Woman left All-Trans hockey game with a concussion after being body slammed by biological male

Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
1
2
|
bh84
Posts
1750
Joined
8/20/2012
Location
Peterborough , ON CA
12/14/2022 11:32am

"Body Slammed" 

Incidental contact at best, nowhere near "body slammed". Accidents happen on the ice regardless of the gender identity of the players. Its hockey, you're standing on knife shoes on a slippery surface and everything around you is rock hard. 

Using this as some sort of dunk on trans athletes is a reach and a half. That said, I hope she's okay. 

2
6
Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/14/2022 11:45am

Am I to understand that you wouldn’t have a problem with a male going up against your female daughter battling for the puck?

4
4
alphado
Posts
4047
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Erie, PA US
12/14/2022 1:27pm

My son plays full contact high school hockey, there are several girls in the league and they dish it out as much as they take it.

3
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65413
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
12/14/2022 1:36pm
alphado wrote:

My son plays full contact high school hockey, there are several girls in the league and they dish it out as much as they take it.

We had a men's team and a women's team. IMO, mixing both is asking for trouble. 

10

The Shop

tuggy450
Posts
1389
Joined
3/12/2016
Location
Massapequa, NY US
12/14/2022 1:50pm Edited Date/Time 12/14/2022 1:51pm

It's so silly to mix biological males with biological females in just about any sport, maybe it makes sense when they are younger, ok I can see some of that, especially in non contact type skills contests. 

This stupidity goes all the way back to Battle of the Sexes, Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs.  Riggs, likely threw the king match because he was a known gambler, kind of con man. Cool story think they made a documentary about it.

In any event There is no doubt if you allowed pretty much any ex motocross champion in drag to race women's motocross, they would be champion for at least a decade. Men, pretending to be women should race in the men's class. Women pretending to be men and off supplemental testosterone hormone replacement therapy race women. If taking TRT you race the men.

1
2
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID US
12/14/2022 1:53pm
bh84 wrote:
"Body Slammed"  Incidental contact at best, nowhere near "body slammed". Accidents happen on the ice regardless of the gender identity of the players. Its hockey, you're...

"Body Slammed" 

Incidental contact at best, nowhere near "body slammed". Accidents happen on the ice regardless of the gender identity of the players. Its hockey, you're standing on knife shoes on a slippery surface and everything around you is rock hard. 

Using this as some sort of dunk on trans athletes is a reach and a half. That said, I hope she's okay. 

I missed the video of it, got a link?

1
APLMAN99
Posts
12213
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
12/14/2022 2:40pm

Just to be clear, it was an 'all trans' hockey game?  So all of the participants are/were trans?  

Seems like every participant would have understood the risks involved, no?

That being said, I've had many friends receive concussions in 'all male' hockey games.  Should biological males be banned from competing in those games because of that?

 

Cool

2
7
steveloyer
Posts
256
Joined
11/29/2022
Location
Palmer, AK US
12/14/2022 2:51pm
bh84 wrote:
"Body Slammed"  Incidental contact at best, nowhere near "body slammed". Accidents happen on the ice regardless of the gender identity of the players. Its hockey, you're...

"Body Slammed" 

Incidental contact at best, nowhere near "body slammed". Accidents happen on the ice regardless of the gender identity of the players. Its hockey, you're standing on knife shoes on a slippery surface and everything around you is rock hard. 

Using this as some sort of dunk on trans athletes is a reach and a half. That said, I hope she's okay. 

LungButter wrote:
I missed the video of it, got a link?

I missed the video of it, got a link?

2
Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/14/2022 2:54pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:

We had a men's team and a women's team. IMO, mixing both is asking for trouble. 

This^^^^

 

2
Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/14/2022 3:02pm

 

9
1
ATKpilot99
Posts
10417
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI US
12/14/2022 4:12pm

All trans league huh ?  Well I'm not a trans but I feel I should be able to join that league or I'm being discriminated against . Of course the being 56 and sucking at hockey may be a problem also . 

3
Muttly
Posts
1959
Joined
10/3/2021
Location
Mills, NM US
12/14/2022 4:54pm
ATKpilot99 wrote:
All trans league huh ?  Well I'm not a trans but I feel I should be able to join that league or I'm being discriminated against...

All trans league huh ?  Well I'm not a trans but I feel I should be able to join that league or I'm being discriminated against . Of course the being 56 and sucking at hockey may be a problem also . 

You’ve found your sense of humor lately. 

Rooster
Posts
4432
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edmonton CA
12/14/2022 5:47pm

You guys sure do spend a lot of time thinking about transgender folk.

I'd tell y'all not to get your panties so bunched up, but it's waay too late for that.

3
8
Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/14/2022 5:54pm

The irony of your name within the same sentence of transgender is palpable.

4
eddie
Posts
3020
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Bragg Creek, AB CA
12/14/2022 6:06pm

Plenty of concussions in hockey to go around for everyone 

1
12/14/2022 6:19pm
tuggy450 wrote:
It's so silly to mix biological males with biological females in just about any sport, maybe it makes sense when they are younger, ok I can...

It's so silly to mix biological males with biological females in just about any sport, maybe it makes sense when they are younger, ok I can see some of that, especially in non contact type skills contests. 

This stupidity goes all the way back to Battle of the Sexes, Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs.  Riggs, likely threw the king match because he was a known gambler, kind of con man. Cool story think they made a documentary about it.

In any event There is no doubt if you allowed pretty much any ex motocross champion in drag to race women's motocross, they would be champion for at least a decade. Men, pretending to be women should race in the men's class. Women pretending to be men and off supplemental testosterone hormone replacement therapy race women. If taking TRT you race the men.

I made a tongue in cheek example of a top tier rider about a month back riding as a Trans. I picked one of the most unlikely riders ever. It would never fly in our sport! Men and women are different. Because you don't want to be a man anymore doesn't mean you're a woman. You're something else. Sorry, you just are. Do I care that you don't want to be a man anymore? No. I can accept you want to and do live your life differently. I can even have a friendship. But don't try and tell me you're an equal to my daughter or wife.

TM

9
2
Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/14/2022 6:20pm

Exactly

1
1
12/14/2022 6:27pm

Just watched the vid. Wasn't a "vicious" hit but nailed her from the backside, down she went and lawn darted into the boards. But when you're that much larger you don't need that much speed because of your mass.

TM

2
2
12/14/2022 6:31pm

Thinking about chopping my dick off so I can battle in the local women's mx class. Do you think a taxidermist would stuff my dick with extra stuff, so I can go fuck myself? 

 

5
alphado
Posts
4047
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Erie, PA US
12/15/2022 6:39am

There is a guy that dresses up like a woman in my beer league.  He is like 6'7" though and has a wicked slapshot.

2
Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/15/2022 6:58am

Slapshot. Now there is a movie. Paul Newman at his finest. And the Hanson triplets. 😂

1
e-wa
Posts
166
Joined
12/18/2013
Location
Pasco, WA US
12/15/2022 3:53pm

That was just incidental contact between learning skaters, not much different than what I have seen on Sunday co-ed nights.

1
1
Muttly
Posts
1959
Joined
10/3/2021
Location
Mills, NM US
12/15/2022 3:57pm

Trans-League, not to be rude, but that’s where they belong. 

2
TeamGreen
Posts
36612
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA US
12/15/2022 4:00pm
alphado wrote:

There is a guy that dresses up like a woman in my beer league.  He is like 6'7" though and has a wicked slapshot.

AlphaDog for the win! Laughing

Muttly
Posts
1959
Joined
10/3/2021
Location
Mills, NM US
12/15/2022 4:03pm
alphado wrote:

There is a guy that dresses up like a woman in my beer league.  He is like 6'7" though and has a wicked slapshot.

Pics or GTFO! 🤣🤣

When Alphabet first hit the boards, he only replied with pictures. Funnier than hell, 99.7% of the time.
 

 

SEEMEFIRST
Posts
13533
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX US
12/15/2022 4:50pm

My buddy was running a co-ed indoor soccer team and was short players one night and asked me to help.

"No problem", I say.

Shit! The women go 100%!

They're hacking and shit like it means something. I finally got sick of it and had a 50-50 ball with one of these women, and she ended up on her noodle.

The whole place went "WHOA".

Fuck that, she'd been hacking me all night, and I was playing 75%.

Last co-ed game I played.

2
1
SEEMEFIRST
Posts
13533
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX US
12/15/2022 4:52pm

Oh, and I was a hack master if I needed to be. If she was a dude? I'd have worked him.

1
12/15/2022 5:27pm
Chatmore wrote:

Slapshot. Now there is a movie. Paul Newman at his finest. And the Hanson triplets. 😂

the Hansen's were not triplets 

ns503
Posts
4555
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies CA
12/15/2022 5:38pm Edited Date/Time 12/15/2022 5:38pm
Chatmore wrote:

Slapshot. Now there is a movie. Paul Newman at his finest. And the Hanson triplets. 😂

lostboy819 wrote:

the Hansen's were not triplets 

Body slammed, and Hanson triplets. Guy knows his hockey for sure. Whistling

Chatmore
Posts
1579
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
12/15/2022 5:55pm Edited Date/Time 12/15/2022 6:04pm

Hey brain trust, I’m fully aware. They were simply regarded as such.

1

Post a reply to: Woman left All-Trans hockey game with a concussion after being body slammed by biological male

The Latest