Side by side, oh my....

Any recommendations on a good utility side by side/UTV? Looking for something to use for work around a 50ish acre property. Hauling wood, dirt, whatever.

So many choices and I have no idea where to begin.

EDIT for more info:

Dump bed and reliability are the most critical things for me. Don't care about color. Focused primarily towards work but wouldn't mind some play thrown in. I would prefer cargo capacity to seating capacity so probably looking at a 2-3 seater.
|
murph783
Posts
1355
Joined
3/2/2011
Location
USA
8/20/2021 6:05pm
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked on em for a handful of years and they’re a solid product
2
2
reded301
Posts
306
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS, USA
8/21/2021 4:29am
murph783 wrote:
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked...
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked on em for a handful of years and they’re a solid product
I worked ON them for a handful of years and think otherwise.
4
1
ns503
Posts
4608
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies, CA
8/21/2021 4:31am
Whatchya got for dealers around there?

Can-Am Defender is a decent all around unit.

Kawi has their utility side too.
1
JustMX
Posts
5301
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
8/21/2021 4:47am
Tractor with a loader, and a carryall on the back.

Get a used atv for the passengers to follow you and to run and get a jug of fuel when you forget to fuel the tractor.
1

The Shop

murph783
Posts
1355
Joined
3/2/2011
Location
USA
8/21/2021 6:13am
murph783 wrote:
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked...
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked on em for a handful of years and they’re a solid product
reded301 wrote:
I worked ON them for a handful of years and think otherwise.
As in you were the end user putting the product to work? I mean granted they’re a little rattle-y and the fit and finish isn’t amazing, but they hold up well if you take a reasonable amount of care of them. And the accessories are nice, they have about any option you could ever want and it all bolts up super simply, it’s pretty idiot proof. Some of the other brands get a little hairy installing aftermarket parts.
1
BMR179
Posts
511
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
East Texas, TX, USA
Fantasy
8/21/2021 6:32am
4010 Mule for utility and work. They are pretty much bullet proof and have a lot of available accessories.
3
reded301
Posts
306
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS, USA
8/21/2021 6:42am Edited Date/Time 8/21/2021 6:45am
murph783 wrote:
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked...
If I were gonna buy one it’d be a Polaris ranger. Maybe a general if I wanted to sacrifice some functionality for more fun. I worked on em for a handful of years and they’re a solid product
reded301 wrote:
I worked ON them for a handful of years and think otherwise.
murph783 wrote:
As in you were the end user putting the product to work? I mean granted they’re a little rattle-y and the fit and finish isn’t amazing...
As in you were the end user putting the product to work? I mean granted they’re a little rattle-y and the fit and finish isn’t amazing, but they hold up well if you take a reasonable amount of care of them. And the accessories are nice, they have about any option you could ever want and it all bolts up super simply, it’s pretty idiot proof. Some of the other brands get a little hairy installing aftermarket parts.
I mean as in I was the guy in town that everyone brought their ATV/SXS to for repairs instead of going to the dealer. It was always a pleasure to work on anything else (mid-engine Can-Am being the exception) but rarely received anything else.
3
8/21/2021 7:46am
ns503 wrote:
Whatchya got for dealers around there?

Can-Am Defender is a decent all around unit.

Kawi has their utility side too.
I have access to pretty much any brand from a dealer perspective. My favorite dealer has:
Yamaha
Suzuki
Kawasaki
Honda
CanAm
KTM
Polaris
reded301
Posts
306
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS, USA
8/21/2021 9:56am
FLmxer wrote:
4010 kawi mule transformation.
https://youtu.be/puR-jzXONgw
That sure looks like it would fit the bill. Even the option for 4 seats.
The only problem with the Mule is that once you get a SXS, you’ll end up wanting to off-road it also and they don’t cross over very well. I’ve got a buddy with one and it struggles badly where most other machines go with ease.
3
skeef
Posts
1454
Joined
7/18/2018
Location
USA
Fantasy
8/21/2021 9:56am
Can-am Defedner. Full cab with A/C / Heat option. IMO much better than the Polaris Ranger.
2
reded301
Posts
306
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS, USA
8/21/2021 10:20am
skeef wrote:
Can-am Defedner. Full cab with A/C / Heat option. IMO much better than the Polaris Ranger.
Gen2 Commander will likely be my next one if I ever grow tired of the Pioneer.
1
8/21/2021 11:38am
skeef wrote:
Can-am Defedner. Full cab with A/C / Heat option. IMO much better than the Polaris Ranger.
reded301 wrote:
Gen2 Commander will likely be my next one if I ever grow tired of the Pioneer.
Interesting as the Pioneer is high on my list. Many long term reviews are very positive with regard to reliability. Any specific reasons you are looking at the can-am vs honda?
Falcon
Posts
12500
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
8/21/2021 2:01pm
OP wants reliability. Do not, under any circumstances, purchase a Polaris.

Soon, Polaris fans will chime in with all kinds of negative responses to my post, but the truth is that Polaris has the worst reliability record, period. By far.
5
1
skeef
Posts
1454
Joined
7/18/2018
Location
USA
Fantasy
8/21/2021 5:44pm
Gen2 commander is a great machine as well. But like others have said on here stay away from polaris. They are notorious for recalls.
1
8/21/2021 7:02pm
If you after something real basic the small 610 mule is bullet proof. Slow and not really useful for recreation.
1
MudPup545
Posts
1700
Joined
11/14/2014
Location
Imlay City, MI, USA
8/22/2021 3:20pm
My dad is on his second Can Am Defender. Been pretty reliable for him. He’s retired and uses it more than his truck. Small, rural farm town and he racked up some pretty crazy miles on his first one. Only upgraded to the new one because it has AC.
2
reded301
Posts
306
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS, USA
8/22/2021 4:40pm Edited Date/Time 8/22/2021 6:23pm
skeef wrote:
Can-am Defedner. Full cab with A/C / Heat option. IMO much better than the Polaris Ranger.
reded301 wrote:
Gen2 Commander will likely be my next one if I ever grow tired of the Pioneer.
Interesting as the Pioneer is high on my list. Many long term reviews are very positive with regard to reliability. Any specific reasons you are looking...
Interesting as the Pioneer is high on my list. Many long term reviews are very positive with regard to reliability. Any specific reasons you are looking at the can-am vs honda?
Not really, I just like the looks of it. My first SXS was an OG Maverick and I liked it but it the cab heat was unbearable and it was a belt burning SOB. The Pioneer is a great car and to be honest, it will be extremely hard for me to go back to a CVT.
1
8/22/2021 5:28pm
ns503 wrote:
Whatchya got for dealers around there?

Can-Am Defender is a decent all around unit.

Kawi has their utility side too.
I have access to pretty much any brand from a dealer perspective. My favorite dealer has:
Yamaha
Suzuki
Kawasaki
Honda
CanAm
KTM
Polaris
Cant go wrong on Honda, Yamaha, Can Am, Kawasaki they all build quality units that hold up well, Polaris not so much.
Polaris is also famous for just deciding to quit making parts for their products so if you did get one I wouldnt hold on to it for any length of time.
4
1
ratbeagle139
Posts
139
Joined
12/16/2020
Location
Lazy E, OK, USA
8/23/2021 10:29am
I’ve owned 2 Kawasaki mules , 1 Yamaha rhino, 3 Polaris Rangers, and currently have a Kawasaki krx1000. They've all been great machines with different purposes. I put 2.5k-3k miles a year on anything I own and I do all the work my self from fluids to belts to axles, drive-shafts, hubs, etc.. Based on what you've said, I would recommend the Polaris ranger, particularly one that’s 2015 or newer and either a 900 or 1000 (570's ride like a mule). Their the perfect mix of work & play IMO and they hold their value better than most others. They might make some noises from time to time but they won’t leave you on the side of the trail, their comfortable, they haul a shit-load, and their by far the easiest to work on. Parts aren’t going anywhere for them either, that’s ridiculous to even mention... They’ve been the #1-selling sxs model for the last 10 years, their not about to stop making them. There’s tons of aftermarket companies that make better, less expensive replacement parts aside from what the OEM offer's as well. Not the case with my new Kawi, anytime something breaks I usually have to overpay to replace said part with the same junk OEM part that failed in the first place. I'm no Polaris die-hard I'm only speaking from experience, the work you mention is very similar to how we use them for hunting chores on the ranch. Maybe other Polaris models have dropped the ball but the last 2 generations of rangers have been great machines for me and the group of guys that I hunt with.

Fixing other people’s broke shit doesn't make anyone a user, or to have skin in the game.. I fix my buddie's 2020 Can-am maverick about every other month but I don't speak badly about the brand because I've never owned one, plain and simple. Most(not all) sxs people have more money than brains, the guys around here don't even wash them until something breaks, let alone do any preventative maintenance and these are often $25k-$32k machines.. I couldn't care less what those types of people have to say when it comes to topics like "brand reliability" because I know how they take care of their stuff. They are not OCD at all like us MXer's.. beware of this when listening to reviews/advice from that crowd. If you grease often, change fluids regularly, and keep them clean, just about any sxs on the market now days will perform well for a long time. Start sitting in them and go for some test rides, watch youtube reviews, talk to unbiased users, pick something YOU like.

Too many folks just like to regurgitate what the only guy they know with one has to say, meanwhile they’ve never owned or put miles on one themselves. Good luck and feel free to message me if you ever have questions, I love nerding out on any/all things sxs.
3
2
mxtech1
Posts
1968
Joined
7/21/2011
Location
Galesburg, IL, USA
8/23/2021 2:53pm
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might be exactly what you are looking for and they can be ordered with a powered dump bed and all sorts of other farm-friendly attachments.

Reliability on these should be really good as Deere typically tests above and beyond and the product itself is engineered for reliability more-so than high performance.

When and if you need service, you can then rely on your local John Deere dealership to help with service work. The Deere dealership and service network is second to none.

We have a couple of the full size 865 XUVs that we use at work and they are always dependable and fun to drive. The engines are smooth with a linear powerband, but still fairly peppy if you want to do some play driving. Suspension is good at low speeds and sprung well enough to handle quite a bit of weight in the bed, but will lack the overall travel and plushness at higher speeds that some of the other "sport" side-by-sides have.

Deere is currently offering 48 months 0% APR if you finance through JD Financial and they also have military and Farm Bureau discounts if you qualify.
2
8/23/2021 5:03pm
mxtech1 wrote:
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might...
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might be exactly what you are looking for and they can be ordered with a powered dump bed and all sorts of other farm-friendly attachments.

Reliability on these should be really good as Deere typically tests above and beyond and the product itself is engineered for reliability more-so than high performance.

When and if you need service, you can then rely on your local John Deere dealership to help with service work. The Deere dealership and service network is second to none.

We have a couple of the full size 865 XUVs that we use at work and they are always dependable and fun to drive. The engines are smooth with a linear powerband, but still fairly peppy if you want to do some play driving. Suspension is good at low speeds and sprung well enough to handle quite a bit of weight in the bed, but will lack the overall travel and plushness at higher speeds that some of the other "sport" side-by-sides have.

Deere is currently offering 48 months 0% APR if you finance through JD Financial and they also have military and Farm Bureau discounts if you qualify.
Thanks for the advice but JD is out. We have owned many of their tractors over the years. We will not purchase another piece of equipment from them until they stop fighting against right to repair. They are the devil, as momma would say.
3
8/23/2021 5:53pm Edited Date/Time 8/23/2021 5:55pm
Damn, hate to derail this thread but I’m kicking around the idea of a new tractor and was looking hard at Deere. The old 2155 has been awesome, but I was looking to upgrade to a 4WD. Always had good luck with them, but I have to agree with the right to repair. That’s bullshit.

As for the SxS, just break open the piggy bank and go get a new Bobcat Toolcat. Laughing I’d like to have one but $$$$.
mxtech1
Posts
1968
Joined
7/21/2011
Location
Galesburg, IL, USA
8/23/2021 7:42pm Edited Date/Time 8/23/2021 7:47pm
mxtech1 wrote:
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might...
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might be exactly what you are looking for and they can be ordered with a powered dump bed and all sorts of other farm-friendly attachments.

Reliability on these should be really good as Deere typically tests above and beyond and the product itself is engineered for reliability more-so than high performance.

When and if you need service, you can then rely on your local John Deere dealership to help with service work. The Deere dealership and service network is second to none.

We have a couple of the full size 865 XUVs that we use at work and they are always dependable and fun to drive. The engines are smooth with a linear powerband, but still fairly peppy if you want to do some play driving. Suspension is good at low speeds and sprung well enough to handle quite a bit of weight in the bed, but will lack the overall travel and plushness at higher speeds that some of the other "sport" side-by-sides have.

Deere is currently offering 48 months 0% APR if you finance through JD Financial and they also have military and Farm Bureau discounts if you qualify.
Thanks for the advice but JD is out. We have owned many of their tractors over the years. We will not purchase another piece of equipment...
Thanks for the advice but JD is out. We have owned many of their tractors over the years. We will not purchase another piece of equipment from them until they stop fighting against right to repair. They are the devil, as momma would say.
That’s unfortunate you feel that way. It’s not just Deere though. Tesla, Johnson & Johnson, AT&T, T-Mobile, Apple, Microsoft, Google, Facebook, GE, Philips, eBay, Caterpillar, CNH Industrial, Claas are some of the other major companies that want right to repair legislation passed carefully rather than blown wide open by government. And I can guarantee all of the Motorsport manufacturers will have the same stance when their electrical and software architecture become complex enough to warrant the same situation. I would argue we somewhat saw that last year when Honda put out bad maps on the 2020 CRFs which required customers to bring the bike back to the dealership for a new payload. Did you abandon your car/truck when the auto OEMs fought with the government for years before they passed legislation in 2012? Resulting in a measles OBD communication port that provides little more than a diagnostic trouble code? Deere (and all other OEMs of modern pieces of equipment) already display diagnostic trouble codes directly on the operator console and those DTCs come with fairly descriptive messages that tell the user exactly what the issue is and how to repair it. In that aspect, they are already more compliant than the auto industry. If an issue occurs, the operator has an idea of what’s wrong before they even get out of the seat. Can you do that with your car?

Did you know that, on average, 95% of all repairs needed on modern machinery can be executed by the average owner? Of the remaining 5% of repairs that an owner typically can’t do, only 2% of repairs involve software issues that require special connection tools and/or electrical hardware components? Do you understand that software and electrical components traditionally have higher system reliability than mechanical components (meaning they RARELY fail or need servicing.) Did you know that even if the OEM made such tools available to the customer, the purchase cost of that software would be exponentially more expensive than just taking the machine to a dealership and letting them handle the fix? Do you think the average customer would even know what to do with the software interface IF they had the ability to access the software system?? I don’t know many people that know how to flash a payload, or how to interpret 16-bit CAN logic, let alone understand the system architecture well enough to understand how all of the electrical domains interface with the software end electrical logic to make it all work. The average person gets in there and starts “troubleshooting” things, I am willing to bet the chance is higher that something will get messed up than the fix occurs.

John Deere is known as an industry leader in providing repair tools to customers. They have hands down the best spare part inventory in the country, publish very in depth technical guides, provide access to training videos and manuals, and even offer remote access machine connectivity for Deere technician assistance when needed.

The mechanical design on side by sides (and most compact tractors for that matter) are not sophisticated enough where any of this right to repair stuff even comes into play.

I don’t mean to hijack the thread, as this topic could be a whole topic of discussion by itself, but the right to repair movement is so misunderstood by the average consumer that it paints many of our otherwise reputable companies in a bad light.
1
2
Team Ideal
Posts
1171
Joined
9/22/2008
Location
Ste. Marie, IL, USA
8/24/2021 4:59am
Honda Pioneer 1000 should be perfect for what you are wanting. I bought mine mainly to use for hunting and working. I have found it to be more than a capable trail machine also. I've got close to 10K miles on mine and not a single problem. Don't skimp and go with the 700, you'll regret it.
3
8/24/2021 12:12pm
mxtech1 wrote:
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might...
If you are primarily looking for something to work the land with, don't rule out the John Deere XUV line. The 835 or 865 models might be exactly what you are looking for and they can be ordered with a powered dump bed and all sorts of other farm-friendly attachments.

Reliability on these should be really good as Deere typically tests above and beyond and the product itself is engineered for reliability more-so than high performance.

When and if you need service, you can then rely on your local John Deere dealership to help with service work. The Deere dealership and service network is second to none.

We have a couple of the full size 865 XUVs that we use at work and they are always dependable and fun to drive. The engines are smooth with a linear powerband, but still fairly peppy if you want to do some play driving. Suspension is good at low speeds and sprung well enough to handle quite a bit of weight in the bed, but will lack the overall travel and plushness at higher speeds that some of the other "sport" side-by-sides have.

Deere is currently offering 48 months 0% APR if you finance through JD Financial and they also have military and Farm Bureau discounts if you qualify.
Thanks for the advice but JD is out. We have owned many of their tractors over the years. We will not purchase another piece of equipment...
Thanks for the advice but JD is out. We have owned many of their tractors over the years. We will not purchase another piece of equipment from them until they stop fighting against right to repair. They are the devil, as momma would say.
mxtech1 wrote:
That’s unfortunate you feel that way. It’s not just Deere though. Tesla, Johnson & Johnson, AT&T, T-Mobile, Apple, Microsoft, Google, Facebook, GE, Philips, eBay, Caterpillar, CNH...
That’s unfortunate you feel that way. It’s not just Deere though. Tesla, Johnson & Johnson, AT&T, T-Mobile, Apple, Microsoft, Google, Facebook, GE, Philips, eBay, Caterpillar, CNH Industrial, Claas are some of the other major companies that want right to repair legislation passed carefully rather than blown wide open by government. And I can guarantee all of the Motorsport manufacturers will have the same stance when their electrical and software architecture become complex enough to warrant the same situation. I would argue we somewhat saw that last year when Honda put out bad maps on the 2020 CRFs which required customers to bring the bike back to the dealership for a new payload. Did you abandon your car/truck when the auto OEMs fought with the government for years before they passed legislation in 2012? Resulting in a measles OBD communication port that provides little more than a diagnostic trouble code? Deere (and all other OEMs of modern pieces of equipment) already display diagnostic trouble codes directly on the operator console and those DTCs come with fairly descriptive messages that tell the user exactly what the issue is and how to repair it. In that aspect, they are already more compliant than the auto industry. If an issue occurs, the operator has an idea of what’s wrong before they even get out of the seat. Can you do that with your car?

Did you know that, on average, 95% of all repairs needed on modern machinery can be executed by the average owner? Of the remaining 5% of repairs that an owner typically can’t do, only 2% of repairs involve software issues that require special connection tools and/or electrical hardware components? Do you understand that software and electrical components traditionally have higher system reliability than mechanical components (meaning they RARELY fail or need servicing.) Did you know that even if the OEM made such tools available to the customer, the purchase cost of that software would be exponentially more expensive than just taking the machine to a dealership and letting them handle the fix? Do you think the average customer would even know what to do with the software interface IF they had the ability to access the software system?? I don’t know many people that know how to flash a payload, or how to interpret 16-bit CAN logic, let alone understand the system architecture well enough to understand how all of the electrical domains interface with the software end electrical logic to make it all work. The average person gets in there and starts “troubleshooting” things, I am willing to bet the chance is higher that something will get messed up than the fix occurs.

John Deere is known as an industry leader in providing repair tools to customers. They have hands down the best spare part inventory in the country, publish very in depth technical guides, provide access to training videos and manuals, and even offer remote access machine connectivity for Deere technician assistance when needed.

The mechanical design on side by sides (and most compact tractors for that matter) are not sophisticated enough where any of this right to repair stuff even comes into play.

I don’t mean to hijack the thread, as this topic could be a whole topic of discussion by itself, but the right to repair movement is so misunderstood by the average consumer that it paints many of our otherwise reputable companies in a bad light.
I agree with much of what you said and realize that many companies are against right to repair for obvious reasons. However, JD and Apple are two huge offenders, spending millions on lobbyists etc...

I very well understand right to repair and it has very little to do with "customers" fixing things. It's more about making resources available for professionals to accomplish work, like how it is with the auto industry.

That's all I will say about that as you are correct that this could be an entire topic unto itself.
8/24/2021 12:19pm
Team Ideal wrote:
Honda Pioneer 1000 should be perfect for what you are wanting. I bought mine mainly to use for hunting and working. I have found it to...
Honda Pioneer 1000 should be perfect for what you are wanting. I bought mine mainly to use for hunting and working. I have found it to be more than a capable trail machine also. I've got close to 10K miles on mine and not a single problem. Don't skimp and go with the 700, you'll regret it.
Yeah, The Pioneer 1000 model line has been very high on my list. Having the ability to convert from 4 seater to 2 seater with bed is nice. It definitely checks all the boxes and then some with being a decent trail machine as well.
2
skeef
Posts
1454
Joined
7/18/2018
Location
USA
Fantasy
8/25/2021 10:13am
Is the Pioneer CVT? I know the Talon uses a standard transmission
Team Ideal
Posts
1171
Joined
9/22/2008
Location
Ste. Marie, IL, USA
8/25/2021 12:49pm
skeef wrote:
Is the Pioneer CVT? I know the Talon uses a standard transmission
The Pioneer was the test mule for the Talon transmission. They're the same except a couple different gear ratio's. Some people are even swapping the lower ratio reverse gear into the Pioneer.

Post a reply to: Side by side, oh my....

The Latest