Timing conundrum

kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
Edited Date/Time 7/14/2020 7:11am
Had a post a while ago about this 09 kx250f not starting. Has spark, getting gas, leakdown and comp tests passed. It only afterfires out the exhaust every few kicks. Bike started 1st kick and ran great before teardown. I thought there was a CDI issue but apparently not.

Timing looks like it should work for me. The intake cam gear looks almost like it slipped though. Can some experienced eyes take a look please? Im about to sledge hammer the crank cases.




|
Factor E
Posts
955
Joined
9/22/2011
Location
So Cal, CA US
7/11/2020 7:50pm Edited Date/Time 7/11/2020 7:57pm
Exhaust cam looks one tooth off
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/12/2020 5:30pm
Factor E wrote:
Exhaust cam looks one tooth off
The dot is flush with the gasket surface. Its dead nuts unless the gear slipped.
Paul_Pitzonka
Posts
693
Joined
5/1/2018
Location
Grand Terrace, CA US
7/12/2020 5:49pm Edited Date/Time 7/12/2020 5:51pm
what was the reason for rebuild/ teardown? It almost looks as if one of the cam gears have spun slightly notice the cam gear teeth are slightly out of alignment... also does the intake cam not have an alignment dot with the head surface? If all else fails You can always degree the cams to make sure the mechanical timing is correct or at least within 1-2 degrees...
BRX-WRX
Posts
234
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Blue Springs, MO US
7/12/2020 6:02pm
I have had problems with hot cams slipping on the shaft with 250 Yamaha and 450 KX. You can tell by where the lobes are pointing compared to the alignment marks. The next time I install a hot cam cam I will spot weld the sprocket to the shaft before installation. These were customer bikes that had this problem show up latter in the year when they started having problems starting. There is alignment holes in sprocket and lobes on OEM cams, not sure how that works on the different stage hot cams?

The Shop

kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/12/2020 6:19pm
what was the reason for rebuild/ teardown? It almost looks as if one of the cam gears have spun slightly notice the cam gear teeth are...
what was the reason for rebuild/ teardown? It almost looks as if one of the cam gears have spun slightly notice the cam gear teeth are slightly out of alignment... also does the intake cam not have an alignment dot with the head surface? If all else fails You can always degree the cams to make sure the mechanical timing is correct or at least within 1-2 degrees...
There was a slight knock. The head cams and valves were new before teardown. I had millennium do the cylinder as it was out of spec. Ken oconnor did the crank rebuild.

The intake cam does have a dot. It is hidden by the head. How would i go about degreeing the cam?
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/12/2020 6:21pm
BRX-WRX wrote:
I have had problems with hot cams slipping on the shaft with 250 Yamaha and 450 KX. You can tell by where the lobes are pointing...
I have had problems with hot cams slipping on the shaft with 250 Yamaha and 450 KX. You can tell by where the lobes are pointing compared to the alignment marks. The next time I install a hot cam cam I will spot weld the sprocket to the shaft before installation. These were customer bikes that had this problem show up latter in the year when they started having problems starting. There is alignment holes in sprocket and lobes on OEM cams, not sure how that works on the different stage hot cams?
I am aware of the holes for alignment. Note the bearing is in the way, but from what i can visually see it looks fine. Thats not actually checking though. I have these cams in my kx450. I may just pop them out and spot weld them.
Paul_Pitzonka
Posts
693
Joined
5/1/2018
Location
Grand Terrace, CA US
7/12/2020 6:38pm Edited Date/Time 7/12/2020 6:39pm
what was the reason for rebuild/ teardown? It almost looks as if one of the cam gears have spun slightly notice the cam gear teeth are...
what was the reason for rebuild/ teardown? It almost looks as if one of the cam gears have spun slightly notice the cam gear teeth are slightly out of alignment... also does the intake cam not have an alignment dot with the head surface? If all else fails You can always degree the cams to make sure the mechanical timing is correct or at least within 1-2 degrees...
kb228 wrote:
There was a slight knock. The head cams and valves were new before teardown. I had millennium do the cylinder as it was out of spec...
There was a slight knock. The head cams and valves were new before teardown. I had millennium do the cylinder as it was out of spec. Ken oconnor did the crank rebuild.

The intake cam does have a dot. It is hidden by the head. How would i go about degreeing the cam?
You need a degree wheel and a dial indicator... there’s plenty of articles available on how to degree a camshaft properly... its a great piece of information to learn for anyone building engine... It not only verifies that the cam profile is correct to the specs provided; it also allows you find any discrepancies between the actual cam lobe position and the timing gears...
Factor E
Posts
955
Joined
9/22/2011
Location
So Cal, CA US
7/12/2020 6:55pm Edited Date/Time 7/12/2020 6:56pm
Is photo with cam chain tensioner in?
Dot prob shouldn't be hidden and even at edge of cyl
Lobes should prob be flat
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/12/2020 6:58pm
Factor E wrote:
Is photo with cam chain tensioner in?
Dot prob shouldn't be hidden and even at edge of cyl
Lobes should prob be flat
Yes tensioner is in.
BRX-WRX
Posts
234
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Blue Springs, MO US
7/12/2020 7:34pm Edited Date/Time 7/12/2020 7:41pm
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared to other makes ? Its normal for the dots to be a little off from this. Some flywheels have 2 alignment marks that the manual does not mention a bought a 1/4" apart. For that reason I pay attention to witch one is closest to dots before disassembly. By the pics they close enough to start. Does the manual tell you how many chain pins to count between gear dots? On the Yamaha I pressed the shaft out of gear realigned pressed back on aligning the holes and spot welded. The KX just put the OEM cam back in and stock piston after overhaul from stage 2 with high compression piston for the 16 year old new owner.
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/13/2020 5:43am
BRX-WRX wrote:
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared...
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared to other makes ? Its normal for the dots to be a little off from this. Some flywheels have 2 alignment marks that the manual does not mention a bought a 1/4" apart. For that reason I pay attention to witch one is closest to dots before disassembly. By the pics they close enough to start. Does the manual tell you how many chain pins to count between gear dots? On the Yamaha I pressed the shaft out of gear realigned pressed back on aligning the holes and spot welded. The KX just put the OEM cam back in and stock piston after overhaul from stage 2 with high compression piston for the 16 year old new owner.
28 pins is what the manual specifies. This engine is freshly rebuilt. All new parts including the timing chain.
Factor E
Posts
955
Joined
9/22/2011
Location
So Cal, CA US
7/13/2020 6:31pm Edited Date/Time 7/13/2020 6:33pm
ck crank position sensor
woodruff key on flywheel broken timing off
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/13/2020 7:24pm
Factor E wrote:
ck crank position sensor
woodruff key on flywheel broken timing off
No was in tact when i assembled it. Bike hasnt ran at all so theres no way it could have sheared.
BRX-WRX
Posts
234
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Blue Springs, MO US
7/13/2020 9:55pm
BRX-WRX wrote:
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared...
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared to other makes ? Its normal for the dots to be a little off from this. Some flywheels have 2 alignment marks that the manual does not mention a bought a 1/4" apart. For that reason I pay attention to witch one is closest to dots before disassembly. By the pics they close enough to start. Does the manual tell you how many chain pins to count between gear dots? On the Yamaha I pressed the shaft out of gear realigned pressed back on aligning the holes and spot welded. The KX just put the OEM cam back in and stock piston after overhaul from stage 2 with high compression piston for the 16 year old new owner.
kb228 wrote:
28 pins is what the manual specifies. This engine is freshly rebuilt. All new parts including the timing chain.
In your pics looks like you are on the 2nd alignment mark on flywheel. I don't have a manual in front of me to help but maybe it should be the 1st mark on flywheel?
1
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/14/2020 4:07am
BRX-WRX wrote:
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared...
The lobes angles looks correct in your pic. I have also noticed the Kawaski timing chain stretches and Kinks sooner than I feel they should compared to other makes ? Its normal for the dots to be a little off from this. Some flywheels have 2 alignment marks that the manual does not mention a bought a 1/4" apart. For that reason I pay attention to witch one is closest to dots before disassembly. By the pics they close enough to start. Does the manual tell you how many chain pins to count between gear dots? On the Yamaha I pressed the shaft out of gear realigned pressed back on aligning the holes and spot welded. The KX just put the OEM cam back in and stock piston after overhaul from stage 2 with high compression piston for the 16 year old new owner.
kb228 wrote:
28 pins is what the manual specifies. This engine is freshly rebuilt. All new parts including the timing chain.
BRX-WRX wrote:
In your pics looks like you are on the 2nd alignment mark on flywheel. I don't have a manual in front of me to help but...
In your pics looks like you are on the 2nd alignment mark on flywheel. I don't have a manual in front of me to help but maybe it should be the 1st mark on flywheel?

1
walent215
Posts
2518
Joined
12/6/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA US
7/14/2020 7:05am Edited Date/Time 7/14/2020 7:11am
So everything is new, timing is correct, electrical all checks out? So i like to go back to the simple things when encountering issues like this but it seems youve exhausted all avenues here? Have you checked grounding points for coil? Could they have given you the wrong cam chain , too long?Did you remove the flywheel? Is it all the way pulled up on the crank? Stator bolts tight? I dont know man, this one is very puzzling. Sorry you are dealing with this, i cant imagine dealing with it myself. Swap a wiring harness with a known good one maybe?
kb228
Posts
6154
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
7/14/2020 7:25am
walent215 wrote:
So everything is new, timing is correct, electrical all checks out? So i like to go back to the simple things when encountering issues like this...
So everything is new, timing is correct, electrical all checks out? So i like to go back to the simple things when encountering issues like this but it seems youve exhausted all avenues here? Have you checked grounding points for coil? Could they have given you the wrong cam chain , too long?Did you remove the flywheel? Is it all the way pulled up on the crank? Stator bolts tight? I dont know man, this one is very puzzling. Sorry you are dealing with this, i cant imagine dealing with it myself. Swap a wiring harness with a known good one maybe?
Its certainly difficult. I ordered a peak voltage adapter to start verifying im getting a strong spark.

The sad thing is this bike was such a reliable starting bike before. Probably the easiest starting bike ive ever seen.

Ill pull the flywheel and verify its good. I put it together correctly, but ill verify anyway. I may also pull the cylinder and just verify the entire top end as well.
3/1/2024 7:54am

Bringing up an old post, what was the outcome with this issue?

 

Im experiencing the same thing on a customers 2009. Bike ran great till he locked up the bottom end, easiest starting bike ive ever seen. We replaced bottom end with wiseco and top end together, cant get this dang thing started unless your bump starting it and even then it will not idle at all. verified good compression, nice bright spark, clean carb, even starting fluid doesnt help. i thew a dial indicator on the piston and physically set engine to TDC, flywheel timing marks are NOT aligned with timing cover- about 1 tooth off. re-timed engine to physical tdc and not flywheel mark and bike started first kick but would not rev out at all. (probably because pick-up timing is off now). ive worked on this bike for years, adjusted valves and re timed countless times in the past, never had this issue. only thing i can think is the wiseco crank has to be keyed wrong? were reusing the original flywheel so no variance there. searching this issue there seems to be ALOT of concerns with Kawasaki timing marks. ive contacted wiseco and theyve got me sending the crank back for inspection. This crank has since been discontinued from wiseco, wonder what the reasoning was. looks like the 2008 timing cover had the timing cover mark in a different location then the 2009, maybe i got a 2008? Ive got so much money and labor wasted in this bike, i could have bought him another 2009 by now.

walent215
Posts
2518
Joined
12/6/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA US
3/1/2024 8:34am
Bringing up an old post, what was the outcome with this issue?   Im experiencing the same thing on a customers 2009. Bike ran great till...

Bringing up an old post, what was the outcome with this issue?

 

Im experiencing the same thing on a customers 2009. Bike ran great till he locked up the bottom end, easiest starting bike ive ever seen. We replaced bottom end with wiseco and top end together, cant get this dang thing started unless your bump starting it and even then it will not idle at all. verified good compression, nice bright spark, clean carb, even starting fluid doesnt help. i thew a dial indicator on the piston and physically set engine to TDC, flywheel timing marks are NOT aligned with timing cover- about 1 tooth off. re-timed engine to physical tdc and not flywheel mark and bike started first kick but would not rev out at all. (probably because pick-up timing is off now). ive worked on this bike for years, adjusted valves and re timed countless times in the past, never had this issue. only thing i can think is the wiseco crank has to be keyed wrong? were reusing the original flywheel so no variance there. searching this issue there seems to be ALOT of concerns with Kawasaki timing marks. ive contacted wiseco and theyve got me sending the crank back for inspection. This crank has since been discontinued from wiseco, wonder what the reasoning was. looks like the 2008 timing cover had the timing cover mark in a different location then the 2009, maybe i got a 2008? Ive got so much money and labor wasted in this bike, i could have bought him another 2009 by now.

Are the cams original ?

if so , 

Cam gear could have slipped on cam 

 

3/1/2024 8:49am

Pro circuit cams. I know that's an issue on these kx's. As far as I can tell they're still spot on. Comparing the lobes to other pictures and forums , I see no degree change. 
but I'll tell you after the issues with this bike, every KX I get in the shop is getting a centerpunch between Cam and gear to visually monitor every valve adjustment. 

Wiscomx
Posts
87
Joined
10/2/2021
Location
West Bend, WI US
3/1/2024 8:57am

Check orientation of tip over sensors, possibly when taken apart it was installed upside down

3/1/2024 10:15am

Don't believe there is a tip over sensor on the 2009 model is there? The 09's are still carbureted and I've got nice bright spark. 

3/1/2024 10:43am

Verified neutral timing switch works as well. But still, physical tdc does not line up with flywheel marks. Anyway to get a diagram of woodruff key vs Rod big end before I send it back?

walent215
Posts
2518
Joined
12/6/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA US
3/1/2024 11:00am

I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded 

I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring it up 

Timing  “ appears “ correct but isn’t 

Hope you get this nailed down !

3/1/2024 11:13am

I'll try to get info out of procircuit, hopefully I can get a degree measurement - probably "confidential" information though. 
 

eye balling it to pro-circuits "actual picture" exhaust looks legit. And when assembled eyeballing lobes looks legit. IMG 0158

3/1/2024 11:19am
walent215 wrote:
I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded  I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring...

I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded 

I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring it up 

Timing  “ appears “ correct but isn’t 

Hope you get this nailed down !

dang dude, i grew up in shitcrest - small world lol

walent215
Posts
2518
Joined
12/6/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA US
3/1/2024 11:39am
walent215 wrote:
I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded  I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring...

I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded 

I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring it up 

Timing  “ appears “ correct but isn’t 

Hope you get this nailed down !

dang dude, i grew up in shitcrest - small world lol

Lol

i would send them into PC and let them inspect them 

I had a hotcam that the gear spun on

sent it in to them so they could inspect it and sure enough the gear had spun on the cam 

they sent me a new one 

4/6/2024 10:49am
walent215 wrote:
I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded  I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring...

I would be very suspect of those cams if they were in the bike when it grenaded 

I’ve had this problem myself is why I bring it up 

Timing  “ appears “ correct but isn’t 

Hope you get this nailed down !

dang dude, i grew up in shitcrest - small world lol

walent215 wrote:
Lol i would send them into PC and let them inspect them  I had a hotcam that the gear spun on sent it in to them...

Lol

i would send them into PC and let them inspect them 

I had a hotcam that the gear spun on

sent it in to them so they could inspect it and sure enough the gear had spun on the cam 

they sent me a new one 

Been through hell on this 09 KX250F, so I figured id share the conclusion for anyone else suffering from headaches. 
 

Pro Circuit doesn't offer these cams any more, they've ditched all their jigs so there's no real way to determine if the cams have slipped. They said the only way to know is to "buy some factory cams and see if it starts with those" 🙄🙄

 

Wiseco refused to tell me it was off but finally accepted my return and my supplier refunded me money. Bought a HotRods crank this time and through the pc cams back in for the hell of it, nothing else changed. Starts first kick just like she should. Such a relief I can finally get this bike out the door, but of course not before I punch alignment marks on the cams.

Every Local moto machine shop or moto mechanic I talk to claims they refuse to use wiseco because they've had so many issues. That's crazy to me. Lesson Learned, TRUST NO ONE ASSUME NOTHING. Double check that tdc mark during install, takes 60 seconds and a couple degrees off kills you. KEEP YOUR OLD PARTS TILL THE FAT LADIES SINGING!

1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
NY US
4/6/2024 7:59pm

Just another reason to never buy a Wiseco crank.

Post a reply to: Timing conundrum

The Latest