AMA riders results in Donington MXoN ...

prozach
Posts
1283
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Eureka, CA, USA
10/1/2008 8:09pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 8:39pm
Rupert X wrote:
Let's analyze this correctly. AMA riders won the overall. AMA riders won 67 % o f the classes outright. Of 105 riders entered, 11, or just...
Let's analyze this correctly.

AMA riders won the overall.

AMA riders won 67 % o f the classes outright.

Of 105 riders entered, 11, or just over ten percent, compete in the

AMA.

For the most part, this small sampling of AMA participants finished

in the top twenty (20) percent of ALL riders competing.

ALL the American riders had at least one top ten (10) finish.

We have fifty states, we only sent riders from two of our states.

96% of tthe fans came to see Bubba throw insane whips over

the tabletops, the other 4% threw bottles at him.

No matter how you slice it, the Americans currently remain at the top of

the motocross food chain.

Can we be beat? Hell yeah.

But not at Red Bud, no way.





Thank you!!! I am so over Euros trying to validate themselves. Very, very few Americans think the Euros suck, so why do so many euros on here constantly talk like we think that way?

The AMA riders are better,

Langston, Millsaps, Short, Townley, Dungey, Stroupe, Canard, M. Alessi, Hepler, Tedesco C. pourcel weren't even there and a few AMA riders still did great even though they were greatly out numbered.
john1753
Posts
744
Joined
9/2/2008
Location
NZ
10/1/2008 8:10pm
Rupert X wrote:
Let's analyze this correctly. AMA riders won the overall. AMA riders won 67 % o f the classes outright. Of 105 riders entered, 11, or just...
Let's analyze this correctly.

AMA riders won the overall.

AMA riders won 67 % o f the classes outright.

Of 105 riders entered, 11, or just over ten percent, compete in the

AMA.

For the most part, this small sampling of AMA participants finished

in the top twenty (20) percent of ALL riders competing.

ALL the American riders had at least one top ten (10) finish.

We have fifty states, we only sent riders from two of our states.

96% of tthe fans came to see Bubba throw insane whips over

the tabletops, the other 4% threw bottles at him.

No matter how you slice it, the Americans currently remain at the top of

the motocross food chain.

Can we be beat? Hell yeah.

But not at Red Bud, no way.





no good american riders are going to live in pissy little states in the middle of nowhere, they are going to live in places like california or florida where motocross is more popular so to say you only sent riders from 2 states is bullshit. plus you have 305,311,475 people to choose from when new zealand only has 4,173,460...
Devil1nNj
Posts
960
Joined
11/12/2006
Location
Hewitt, NJ, USA
10/1/2008 8:14pm
BITTERNESS

from that sour taste of defeat.

That is the fuel of these posts, and this is the exhaust.

Unfortunately it does not smell as sweet as some U4.
More like that egg smell when your following someone up a hill...
john1753
Posts
744
Joined
9/2/2008
Location
NZ
10/1/2008 8:20pm
Rupert X wrote:
Let's analyze this correctly. AMA riders won the overall. AMA riders won 67 % o f the classes outright. Of 105 riders entered, 11, or just...
Let's analyze this correctly.

AMA riders won the overall.

AMA riders won 67 % o f the classes outright.

Of 105 riders entered, 11, or just over ten percent, compete in the

AMA.

For the most part, this small sampling of AMA participants finished

in the top twenty (20) percent of ALL riders competing.

ALL the American riders had at least one top ten (10) finish.

We have fifty states, we only sent riders from two of our states.

96% of tthe fans came to see Bubba throw insane whips over

the tabletops, the other 4% threw bottles at him.

No matter how you slice it, the Americans currently remain at the top of

the motocross food chain.

Can we be beat? Hell yeah.

But not at Red Bud, no way.





prozach wrote:
Thank you!!! I am so over Euros trying to validate themselves. Very, very few Americans think the Euros suck, so why do so many euros on...
Thank you!!! I am so over Euros trying to validate themselves. Very, very few Americans think the Euros suck, so why do so many euros on here constantly talk like we think that way?

The AMA riders are better,

Langston, Millsaps, Short, Townley, Dungey, Stroupe, Canard, M. Alessi, Hepler, Tedesco C. pourcel weren't even there and a few AMA riders still did great even though they were greatly out numbered.
langston, townley, alessi and pourcel aren't americans and so wouldn't have made a difference to americas results if they were at the event

The Shop

prozach
Posts
1283
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Eureka, CA, USA
10/1/2008 8:25pm
idiots everywhere, this thread was about AMA vs GP riders!!
john1753
Posts
744
Joined
9/2/2008
Location
NZ
10/1/2008 8:30pm
prozach wrote:
idiots everywhere, this thread was about AMA vs GP riders!!
another amerian who thinks it all about himself
prozach
Posts
1283
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Eureka, CA, USA
10/1/2008 8:41pm
Not my problem you can't read. You tried to correct me when there was nothing to correct. Therefor this is about you being all about yourself. Admit you were wrong and call it a day. That is if you are man enough to do that.

Ha, ha. i don't care. Just trying to make you look not so dumb by making irrelevant points. Go on as you were.
john1753
Posts
744
Joined
9/2/2008
Location
NZ
10/1/2008 8:50pm
irrelevant?!?! the subject is MXoN, not AMA vs GP
prozach
Posts
1283
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Eureka, CA, USA
10/1/2008 9:29pm
john1753 wrote:
irrelevant?!?! the subject is MXoN, not AMA vs GP
you are killing me!! Read the title of the thread and the first post. If you still don't get I give up trying to help you. Smile
john1753
Posts
744
Joined
9/2/2008
Location
NZ
10/1/2008 9:49pm
"AMA riders results in "Donington MXoN" not " subject for dumb asses like prozach"
mxgeoff
Posts
1261
Joined
5/26/2008
Location
vegas, SH
10/1/2008 10:22pm
I think it proved what we all already knew. On American soil the AMA guys rule. On european soil it is more a level playing field.

I don't think too many of the leading GP guys (apart from maybe Searle, Pourcel and maybe one or two others) rode that well. The AMA guys really struggled in these conditions, and just like in 2006 at Matterly Basin is shows how different the circuits are in europe and America.

All respect to team America, they rule the roost by miles. Could a B-team win the event, that is a big question mark, I don'think they could. After Stewart and Villopoto the playing field between AMA and FIM is pretty level.

I was impressed with Cooper though, and Bryne and Metcalfe on the saturday were impressive. I think the depth in America is deeper than we euro's thought.

Geoff
10/1/2008 10:26pm
Geoff, that seemed to be an honest post., no stirring of the poop pot.
mxgeoff
Posts
1261
Joined
5/26/2008
Location
vegas, SH
10/1/2008 10:49pm
Geoff, that seemed to be an honest post., no stirring of the poop pot.
It is easy to make it look something it isn't, but to be honest, the level in the AMA series looks pretty f*cking strong. I didn't believe Metcalfe, Bryne and Cooper were that good, but they have improved a lot this year.

I can't wait for next year, again hard pack and the GP guys begin to think they can run with the AMA guys and that will make it exciting. Stewart and Villopoto are fast, but in my opinion this new breed of GP riders are catching up.

Pourcel wasn't worried about Stewart at all in that second moto, and had it not been for his back brake line braking on the second lap he would have maybe held his own.

Ok, I made the bit about the brake line up, hahaha.

Geoff
jo2910
Posts
863
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
London, GB
10/2/2008 1:59am
If the USA were to send more than one team on a perfect day they could get two teams on the podium. But in the end thsi is motocross racing someone is bond to have a shitty start and struggle through the pack, someone will go down at some point, a mechanical will happen, one rider will be on top form and another will have a bad day, or struggle with bike setup.... In the end you'll end up with another mix of GP and AMA riders in the results order. And if you were to run the race again tomorrow it will probably be different again....
mccread
Posts
5934
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/2/2008 3:01am
I thought the AMA riders were disapointing Matin Bar was quicker than Metcaffe in qualyfying... obvioulsy Rv and bubba are ver very fast but I think AC could have ran with RV, Rattary stayed with him in the 2nd moto. Sealre caught passed and left Metty in the 2nd moto. And Villo although fast was 3rd mx2 until Tyla crashed in the first moto, at millville RV came from last to 2nd

Ferry is nothing special he is just anopther one of the boys in GPs he got passed by the 11th placed rider in mx2 at one stage and Osbourne flew past him! If Boissieres wheel didn't break france would have one the US got lucky.

If the US struggle to win a MXDN with their enclosed pit area 50 people entourage no wonder those guys dont actually have a crack at the individual world championship!

US riders are verated imo

The top Americans are the fastest in the world in the US but its no wonder why they dont race a world championship they cant hack it outside their comfort zone and groomed loamy tracks especially for a full GP season.

Guys like Brown and Osbourne and Hamblin deserve alot of respect for stepping up to the world championship and proving their speed outside their own country ( everyone is faster in their own country)

James went 24-0 in the US and has yet to win an OA outside the US maybe he should step up and race the GPs and become the true World Champion against the best riders in the world. becuase in the US his comp this year were not on the same level as the GP guys clearly.
mccread
Posts
5934
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/2/2008 3:03am
If europe wer to send a team against he US states they would win too, winning the MXDN does not mean your riders were faster than all the other riders from different countries ie Ferry got beat in every moto yet you guys make it out like he is superior to all the other riders who beat him!
jo2910
Posts
863
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
London, GB
10/2/2008 3:27am
lol mcread you're going to make more friends with this post!

Even as a Euro you're definetly pushing it there. JS would win the GP series as well. Might take a few races to adapt fully but with the preparation he woudl be on top no question. Same for RV maybe AC could run with him but at the moment they both have crazy confidence and they know they can beat anyone. They are both winning machines. Stewart was killing it this weekend he just made one mistake in this second race. On saturday the front tire had a problem. if he was to race the GPs he would maybe make the odd mistake but would win easy like he has in the US especially cuz all the riders would look up at him.

Plus why on earthe would he leave his millions he gets for SX only contract to race far away from his home country and comfort for less money in Europe.

SX makes the $$$ they earn not outdoors
FastEddy
Posts
14815
Joined
8/3/2008
Location
💀, FL, USA
10/2/2008 3:35am Edited Date/Time 10/2/2008 3:41am
McCread , Your an idiot.....

James was clearly faster then Pourcel or any GP's guys for that matter and there was no competition for him.
James did go 24-0 here in the states and he won his qually over there and also won his first moto by over 21 seconds over Pourcel , if you call that competition you are a fool. James made a mistake and went down (couldnt get the bike started), happens to the best of them, im sure if that had happened in a National Alessi would have capitalized on it and won an OA, just as Pourcel did....

On a side note: RV turned faster laps times in the MX1 MX2 race the Pourcel did. Smile
RV 2:02.667
SP 2:03.369

Face it you guys got your asses handed to you again, even though the USA did have a very bad day.

Why do you come on here and spout lies and bullshit hoping people wont look the results up?
Again McIdiot- In qualifying Martin Bar's best time was 2:07.038 to Mettys 2:02.871.
Also at the finish Martin Bar was over 1minute behind Metty.


While we are on the subject of MXdN.
Ireland didnt even make the A-Main ,kinda funny they got beat out of the A-Main by a team with a girl on it. hehehehhee LOL Smile
FastEddy
Posts
14815
Joined
8/3/2008
Location
💀, FL, USA
10/2/2008 3:53am Edited Date/Time 10/2/2008 4:17am
"Rattary stayed with him in the 2nd moto"

Also McCread - Rattray got lapped by RV in the second MX2 race...
If you call that staying with someone -your foolish. lol

Hehehe.. A LAPPER trying to battle with the leader is just retarded.
jo2910
Posts
863
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
London, GB
10/2/2008 4:13am Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 8:39pm
FastEddy wrote:
"Rattary stayed with him in the 2nd moto" Also McCread - Rattray got lapped by RV in the second MX2 race... If you call that staying...
"Rattary stayed with him in the 2nd moto"

Also McCread - Rattray got lapped by RV in the second MX2 race...
If you call that staying with someone -your foolish. lol

Hehehe.. A LAPPER trying to battle with the leader is just retarded.
Great FastEddy you just made yourself look even more stupid the McRead! Should have kept to only one post!

Rattray didn't battle with RV at all. He let him through after he had crashed, opened the door for him and then just followed him around with two or three bikes length. Nothing retarded there! He's not going to slow down is he. Even a lapper is doing his own race Tyla had a lot of catching up to do and try to make points by passing as many people he could. He put a very impressive charge good on him for keeping on charging through the moto!!!

And Yes he stayed with him. Ok he didn't have any pressure and maybe RV was not pushing hard but still he matched RV's pace!
FastEddy
Posts
14815
Joined
8/3/2008
Location
💀, FL, USA
10/2/2008 4:18am Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 8:39pm
jo2910 wrote:
Great FastEddy you just made yourself look even more stupid the McRead! Should have kept to only one post! Rattray didn't battle with RV at all...
Great FastEddy you just made yourself look even more stupid the McRead! Should have kept to only one post!

Rattray didn't battle with RV at all. He let him through after he had crashed, opened the door for him and then just followed him around with two or three bikes length. Nothing retarded there! He's not going to slow down is he. Even a lapper is doing his own race Tyla had a lot of catching up to do and try to make points by passing as many people he could. He put a very impressive charge good on him for keeping on charging through the moto!!!

And Yes he stayed with him. Ok he didn't have any pressure and maybe RV was not pushing hard but still he matched RV's pace!
I seen the race and my comment

"Hehehe.. A LAPPER trying to battle with the leader is just retarded."

Was not directed at Rattray, it was a comment about lappers in general.

Use some common sense...stupid one. Wink
jamma10
Posts
10573
Joined
8/24/2008
Location
Bristol, GB
10/2/2008 6:22am Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 8:39pm
mxgeoff wrote:
I think it proved what we all already knew. On American soil the AMA guys rule. On european soil it is more a level playing field...
I think it proved what we all already knew. On American soil the AMA guys rule. On european soil it is more a level playing field.

I don't think too many of the leading GP guys (apart from maybe Searle, Pourcel and maybe one or two others) rode that well. The AMA guys really struggled in these conditions, and just like in 2006 at Matterly Basin is shows how different the circuits are in europe and America.

All respect to team America, they rule the roost by miles. Could a B-team win the event, that is a big question mark, I don'think they could. After Stewart and Villopoto the playing field between AMA and FIM is pretty level.

I was impressed with Cooper though, and Bryne and Metcalfe on the saturday were impressive. I think the depth in America is deeper than we euro's thought.

Geoff
I don't think anyone over here underestimates riders that can finish between 1-10, even 1-20 in the AMA. But at the same time the only riders that we would admit to being a real threat are Villopoto & Stewart (RC when he was still riding).


Short, Dungey, Grant, Ferry, Byrne, Lawrence, Alessi, Millsaps, Metcalfe and possibly Izzi & Hamblin would probably fit into the next category. We respect them all immensely, they're incredible riders but we also know we have guys capable of beating them. Alessi, Brown and Hamblin have proved that in recent years.


While few Americans bother to take an interest in the World Championship (which the media could be blamed for), the majority of Motocross fans from around the world follow the AMA aswell as GP's. For example they show the AMA Outdoor series on TV here in England - although two weeks late - and this, alongside the fact that we've grown up reading about the American MX & SX, gives us a broad overview of what's going on both sides of the Atlantic, not simply a prejudicial view based on the des Nations each year.


kb450
Posts
141
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Anderson, SC, USA
10/2/2008 8:28am
mccread wrote:
I thought the AMA riders were disapointing Matin Bar was quicker than Metcaffe in qualyfying... obvioulsy Rv and bubba are ver very fast but I think...
I thought the AMA riders were disapointing Matin Bar was quicker than Metcaffe in qualyfying... obvioulsy Rv and bubba are ver very fast but I think AC could have ran with RV, Rattary stayed with him in the 2nd moto. Sealre caught passed and left Metty in the 2nd moto. And Villo although fast was 3rd mx2 until Tyla crashed in the first moto, at millville RV came from last to 2nd

Ferry is nothing special he is just anopther one of the boys in GPs he got passed by the 11th placed rider in mx2 at one stage and Osbourne flew past him! If Boissieres wheel didn't break france would have one the US got lucky.

If the US struggle to win a MXDN with their enclosed pit area 50 people entourage no wonder those guys dont actually have a crack at the individual world championship!

US riders are verated imo

The top Americans are the fastest in the world in the US but its no wonder why they dont race a world championship they cant hack it outside their comfort zone and groomed loamy tracks especially for a full GP season.

Guys like Brown and Osbourne and Hamblin deserve alot of respect for stepping up to the world championship and proving their speed outside their own country ( everyone is faster in their own country)

James went 24-0 in the US and has yet to win an OA outside the US maybe he should step up and race the GPs and become the true World Champion against the best riders in the world. becuase in the US his comp this year were not on the same level as the GP guys clearly.
Ferry, for being nothing special somehow still picked up the overall. Not sure where you get your opinions from?
AJ
Posts
933
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Lowell, IN, USA
10/2/2008 8:35am
how many ways can this get disected?


JS 1/23 9th o/a
RV 10/1 1st O/A
TF 5/9 12st O/A

took the team win ,and two out of three individual class wins.


it's like everyones somehow disppaiontred they dint completely sweep.

but how about sme perspective?

RV goes 1/10 and gets the overall..
tim overalls MX3 with a 5/9

no other indivdual riders in thier respective classes fared any better,,


I honestly dd not expect the team to take all three individual class wins.
i dont think many people did..?

the expectation is the USA team would likely win, (baring crashes /weather/ weird luck)
and that they would likely win two individual classe..

and thats what happened, they just dint win the expected MX1.

and seb pourcel rode great to take that win..
(sorry it's not a huge surprise to me,, or to anyone?
that if JS had troubles(which he did ) seb might win it)

so the event and even the individual classes ended up pretty much as fans from
either side of the pond would expect..

i just dont see the drama..



if some fans are surprised that seb and a few other GP regulars could hang in there tough,,
or that in the way the structure 9of the event, with classes and finshes being combined
,that a 1/10 or 5/9 might easily be the very best scores in a particular individual class.
thats silly,
and is a pretty minor thing to have endless day after day threads on..


but carry on, its what this place does best..

Wink


The GP riders are obviuosly great MX racers.. to think differently is foolish..
how many world GP champs need to come over and win the nats to get that level of respect?


once again the results in the mxdn show that if you take 3 riders from each country, hodge podge the scoring and classses as much as you can,,
the USA will likely have the strongest 3 rider team.

whats amazing is the very small countrires that have always done well,, like belgium..
in a event structered like the MXdN.
something in the water there..?

someoine needs to bottle that stuff and market it as mxpowerade in the USA..

(a good argument could be made for the water in florida as well )




10/2/2008 12:32pm
Jarid332 wrote:
All that matters is the winning team was all AMA Racers. So take your shit else where.

AMA 1
FIM 0

NEXT!
Shit ??? Are you sure ???

Wink
10/2/2008 12:34pm
Larry wrote:

AMA riders won the event and that's the point. What is your point?
We endless heard all year long that AMA riders pace is a lot better than GP riders pace.

You know what I mean ???

Wink
10/2/2008 12:45pm
jamma10 wrote:
I don't think anyone over here underestimates riders that can finish between 1-10, even 1-20 in the AMA. But at the same time the only riders...
I don't think anyone over here underestimates riders that can finish between 1-10, even 1-20 in the AMA. But at the same time the only riders that we would admit to being a real threat are Villopoto & Stewart (RC when he was still riding).


Short, Dungey, Grant, Ferry, Byrne, Lawrence, Alessi, Millsaps, Metcalfe and possibly Izzi & Hamblin would probably fit into the next category. We respect them all immensely, they're incredible riders but we also know we have guys capable of beating them. Alessi, Brown and Hamblin have proved that in recent years.


While few Americans bother to take an interest in the World Championship (which the media could be blamed for), the majority of Motocross fans from around the world follow the AMA aswell as GP's. For example they show the AMA Outdoor series on TV here in England - although two weeks late - and this, alongside the fact that we've grown up reading about the American MX & SX, gives us a broad overview of what's going on both sides of the Atlantic, not simply a prejudicial view based on the des Nations each year.


Agree.
CalimeroFan
Posts
611
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
MX Town, ZA
10/2/2008 2:15pm
Why making a big deal out of it. 2 things are as clear as they get:
1. Bubba and Villopoto are the two best riders in the world, that's why team USA can't be beat.
- Behind it is completely open. Anyone, no mather if he's riding AMA or GP's, can win if those 2 are not in. In the USA or in Europe.
10/2/2008 2:28pm
Why making a big deal out of it. 2 things are as clear as they get: 1. Bubba and Villopoto are the two best riders in...
Why making a big deal out of it. 2 things are as clear as they get:
1. Bubba and Villopoto are the two best riders in the world, that's why team USA can't be beat.
- Behind it is completely open. Anyone, no mather if he's riding AMA or GP's, can win if those 2 are not in. In the USA or in Europe.
Right.
unii #336
Posts
8
Joined
10/2/2008
Location
Wigan, VG
10/2/2008 2:31pm
villopto is better than bubba !

Post a reply to: AMA riders results in Donington MXoN ...

The Latest