli's situation was different and unique and obviously Chase feels a little weird about it, too.

There’s just a whole lot of warmth in that post lol

Park Boys
Posts
3816
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
5/8/2023 4:16pm
Magoofan wrote:
Agreed.  I was only saying that I wanted Webb to title...but not against an injured Tomac. It's even worse in Chase's case...he was third place a...

Agreed.  I was only saying that I wanted Webb to title...but not against an injured Tomac.

It's even worse in Chase's case...he was third place a week ago.     Inheriting a title from 18 points back due to injury sucks.

 

You’re assuming Webb could have beaten Sexton for this title? They were close in points. 

4
kpiper
Posts
2360
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
AZ US
5/8/2023 4:22pm
Park Boys wrote:

You’re assuming Webb could have beaten Sexton for this title? They were close in points. 

Of course, Webb could have beaten Sexton...he has the finger gun.

1
2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65697
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
5/8/2023 4:38pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:
And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend.  No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the...

And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend. 

No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the record books. 

kpiper wrote:
That is very true but Chase will always know it and you can tell he does with the way he responded to all this. Fans will...

That is very true but Chase will always know it and you can tell he does with the way he responded to all this. Fans will forget what happened to ET and CW but Chase won't. Having said that, Chase was the fastest guy this year so he can hold on to that. Winning this way is not fulfilling though.

Seeing his reaction to what happened to Eli really shows what Chase is made up of. Seems like a great person. Classy guy.

I would think it would be tough for any racer that has integrity to accept winning a title the way he's about to. Not because he isn't deserving, he certainly is. 

The title fight was heading into the final rounds when two of the top contenders unfortunately bowed out of the championship due to weird situations. It would be different if they had gotten injured early on in the season or crashed out on their own, but that's wasn't the case for either guy.

Chase has been vocal about wanting to beat Tomac straight up and was looking forward to have another chance to do so this summer to try and redeem himself after the 2022 MX season.

Every racer wants to beat the best to be considered the best. 

At the end of the day Chase will go in the record books as the 2023 450 Supercross Champion and that is all that matters. 

6
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
5/8/2023 4:38pm
Park Boys wrote:

You’re assuming Webb could have beaten Sexton for this title? They were close in points. 

kpiper wrote:

Of course, Webb could have beaten Sexton...he has the finger gun.

Grinning  I lol'd

 

...and now we know the reason for the finger-gun (recent Webb interview)

 

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
5/8/2023 4:45pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:
I would think it would be tough for any racer that has integrity to accept winning a title the way he's about to. Not because he...

I would think it would be tough for any racer that has integrity to accept winning a title the way he's about to. Not because he isn't deserving, he certainly is. 

The title fight was heading into the final rounds when two of the top contenders unfortunately bowed out of the championship due to weird situations. It would be different if they had gotten injured early on in the season or crashed out on their own, but that's wasn't the case for either guy.

Chase has been vocal about wanting to beat Tomac straight up and was looking forward to have another chance to do so this summer to try and redeem himself after the 2022 MX season.

Every racer wants to beat the best to be considered the best. 

At the end of the day Chase will go in the record books as the 2023 450 Supercross Champion and that is all that matters. 

Mav.  You nailed it.

"Every racer wants to beat the best to be the considered best".        Chase knows he didn't accomplish that in the end and he likely won't ever get that chance.        Chase is on his way up....Eli is on his way out.  This is how it's always been.

Tomac was clearly  the best this year.   Webb gave him hell this year and it was awesome.   By the time Chase righted the "crash" ship....he was all those points down. 

The whole deal....

Sucks for Chase.

Sucks for Webb

Sucks for Eli

Sucks for us fans.

 

3
2
kpiper
Posts
2360
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
AZ US
5/8/2023 5:00pm
Magoofan wrote:
Mav.  You nailed it. "Every racer wants to beat the best to be the considered best".        Chase knows he didn't accomplish that in...

Mav.  You nailed it.

"Every racer wants to beat the best to be the considered best".        Chase knows he didn't accomplish that in the end and he likely won't ever get that chance.        Chase is on his way up....Eli is on his way out.  This is how it's always been.

Tomac was clearly  the best this year.   Webb gave him hell this year and it was awesome.   By the time Chase righted the "crash" ship....he was all those points down. 

The whole deal....

Sucks for Chase.

Sucks for Webb

Sucks for Eli

Sucks for us fans.

 

This is true but such is life. Unfinished business for Chase in 2024. No way he doesn't think that.

kpiper
Posts
2360
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
AZ US
5/8/2023 5:04pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:
I would think it would be tough for any racer that has integrity to accept winning a title the way he's about to. Not because he...

I would think it would be tough for any racer that has integrity to accept winning a title the way he's about to. Not because he isn't deserving, he certainly is. 

The title fight was heading into the final rounds when two of the top contenders unfortunately bowed out of the championship due to weird situations. It would be different if they had gotten injured early on in the season or crashed out on their own, but that's wasn't the case for either guy.

Chase has been vocal about wanting to beat Tomac straight up and was looking forward to have another chance to do so this summer to try and redeem himself after the 2022 MX season.

Every racer wants to beat the best to be considered the best. 

At the end of the day Chase will go in the record books as the 2023 450 Supercross Champion and that is all that matters. 

Everything you say is true except I think it does matter to Chase even though he got the title. He didn't beat Eli and he knows it. And 2024 is no given for him that is for sure.

For Eli, at least he can say he was winning his last race (if it turns out to be so)! Wink

1
Pop Shmoke
Posts
1800
Joined
6/17/2020
Location
Boston, MA US
5/8/2023 5:47pm Edited Date/Time 5/8/2023 5:49pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:
And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend.  No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the...

And if Tomac hadn't had a freak injury he'd be holding up SX title number 3 this weekend. 

No ifs, ands, or buts listed in the record books. 

kpiper wrote:
That is very true but Chase will always know it and you can tell he does with the way he responded to all this. Fans will...

That is very true but Chase will always know it and you can tell he does with the way he responded to all this. Fans will forget what happened to ET and CW but Chase won't. Having said that, Chase was the fastest guy this year so he can hold on to that. Winning this way is not fulfilling though.

Seeing his reaction to what happened to Eli really shows what Chase is made up of. Seems like a great person. Classy guy.

In most cases it is true that ppl forget what happened and only remember who won… but this was not most cases. This was the biggest upset in the history of supercross, and its going to go down in infamy. Ppl will remember where they were when this happened and are not going to forget what happened to Tomac.
 

20 years from now when it looks like a guy is going to win a title with a couple races left ppl will say “yea but remember tomac in 23’ it aint over till its over”. Not a chance in hell this just fades away into the background noise, we all just witnessed history the other night, and were never going to forget it. Just like how we all remember when ricky finally beat mcgrath, certain things are so big you remember them for the rest of your life. This is one of those things.

1
dingo
Posts
40
Joined
7/28/2019
Location
PA US
5/8/2023 5:59pm

I wouldn’t care how I win the title, as long as that championship bonus check clears!

 

Thats also probably why I’m not winning titles 

TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
5/8/2023 7:31pm

Eli was on the cusp of 3 in a row SX and MX combined. Hadn’t been done since Dungey (15 SX, 15 MX, 16 SX). Villopoto also did it twice (11 SX, 11MX, 12 SX, and 13 SX, 13 MX, 14 SX). Nobody since Carmichael had defended both championships the following year, something Tomac looked poised to do this year.

TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
5/8/2023 7:36pm
Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had...

Back in 2003, if you told me Chad and Stew were only gonna win 2 titles each, I would have said you are mad.. Furthermore, had you said the same about Eli, I would have said no way.. but here we are.

Really puts into perspective how brutally difficult it is to stay consistent in this sport.

Imagine telling someone after the 2009 season that neither Chad nor Stew would ever win another title.

From 2008 MX and 2009 SX Stew had 23 wins out 29 races. I said, well, he’s going to break every record and dominate for the...

From 2008 MX and 2009 SX Stew had 23 wins out 29 races. I said, well, he’s going to break every record and dominate for the next 5-6 years. Little did I know, injuries, bad bikes(Yamaha), and just bad decision making would be what dominated for the rest of his career. Just so disappointing with the way his career went after 2009.

Absolute insanity that he went SX only right when he was at his peak and was completely dominating everything. It’s arguably the most baffling career decision in our entire sport’s history. It really seemed to derail his entire career too. Would have loved to see prime James there when the Ryans came into their own.

1
smee113
Posts
456
Joined
5/7/2014
Location
Houston, TX US
5/9/2023 2:59pm
Pop Shmoke wrote:
In most cases it is true that ppl forget what happened and only remember who won… but this was not most cases. This was the biggest...

In most cases it is true that ppl forget what happened and only remember who won… but this was not most cases. This was the biggest upset in the history of supercross, and its going to go down in infamy. Ppl will remember where they were when this happened and are not going to forget what happened to Tomac.
 

20 years from now when it looks like a guy is going to win a title with a couple races left ppl will say “yea but remember tomac in 23’ it aint over till its over”. Not a chance in hell this just fades away into the background noise, we all just witnessed history the other night, and were never going to forget it. Just like how we all remember when ricky finally beat mcgrath, certain things are so big you remember them for the rest of your life. This is one of those things.

With how short this sport's memory is, I highly doubt it.

Post a reply to: The Elusive third title..

The Latest