Racing a stock bike in supercross?

BBarnes720
Posts
70
Joined
2/4/2009
Location
Murphy, NC, USA
Edited Date/Time 2/10/2013 8:31pm
Andrew Short’s results are almost identical on a stock bike or a factory Honda. He has placed 6th in the last 2 races.

Could it be a huge marketing tool, to purposely race, a close to stock bike against the so-called factory bikes?

I think the story could be portrayed, as the underdog and receive a substantial amount of TV exposure.

I know when I line up against guys that drive up in the $100,000 set up and I only have the used bike and old pickup truck, that it makes me think for a few seconds, how my results would change if I had their set up.

With a rider announcing on TV that he is racing a bike off the show room floor and finishing in the top 10, I think the normal viewer can relate and therefore sell more motorcycles.

What is your opinion?
|
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
2/8/2013 2:53pm
I think Yamaha and Hannah beat them to it. Wink
mgifracing
Posts
1910
Joined
1/25/2007
Location
Newton, KS, USA
2/8/2013 2:58pm
Gotta agree with ya Barnes, I mostly ride an 05 kx 125 and go to the track in a shit box S 10. Nothing makes my day more than smoking a bunch of highly modded 450's in the vet class.Evil
qtrracer
Posts
148
Joined
12/21/2010
Location
Simi Valley, CA, USA
2/8/2013 2:59pm
GuyB wrote:
I think Yamaha and Hannah beat them to it. Wink
Before his injury I think Bob could ride circles around almost anyone riding almost anything.
BBarnes720
Posts
70
Joined
2/4/2009
Location
Murphy, NC, USA
2/8/2013 3:07pm
GuyB wrote:
I think Yamaha and Hannah beat them to it. Wink
I agree. I know many riders do not have the luxury of expensive parts.

I just think it could be a marketing bonus for the manufactures. I think Short can do it on a bike straight off the showroom.

I’m just using Short as an example, I believe most of the top 20 can do this and it just needs to be advertised for the average viewer on TV.

The Shop

Spartacus
Posts
2269
Joined
5/20/2011
Location
USA
2/8/2013 3:12pm
But with the production rule they're all pretty close to show room stock except tires, right?
BBarnes720
Posts
70
Joined
2/4/2009
Location
Murphy, NC, USA
2/8/2013 3:24pm
Spartacus wrote:
But with the production rule they're all pretty close to show room stock except tires, right?
All my friends perceive every factory bike that makes the main of a supercross is over $50,000.

I just think, an advertised stock bike that makes the main could be an advertising asset and therefore benefit our sport?
JW381
Posts
10638
Joined
7/21/2009
Location
Harrisburg, OR, USA
2/8/2013 3:37pm
Spartacus wrote:
But with the production rule they're all pretty close to show room stock except tires, right?
And suspension, I thought. I thought factory suspension was like 60K and rode like a video game. Maybe that's just hype that I'm believing.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
2/8/2013 3:42pm
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
rpoint116
Posts
870
Joined
6/25/2008
Location
Tempe, AZ, USA
2/8/2013 4:05pm
That's why motocross is the coolest motorsport. If your good enough, you could WIN on (almost) anything!!

Remember when JS 259 & RC were winning championships on 2-strokes against the 4-strokes? How much torque & HP were they down...
TX24
Posts
2767
Joined
5/7/2010
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
2/8/2013 4:10pm
I wonder in a tiny way if it might be like my justification of not buying a 2013 compared to my 2010. I don't think I would be any faster, I do think it would be easier to go the speed I am now.
montesagold
Posts
684
Joined
10/15/2009
Location
East, TN, USA
2/8/2013 4:10pm
newmann wrote:
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and...
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
I think the biggest difference from stock would be suspension. You know that Short never put any time on the bike before he got the suspension setup up better than anyone on here will ever feel. These guys are such good test riders which speeds up that process as well. The big gaps would be with horsepower/power curves and other trick parts.
In other words stock suspension at race pace would get someone killed real quick.
APLMAN99
Posts
13069
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
2/8/2013 4:12pm
BBarnes720 wrote:
Andrew Short’s results are almost identical on a stock bike or a factory Honda. He has placed 6th in the last 2 races. Could it be...
Andrew Short’s results are almost identical on a stock bike or a factory Honda. He has placed 6th in the last 2 races.

Could it be a huge marketing tool, to purposely race, a close to stock bike against the so-called factory bikes?

I think the story could be portrayed, as the underdog and receive a substantial amount of TV exposure.

I know when I line up against guys that drive up in the $100,000 set up and I only have the used bike and old pickup truck, that it makes me think for a few seconds, how my results would change if I had their set up.

With a rider announcing on TV that he is racing a bike off the show room floor and finishing in the top 10, I think the normal viewer can relate and therefore sell more motorcycles.

What is your opinion?
Stock? I don't think anyone in the main event is riding a stock bike.......
gt80rider
Posts
7434
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO, USA
2/8/2013 5:58pm
mgifracing wrote:
Gotta agree with ya Barnes, I mostly ride an 05 kx 125 and go to the track in a shit box S 10. Nothing makes my...
Gotta agree with ya Barnes, I mostly ride an 05 kx 125 and go to the track in a shit box S 10. Nothing makes my day more than smoking a bunch of highly modded 450's in the vet class.Evil
But the point of this thread is- ok, so you smoke the high buck 450's on your older 125, but what would you do if you were racing a $30k 450? would you be slower simply because you are dialed on your 125 or it suits your style? or would you cut off 6 seconds a lap? that is the question here...
mx_563
Posts
2259
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
2/8/2013 6:10pm
#1) Two 6th place finishes for Andrew is not enough for an international multi-billion dollar corporation to attempt something as risky as fielding a pure production bike in Supercross. Even KTM, whose slogan is "Ready to Race" is fielding "Factory" equipment.

#2) most consumers would prefer the $100,000 rig to your used bike and pick-up. The rig won't make them go any faster or win any more trophies, but that doesn't matter. You have to create a marketing campaign based on that fact. The number of slow overweight practice riders (that don't ever race) with blinged out bikes far outweighs the number of competitive (meaning they race) consumers with enough sense to know that [for example] a set of fresh tires will do more for you on Sunday than a set of anodized hubs.
You can also look at the days before the production rule. Glover showed that you could be competitive on a YZ490 against the Works Hondas. Do you think Yamaha sold more YZ490s than Honda sold CR500s????????? Ha!
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
2/8/2013 6:22pm
I think the biggest difference from stock may be simply the team support, expertise and resources that go into refining it. A lot of the bits are available or doable with the money to get there.
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
2/8/2013 6:47pm
newmann wrote:
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and...
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do, with off the showroom floor suspension.

I also think what Hannah did was a different time and place. Look at how Supercross suspension worked back in the day vs. now.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
2/8/2013 7:13pm
newmann wrote:
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and...
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
GuyB wrote:
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do...
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do, with off the showroom floor suspension.

I also think what Hannah did was a different time and place. Look at how Supercross suspension worked back in the day vs. now.
So the internals in the suspension of a brand new 450 are such junk that they can't be polished, tweaked and tuned by the factory engineers and technicians themselves to be able to be ridden around a modern sx track by the best riders in the world? Some of them already come with DLC coatings and with the amazing air forks, they won't even have to change springs. Or is it that it takes works suspension to get a 250 pound "tub of shit"(since we are referencing Hannah here!!!) around a modern SX track.
al711
Posts
147
Joined
1/5/2013
Location
Athens, AL, USA
2/8/2013 7:13pm
newmann wrote:
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and...
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
GuyB wrote:
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do...
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do, with off the showroom floor suspension.

I also think what Hannah did was a different time and place. Look at how Supercross suspension worked back in the day vs. now.
Guy I respectfully disagree with you on the Hannah reference. In the 70's "factory" bikes were hand built one offs, Howertons RM at saddleback was way lighter, faster and much better suspended than Hannah's modded production Yamaha. As a moto fanatic in the 70's I was in awe of what Hannah could on a production based bike against true "works" bikes, he was truly talented!
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
2/8/2013 7:36pm
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78. His later bikes were full works OW's in 78, 79, and even the 81 when he battled with Howerton.
al711
Posts
147
Joined
1/5/2013
Location
Athens, AL, USA
2/8/2013 7:55pm
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78...
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78. His later bikes were full works OW's in 78, 79, and even the 81 when he battled with Howerton.
I think you're right, I should have used a better example. The later mid 80's yamaha's perhaps?
yam261
Posts
449
Joined
4/28/2011
Location
CA
2/8/2013 7:58pm Edited Date/Time 2/8/2013 8:01pm
mgifracing wrote:
Gotta agree with ya Barnes, I mostly ride an 05 kx 125 and go to the track in a shit box S 10. Nothing makes my...
Gotta agree with ya Barnes, I mostly ride an 05 kx 125 and go to the track in a shit box S 10. Nothing makes my day more than smoking a bunch of highly modded 450's in the vet class.Evil
I wish i could say the same. I show up in a 93 ford ranger and race a a 01 yz250 smoker. I get smoked in the +40 class.
1911
Posts
5019
Joined
4/2/2008
Location
LAS VEGAS, NV, USA
2/8/2013 8:04pm
newmann wrote:
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and...
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
GuyB wrote:
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do...
How stock is "stock"? I don't think you could do the fast transitions and whoops that these guys hit in SX, at the speed they do, with off the showroom floor suspension.

I also think what Hannah did was a different time and place. Look at how Supercross suspension worked back in the day vs. now.
al711 wrote:
Guy I respectfully disagree with you on the Hannah reference. In the 70's "factory" bikes were hand built one offs, Howertons RM at saddleback was way...
Guy I respectfully disagree with you on the Hannah reference. In the 70's "factory" bikes were hand built one offs, Howertons RM at saddleback was way lighter, faster and much better suspended than Hannah's modded production Yamaha. As a moto fanatic in the 70's I was in awe of what Hannah could on a production based bike against true "works" bikes, he was truly talented!
I agree with al711.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
2/8/2013 8:23pm
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78...
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78. His later bikes were full works OW's in 78, 79, and even the 81 when he battled with Howerton.
al711 wrote:
I think you're right, I should have used a better example. The later mid 80's yamaha's perhaps?
Well, all the bikes were production based 86 on, and running works suspension like today except that back then the stock stuff wasn't nearly as improveable as it is today in terms of material and design. What RJ and Glover accomished on production based bike in 82 to 85 was pretty incredible, especially RJ in 82. Not sure they didn't get special suspension though. Someone else might know.
mrquick
Posts
1430
Joined
10/9/2006
Location
Union City, TN, USA
2/8/2013 8:33pm
You guys dont really believe that Shorty's bike was pushed off the showroom floor,loaded into his truck and
taken straight to the track and raced...do you? Really?
APLMAN99
Posts
13069
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
2/8/2013 9:09pm
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78...
I don't think Hannah's bikes were production based but for one florida winter series and maybe a SX season early on, maybe 77 or preseason 78. His later bikes were full works OW's in 78, 79, and even the 81 when he battled with Howerton.
I think he raced a 79 DG YZ in Florida, and a production based bike in some supercrosses in 77. They raffled off some of the supercross bikes I'm pretty sure.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
2/8/2013 10:10pm
I'm pretty sure that was all in 77, I'm inuding the raffles. My bud went out a bought one of the 77 250s, which was a great bike. But could be wrong, and it may have been so in Florida in 78 too.
APLMAN99
Posts
13069
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
2/8/2013 10:14pm
I'm pretty sure that was all in 77, I'm inuding the raffles. My bud went out a bought one of the 77 250s, which was a...
I'm pretty sure that was all in 77, I'm inuding the raffles. My bud went out a bought one of the 77 250s, which was a great bike. But could be wrong, and it may have been so in Florida in 78 too.
Maybe he raced a YZ a couple of times in Florida. I can picture a photo of him on a 79, and in the story I think it said he was borrowing Savitski's bikes for the series. Definitely had the "FIM style" side plates on it.......
Choppy
Posts
1931
Joined
12/16/2012
Location
USA
2/8/2013 10:57pm
newmann wrote:
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and...
Funny stuff, when I mentioned the idea of RV racing a factory race team prepped...but otherwise stock KX450F, people here were saying he would die and that it would be stupid and that it would be impossible.Laughing Even Guy B!!!Tongue Did Short get that new bike of his from Pep Boys??? LMAO! (read the thread)

http://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/If-RV-and-the-2012-KX450-…
Putting someone on a completely stock bike would mean he's also on STOCK suspension.

So you want to take a million dollar talent, put him on a stock bike with stock suspension when he's been testing a factory race bike the entire off season and see how it goes?

Wouldn't Kawasaki have more to lose if RV had a bad race?
Fearo
Posts
1383
Joined
12/17/2009
Location
BE
2/9/2013 12:18am Edited Date/Time 2/9/2013 12:22am
I think a whole lot of people misunderstand a factory bike for what it really is. Sure it has unobtanium parts and pretty much bottomless resources, but the way I see it, that's not what makes it stand out from any other bike. In my opinion, there's two things that stand out on a factory bike: strength (durability) and customization.

Have a look at any review of a factory bike and you will notice it immediately. Connecting rods, pistons, brake calipers, cases, suspension components,...you name it. Most of these parts will be made of a stronger material than stock. Not necessarily 'better', but always stronger and with tighter tolerances.

And then there's the customization, which speaks for itself. I've read reviews of bikes where a factory rider had something like five subframes to choose from, 4 different brake setups, exhaust pipes... Not to mention these teams have multiple sets of suspension ready for every rider and factory tyres...

As far as the motor itself goes, I think there's a huge difference is whether you're talking about a 250 or a 450. With the 450 you're searching for the perfect power 'delivery'. That's something that probably a lot of engine tuners can do, as it most likely requires more insight, skills and brains than anything else.

On a 250 on the other hand you're searching for for every 1/10 of a HP that you can squeeze out of that thing, which is probably a whole lot more dependant on the parts you have at hand.
2/9/2013 12:55am
I'm pretty sure if yo took that bike after the main event and tore it down you'd be amazed at the Non-stock parts that go to make it up

"Stock bike" sounds impressive,I wouldn't doubt that its way nearer to the bike they took "off the showroom floor" and Short,being the amazing rider he is has the talent to maximize the bike's potential but with the great parts that are readily available,I'm sure they'd use a whole lot of them

Post a reply to: Racing a stock bike in supercross?

The Latest