Stewart Appeal Announcement?

burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
4/23/2015 9:23pm Edited Date/Time 4/24/2015 5:53am
The FIM is just flexing its muscles. The promoters have given them free reign to do with the riders as they please. The FIM could ban him for life and Feld and DC would just ... let them.
dice78
Posts
30
Joined
1/18/2011
Location
Amsterdam, NY, USA
4/23/2015 9:34pm
where the hell is the ama mxsports or who ever is partners with the FIM. The FIM is shitting all over our series and we have no say..if it was AC222 this shit be over and he be racing by now.. step the hell up AMA MXsports and who ever runs SX and get this shit done.. is JS7 in or out for MX
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
4/23/2015 9:44pm Edited Date/Time 4/23/2015 10:11pm
It's the promoters's sport. They put on the show and list who they want to sponsor or sanction it, based on money and relationships. The riders are only participants, and basically have no bearing or worth. The AMA has no bearing at all and can't do anything about any of this. The FIM won't answer and we won't see JS7 until next season, if at all. James needs to start thinking about selling stuff and sizing down.
Seamorbutts
Posts
1510
Joined
4/20/2013
Location
Lake Charles, LA, USA
4/23/2015 11:04pm Edited Date/Time 4/23/2015 11:05pm
burn1986 wrote:
It's the promoters's sport. They put on the show and list who they want to sponsor or sanction it, based on money and relationships. The riders...
It's the promoters's sport. They put on the show and list who they want to sponsor or sanction it, based on money and relationships. The riders are only participants, and basically have no bearing or worth. The AMA has no bearing at all and can't do anything about any of this. The FIM won't answer and we won't see JS7 until next season, if at all. James needs to start thinking about selling stuff and sizing down.
Selling stuff and sizing down? Lol...Fear monger!

The Shop

dirtdog36
Posts
426
Joined
8/6/2010
Location
Nashville, TN, USA
4/24/2015 6:31am Edited Date/Time 4/24/2015 6:33am
I still don't understand why the AMA/FELD/MXSPORTS does not just walk away from FIM/WADA/OTHERS

As has been stated many many many times over, the people paying these teams, AutoTrader, Toyota, BTO, Discount Tires, Crossland, MotoConcepts, Monster, RedBull others... don't sponsor these teams because of what is going on in Europe and give two shits about the MXDN ---- they are going after the American market and the demographics that MX/SX brings. (Supercross more than MX, and if you don't believe that go read Holigans post from back in the day about trying to get money to race outdoors)

Someone is going to get so sideways on this and miss the point, and say that Monster and RedBull are sponsoring on both sides of the pond. Yes they are but out of different add budgets. They are sponsoring the American series and riders for the exposure they get in the US. All sponsorship is, is a form of advertising. These people want to advertise in the US.

And alternately they are sponsoring JH and AC due to the exposure they get in the European market
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
4/24/2015 6:48am Edited Date/Time 4/24/2015 8:03am
Monster and Redbull don't put as much pressure on the promoters as wealthy MX/SX industry insiders and OEMs. They put the pressure on the promoters (Feld and DC) and the promoters give them what they want/ pay for. In short, the promoters don't care (about James, the sport, etc) as long as they get paid.
4/25/2015 12:01am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 12:08am
Are they SERIOUSLY going to (again) wait until 1 week before the season starts before giving an answer to the appeal?? All that shows is a total lack of respect for the individual, the team, the sponsors and the fans. And no, I realize they don't owe the Stewart camp anything as he was in the wrong but they also have a chance to somewhat right a seriously excessively wrong punishment.

This is why the AMA, Feld and MX Sports should part ways with the FIM or whoever else is involved in this fiasco. There is ZERO reason that a decision should not have been made on the appeal. It is like they are using their power to dangle the carrot, so to speak.

I'm telling you...and I HATE to admit it because I am a huge fan of his....but if this was AC222 I do not think the FIM would not be dragging their feet like this. I do not see it. It is sad that I feel that way but I do. And that is zero disrespect for Tony as he is a great representative of our sport and even takes an inhaler ( I think) so he followed all the proper channels unlike James. I am just saying that IF it was him I think this would have been handled much more timely.

4/25/2015 12:05am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 12:08am
My apologies. Double post.
Regis
Posts
2777
Joined
6/17/2008
Location
Gonzales, LA, USA
4/25/2015 5:02am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 5:07am
500guy wrote:
Don't kid yourself, The FIM guy's who we know are linked to the GP's play hard ball and this is simply a big FU to the...
Don't kid yourself, The FIM guy's who we know are linked to the GP's play hard ball and this is simply a big FU to the American series both of them.

I just wonder what happens if a rider tests positive in the out doors and the AMA series suspends a rider from racing SX or GP's , bet some panties get wadded up on that.
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
machine
Posts
6404
Joined
1/5/2011
Location
Collettsville, NC, USA
4/25/2015 5:19am
Regis wrote:
I bet the people that need to know, already know. This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with...
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
Yep...
logan_140
Posts
3724
Joined
6/9/2014
Location
Lakeland, FL, USA
4/25/2015 5:57am
Feel so bad for stewart, once again training to be prepared for the Nationals not even knowing if he can race.. Fim handled this so poorly
4/25/2015 6:24am
Regis wrote:
I bet the people that need to know, already know. This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with...
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
machine wrote:
Yep...
"Clear cut rules and punishments"?

Really?

Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is anything but clear and transparent.
motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
4/25/2015 6:42am
I pretty much agree with you. And when you think about it MX/SX is like only one team in another sport traveling around the country. When you only really have a handful of stars and then to allow arguably your biggest star to be out this long for what James is guilty of is ridiculous.
FARANG
Posts
861
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
4/25/2015 6:50am
Kind of funny how the FIM are toying with Stewart IMO.

Reminds me of the way Stewart has been toying with the fans over the years. Throwing them a bone when he needs some support, otherwise ignoring them.

Seems he's pissed off the FIM, I don't see any reduction in the ban and that would be the correct decision IMO.
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
4/25/2015 6:59am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 7:03am
500guy wrote:
Don't kid yourself, The FIM guy's who we know are linked to the GP's play hard ball and this is simply a big FU to the...
Don't kid yourself, The FIM guy's who we know are linked to the GP's play hard ball and this is simply a big FU to the American series both of them.

I just wonder what happens if a rider tests positive in the out doors and the AMA series suspends a rider from racing SX or GP's , bet some panties get wadded up on that.
Regis wrote:
I bet the people that need to know, already know. This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with...
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
I love people who crusade for the bullies, with statements like "Well, you shouldn't have been in his way" or "You have to give up your lunch money, so what. You know the rules around here."

Lets crusade for the no response from FIM appeal procedures, and levying the letter of the law to a US rider from a European based organization. Shouldn't this be reciprocal? Couldn't the AMA regulate the GPs, since the FIM regulates the SX and MX series?

Maybe we need a super analytical legal response as to why JS will be banned from the MX series too. Then we can all clap for the wonderful justice of it all.

But this is all moot. JS7 is done, and the FIM crusaders, Feld, and DC will go home and sleep well knowing justice was done. Its a wonderful world we live in.
Zracer
Posts
1479
Joined
2/17/2013
Location
Saint Clair, MI, USA
4/25/2015 7:06am
500guy wrote:
Don't kid yourself, The FIM guy's who we know are linked to the GP's play hard ball and this is simply a big FU to the...
Don't kid yourself, The FIM guy's who we know are linked to the GP's play hard ball and this is simply a big FU to the American series both of them.

I just wonder what happens if a rider tests positive in the out doors and the AMA series suspends a rider from racing SX or GP's , bet some panties get wadded up on that.
Regis wrote:
I bet the people that need to know, already know. This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with...
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
burn1986 wrote:
I love people who crusade for the bullies, with statements like "Well, you shouldn't have been in his way" or "You have to give up your...
I love people who crusade for the bullies, with statements like "Well, you shouldn't have been in his way" or "You have to give up your lunch money, so what. You know the rules around here."

Lets crusade for the no response from FIM appeal procedures, and levying the letter of the law to a US rider from a European based organization. Shouldn't this be reciprocal? Couldn't the AMA regulate the GPs, since the FIM regulates the SX and MX series?

Maybe we need a super analytical legal response as to why JS will be banned from the MX series too. Then we can all clap for the wonderful justice of it all.

But this is all moot. JS7 is done, and the FIM crusaders, Feld, and DC will go home and sleep well knowing justice was done. Its a wonderful world we live in.
I love people who just whine about the same crap over and over on the web. Wasnt this shit settled over 5 months ago? Go grab a Free James sign and head on over to FIM HQ to protest like the big people, or you just stfu and wait for August like everybody else.
davistld01
Posts
9414
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Springfield, MO, USA
4/25/2015 7:32am
FARANG wrote:
Kind of funny how the FIM are toying with Stewart IMO. Reminds me of the way Stewart has been toying with the fans over the years...
Kind of funny how the FIM are toying with Stewart IMO.

Reminds me of the way Stewart has been toying with the fans over the years. Throwing them a bone when he needs some support, otherwise ignoring them.

Seems he's pissed off the FIM, I don't see any reduction in the ban and that would be the correct decision IMO.


Fraser
Posts
780
Joined
9/12/2008
Location
Leics, GB
4/25/2015 9:16am
Are they SERIOUSLY going to (again) wait until 1 week before the season starts before giving an answer to the appeal?? All that shows is a...
Are they SERIOUSLY going to (again) wait until 1 week before the season starts before giving an answer to the appeal?? All that shows is a total lack of respect for the individual, the team, the sponsors and the fans. And no, I realize they don't owe the Stewart camp anything as he was in the wrong but they also have a chance to somewhat right a seriously excessively wrong punishment.

This is why the AMA, Feld and MX Sports should part ways with the FIM or whoever else is involved in this fiasco. There is ZERO reason that a decision should not have been made on the appeal. It is like they are using their power to dangle the carrot, so to speak.

I'm telling you...and I HATE to admit it because I am a huge fan of his....but if this was AC222 I do not think the FIM would not be dragging their feet like this. I do not see it. It is sad that I feel that way but I do. And that is zero disrespect for Tony as he is a great representative of our sport and even takes an inhaler ( I think) so he followed all the proper channels unlike James. I am just saying that IF it was him I think this would have been handled much more timely.

Starchild, 'seriously excessive punishment'?? And yet it was precisely within the WADA recommendations for the offence.
Fraser
Posts
780
Joined
9/12/2008
Location
Leics, GB
4/25/2015 9:17am
Regis wrote:
I bet the people that need to know, already know. This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with...
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
machine wrote:
Yep...
[i]"Clear cut rules and punishments"? [/i] Really? Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is...
"Clear cut rules and punishments"?

Really?

Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is anything but clear and transparent.
Very transparent. He's banned until August. As the FIM ruled, unless he wins an appeal nothing has changed. Nothing uncertain about it whatsoever.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13350
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
4/25/2015 9:28am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 10:07am
[i]"Clear cut rules and punishments"? [/i] Really? Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is...
"Clear cut rules and punishments"?

Really?

Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is anything but clear and transparent.
Because people have chosen to be willfully ignorant of the rules, yourself included if you don't believe the rules ~ which have been in place since 2009 at least ~ aren't utterly clear about what the consequences were and what could be done to avoid them.

It's a helluva a cautionary tale for the other guys, or any other athlete in any other sport. But that good can't come about as long as people are in denial about what the sport signed up for and their own blame for the consequences of choosing to remain ignorant to what they agreed to abide by. It's not like the sport had to bring this system in.

Another issue to bear in mind is that you will never hear about compliance, about the people (including others apparently when Stew was drawn) who had someone read the rules and guide them through the TUE process so that they would comply. You only hear about the exceptions of the people who didn't comply.
h&m_cycle
Posts
4410
Joined
2/23/2014
Location
Steubenville, OH, USA
4/25/2015 9:33am
Regis wrote:
I bet the people that need to know, already know. This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with...
I bet the people that need to know, already know.

This is not a F YOU to an American series. This is WADA / USADA with clear cut rules and punishments and then some with "I can't believe it" attitudes who want to point the finger elsewhere.

It amazes me (not necessarily you Jay, but I just replied to your post) that some of the people posting feel the rule makers and rule enforcers are the problem. As if the promotors should just walk away from the integrity of rules just because a star was popped for not playing by them.

Come on. I miss JS7 too and SX is a snoozer without him but, you do the crime, you do the time. Regardless if you are the fastest man in the planet and regardless if you are a GP star or SX star.
machine wrote:
Yep...
[i]"Clear cut rules and punishments"? [/i] Really? Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is...
"Clear cut rules and punishments"?

Really?

Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is anything but clear and transparent.
He knows he was banned for 18 months, they're not knocking time served off so forget about it.

get over it, you'll live. This is not a real sport. It's a daredevil side show. It's over when Evil jumps the buses.



FreshTopEnd
Posts
13350
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
4/25/2015 9:37am
burn1986 wrote:
I love people who crusade for the bullies, with statements like "Well, you shouldn't have been in his way" or "You have to give up your...
I love people who crusade for the bullies, with statements like "Well, you shouldn't have been in his way" or "You have to give up your lunch money, so what. You know the rules around here."

Lets crusade for the no response from FIM appeal procedures, and levying the letter of the law to a US rider from a European based organization. Shouldn't this be reciprocal? Couldn't the AMA regulate the GPs, since the FIM regulates the SX and MX series?

Maybe we need a super analytical legal response as to why JS will be banned from the MX series too. Then we can all clap for the wonderful justice of it all.

But this is all moot. JS7 is done, and the FIM crusaders, Feld, and DC will go home and sleep well knowing justice was done. Its a wonderful world we live in.
There is no hope for this country
rcm406
Posts
3639
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Atlanta, GA, USA
4/25/2015 9:40am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 9:40am
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a decision. It's either yes you can race or no you can't. It's not that hard! Stop stringing him and the fans along!
h&m_cycle
Posts
4410
Joined
2/23/2014
Location
Steubenville, OH, USA
4/25/2015 9:44am
I can't believe people would blame Feld & DC for this mess, They both want James out there.

Team Stewart broke the rules, it's 18 months.
hvaughn88
Posts
8361
Joined
6/19/2013
Location
Conway, AR, USA
4/25/2015 9:47am
[i]"Clear cut rules and punishments"? [/i] Really? Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is...
"Clear cut rules and punishments"?

Really?

Then explain why there is absolute uncertainty surrounding what James' actual punishment is (aka length of ban)? This is anything but clear and transparent.
Because people have chosen to be willfully ignorant of the rules, yourself included if you don't believe the rules ~ which have been in place since...
Because people have chosen to be willfully ignorant of the rules, yourself included if you don't believe the rules ~ which have been in place since 2009 at least ~ aren't utterly clear about what the consequences were and what could be done to avoid them.

It's a helluva a cautionary tale for the other guys, or any other athlete in any other sport. But that good can't come about as long as people are in denial about what the sport signed up for and their own blame for the consequences of choosing to remain ignorant to what they agreed to abide by. It's not like the sport had to bring this system in.

Another issue to bear in mind is that you will never hear about compliance, about the people (including others apparently when Stew was drawn) who had someone read the rules and guide them through the TUE process so that they would comply. You only hear about the exceptions of the people who didn't comply.
Ding ding ding! It blows me away that people still think this is some kind of witch hunt.
hvaughn88
Posts
8361
Joined
6/19/2013
Location
Conway, AR, USA
4/25/2015 9:49am
rcm406 wrote:
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a...
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a decision. It's either yes you can race or no you can't. It's not that hard! Stop stringing him and the fans along!
Actually, James is arguing the punishment.
IceMan446
Posts
4676
Joined
1/10/2010
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
4/25/2015 10:36am
This is another reason, of the many, that the riders need to start a union.

dirtdog36
Posts
426
Joined
8/6/2010
Location
Nashville, TN, USA
4/25/2015 10:42am
rcm406 wrote:
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a...
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a decision. It's either yes you can race or no you can't. It's not that hard! Stop stringing him and the fans along!
This x100000000000

Guys, there was an appeal and there was supposed to be an announcement. NO announcement STILL. Remember how long it was originally before we got any real info on the original findings and punishment

This is the crazy part. The total lack of communication and delayed timelines. This would not be happening in any other sport b/c ESPN, Bleacher Report, Yahoo Sports and others would be digging into it and calling it what it is. Looks at how the NCAA bullshit gets called all the time by the press. BUT, MX/SX wants to be sooooooo secretive we get nothing. And we wonder why we get even less press than Indy car and that series is truly dying on the vine!!

This is totally 100% unprofessional. If the appeal has been denied then have the balls to make an announcement and say so!!!! But they haven't! - Thats the issue


DownSouth
Posts
9969
Joined
7/5/2008
Location
Tallapoosa, GA, USA
4/25/2015 10:46am Edited Date/Time 4/25/2015 10:49am
rcm406 wrote:
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a...
Geezus people, at this point I don't think anyone is arguing the punishment. The issue is the length of time it takes them to make a decision. It's either yes you can race or no you can't. It's not that hard! Stop stringing him and the fans along!
dirtdog36 wrote:
This x100000000000 Guys, there was an appeal and there was supposed to be an announcement. NO announcement STILL. Remember how long it was originally before we...
This x100000000000

Guys, there was an appeal and there was supposed to be an announcement. NO announcement STILL. Remember how long it was originally before we got any real info on the original findings and punishment

This is the crazy part. The total lack of communication and delayed timelines. This would not be happening in any other sport b/c ESPN, Bleacher Report, Yahoo Sports and others would be digging into it and calling it what it is. Looks at how the NCAA bullshit gets called all the time by the press. BUT, MX/SX wants to be sooooooo secretive we get nothing. And we wonder why we get even less press than Indy car and that series is truly dying on the vine!!

This is totally 100% unprofessional. If the appeal has been denied then have the balls to make an announcement and say so!!!! But they haven't! - Thats the issue


When was there ever an official announcement of when the results of the appeal would be known? Other than internet rumors I never saw anything legit regarding a timeframe.

He is suspended until August so anything earlier than that is a bonus.
A. DLeary
Posts
537
Joined
3/13/2015
Location
USA
4/25/2015 12:05pm
DownSouth wrote:
When was there ever an official announcement of when the results of the appeal would be known? Other than internet rumors I never saw anything legit...
When was there ever an official announcement of when the results of the appeal would be known? Other than internet rumors I never saw anything legit regarding a timeframe.

He is suspended until August so anything earlier than that is a bonus.
I don't think you understand the point of an appeal, and I think you fail to grasp the idea of due process in a timley manner. I don't know of any other organization that uses WADA drug testing that takes this long to hear an appeal and rule on it. It's a joke.

Post a reply to: Stewart Appeal Announcement?

The Latest