Tomac vs Herlings

blockhead17
Posts
2919
Joined
6/13/2018
Location
Tokyo, JP
Edited Date/Time 9/7/2022 3:13pm
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate..
WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes on bikes right now.. and in most people’s opinion, if they races a series together it’s 50/50..
But I’ll offer this;
Herlings always seems to be hurt or recovering..
Eli is never hurt apart from that arm injury, he is always there..
Would it be safe to assume, Eli rides within his limits and Herlings pushes the envelope?
These “let’s see Herlings at Anaheim” posts are completely irrelevant so please stop..
6
|
USA
Posts
2692
Joined
9/4/2016
Location
Richmond, TX, USA
9/7/2022 12:26pm
Big Lenny:

James Stewart would beat both of them ya poindexter.. stupid
3
3
davis224
Posts
7628
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL, USA
9/7/2022 12:29pm
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate.. WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes...
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate..
WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes on bikes right now.. and in most people’s opinion, if they races a series together it’s 50/50..
But I’ll offer this;
Herlings always seems to be hurt or recovering..
Eli is never hurt apart from that arm injury, he is always there..
Would it be safe to assume, Eli rides within his limits and Herlings pushes the envelope?
These “let’s see Herlings at Anaheim” posts are completely irrelevant so please stop..
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the envelope. Don't know why, but some people just break every time they hit the ground.
6
captmoto
Posts
5929
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
9/7/2022 12:31pm
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate.. WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes...
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate..
WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes on bikes right now.. and in most people’s opinion, if they races a series together it’s 50/50..
But I’ll offer this;
Herlings always seems to be hurt or recovering..
Eli is never hurt apart from that arm injury, he is always there..
Would it be safe to assume, Eli rides within his limits and Herlings pushes the envelope?
These “let’s see Herlings at Anaheim” posts are completely irrelevant so please stop..
davis224 wrote:
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the...
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the envelope. Don't know why, but some people just break every time they hit the ground.
AC style.
5
dingo
Posts
40
Joined
7/28/2019
Location
USA
9/7/2022 12:37pm
Tomac has another gear we rarely get to see. We saw it the first 2 and a half rounds of 2015. We saw it at the end of moto 1 at Ironman this year. That’s how he stays healthy. No doubt that FMOTP speed is there when he needs it.
7
1

The Shop

blockhead17
Posts
2919
Joined
6/13/2018
Location
Tokyo, JP
9/7/2022 12:51pm
dingo wrote:
Tomac has another gear we rarely get to see. We saw it the first 2 and a half rounds of 2015. We saw it at the...
Tomac has another gear we rarely get to see. We saw it the first 2 and a half rounds of 2015. We saw it at the end of moto 1 at Ironman this year. That’s how he stays healthy. No doubt that FMOTP speed is there when he needs it.
Yeah this.. I feel like Tomac HAS an extra gear.. he chooses not to use it, but every now and then we see him say “fuck it” and drop like 3-5 seconds a lap..
that lap where he passed chase back at Ironman was an example of this..
8
2
MPJC
Posts
2082
Joined
5/18/2017
Location
CA
9/7/2022 12:53pm
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate.. WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes...
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate..
WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes on bikes right now.. and in most people’s opinion, if they races a series together it’s 50/50..
But I’ll offer this;
Herlings always seems to be hurt or recovering..
Eli is never hurt apart from that arm injury, he is always there..
Would it be safe to assume, Eli rides within his limits and Herlings pushes the envelope?
These “let’s see Herlings at Anaheim” posts are completely irrelevant so please stop..
davis224 wrote:
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the...
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the envelope. Don't know why, but some people just break every time they hit the ground.
I wonder if Herlings is less focused so more accident prone when he's not full-on racing? Sometimes just plain bad luck factors in.
1
Mavetism
Posts
6601
Joined
4/15/2019
Location
Hannover, DE
9/7/2022 1:12pm
MPJC wrote:
I wonder if Herlings is less focused so more accident prone when he's not full-on racing? Sometimes just plain bad luck factors in.
He for sure crashed a lot on his own in his 250 career, but holy shit he had a lot of bad luck on the 450. Like another rider riding over his foot on a sighting lap, Jorge Prado cross jumping him, a rider jumping on his shoulder last year Vialle and him colliding during photo shooting.. It's not all on him..
2
Press516
Posts
6038
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Gilbert, AZ, USA
9/7/2022 1:19pm
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate.. WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes...
It seems like every Tomac thread, MXGP, MXDN thread etc turns into a Herlings vs Eli debate..
WE ALL KNOW, they are the 2 baddest dudes on bikes right now.. and in most people’s opinion, if they races a series together it’s 50/50..
But I’ll offer this;
Herlings always seems to be hurt or recovering..
Eli is never hurt apart from that arm injury, he is always there..
Would it be safe to assume, Eli rides within his limits and Herlings pushes the envelope?
These “let’s see Herlings at Anaheim” posts are completely irrelevant so please stop..
davis224 wrote:
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the...
With 2 of his most recent injuries being during a photo shoot and a sight lap, I don't think you can blame those on pushing the envelope. Don't know why, but some people just break every time they hit the ground.
captmoto wrote:
AC style.
Sad, but true...

I had no interest in commenting on Tomac vs Herlings, but you had to somehow get AC in there... Wink
1
9/7/2022 1:50pm
dingo wrote:
Tomac has another gear we rarely get to see. We saw it the first 2 and a half rounds of 2015. We saw it at the...
Tomac has another gear we rarely get to see. We saw it the first 2 and a half rounds of 2015. We saw it at the end of moto 1 at Ironman this year. That’s how he stays healthy. No doubt that FMOTP speed is there when he needs it.
when he needs it ? he never won a moto at MXON or outside USA .. so when does he needs it ? asking fro a friend
8
RG1
Posts
4651
Joined
7/12/2015
Location
GB
9/7/2022 2:05pm
Herlings doesn’t crash anywhere near as much as his injury record suggests. He just hurts himself basically every time he does
2
1
DonM
Posts
9083
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
9/7/2022 2:10pm
RG1 wrote:
Herlings doesn’t crash anywhere near as much as his injury record suggests. He just hurts himself basically every time he does
Which in turn limits the time on the bike with the opportunity to crash and injure himself....
3
1
ATKpilot99
Posts
10523
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI, USA
9/7/2022 2:37pm
RG1 wrote:
Herlings doesn’t crash anywhere near as much as his injury record suggests. He just hurts himself basically every time he does
And it always seems some kind of freak occurrence or tipover . I can't think of any yard sale crashes from riding over his head.
2
Press516
Posts
6038
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Gilbert, AZ, USA
9/7/2022 3:13pm
RG1 wrote:
Herlings doesn’t crash anywhere near as much as his injury record suggests. He just hurts himself basically every time he does
ATKpilot99 wrote:
And it always seems some kind of freak occurrence or tipover . I can't think of any yard sale crashes from riding over his head.
That's the tough part with Herlings... He seems to injure so easily. Unlike the broken shoulder which was not on him at all.
2

Post a reply to: Tomac vs Herlings

The Latest