Why has USA never produced a vollume selling Motocross Bike?

FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
10/12/2011 10:18am
Seriously and you can shout and scream all you like with the responses but America as a whole just isn't any good at Engineering is it...
Seriously and you can shout and scream all you like with the responses but America as a whole just isn't any good at Engineering is it? And it is nothing to do with rates or labour or anything like that, it's just not had the attention of other sciences.

If you look at the history of your auto it's not great, sure you have Harley and there have been other gems across time but en-mass nothing is that well engineered and the majority of the world simply do it better. take a small v6 from Japan or Germany and compare it to a big V8 from America - you (mass generalisation I know) can't even get close to the efficiency, power output, reliability etc on offer, why a country so large cannot do this is beyond me and probably the rest of the world - with the resource on offer America really should be doing better in my opinion.
Actually, America is awesome at engineering, unequalled in many respects, but engineering a product and mass producing it at a cost point most people can afford are two very different things.
ayearinmx
Posts
2760
Joined
3/5/2007
Location
GB
10/12/2011 10:30am
ehr400 wrote:
Bentley- owned by the germans Rolls royce - owned by germans MG- They even in buisness? Lol Rover- owned by the germans Jaguar- owned by Ford...
Bentley- owned by the germans
Rolls royce - owned by germans
MG- They even in buisness? Lol
Rover- owned by the germans
Jaguar- owned by Ford, now Tata
Morgan- kit cars, we have thousands of those here in the USA
Eagle- ? go karts?
Mini- BMW
Lotus- still building 1976 Esprits?


Mclaren- Only true in house manufacturer that is exceptional

The question is what do you ENGINEER and manufacturer? Brag about those facts first.
"And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even build any more?"

I just gave you a list...... and now you change it to "own".... which is kinda stupid when you're in debt to China over $4.4 trillion.....

anyway,
Bentley - made in Crewe, England proof
Rolls Royce - Goodwood, England
Morgan - a kit car?? dunno why i even continue when you are so ignorant.....
Mini - Bristol, England proof

oh, and Lotus, they make these..... ..... look like a 1976 Esprit to you? idiot.....
mom241
Posts
992
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Shawnee, OK, USA
10/12/2011 10:32am
Pretty sure we (America) put a man on the moon. I'd say that took some engineering (my dad was one of them).
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
10/12/2011 10:38am
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000 bikes that could be sold for what, $7K in today's money?

What does that have to do with engineering or building exotic six figure cars?

The Shop

ayearinmx
Posts
2760
Joined
3/5/2007
Location
GB
10/12/2011 10:41am
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000...
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000 bikes that could be sold for what, $7K in today's money?

What does that have to do with engineering or building exotic six figure cars?
when some idiot says something like this..... that's how, but it insults Britain/Europe, so no big deal

"And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even build any more? I know you will throw some F! teams and whatever but how is your car industry? Motorcycle? Planes? Shipyards? Manufacturing? Before you go all Euro on this topic and fuck it up get your shit straight first. "

oh, and that Lotus is only five figures
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
10/12/2011 10:55am
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000...
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000 bikes that could be sold for what, $7K in today's money?

What does that have to do with engineering or building exotic six figure cars?
ayearinmx wrote:
when some idiot says something like this..... that's how, but it insults Britain/Europe, so no big deal "And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever...
when some idiot says something like this..... that's how, but it insults Britain/Europe, so no big deal

"And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even build any more? I know you will throw some F! teams and whatever but how is your car industry? Motorcycle? Planes? Shipyards? Manufacturing? Before you go all Euro on this topic and fuck it up get your shit straight first. "

oh, and that Lotus is only five figures
Did you catch the part where the brit first said Americans are poor at engineering and triggered that whole fiasco?

Sorry, it wasn't even a response to you. It was a response to how this off track from volume production to cool bikes someone might cobble together. That's talking about Accords and Malibus, not Lotus's or other exotics. Yup people might be able to cobble together a all US made bike. Maybe even someone could build ten US-made $75K from scratch bikes, the equivalent to a Mclaren.

The are engineers from every country in the world passionate about pushing the limits on engine, chassis and design, and the production market for actual products is saturated and small.
ayearinmx
Posts
2760
Joined
3/5/2007
Location
GB
10/12/2011 11:04am
Show me anywhere that he called someone a retard, or used profanity against an entire nation, oh and an entire continent, but yea.... you are right, but he did say (cover you kid's ears and eyes)..... "america just isn't any good" ....... woah.... steady, that was pretty harsh

a definite trigger that certainly warranted the four-letter outburst..... uh huh Huh

"Seriously and you can shout and scream all you like with the responses but America as a whole just isn't any good at Engineering is it? And it is nothing to do with rates or labour or anything like that, it's just not had the attention of other sciences.

If you look at the history of your auto it's not great, sure you have Harley and there have been other gems across time but en-mass nothing is that well engineered and the majority of the world simply do it better. take a small v6 from Japan or Germany and compare it to a big V8 from America - you (mass generalisation I know) can't even get close to the efficiency, power output, reliability etc on offer, why a country so large cannot do this is beyond me and probably the rest of the world - with the resource on offer America really should be doing better in my opinion. "
Deetsmx
Posts
888
Joined
4/21/2008
Location
Visalia, CA, USA
10/12/2011 11:05am
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000...
Back to the original post, we were talking about motocross bikes and ones that could be sold in volume right? So you're talking about producing 5,000 bikes that could be sold for what, $7K in today's money?

What does that have to do with engineering or building exotic six figure cars?
ayearinmx wrote:
when some idiot says something like this..... that's how, but it insults Britain/Europe, so no big deal "And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever...
when some idiot says something like this..... that's how, but it insults Britain/Europe, so no big deal

"And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even build any more? I know you will throw some F! teams and whatever but how is your car industry? Motorcycle? Planes? Shipyards? Manufacturing? Before you go all Euro on this topic and fuck it up get your shit straight first. "

oh, and that Lotus is only five figures
Lotus also uses Toyota engines
steedmills
Posts
1841
Joined
2/21/2011
Location
NL
10/12/2011 11:11am
newmann wrote:
Old car joke:

Why don't the Brits build computers?


Because they couldn't figure out how to make them leak oil.


Tongue
Laughing Laughing Laughing
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
10/12/2011 11:12am
Stating that "America as a whole is just isn't any good at Engineering is it?" is clueless beyond belief. If you want to stand and defend that one, so be it.

And if you want to get in the gutter with someone provoked by it, have at it. There were plenty of other reasonable reactions that contest the original Brits ignorant statement about American engineering, including mine. If you are hot to have a go at me, fine.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
10/12/2011 11:15am
Deetsmx wrote:
Lotus also uses Toyota engines
In the Elise, not all it's production cars, and Lotus has an exceptional tradition of engineering. There are a lot of American, English, Italian and German auto manufactueres with exceptional engineering traditions that remain on the cutting edge. All of them also have spotty records from time to time of putting that into practice in volume production.
carlosmacho
Posts
1493
Joined
12/8/2009
Location
Lost Wages, NV, USA
10/12/2011 11:16am
robkinuk wrote:
As America is the largest market for off road bikes globally, why has an American company never produced a vollume selling Motocross bike? I know we...
As America is the largest market for off road bikes globally, why has an American company never produced a vollume selling Motocross bike? I know we have had attempts from ATK, Harley Davidson, Cannondale etc but it seem's that there must be enough engineering talent in US and marketing savvy to be able to produce a bike.

After all you have world leading aerospace, NASA, car,Nascar & computer industry manufacturer's, but seem to leave it to other countries such as Japan, Austria, Germany, Italy, Gt Britain , Czechoslovakia etc to lead the way.
Did the AMA production ruling stiffle US talent?

Wouldn't the American consumer's passion for anything homegrown give a US factory a head start in marketing a competitive bike?
Not enough money in it. Labor unions are partly to blame. It is why Honda and Toyota build cars in US factories and Chevy builds them in Canada and Mexico.If you were a big corp in America and wanted to make big money you would not want to build in the US. Cheap labor with no unions are just across the boarder, Make a run for the border. But in the case motorcycles not enough money to do it off shore, to many other ways to make money with less competition and higher profits
redalert144
Posts
1777
Joined
5/24/2009
Location
Yuma, AZ, USA
10/12/2011 11:19am
ehr400 wrote:
Bentley- owned by the germans Rolls royce - owned by germans MG- They even in buisness? Lol Rover- owned by the germans Jaguar- owned by Ford...
Bentley- owned by the germans
Rolls royce - owned by germans
MG- They even in buisness? Lol
Rover- owned by the germans
Jaguar- owned by Ford, now Tata
Morgan- kit cars, we have thousands of those here in the USA
Eagle- ? go karts?
Mini- BMW
Lotus- still building 1976 Esprits?


Mclaren- Only true in house manufacturer that is exceptional

The question is what do you ENGINEER and manufacturer? Brag about those facts first.
ayearinmx wrote:
"And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even [b]build[/b] any more?" I just gave you a list...
"And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even build any more?"

I just gave you a list...... and now you change it to "own".... which is kinda stupid when you're in debt to China over $4.4 trillion.....

anyway,
Bentley - made in Crewe, England proof
Rolls Royce - Goodwood, England
Morgan - a kit car?? dunno why i even continue when you are so ignorant.....
Mini - Bristol, England proof

oh, and Lotus, they make these..... ..... look like a 1976 Esprit to you? idiot.....
Why that reasoning Toyota trucks and Camrys being built in the USA, makes Toyota an American company
redalert144
Posts
1777
Joined
5/24/2009
Location
Yuma, AZ, USA
10/12/2011 11:20am
Deetsmx wrote:
Lotus also uses Toyota engines
In the Elise, not all it's production cars, and Lotus has an exceptional tradition of engineering. There are a lot of American, English, Italian and German...
In the Elise, not all it's production cars, and Lotus has an exceptional tradition of engineering. There are a lot of American, English, Italian and German auto manufactueres with exceptional engineering traditions that remain on the cutting edge. All of them also have spotty records from time to time of putting that into practice in volume production.
Pretty sure they just use the Toyota engines in the cars they ship here
kongols
Posts
24231
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
10/12/2011 11:25am Edited Date/Time 10/12/2011 11:26am
Why that reasoning Toyota trucks and Camrys being built in the USA, makes Toyota an American company
They are still english company`s with english management and part owners, just because germans invested some money doesn`t mean they lost their identity.
steedmills
Posts
1841
Joined
2/21/2011
Location
NL
10/12/2011 11:26am
FastEddy
Posts
14815
Joined
8/3/2008
Location
💀, FL, USA
10/12/2011 11:28am Edited Date/Time 10/12/2011 11:28am
Deetsmx wrote:
Lotus also uses Toyota engines
America #1 again! Woohoo Woohoo Woohoo Smile
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13361
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
10/12/2011 11:46am Edited Date/Time 10/12/2011 11:50am
If I can wave the white flag for a moment, a story. By way of introduction, some of you know my family on both sides is Canadian; I'm one of only two (my youngest sister is the other) from all my generation born here in the states. I'm a citizen of both the US and Canada.

So, to the story, three of my uncles served in the RAF or RCAF in WWII. One of them was a mechanic who worked on the Rolls Royce Merlin engines for a variety of allied aircraft. One of the great aircraft engines of all time, partuclarly after the Ford of England redesign for mass production. I spoke to him a month ago and he told me how trick the English built engines were. Custom bolts for different locations on manifolds and joints, which required a mechanic to have a large kit readily at hand. Metal to metal head/cylinder and other mating surfaces without using gaskets, which performed marvelously when perfect and terrible with the least flaw from use or improper tolerances. They were beautiful and tempermental, not the best combination for mass war production and maintenance for pilots putting ther necks on the line. On the other hand, manufacture of a certain number of engines was contracted out to Packard in the US. These engines, he said, used standard bolts everywhere so a mechanics could work quickly with a small kit, and used gaskets, which proved to be far more reliable and consistent. One was essentially a works engine and the other a production engine. Which was optimal depended on the end use. It wasn't a question of the engineering, the underlying design was the same, but the ability to produce and maintain a product that met the end need. A works engine wasn't cutting it with the demands of combat and mass production.

The same sort of distinction works here. If we want to talk about a limited run of exotics destined for a small group of probably highly motivated customers, that's one thing (whether cars or bikes). If you want to mass produce a bike, especially the sort of lower cost, high performance machine many here have been advocating, that's another, especially if you're not borrowing parts from other brands. I don't doubt that Mitch could do an incredible bike from all-American components without a huge investment in production infrastructure. And he might find 25 people, maybe, who would pay the freight. Ask him again if he wanted to absorb the risk of developing the capability to build a run of 5,000 and I think the chances are nil.
Rooster
Posts
4432
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edmonton, CA
10/12/2011 12:06pm
mom241 wrote:
Pretty sure we (America) put a man on the moon. I'd say that took some engineering (my dad was one of them).
Yup, a great team of engineers. Many Americans among them, but not all were born or educated in the USA.

Wernher von Braun defecting gave you the basics and a team of Canadians from the avro project were invaluable to designing the mercury rockets, gemini rockets, lunar lander, and later providing oversight to the apollo rockets, and the shuttle program.

The rockets that went to the moon may have had the stars and stripes on them, but they weren't solely the work of American engineers.
Erick
Posts
181
Joined
1/20/2010
Location
NL
10/12/2011 12:40pm
mom241 wrote:
Pretty sure we (America) put a man on the moon. I'd say that took some engineering (my dad was one of them).
Rooster wrote:
Yup, a great team of engineers. Many Americans among them, but not all were born or educated in the USA. Wernher von Braun defecting gave you...
Yup, a great team of engineers. Many Americans among them, but not all were born or educated in the USA.

Wernher von Braun defecting gave you the basics and a team of Canadians from the avro project were invaluable to designing the mercury rockets, gemini rockets, lunar lander, and later providing oversight to the apollo rockets, and the shuttle program.

The rockets that went to the moon may have had the stars and stripes on them, but they weren't solely the work of American engineers.
This is true. A lot of people come from all over the world to work in the USA. I believe the engineering has a very high percentage of foreign engineers. But it is plain dumb to say Americans suck at engineering. Look at all the aircraft companies and the whole military industry. There is a lot of high tech stuff made in the USA. You cannot deny this.

About the cost of labour... Look at KTM, Austria is not really a 3rd world country Tongue and they can make very good dirtbikes which sell for about the same price as a japanese bike.

The question you ask is a very good one. I honestly don't have a clue. I am pretty sure there is history involved.

When you watch the movie: On Any Sunday 1 they kinda make fun of a japanese bike (it broke). But a few years later everyone was on japanese bikes. This is because propably because of the price and quality of those bikes compared to what was offered at the time.

I think there is surely a market for US made motocross bikes.
TeamGreen
Posts
37814
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
10/12/2011 12:59pm
C O G

Specifically from a "Labor" stand-point.
RocketLab
Posts
604
Joined
11/18/2009
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
10/12/2011 1:31pm
It seems to me that all of the Japanese 4 and Husky/BMW motorcycles are all small cogs in big corporate wheels. It would seem nowadays that it would take a much bigger conglomerate in the US to attempt to build motorcycles as an aside. I know there are "boutique" bike builders such as TM, Husaberg and such but haven't they been around awhile? KTM, Aprila, Ducati are maybe too big to call boutique but they all have a long history.

Besides Harley and their aborted attempt I can't see any other company stepping into that arena in the US. Especially if they study the Cannondale model's outcome.

As far as engineering goes each country has it's claim to fame. I will say that I am often surprised and impressed at the number of very clever inventions and innovations the Brits have done this century. And yes NASA and the defense industry are great American engineering feats but I think the euros with F1 and the great car names produced over the years may have us trumped in the car arenas.
jeffro503
Posts
27651
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR, USA
10/12/2011 1:36pm
newmann wrote:
[img]http://www.cobramotorcycle.com/images/2011/2011_cx65_sideview_2.jpg[/img] 2011 model CX65 retail $4398.00. Just hit the enlarge button 50% and there you have a full size bike.14" and 12" rims x 50% increase...


2011 model CX65 retail $4398.00. Just hit the enlarge button 50% and there you have a full size bike.14" and 12" rims x 50% increase equals 21" and 18". That's full size. Now the price. $4398.00 plus 50% comes out to be $6597.00. Not too bad.Smile
pound for pound.....if that bike was the size of a 450....it would be putting out about 163 HP. You would never need to shift out of 1st gear. Oh wait.....these are auto's right? Just pin it and go. Do an entire whoop section , triple and a rad timing section with one twist of the throttle.
NP301
Posts
2669
Joined
1/19/2010
Location
Keene, NH, USA
10/12/2011 1:42pm
It would not be hard to BASE a chassis design on KTM or a Jap company! And then make some tweaks to it!? Also There are plenty of USA manufactures that make Engines. So any of you saying its stupid or impossible it's not.

Suspension: http://www.foxracingshox.com/product.php?m=moto&t=shocks&p=3341&ref=fil…
Suspension: http://www.monroe.com/products?utm_source=msn&utm_medium=cpc&utm_term=s…

Engine: 2 stroke http://www.2si.com/ (AMW Cuyuna Engine Co)
Engine: 4 stroke in house or John Deere Wink

Chassis: In house or JGR would be able to make one.

Plastics: www.americanplasticscompany.com, ufo etc

Wheels: In house or http://www.buchananspokes.net

Hubs: in house or http://www.balleracing.com/Hubs.htm


So any of you saying it is stupid or impossible are wrong! As long as you have machines to make parts, you can make EVERYTHING on a motorcycle accept for a few parts on a mill and lathe. Also you can cast..... So hate on!!! Evil Cool
hgabriel
Posts
7
Joined
10/12/2011
Location
Dresden, DE
10/12/2011 2:00pm
daveoevo
Posts
194
Joined
5/1/2011
Location
GB
10/12/2011 2:29pm
I wonder whether American engineering is more geared for Americans. With out getting in to the whole our engineering is better than yours argument i'm sure and know you produce some great products.
All the manufacturers that produce and sell adult mx bikes sell in the countries all over the world so the products have to be suitible for those markets. Thats why F150 pick ups dont fly of the show room floors in europe and asia they just dont fulfil what those customers want.
In short I dont think the US couldnt make a decent bike I just think no one would want to waste the time and millions to sell a few hundred dirtbikes for $7000. You would need to make it good enough to sell everywhere.
nickm
Posts
702
Joined
9/15/2011
Location
CA
10/12/2011 2:56pm
ehr400 wrote:
Shhhhhh! That doesnt happen ever with them! I cant tell how many Japanese and Chinese engineers I see every year at the Detroit auto show taking...
Shhhhhh! That doesnt happen ever with them! I cant tell how many Japanese and Chinese engineers I see every year at the Detroit auto show taking pictures of every aspect of the new cars and prototypes from the Americans and germans. It is almost comical, and guess what! 2 years later they are putting it on their cars.

And to the retard from Britain, Munro or whatever. Seriously, what the fuck does your country even build any more? I know you will throw some F! teams and whatever but how is your car industry? Motorcycle? Planes? Shipyards? Manufacturing? Before you go all Euro on this topic and fuck it up get your shit straight first.
kongols wrote:
Land Rover is probably the best SUV`s there is. Aston Martin, well , Aston Martin is Aston Martin.
Yeah, they are both owned by an Indian company named Tata...neither of them are british companies anymore...and as you know Ford owned them both before they sold them to Tata.
motogrady
Posts
3931
Joined
1/27/2008
Location
USA
10/12/2011 3:06pm
Cannondale was a prime example.

They couldn't keep it simple. The engineers just had to show how smart they were.
Instead of playing the game they way it's done in the real world, that is spy and copy everything you can,
no, they went and made a overweight, overly complex machine that no one could afford.

We're just too lazy. Life is just too good to go out and put 40 hrs a week on some assembly line.
Unless we're getting 65 an hour with bennies, that is.
machine
Posts
6404
Joined
1/5/2011
Location
Collettsville, NC, USA
10/12/2011 3:17pm
I think this all comes down to it's no whether we have the ability to build one, but the price point and whether or not it's lucrative enough or not.


Oh, to the Brits that are taking jabs at our country. Your poking an angry bear with a stick, especially right now. We may be a country that's currently torn apart, but that's a sure way to get us to pull together, so shut your pie holes!
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/12/2011 3:21pm
Lots of people saying no one would be interested in building something moto related yet there is some little company in San Francisco chipping away at an amazingly good looking electric mx bike with a projected price in the 13-15 thousand dollar range? Yikes.

Post a reply to: Why has USA never produced a vollume selling Motocross Bike?

The Latest