Reed Fined?

todder
Profile picture for user todder
Posts
1608
Joined
10/20/2006
Location
Sw, WI US
todder
Edited Date/Time 1/26/2012 7:09am
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming in too hot, but Reed crosses the track to hit the points leader then admits that it is the only way he had a chance to win the title.! The AMA sucks.
|
mrquick
Profile picture for user mrquick
Posts
1430
Joined
10/9/2006
Location
Union City, TN US
mrquick 5/3/2009 1:51pm
5/3/2009 1:51pm
It was a love tap...Reed could have cleaned his clock if he wanted to. But he doesn't roll that way.
todder
Profile picture for user todder
Posts
1608
Joined
10/20/2006
Location
Sw, WI US
todder 5/3/2009 1:53pm
5/3/2009 1:53pm
Everyone can aurgue to the moon but Reed admitted it. What if he did that and James went down with a carrer ending injury and Reed admits that is the only way he could have won.
MxDaD324
Profile picture for user MxDaD324
Posts
1628
Joined
9/28/2008
Location
Mechanicsville, MD US
MxDaD324 5/3/2009 1:53pm
5/3/2009 1:53pm
ohhh boy here we go
Yamaha336
Profile picture for user Yamaha336
Posts
1219
Joined
5/2/2008
Location
Woodstock, IL US
Yamaha336 5/3/2009 1:54pm
5/3/2009 1:54pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 2:01pm
mrquick wrote:
It was a love tap...Reed could have cleaned his clock if he wanted to. But he doesn't roll that way.
It wasn't a love tap. It was a last desperate measure of a complete shitbag of a man. After all the calling out he did at the press conference and how dirty the riding was, he went and pulled a Chisolm x6!

The Shop

See All »
MX479Guy
Profile picture for user MX479Guy
Posts
2577
Joined
4/5/2009
Location
Atlantic Beach, FL US
MX479Guy 5/3/2009 1:56pm
5/3/2009 1:56pm
Reed admitted that something would have happened in order for him to win the race. He never said he tried to take James out. If he wanted to make an honest take out attempt it would have been way better then that, or at least he would have tried it several times.
GoRide2
Profile picture for user GoRide2
Posts
1377
Joined
8/30/2008
Location
El Cajon, CA US
GoRide2 5/3/2009 1:56pm
5/3/2009 1:56pm
mrquick wrote:
It was a love tap...Reed could have cleaned his clock if he wanted to. But he doesn't roll that way.
Yamaha336 wrote:
It wasn't a love tap. It was a last desperate measure of a complete shitbag of a man. After all the calling out he did at...
It wasn't a love tap. It was a last desperate measure of a complete shitbag of a man. After all the calling out he did at the press conference and how dirty the riding was, he went and pulled a Chisolm x6!
In order for that move to be any form of a "Chisolm" he would have had to be a lap down and not been involved in the championship. Some of you will never get it.
todder
Profile picture for user todder
Posts
1608
Joined
10/20/2006
Location
Sw, WI US
todder 5/3/2009 2:02pm
5/3/2009 2:02pm
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting it. Far worse than some team mate lapper getting in the way for a split second.
wavslide
Profile picture for user wavslide
Posts
227
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Oceanside, CA US
wavslide 5/3/2009 2:03pm
5/3/2009 2:03pm
Send him to the JLaw Attitude Rehabilitation and Recovery Camp.
Yamaha336
Profile picture for user Yamaha336
Posts
1219
Joined
5/2/2008
Location
Woodstock, IL US
Yamaha336 5/3/2009 2:04pm
5/3/2009 2:04pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 3:00pm
GoRide2 wrote:
In order for that move to be any form of a "Chisolm" he would have had to be a lap down and not been involved in...
In order for that move to be any form of a "Chisolm" he would have had to be a lap down and not been involved in the championship. Some of you will never get it.
Obviously you are the dense one here. Stewart gave Reed plenty of room to go by on lap 7. Reed chose not to go around because there was no place to park Stewart in that section. It was a "planned" move therefore making it WORSE than Chisolms. Not to mention all the smack Reed has been talking about dirty riding this week. Then he goes out there and pulls that stunt.
WhKnuckle
Profile picture for user WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
TX US
WhKnuckle 5/3/2009 2:05pm
5/3/2009 2:05pm
It wasn't all that bad of a bump in my opinion, but it was dumb. If Reed had followed Stewart around for three laps obviously trying to find the perfect place to torpedo him, and then actually managed to knock him down and out of the race, the AMA would have DQed him anyway. Reed would have done better to go out and try to win the race and let the chips fall where they may.

Actually, I just watched the start again and Reed definitely hesitated a little and let Villo and Stewart out ahead of him. He looked like he actually tried to make sure Stewart was ahead of him. I think he only had one game plan, and that was to take Stewart out. Dumb, very dumb - if it worked, he'd get DQed and if it didn't, he wouldn't be in a position to capitalize if Stewart crashed on his own because he wouldn't be in a position to win the race.

Also dumb because he'll line up next to Stewart a lot more and Stewart can cut the bike out from under a guy in a hurry. Stewart will get even, you can bet on that.
todder
Profile picture for user todder
Posts
1608
Joined
10/20/2006
Location
Sw, WI US
todder 5/3/2009 2:06pm
5/3/2009 2:06pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 11:44pm
wavslide wrote:
Send him to the JLaw Attitude Rehabilitation and Recovery Camp.
Tongue

Yeah if you watch the move from the other camera angle when the riders are coming towards the camera it shows how blatant that was. I just keep thinking what if James went off track and hit something, a pole or any of that shit out there in the back, Reeds a fucking coward. Why did he wait for back there, not in view of the crowd he was proably thinking, nevermind the 3 tv cameras back there!
WhKnuckle
Profile picture for user WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
TX US
WhKnuckle 5/3/2009 2:06pm
5/3/2009 2:06pm
todder wrote:
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting...
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting it. Far worse than some team mate lapper getting in the way for a split second.
Not only that, he drove right across the groove out into the marbles to hit James in the fastest corner in the track. It wasn't that hard of a hit, but it was a blatant effort to knock him down. The AMA and FIM wouldn't have had any choice but to DQ him if he'd been successful, so what's the point?
googs
Profile picture for user googs
Posts
444
Joined
2/1/2009
Location
Sydney AU
googs 5/3/2009 2:09pm
5/3/2009 2:09pm
maybe CR should have crossed jumped JS somewhere that seems to unsettle riders pretty good.

he could ask james how to do it.....

wavslide
Profile picture for user wavslide
Posts
227
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Oceanside, CA US
wavslide 5/3/2009 2:10pm
5/3/2009 2:10pm
todder wrote:
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting...
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting it. Far worse than some team mate lapper getting in the way for a split second.
WhKnuckle wrote:
Not only that, he drove right across the groove out into the marbles to hit James in the fastest corner in the track. It wasn't that...
Not only that, he drove right across the groove out into the marbles to hit James in the fastest corner in the track. It wasn't that hard of a hit, but it was a blatant effort to knock him down. The AMA and FIM wouldn't have had any choice but to DQ him if he'd been successful, so what's the point?
To be consistant with penalties and fines. No favorites, RC's gone.
WhKnuckle
Profile picture for user WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
TX US
WhKnuckle 5/3/2009 2:11pm
5/3/2009 2:11pm
todder wrote:
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting...
Goride you dont seem to understand Reed attempted to crash points leader, coming completly across the widest part of the track to do so. Then admitting it. Far worse than some team mate lapper getting in the way for a split second.
WhKnuckle wrote:
Not only that, he drove right across the groove out into the marbles to hit James in the fastest corner in the track. It wasn't that...
Not only that, he drove right across the groove out into the marbles to hit James in the fastest corner in the track. It wasn't that hard of a hit, but it was a blatant effort to knock him down. The AMA and FIM wouldn't have had any choice but to DQ him if he'd been successful, so what's the point?
wavslide wrote:
To be consistant with penalties and fines. No favorites, RC's gone.
No, what I meant was, what was Reed's point? The only outcome if he'd knocked Stewart down would be a DQ for Reed. The AMA and FIM wouldn't have had any choice about it.
jbomx363
Profile picture for user jbomx363
Posts
2008
Joined
9/4/2007
Location
Denham Springs, LA US
jbomx363 5/3/2009 2:12pm
5/3/2009 2:12pm
todder wrote:
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming...
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming in too hot, but Reed crosses the track to hit the points leader then admits that it is the only way he had a chance to win the title.! The AMA sucks.
You're quite simply. A dolt.
eddie
Profile picture for user eddie
Posts
3020
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Bragg Creek, AB CA
eddie 5/3/2009 2:14pm
5/3/2009 2:14pm
todder wrote:
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming...
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming in too hot, but Reed crosses the track to hit the points leader then admits that it is the only way he had a chance to win the title.! The AMA sucks.
jbomx363 wrote:
You're quite simply. A dolt.
agreed . chad bumping stewart was racing . chisholm bumping reed while being lapped was chickenshit team tactics .
GoRide2
Profile picture for user GoRide2
Posts
1377
Joined
8/30/2008
Location
El Cajon, CA US
GoRide2 5/3/2009 2:15pm
5/3/2009 2:15pm
I wish that JLaw would take you out

Pit Row

See All »
Void Main
Profile picture for user Void Main
Posts
17013
Joined
3/19/2008
Location
US
Void Main 5/3/2009 2:17pm
5/3/2009 2:17pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 2:18pm
todder wrote:
Everyone can aurgue to the moon but Reed admitted it. What if he did that and James went down with a carrer ending injury and Reed...
Everyone can aurgue to the moon but Reed admitted it. What if he did that and James went down with a carrer ending injury and Reed admits that is the only way he could have won.
Then Reed would be wearing the #1 plate again next year, but he didn't so he won't be wearing the #1 plate next year.
race
Profile picture for user race
Posts
3480
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
CA US
race 5/3/2009 2:27pm
5/3/2009 2:27pm
todder wrote:
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming...
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming in too hot, but Reed crosses the track to hit the points leader then admits that it is the only way he had a chance to win the title.! The AMA sucks.
Just in from the AMA -

"No action whatsoever is found warranted in Reed's pass on James Stewart.

We do rule though, that todder and 336 are the definition of 'kotex cowboys' and should find another sport to do their whining."






bigcat
Profile picture for user bigcat
Posts
547
Joined
1/8/2009
Location
N, TX US
bigcat 5/3/2009 2:45pm
5/3/2009 2:45pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 3:08pm
Yamaha336 wrote:
Obviously you are the dense one here. Stewart gave Reed plenty of room to go by on lap 7. Reed chose not to go around because...
Obviously you are the dense one here. Stewart gave Reed plenty of room to go by on lap 7. Reed chose not to go around because there was no place to park Stewart in that section. It was a "planned" move therefore making it WORSE than Chisolms. Not to mention all the smack Reed has been talking about dirty riding this week. Then he goes out there and pulls that stunt.
The only one dense in this thread is you.

So you are not only a proven liar,you also have no clue.

Maybe you should call your uncle for some advice on racing and spelling.

Oh thats right you lied about that didn't you.

What a tool...Shocked
ChrisB
Profile picture for user ChrisB
Posts
678
Joined
4/7/2009
Location
Rancho Santa Margarita, CA US
ChrisB 5/3/2009 2:54pm
5/3/2009 2:54pm
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same lap...
Yamaha336
Profile picture for user Yamaha336
Posts
1219
Joined
5/2/2008
Location
Woodstock, IL US
Yamaha336 5/3/2009 3:00pm
5/3/2009 3:00pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 3:01pm
bigcat wrote:
The only one dense in this thread is you. So you are not only a proven liar,you also have no clue. Maybe you should call your...
The only one dense in this thread is you.

So you are not only a proven liar,you also have no clue.

Maybe you should call your uncle for some advice on racing and spelling.

Oh thats right you lied about that didn't you.

What a tool...Shocked
Read your first sentence again and then stfu! What a nutjob!
catatonic
Profile picture for user catatonic
Posts
1575
Joined
3/20/2008
Location
Cape cod, MA US
catatonic 5/3/2009 3:39pm
5/3/2009 3:39pm
ChrisB wrote:
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same...
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same lap...
right on......I've been hit hard enough to jar teeth loose in the +30 b class.
Craze
Profile picture for user Craze
Posts
1410
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Sin City, NV US
Craze 5/3/2009 3:44pm
5/3/2009 3:44pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 11:44pm
todder wrote:
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming...
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming in too hot, but Reed crosses the track to hit the points leader then admits that it is the only way he had a chance to win the title.! The AMA sucks.
Blatant take out? Hardly...if you look at the video, Reed never changes his line.......JBS "Blatantly" squares the corner into him.....Not that it mattered either way


Here's a "Blatant" take out





WhKnuckle
Profile picture for user WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
TX US
WhKnuckle 5/3/2009 4:02pm
5/3/2009 4:02pm
ChrisB wrote:
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same...
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same lap...
catatonic wrote:
right on......I've been hit hard enough to jar teeth loose in the +30 b class.
I've been hit harder by my son on a YZ85 than Chisholm hit Reed, too. So what? The point is, if Reed had actually knocked Stewart down, he'd have been DQed and that'd be that.
Void Main
Profile picture for user Void Main
Posts
17013
Joined
3/19/2008
Location
US
Void Main 5/3/2009 4:13pm
5/3/2009 4:13pm
ChrisB wrote:
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same...
I've been hit a whole lot harder than that for a $2 plastic trophy... But, at least the guy that hit me was on the same lap...
catatonic wrote:
right on......I've been hit hard enough to jar teeth loose in the +30 b class.
WhKnuckle wrote:
I've been hit harder by my son on a YZ85 than Chisholm hit Reed, too. So what? The point is, if Reed had actually knocked Stewart...
I've been hit harder by my son on a YZ85 than Chisholm hit Reed, too. So what? The point is, if Reed had actually knocked Stewart down, he'd have been DQed and that'd be that.
if Reed had actually knocked Stewart down, he'd have been DQed and that'd be that.

Are you sure about that?
WhKnuckle
Profile picture for user WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
TX US
WhKnuckle 5/3/2009 4:25pm
5/3/2009 4:25pm
catatonic wrote:
right on......I've been hit hard enough to jar teeth loose in the +30 b class.
WhKnuckle wrote:
I've been hit harder by my son on a YZ85 than Chisholm hit Reed, too. So what? The point is, if Reed had actually knocked Stewart...
I've been hit harder by my son on a YZ85 than Chisholm hit Reed, too. So what? The point is, if Reed had actually knocked Stewart down, he'd have been DQed and that'd be that.
Void Main wrote:
if Reed had actually knocked Stewart down, he'd have been DQed and that'd be that.

Are you sure about that?
Absolutely. If Reed followed Stewart around for 3 laps, with Stewart trail riding trying to get Reed to pass, and then Reed harpooned him and knocked him down, the AMA and FIM would have had a no-brainer decision. They'd have had no choice.
jib-tmb
Profile picture for user jib-tmb
Posts
835
Joined
8/8/2008
Location
Meadville, PA US
jib-tmb 5/3/2009 4:27pm
5/3/2009 4:27pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 4:43pm
I think Reed would have had better chance if he would have just stayed right on Stewarts ass. Then he might have been able to force James into a mistake. Passing him didn't make any difference.
Void Main
Profile picture for user Void Main
Posts
17013
Joined
3/19/2008
Location
US
Void Main 5/3/2009 4:41pm
5/3/2009 4:41pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2009 4:42pm
todder wrote:
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming...
Will any action be taken against Reed for his blatant take out attempt? Chisolms's could be a argued, Jlaw's- Helper hit, he says he was coming in too hot, but Reed crosses the track to hit the points leader then admits that it is the only way he had a chance to win the title.! The AMA sucks.
Of course Chad isn't going to do a harpoon takeout but what if Chad got into James' back wheel when trying to pass him on a tight corner and James went down? It could have easily been intentional but not blatant. What about a block pass with a brake check (something Carmichael used to do many times)?

Post a reply to: Reed Fined?